Open 570: Making Friends and Enemies (Mafia Wins!)

[Metal Sonic]

Yes

Never played with anyone before (except shinobi but shhh)

Looking forward to 'making new friends'!

[Metal Sonic]

Hello friends and enemies! My name is Metal Sonic, pleased to meet you! I am here to break RVS today!

You see, Beastcharizard fell for my evil plan again! I requested him NOT to give me a Vanilla Town role, but in reality I wanted a Vanilla Town role, so that I don't have to play scum! Now, he fell for my trick, and he gave me a Vanilla Town role! So I am an ordinary Vanilla Townie!

I'm here to help the town catch the scum!


So beware, Mafia team! I will help the town and the masons to hunt you down! I think the masons should not claim first at all, and my partner should instead try to find out who is town and masonize them so that eventually town will get a strong townblock of town! Then, the scum cannot do anything to us anymore!

So scum, beware! The Mafia Catcher is out to get you!

Have fun everyone!

[Metal Sonic]

I am a vanilla townie, of course!

I repeated that many times in my post, didn't I?

[Metal Sonic]

Hmmmmmm Sonic might be Scum.

Replace 'Sonic' with any other player in the playerlist and the statement still makes sense! Cool huh?


Hmmmmmm

(insert player name here)

might be Scum.

[Metal Sonic]

Hmmmmmm _____

goodmorning

__ might be Scum.

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: goodmorning

[Metal Sonic]

blatantly manipulative

You see, Beastcharizard fell for my evil plan again! I requested him NOT to give me a Vanilla Town role, but in reality I wanted a Vanilla Town role, so that I don't have to play scum! Now, he fell for my trick, and he gave me a Vanilla Town role! So I am an ordinary Vanilla Townie!

You have no idea...

[Metal Sonic]

Scum have partner

s

, not partner!

Did you fail English grammar class or are you scum?

Must Uncle Sonic teach you the difference between singular and plural nouns now?

VOTE: Zebulin

[Metal Sonic]

No. I was just trying out the 'fill in someone's name' trick that goodmorning showed us earlier.

[Metal Sonic]

I think it's okay^

Seems like RVS to me.

[Metal Sonic]

With regard to 33

[Metal Sonic]

Some people point their gun before asking questions. Others ask their questions before pointing their gun.

That's an interesting observation though, and it is noted for future consideration.

[Metal Sonic]

Oh yay! Hi meow! Are you town?

[Metal Sonic]

Why are you asking so many questions?

Don't you have any comments on the game state?

How long have you been playing mafia?

Who do you think is scum?

Who do you think is town?

Are you scum?

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: bluebloodedtoffee

[Metal Sonic]

OK, so yeah.

I found scum.

Sheep me.


That's even better than goodmorning's can trick!

[Metal Sonic]

Why did you vote EspressoDan? Was that an RVS vote? My apologies, but you do not appear to be in the RVS mood.

[Metal Sonic]

Why, I'm trying to find out who's scum and catch them, of course!

This must be your first time seeing a master at work! No worries, watch and learn!

Bluebloodedtoffee, aren't you going to answer my questions? You should set a precedent for question-answering, otherwise people wouldn't want to answer your questions anymore for being a hypocrite

[Metal Sonic]

Bluebloodedtoffee, aren't you going to answer my questions? You should set a precedent for question-answering, otherwise people wouldn't want to answer your questions anymore for being a hypocrite

You should also set a precedent for answering questions. Given that you completely ignored my questions in 55.

I already have. I have answered everyone's questions but yours. just saying.

So I have set a precedent for answering questions. Why aren't you following my lead? Bad boy :3

[Metal Sonic]

Why, I'm trying to find out who's scum and catch them, of course!

This must be your first time seeing a master at work! No worries, watch and learn!

Bluebloodedtoffee, aren't you going to answer my questions? You should set a precedent for question-answering, otherwise people wouldn't want to answer your questions anymore for being a hypocrite

How exactly is your playstyle supposed to help us find scum? Everybody seems pretty clueless in regards to how you're handling things right now.

Go hunt scum, silly! Don't bother about me, I already said that I'm a Vanilla Townie!

[Metal Sonic]

"What if he actually is a mason? Are you going to run him up just to find out? "


Best.

[Metal Sonic]

Bad VT? Wow that's rude, go take a look at my postbit.

[Metal Sonic]

Then look at yours.

[Metal Sonic]

Oh, Uncle Sonic understands what is going on now!

UNVOTE: Toffee

Uncle Sonic forgives you for your bad behavior!

Uncle Sonic is very patient with youngsters these days.

Just remember, all that I'm doing is for your best interests! Uncle Sonic is just protecting you from the nasty, evil scum!


VOTE: EspressoDan

Let's see what Huntress's line of inquiry has to offer!

[Metal Sonic]

Haven't you heard? A vote is the town's best weapon!

Scum have nightkills, teammates, and their own votes, but all we poor Townspeople only have a single vote! It's certainly an uphill battle!

But we have the numbers! In order to win, we need to have teamwork!

Be a good sport, will ya?

[Metal Sonic]

Uncle Sonic's Scumhunting List!

~Uncle Sonic~

Metal Sonic

Good!

BlueBloodedToffee
Huntress
Shinobi
Malakittens
Zebulin

Maybe good?

EspressoDan
nopointactingup

No Read

Rambler
Alpha Sapphire
AssMuffin
nyanyanay
goodmorning

No Good!

[Metal Sonic]

^Are you scumreading me for not having been here, or is it still OMGUS?

I have no read on you, as you have not been here, but you are relatively scummier than the lurkers based on your previous posts so far.

[Metal Sonic]

I have no definitive scumreads at the moment (It's page 5, lol), but quite a few townreads have surfaced.

It goes without saying that the above list is subject to change.

[Metal Sonic]

Well, I still haven't read pages 2-4, so I'm not really at much of anywhere at present. Will probably post much more soonish though.

How slow at reading must you be to be unable to read two pages?

Obviously, it's scum-alignment-reading-speed-failure-and-beetlejuice syndrome!

[Metal Sonic]

Haven't you heard? A vote is the town's best weapon!

A vote is a good weapon; however, when it only sticks on someone for a page or so, it pretty much becomes useless. Your vote serves no purpose as you're expected to move it onto the next target within the next 25 posts.

GM - Where you at? What you thinking? Let's talk.

I don't want to be pointing my weapon and accidentally killing someone who is town.

[Metal Sonic]

If one vote can't kill someone, then why are you making such a big fuss?

Sonny, you have to look at the big picture!


Why don't you be helpful and try to find some of the scum yourself, and let Uncle Sonic do his job!

[Metal Sonic]

Ms knock it off please. I know you find it funny but it's really not

((

[Metal Sonic]

Ms knock it off please. I know you find it funny but it's really not

Scumhunt with me please! I feel very alone meow!

Me-you-huntress-shinobi would make a good elite team town block!

[Metal Sonic]

Also those who were in the game from the start. Were there Day 1 start PMs sent out?

There were day start PMs but no link to the game thread. New mod.

[Metal Sonic]

Toffee pressures Metal Sonic

Metal Sonic tells Toffee to leave him alone


I don't like this at all. Town should be fine with scumhunting, even if it's on them (since they can say all their thoughts; as town, they have nothing to hide). Also, the uncle sonic thing bugs me.

Will post more when I have time

/!\ NEW PLAYER ALERT /!\

[Metal Sonic]

Well, I still haven't read pages 2-4, so I'm not really at much of anywhere at present. Will probably post much more soonish though.

How slow at reading must you be to be unable to read two pages?

Obviously, it's scum-alignment-reading-speed-failure-and-beetlejuice syndrome!

I actually read quite quickly, but I haven't been able to sit down at the computer for more than a few minutes at a time and I'd really rather only read it once for now.

Beetlejuice? Really?

Haven't you heard? A vote is the town's best weapon!

A vote is a good weapon; however, when it only sticks on someone for a page or so, it pretty much becomes useless. Your vote serves no purpose as you're expected to move it onto the next target within the next 25 posts.

I don't want to be pointing my weapon and accidentally killing someone who is town.

I can't even this contradiction.

Ms knock it off please. I know you find it funny but it's really not

THIS

Hmmmm p2 Zeb looked like reachy Scum but p6 Zeb looks much townier.

@Josh: Well, there's not a lot of mileage in a grudge.

@Huntress: The best townbloc is a joke townbloc. LET'S START A COUNTERBLOC OMG

Also those who were in the game from the start. Were there Day 1 start PMs sent out?

There were day start PMs but no link to the game thread. New mod.

I object to the characterisation of non-link daystart PMs as something a new mod would do.

Does this mean that you have read the game already?

Lol, why post prod dodges in a game that moves at half a page in 24 hours that's ridiculous (and scummy)

[Metal Sonic]

I really think that the fairest way is to replace the dude

[Metal Sonic]

Or we could do what people call a 'policy lynch'

[Metal Sonic]

I think it's weird that MS is reading me as town so early.

Especially considering how hard I wound up burning him in the last game I was in.

You didn't burn me, marquis did.

[Metal Sonic]

Does this mean that you have read the game already?

Does this mean you read the rest of my post already?

On lurker PLs: meh.

Yes or no? Answer the goddamn question.

[Metal Sonic]

Comments on the game state? I have a pretty strong scumread right now, guess who it is?

[Metal Sonic]

Yeeeeeeeah

[Metal Sonic]

You'll be even more surprised if I push your lynch through before we hit 20 pages

If it happens at 15 I can win a medal. Or something

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: goodmorning

This is a serious vote

All your posts so far were 'Lynch me! I'm scum!' In Mafianese

[Metal Sonic]

Well, I still haven't read pages 2-4, so I'm not really at much of anywhere at present. Will probably post much more soonish though.

How slow at reading must you be to be unable to read two pages?

Obviously, it's scum-alignment-reading-speed-failure-and-beetlejuice syndrome!

I actually read quite quickly, but I haven't been able to sit down at the computer for more than a few minutes at a time and I'd really rather only read it once for now.

Beetlejuice? Really?

Haven't you heard? A vote is the town's best weapon!

A vote is a good weapon; however, when it only sticks on someone for a page or so, it pretty much becomes useless. Your vote serves no purpose as you're expected to move it onto the next target within the next 25 posts.

I don't want to be pointing my weapon and accidentally killing someone who is town.

I can't even this contradiction.

Ms knock it off please. I know you find it funny but it's really not

THIS

Hmmmm p2 Zeb looked like reachy Scum but p6 Zeb looks much townier.

@Josh: Well, there's not a lot of mileage in a grudge.

@Huntress: The best townbloc is a joke townbloc. LET'S START A COUNTERBLOC OMG

Also those who were in the game from the start. Were there Day 1 start PMs sent out?

There were day start PMs but no link to the game thread. New mod.

I object to the characterisation of non-link daystart PMs as something a new mod would do.

Does this mean that you have read the game already?

Lol, why post prod dodges in a game that moves at half a page in 24 hours that's ridiculous (and scummy)

This post in particular was one of the worst catchup posts that I would only expect from bad VIs (user VDA) or just textbook scum.

It does not provide any substantiation comments on the game state, does not give any reads, does not mention if anybody is town, and are just lackadaisical comments that provide absolutely no contribution or any form of curiosity of scum hunting nature that would be expected from a townie.

I called you out for lurking, so you read the previous pages and made a few swift comments to appease te town and super quote blocks to make your post seem long. Like, it takes only 10 minutes max to read 2 pages of content, and for the past few days you checked the thread only to prod dodge. When an expected analysis of the previous two pages was to be analyses, you gave no analysis whatsoever. No reads, no scumhunting, nothing.



Dead

[Metal Sonic]

Does this mean that you have read the game already?

Does this mean you read the rest of my post already?

On lurker PLs: meh.

Yes or no? Answer the goddamn question.

That's why I asked, scumbutt

[Metal Sonic]

Lol

Coming from the person who can't read 2 pages

[Metal Sonic]

You think town semi-role fish?

I never semi role-fished. All I said was that I am a Vanilla Townie over and over. I told the masons to stay quiet. If anyone is going to get rolefished, it's the scum.

[Metal Sonic]

Go and vote goodmorning now please.

I want to watch this guy flail even though I already have a pretty good idea that he is caught scum.

[Metal Sonic]

Why would MS feel the need to answer a question directed at someone else?

You see, that answers this question too.


Anyway, you were making a post concerning me, so now I have even more reason to butt in and answer a question directed to someone else.

[Metal Sonic]

UNVOTE:

Mod: Can we have a VC please?

Your vote on me never really bothered me. What I want is a vote on goodmorning the scum.

Ironically, Goodmorning received 3 votes during RVS and these lurkers probably haven't removed their votes yet. With your vote, goodmorning will be at L-2. If he is scum as I predict, he is going to cry, lol.

Figuratively. Nobody cries over a game. With no prizes. hehe

[Metal Sonic]

You see, that answers this question too.

Anyway, you were making a post concerning me, so now I have even more reason to butt in and answer a question directed to someone else.

That's apt. You answered another question that wasn't aimed at you so you could follow up with that defence.

It may have been talking

about

you, but it wasn't

to

you. I would prefer it if you could leave people to answer the questions that are directed at them and not you.

Sure, fine, I won't interrupt.

Both you and me are active now, though,

I know you are town.

You know I am town.

Let's have some constructive discussion

[Metal Sonic]

Annoying. My live discussion offers always get declined!

[Metal Sonic]

Don't lie to yourself; you know, deep down in your heart, that I am town.

But that's not the discussion that I want to have.

Specifically I want you to read all the interactions and replies that goodmorning has given me and your opinions on them. It's only a few, so I hope you can comment on most of the posts that he has.

[Metal Sonic]

And while you're at it, I want your general observations on Huntress and Shinobi as well.

[Metal Sonic]

Josh is pretty town.

No read on NPAU he has barely posted

[Metal Sonic]

particularly scummy from her so far.

I see LOTS of scummy things from her.


Your eyes aren't attuned to scumcatching yet, unfortunately.

Yes, hard truth, Mala told me to knock off the "Uncle Sonic" act, but yeah.

[Metal Sonic]

How are you town-reading Shinobi?

PEdit - what has she done that is scummy?

I don't have any good answers besides "He looks town". He did mention that he "burned" me in another game, that was half-true. I was townreading him for quite awhile until the later part of the game where he became obvscum. It might be happening now, and I have no way to find out.



Look at how defensive she is. And I wrote a pretty big case against her for a game with less than ten pages. You read that, didn't you?


PS: I just realised that goodmorning is female. Then I tried to go to her GTKAS to attempt to find out her age (out of curiosity). It wasn't put there so I had to guess.

[Metal Sonic]

I don't have any good answers besides "He looks town". He did mention that he "burned" me in another game, that was half-true. I was townreading him for quite awhile until the later part of the game where he became obvscum. It might be happening now, and I have no way to find out.



Look at how defensive she is. And I wrote a pretty big case against her for a game with less than ten pages. You read that, didn't you?

Hmm, maybe you shouldn't town-read people so quickly. Shinobi really hasn't done much. I feel like you're town-reading people to appease.

Defensiveness does not equal scum. I did read your case and I agreed with it. I just don't agree with the conclusion that she is scum because of it.

Maybe. The content in this game is very little and it's affecting my results, I'm working with what I have. In a larger game, it would be very obvious to me who is town and not. I'm playing Uncle Sonic to appease, by the way, so you're not totally wrong.

Defensiveness does equal scum. Active lurking also equals scum. Not contributing to the town despite being here =

refusing

to contribute = scum. What else? Right. Having bad reactions when one is being put at L-3 at page 7 probably adds quite a few scumpoints too.

[Metal Sonic]

Maybe. The content in this game is very little and it's affecting my results, I'm working with what I have. In a larger game, it would be very obvious to me who is town and not. I'm playing Uncle Sonic to appease, by the way, so you're not totally wrong.

Defensiveness does equal scum. Active lurking also equals scum. Not contributing to the town despite being here =

refusing

to contribute = scum. What else? Right. Having bad reactions when one is being put at L-3 at page 7 probably adds quite a few scumpoints too.

I agree that we have too many people not contributing.

I am a defensive player. So many people misinterpret this as scummy. It's not always the case. Active lurking I agree is scummy, which is why I have asked GM to actually do something.

You don't think someone has the right to react badly if they are put to L-3 after 7 pages when half the votes on them are RVS votes?

That's cause they can't differentiate between town-defensive and scum-defensive.


Likewise, she reacted scummily-badly. One can react well or react badly. Bad is synonymous for scum, by the way.

Nobody has the right to react badly. They have the right to react, but never react badly. If one reacts badly, one is likely scum.

That is pretty much it.

[Metal Sonic]

"Boo hoo, gm hasn't read these fucking pages yet" WELL EFFORT IS NOT AND HAS NEVER BEEN INDICATIVE OF ALIGNMENT

lol, cut the bullshit lol, both you and i know what's going on and you know that i perfectly understand "EFFORT IS NOT AND HAS NEVER BEEN INDICATIVE OF ALIGNMENT"

go throw the wool over the newbie's eyes if you want though i actually want to see your flail

[Metal Sonic]

it's almost like i care about solving the game and you don't

yeah we all can see that you care a fuckton

[Metal Sonic]

See, I actually quite like that post. It screams "NEWBTOWN" in neon letters.

Toffee pressures Metal Sonic

Metal Sonic tells Toffee to leave him alone


I don't like this at all. Town should be fine with scumhunting, even if it's on them (since they can say all their thoughts; as town, they have nothing to hide). Also, the uncle sonic thing bugs me.

Will post more when I have time

/!\ NEW PLAYER ALERT /!\

you copy me or something?

[Metal Sonic]

I am doing something. That something just doesn't extend to pages 3-4 atm.

you can post giant wall to cover your ass but refuse to read 2 pages? you know how ridiculous you sound?

like, its not pages 30-40, its 3-4. even a first grader can read that in the amount of time you took to make 210. theme games can make 2 pages in an hour. what, you don't play theme games? DA-MN!



guns are out baby, Uncle Sonic is here to catch the big scum in the sonic-net!

[Metal Sonic]

lets lay this on the table

you think that you've been caught for the wrong reasons and now you're throwing a hissy fit.

reaction test - bam!

[Metal Sonic]

Genius.

Lynch goodmorning she is quite scum

[Metal Sonic]

Vc first

[Metal Sonic]

No. Zebulon is a new + bad player but he is town.

He is mislynch bait, do not take it.

[Metal Sonic]

I don't have so many votes on me :/ count properly


For example, Peabody is voting BBT not me

[Metal Sonic]

And I think there were more ppl voting goodmorning

[Metal Sonic]

Overzealous and naive.

[Metal Sonic]

Josh's play is way more impressive than what happened in Marvel Avengers.


Bluebloodedtoffee, come to your senses please. Uncle Sonic is being very patient with you!

[Metal Sonic]

Zebulon is mislynch fodder and I'm sticking to that pretty adamantly. No lynching him today. Or ever.


See him, still a 'Goon', not even mafia scum

[Metal Sonic]

Umm I think that the masons can recruit every night let me check

[Metal Sonic]

Oh, shit.

[Metal Sonic]

I mean, yeah, it's only a one-shot cop. Not a multiple night thing. Poop.

[Metal Sonic]

You're good though. Super town. Screw Toffee and let's hunt scum together.

[Metal Sonic]

You are a lot of a hypocrite, lol. Agreeing with that now.

[Metal Sonic]

Too bad hypocritism isn't a scum tell, just a bad attitude.

[Metal Sonic]

Toffee dude only plays micros.

:/

[Metal Sonic]

You are a good mod.


But a bad scum. Bad. Nasty bad.

[Metal Sonic]

Mr Peabody, can you get a more high res avatar pretty please?

[Metal Sonic]

Mr Peabody, can you get a more high res avatar pretty please?

But...

I had this for years...

But...

I like how you had your account before the movie came out xD



@Shinobi, yeah, BBT just 'doesn't get it'

[Metal Sonic]

Booooring~

[Metal Sonic]

Like, even if I have caught goodmorningscum, her partners will defend her so I am at an impasse!

Sure, lets wait till deadline

[Metal Sonic]

Like, even if I have caught goodmorningscum, her partners will defend her so I am at an impasse!

Sure, lets wait till deadline

Cool. If you know who her partners are, can you just tell us the scumteam and we can win the game? Or are you insinuating that anyone who doesn't sheep you is scum?

I mean, this looks like you're giving up pushing your case(?) because there's peeps who don't agree with you. I don't see the point in that.

If I know who her partners are, then I must be the mod!

[Metal Sonic]

Sweet postbit.

[Metal Sonic]

My vote is still on her. I don't see a problem

[Metal Sonic]

I don't like your avatar

I don't like how slow sonic is.

[Metal Sonic]

No sonics are very fast

[Metal Sonic]

You are very narrow minded you know

[Metal Sonic]

Did nobody ever tell you this

[Metal Sonic]

I have been trying to figure out how dense you are so I can gauge how blunt must I be with you

[Metal Sonic]

Good morning is very sharp and smart

But scum



Josh is on all the right notes for me for this game

[Metal Sonic]

Zebulon is very new; since this is an open game I'm not down for policy lynching that dude


I saw newb town

[Metal Sonic]

Meanwhile good morning is pro scum can we terminate her before she rips the town to pieces?

[Metal Sonic]

Zebulon is very new; since this is an open game I'm not down for policy lynching that dude


I saw newb town

Zebulon is very new; since this is an open game I'm not down for lynching that dude


I saw newb town

^I agree.

Interesting. What makes your reads newb town and not newb scum?

NPAU:

Come on back to the party. We miss you and you should come contribute more.

Zebulin:

Keep your reads lists in the thread, please. It goes along with the whole not-editing-posts thing. Also goes along with not talking about the game outside of it. Just keep everything game related in this thread and you're good.

Btw, finished my ISO reads. Mostly the same as before. Notable changes: Mala and Shinobi look a little better upon closer examination. (Mala's (329) sets off a few red flags, but meh.)

Newb scums are obvious scums

Newb towns are vi

[Metal Sonic]

Alright. That's a fair enough point for the moment. Why are you pushing a lynch on goodmorning again? What makes a scum GM opposed to a town GM to you? Gimme something good.

"I dont have meta on goodmorning. But she's checking lots of stuff on my scum-catcher-checklist. You shall take it for a fact that my scum-catcher-checklist is infallible.

Of course, she is a good player, after I have caught her she has been more careful and has ceased to drop any more scumtells.

If this is going to be like pulling teeth, then we will just let the masons (attempt to) recruit her tonight and be done with it.

[Metal Sonic]

Uncle Sonic's Scumhunting List!

~Uncle Sonic~

Metal Sonic

Good!

Josh_B
BlueBloodedToffee
Zebulin
Malakittens
Shinobi

Maybe good?

Huntress
Peabody
Scripten
nopointactingup

No Read

Ucitron
hephaestus

No Good!

goodmorning

[Metal Sonic]

BlueBloodedToffee,

Who do you think is the towniest at the moment? Help me fix my read list. ^

Maybe there is a townread that needs to sit up there, but is in my No Read or Maybe Town section.

[Metal Sonic]

Oh, and as a side note:

This is not related to mafia in any way

Just a request,

Scripten, can you please change your avatar? Thanks.

[Metal Sonic]

Annoying you makes him scum?

For him it might. When I was scum partners with him he walked the thin line of my patience. I ended up blowing up his hydra partner in thread with my engaging which then got me frustrated. So yes him being annoying could potentially be a scum tell for him. I don't know for sure.

When was this?

[Metal Sonic]

Scripten, can you please change your avatar? Thanks.

I suppose I could. What needs changed about it?

It looks like a bad demon thing. Ew

[Metal Sonic]

Wow that was a looong time ago.



Recent examples are more of xmen and marvel avengers

[Metal Sonic]

"Why the hell are you being so douchey-baggy."

Best.

[Metal Sonic]

Npau has suddenly become a scum read based on 439.

And he is easier to kill than goodmorning

vote npau

[Metal Sonic]

ok beast you really have to get more updated with the vote counts preferably one every 5 pages at least or else people are going to replace out

Because I have a good interest to replace out myself :/ but I am staying because /support the charizard/

[Metal Sonic]

If npau is town then Hephaestus is conf scum

This is a factual logic conclusion

[Metal Sonic]

Npau is still likely scum


I have no motivation to write cases just go lynch him just go

[Metal Sonic]

Why don't you hate the wagon?

MS, how did you come to that conclusion?

he is happy to vote me or npau

if both of us are town, he is happy to vote town

and that is only what scum will do

[Metal Sonic]

MS - Are you still town-reading Mala?

And scum-reading GM?

yes and yes. I have static reads. Unless a player has made something that definitively makes me want to reconsider their alignment, they will remain static in my readslist.


So this method is flawed in that there might be scum in my townpile. But it has a 100% rate of catching scum correctly so you're gonna have to trust me on that one

>hence goodmorning should die but *shrugs* she is skilled <

[Metal Sonic]

I am happy to have a gm wagon

VOTE: gm

[Metal Sonic]

MS - Are you still town-reading Mala?

And scum-reading GM?

yes and yes. I have static reads. Unless a player has made something that definitively makes me want to reconsider their alignment, they will remain static in my readslist.


So this method is flawed in that there might be scum in my townpile. But it has a 100% rate of catching scum correctly so you're gonna have to trust me on that one

>hence goodmorning should die but *shrugs* she is skilled <

Isn't the 100% rate of catching scum bit a little brash? Don't see how this can be correct if there are scum in the town pile, unless you're trying to claim you never put town in the scum pile.

Yeah the latter

[Metal Sonic]

Which is why your top (and only) 3 scumreads in your post 905 Suburban Warfare readslist were TOTALLY NOT ALL TOWN OR ANYTHING, NOPE.

And it's not like the majority of your votes in that game were on Town or anything, NUH-UH.

this is totally not a steaming pile of lies and bullshit everyone

fucking totally

The end game one had chamber and shinobi and the only scum I missed was marquis

Besides I played shit that game go find another example

[Metal Sonic]

That *early* game

[Metal Sonic]

Not 'voted'


That's a grand misrep bro

I'm pretty sure some of my votes in this game landed on many town


How about... 'Pushed strongly'

[Metal Sonic]

'Pushed strongly and resulted in a lynch'

[Metal Sonic]

I'm not gonna argue this point though

The point is lynch gm

[Metal Sonic]

Don't try to bait me into looking arrogant u scumbag :p

[Metal Sonic]

So BBT, how about that reads list? You seem so obsessed about what everyone else thinks, but seem to be dispensing your own ideas with a dropper.

OK Dave, because I am town I will comply with what I see as a very reasonable request. I would expect others to do the same had I asked such a pro-town and game-progressing question.

Town

Pea
------
Dave
Huntress
Josh
------
Scripten
Uct
Heph
------
MS
------
NPAU
Mala
GM

Scum

Did you say something about huntress being scummy or something earlier? Or did someone else say that?

Where is shinobi?

Why do you have Dave as a high town read?

[Metal Sonic]

MS, multiple people have taken issue with this post;

Npau has suddenly become a scum read based on 439.

And he is easier to kill than goodmorning

vote npau

Do you have a response?

I agree that I worded it strangely

But they are picking a mountain out of a molehill. Besides, if my read on npau is right, naturally his partners will try to save him. Well, partner, since gm is immobilized right now by my scum catching magic lasso


And then there are also the inquisitive/curious/naive/over zealous/dumb town

[Metal Sonic]

I just ISO'd myself.

I didn't like some of Huntress' early posting but that's about it, I'm fairly confident she is town at this moment.

Nice. Except that I have been calling huntress town since the start of the game but at least you are improving

[Metal Sonic]

Why is the deadline so disgustingly long lol

[Metal Sonic]

Lol 3 weeks deadline

when I was running Artemis fowl mafia the deadline was 14 days and even there was losers replacing out like nobody's business, lol @21 days for a 13 player game seriously??

[Metal Sonic]

Shit, can't change deadline in the middle of a game


/annoyed

[Metal Sonic]

You should only feel good when you get NKed, cause if you are getting lunged it means your play is bad or you are really scum

Why would you feel good to get lynched?

[Metal Sonic]

UNVOTE:


I hate terrible play from pple like you -___-


VOTE: npau

[Metal Sonic]

And when you get shot in the night it means scum feels that you are a threat.


I hate getting lynched because it reflects poorly on myself and I have been trying to minimize that ever happening since 2013

[Metal Sonic]

Masons should recruit goodmorning tonight to 'cop' her and we should lynch npau today

[Metal Sonic]

jesus ms stop.

also im getting cold feet on a gm lynch surprisingly.

going to UNVOTE: gm

going to get my ducks in a row and then sort something out in my head and then present it to the jury.

See you after work

Yea cold feet

[Metal Sonic]

EFFORT IS NOT AND HAS NEVER BEEN INDICATIVE OF ALIGNMENT

my scumread on hephaestus is mainly based on him being 100% useless.

You're a funny gal

This is a post that makes my feet much warmer about lynching good morning

[Metal Sonic]

Gm best lynch, npau safest lynch

[Metal Sonic]

too many walls that i dont feel like reading




/moralegoingdown

[Metal Sonic]

yea

[Metal Sonic]

they are beating around the bush and circlejerking i dont like that

[Metal Sonic]

i don't want to lynch him cause his avatar is colorful and nice

[Metal Sonic]

lol



the real reason is

i am going to entertain lynching from gm/npau today

[Metal Sonic]

they are beating around the bush and circlejerking i dont like that

I will just skim ok

[Metal Sonic]

i dont rly care lalalala

[Metal Sonic]

YEA

[Metal Sonic]

You're scummy because you are acting scummy

damn!

[Metal Sonic]

if i replace out and request access to spoilers i think it would make it very easier wouldn't it

i just want to know if im right

[Metal Sonic]

i like how this is going to hit 40 pages though, i thought we were in a shithole from the looks of the first 72 hours

[Metal Sonic]

Because if you're town and think you have caught scum, why even think of replacing out? If you're town and think you're right about town, you'd stay to play the next day and catch the scum on the wagon.

no, i just dont give enough fucks to do that

if i have caught scum i can just look at the answer key and be done with all the stupid lynching



worse than pulling teeth

[Metal Sonic]

that is actually a towny-sounding 'before death' post

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: josh

[Metal Sonic]

Yeah beast was ok. Long deadlines got too boring though


Ha gm gotcha

[Metal Sonic]

i am VERY SAD you did not follow up with this :'(

Up to page 27.

Liking Huntress more after reading more of her.

Liked Shinobi's attempt to act as a peacemaker between BBT and Mala in 583. This sort of thing shows town most of the time.

Changed my mind about the Zebulin slot. Liking davesaz a lot.

Not quite sure about uctriton, but he slighly leans towards town.

hephaestus is most likely scum.

My other reads remain the same.

goodmorning/Peabody/hephaestus is my first guess at a scumteam.

--

Pausing for a while as I have to go, will continue reading soon.

[Metal Sonic]

toffee obv mason lololol

i was very frustrated

[Metal Sonic]

How are you town-reading Shinobi?

PEdit - what has she done that is scummy?

I don't have any good answers besides "He looks town". He did mention that he "burned" me in another game, that was half-true. I was townreading him for quite awhile until the later part of the game where he became obvscum. It might be happening now, and I have no way to find out.



Look at how defensive she is. And I wrote a pretty big case against her for a game with less than ten pages. You read that, didn't you?


PS: I just realised that goodmorning is female. Then I tried to go to her GTKAS to attempt to find out her age (out of curiosity). It wasn't put there so I had to guess.

Josh's play is way more impressive than what happened in Marvel Avengers.


Bluebloodedtoffee, come to your senses please. Uncle Sonic is being very patient with you!

You're good though. Super town. Screw Toffee and let's hunt scum together.

BlueBloodedToffee,

Who do you think is the towniest at the moment? Help me fix my read list. ^

Maybe there is a townread that needs to sit up there, but is in my No Read or Maybe Town section.