[OLD] Open Setup Ideas and Discussion

[Riddleton]

I like the setup. I'm worried it might be balanced towards town because of judgement day. I find it unlikely the martyrs would miss and send a townie to hell on judgement day, when basically they've had a lot of the game to talk to themselves and work the game out.

[Riddleton]

-Only townies who are sent to heaven are added to the dead PT. Townies who are sent to heaven have a separate martyr PT.

This doesn't quite make sense, wouldn't this qualify the dead QT as the Martyr QT?

I think he means there are two "dead" QTs. One general dead QT, and another one just for those who are sent to heaven (martyrs)

[Riddleton]

It's breakable.

[Riddleton]

Because its gg for towm when 1 scu, dies and the three flavour docs remain

2 docs cross protect. So basically BP.

[Riddleton]

so if water mafia dies, earth/fire docs claim, earth doc targets fire doc, and fire doc targers earth doc

[Riddleton]

1 goon left, 3 docs

all docs claim, and do this at night:

water ->earth
earth-> fire
fire -> water

water vuln. to earth
earth vuln. to fire
fire vuln. to water

---

if earth dies, it's a fire goon still alive
water -> fire
fire -> water

still breakable

[Riddleton]

I agree with Llamafluff, the immunity to their own element should be taken away, IMO.

With regards to your recent one posted, I'll have a look. I still think it can be broken with doctor trickery though, though I haven't checked in more detail.

[Riddleton]

normal elementals is still broken to my strategy earlier for 1 goon vs 3 docs.