Ok so cleaning fish tanks took priority over this yesterday, but I have an hour and then maybe some time before work tonight, so here it goes.
Gamr wrote: At the time boon didn't claim a power role.
He claimed to have a role that confirmed multiball. I doubt he was claiming scum and he never implied negative utility. He was softclaiming a power role. And I said you were pushing a "potential" power role anyway so you are kind of missing the point. Even if this is my interpretation of Aneninen's point, not my own. If you think Aneninen was truly chainsawing as you say, get back to me when one of them flips scum. Associatives are flimsy at best on Day 1.
Lol at Nero voting Thor for trolling him (page 43). I'm trying to decide if this is a town tell or not.
The TSO vs Axle arguement is a little boring, but I feel like I should throw in my two cents. Axle asked TSO for Aneninen's posts that absolutely can NOT come from town. TSO gives a quote wall and attacks Axle for focusing on the RVS vote in the quote wall. I actually think Axle is making a good point that TSO is making more of a case than what is actually there, especially when he admits that the RVS post was more "I disagree with" than "town couldn't possibly" because at that point, TSO isn't really doing what was asked of him to make his case. As for my conclusion on the arguement, Axle looks obvtown. TSO, not so much.
script wrote: I can't give you any real specifics. I've never played with neighborhoods before. However, more information for town is usually a good thing. I also can't see the reveal being particularly anti-town, either. Unless scum get their own neighborhood (which seems like it'd be a little game breaking), they'll probably tell their team all about the composition of their individual hoods, anyway. While this may not cover every hood in the game, it would still be more information than town will have.
I actually agree with most of this. However, it doesn't address my question at all. You specifically said that knowing neighborhoods will be more useful LATER. I asked why later as opposed to now?
I don't understand why people are having trouble reading Axle's posts...The only thing that bothers me is that I phone post, so spoiler tags are basically the same as invisible text which isn't allowed for very good reason.
Thor, basically, you asked me in the neighborhood about my experience as a neighbor. I told you that I had a game or two in my past that I barely remember where I was a neighbor and one semi recent one, but I was scum. I continued that thought by saying I don't even know how I should play town neighbor because there isn't much benefit when anything I can say to you in the neighborhood, I can also say in the game thread. Again, I don't see where you are getting "terrible" from this, much less "terrible, must be town". Basically, it doesn't make sense as a genuine read unless I am seriously missing something, but it makes all kinds of sense for you to find an excuse to call me town if you are scum who I am townreading.
Gamr's push on Aneninen is getting so bad.
Oquote="TSO"] If anyone wants to talk about why Aneninen is scum, I'm open to that.[/quote]
Let's talk. Start by summarizing your case. Use only the strongest arguements and show me why this absolutely can not be town.
Nero wrote: I've played in enough games with scum sprinkled in the hoods to auto default think that. hy should I think there are no scum in the hoods this game? + there's 12 hoodies so I think the probability that all 5-6 scum are in those 9 players outside the hoods is near 0%. I am NOT suggesting that we randomly lynch hoodies until we find the hood scum but just letting town know they are there and not to ignore the hoods and letting scum know that I know they are hiding.
So you think that without you being here to guide us, we'd all make the mistake of assuming neighbors are the same thing as masons or...?
Tier, what is your read on TSO? And how was Script's 1105 an empty post?
Nero wrote: I also dislike fon'z "catchup" post being a bandwagon hop onto PV.
Why so sure that he'd town read someone who nearly half the game is scumreading?
Goodmorning, how would you define "vanity wagon"?
So without the "fucking shitty" etc to make it sound worse, TSO, let me know if I'm understanding your Aneninen case correctly. He called you scum. You said his reasons were bad. He didn't respond. Town would absolutely 100% of the time respond, so he's scum?
Aneninen, can I have your thoughts on the two lines I'm posting before this one?
Dave, do you honestly believe that Tier and myself are tunneling you?
Tier, I disagree with you where you say Aneninen's 418 doesn't at least imply a scum read on TSO.
I'm on Page 50. Will try to keep going before work. After that, I'll be working pretty much 16 hour days through deadline, but I'll check in and help with a deadline lynch if needed.