InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Nero Cain]

so anyways...the reason why I suggested doing a limited mass claim is 'cause well my role pm says "you count as a human". I think its sort of silly to tell me that I'm a human and then tell me that I count as a human, its kinda like duh. So it makes me think there's some purpose its there, like this game has maybe specific race counts or something...idk. Or it could just mean nothing and I'm reading in to much. Discuss.

[Nero Cain]

teehee!

[Nero Cain]

Why do you think humans are guaranteed inno?

[Nero Cain]

Yeah mine says I count as my race

interesting....

[Nero Cain]

if a massclaim went down D1, it would be the Frodo, sam, pippin, merry, bilbo, legolas, boromir aragorn, gimli, elrond, galadriel, treebeard, smeagol. this is not broken in any way at all. you're welcome to try and guess which of these 13 is a scum fakeclaim.

Aren't those all pretty mainish characters except for maybe like the last 4? Who were the fake claims?

[Nero Cain]

Can you guys not speculate on who the fakeclaims are, let Shos answer in his next post.

[Nero Cain]

Yeah mine says I count as my race

interesting....

Why? A few others have said the same

Who? I must have missed this

Nero, the fakeclaims were Legolas, Gimli, and Galadriel. There were also some other fakeclaims that didn't make sense with the rest of the game design, like Tom Bombadil and Sauron. The three we chose were the only possible ones to choose.

-Bulba

this makes me think Shos is scum again. Those are some p important characters so like shos' "a main character can't be a fake claim" is p silly.

[Nero Cain]

yes, explain.

[Nero Cain]

Nero, Majiffy in 3025. You in 3021. I think Shos said it somewhere

ignore this, I misread your post

[Nero Cain]

mhork?

[Nero Cain]

vote:BOP

[Nero Cain]

oh oh oh oh, can I guess?

[Nero Cain]

Why?

[Nero Cain]

ok

guilty on abomination

[Nero Cain]

I'm helping to get scum Titus lynched, I'm helping to get scum Titus lynched , I'm helping to get scum Titus lynched

[Nero Cain]

I voted you 'cause you tried hard to not get lemi lynched and you are therefore a good possible buddy.

That claim a guilty on me is fucking stupid but i'd still v1 you.

[Nero Cain]

I could ask you the same thing

[Nero Cain]

*yawn* your scum team along with shit players like AP couldn't mislynch me yesterday, it won't happen today.

[Nero Cain]

ok, why am I scummy?

[Nero Cain]

we can lynch neil scum tomorrow, but tonight we dine on birds (of prey)

[Nero Cain]

neil, how do you know lemi?

[Nero Cain]

lol

[Nero Cain]

there's no guilty on abomination. idk, Tituscum was being really strange and wanted me to fake a guilty for some reason so I did. Now help us lynch the birds.

[Nero Cain]

Did BOP just soft claim????

Also

VOTE: Nero Cain

I was sort of fooled by Shannon, but after it was all said and done, I knew I was biased. Damnitt. Never again.

Lynch BoP first.

Don't put your vote on a useless place.

Unless you want to be noosed in the incoming days after the birds are dead.

- b -

You think I'm scum?

[Nero Cain]

NC is tonw.

[Nero Cain]

I know it was meant to say town, I'm just a lil' wary that you'd call me town after calling me scum all yesterday.

[Nero Cain]

you also aren't helping to lynch BOP and that is sad face. What are you thinking there?

[Nero Cain]

????????

[Nero Cain]

crumbs=//=town

+

This "claim a guilty on me" is really stupid but we can still 1v1, now go self vote.

[Nero Cain]

Neil, you have 1 post to call it a joke or be scumfirmed when I clsim/flip.

I see that scum decided to bus

[Nero Cain]

Shos, why do you have a town read on me?

[Nero Cain]

b/c there's like a zillion scum in this game and we can only lynch one a day so today we'll do BOP. We can do all of Kat, Neil, Jiffy and maaayyybbbe Shos in the next coing days.

[Nero Cain]

I still think Shos could be scum but you tunneling him all day and doing nothing else doesn't exactly fill me with confidence.

[Nero Cain]

Why?? Pointless votes on those 2 right now.

She's wrong as fuck about me but Jiffy isn't exactly horrible, just not who we are wagoning today. Maybe Mhork and SG.

[Nero Cain]

yeah....p sure that I am NOT doing that

[Nero Cain]

and how is that using unflipped associates to suggest that you are scummy for totes tunneling on Shos all day?

[Nero Cain]

She's saying that all her "fake claim a guilty on me" We should lynch her, then Jiffy.

[Nero Cain]

Are you saying she has scaly skin?

[Nero Cain]

and how is that using unflipped associates to suggest that you are scummy for totes tunneling on Shos all day?

Because you're saying Shos is town because you think I'm scum. And I'm not scum.

no I didn't. I called you scum, you said you weren't and then I explained that you tunneling on Shos all day doesn't fill me with confidence. That has nothing t do with Shos and everything to do with why I was scumreading you.

She's saying that all her "fake claim a guilty on me" We should lynch her, then Jiffy.

Lynch who and why? Because I'm not following your tardlogic.

BOP claims ascetic and that she was crumbing that.
Mists asks where she was crumbing that.
I told mist that all her "claim a guilty on me" were crumbs. She could have others but I know those were designed as crumbs.
The part that says "We should lynch her, then Jiffy." Is my belief that we should lynch BOP today and you tomorrow.

[Nero Cain]

Do y'all seriously think I'm that vain?

yes

[Nero Cain]

and how is that using unflipped associates to suggest that you are scummy for totes tunneling on Shos all day?

Because you're saying Shos is town because you think I'm scum. And I'm not scum.

She's saying that all her "fake claim a guilty on me" We should lynch her, then Jiffy.

Lynch who and why? Because I'm not following your tardlogic.

I am beginning to think [ongoing].

I enjoy the fact that you are parroting his bullshit

[Nero Cain]

says that guy that can't make a fake case on me

[Nero Cain]

yea...you aren't reading this thread at all are you?

[Nero Cain]

She's saying that all her "fake claim a guilty on me" We should lynch her, then Jiffy.

Doesn't shos effectively have an innocent result on Majiffy? So if you think Majiffy is scum, shouldn't you be voting shos first?

really? I don't remember that. So i'll look in a min. Why should I vote Shos if I'm voting BOP who has a bigger wagon?

[Nero Cain]

Played much with katsuki?

Nope

I have but it's been a while. Geists is probably suggesting that this is a lurker lynch.

I think giests is saying that this is normal anti-town/dgaf kat

Also Egg, Shos claims to have targeted jiffy but his action did nothing. Can you explain how this is an inno?

[Nero Cain]

then utility lynch it

[Nero Cain]

I'll admit that I sometimes need things explained to me newbie style. Sew kan u explain 2 me how shos' no duel zult is an inno?

[Nero Cain]

meh, idk. I think a 7 person mafia in a 28 game is low adding in an sk only gives us 8 which makes for a 20/7/1 setup is probable. Someone also suggested than the bo7 ITG weren't 7 members. And AD and someone else says that their pms suggests that this is multiball. I'm also relatively certain that Beast claimed psn doc, weather that's sk kill flavor or a 2nd scum team, idk.

But I also HIGHLY doubt that the only scum are undead. So ok, I can see Jiffy half confirmed.

[Nero Cain]

If all scums are undead and shos checked, shouldn't shos be getting a result and not Majiffy?

the way I read Shos's role claim is that he learns races when targeted and that his "vig" is actually more like a role thief thing.

[Nero Cain]

I'm beginning to doubt Elf is scum, so no.

What do you think of molla saying that he doubts his and elfs role don't exist together?

[Nero Cain]

that wouldn't confirm two people

[Nero Cain]

can we just lynch BOP

or Mhork

or SG

or Bulba

or neil

or abomination

or mist

or kat

or jiffy

I don't have town reads on any of those

[Nero Cain]

shos, why am I a townread for you now?

[Nero Cain]

Mala why are you scumreading Majiffy?

you really don't understand what's scummy about Jiffy pushing a shos lynch all day and nothing else?

[Nero Cain]

I deff would love Shroom to be strung up with a close second at Abom

agree with abom but I'm kinda fence sity on Shroomish. Like I didn't really like Klick but there was something from shroomish that I really liked so...idk.

Don't get me wrong, I like the Nero case and have a gut read on him.

Sorry, bro. That "case" on me is shit and you should feel dumb for buying SG's shit. Me pointing out that SG switched her reads on Abom is pro-town 'cause that's like what town is supposed to do. Her getting pissy and saying that I'm somehow scummy for pointing this out is NOT a town reaction. The other part, about my not pushing her right off the bat is just more discredit.

[Nero Cain]

really liking how Shos is avoiding why he has a town read on me.

[Nero Cain]

You are one of those who I can actuallykeep track of. You are active, consistent and do not bullshit (too much), whereas most of the other players in this game are significantly less in my memory.

is this to me?

Me pointing out that SG switched her reads on Abom is pro-town 'cause that's like what town is supposed to do. Her getting pissy and saying that I'm somehow scummy for pointing this out is NOT a town reaction. The other part, about my not pushing her right off the bat is just more discredit.

You still haven't managed to point out how what you did was pro-town, and it's kinda wonky to then toss in the word 'discredit' since thats what you were doing with your 'pro-town' call out in the first place as that is the beginning and end of what you were doing with it.

I think its town play 101 to see a contradiction and go "huh"? If you were town you'd agree but you aren't so...

Also me pointing out your contradiction isn't a discredit at all.

[Nero Cain]

vote:neil

he and lemi prob have the same alignment.

[Nero Cain]

And with the universal read pretty much of everyone who's commented on Nero except one person, Nero is already pretty much confirmed suspicious

If you are town then you should stop listening to scum. I don't think any townies have ever suspected me.

[Nero Cain]

u ain't gonna mislynch me, bro.

[Nero Cain]

This is weak, but I didn't really like Nero's move on you in any case.

*shrugz*

I've had a scumread on his slot the whole game. Neil being an over reactive condensing asshole kinda looks like his play from Star Wars but meh, even if he's town then he's not going to help the town. Though specifically, I didn't like his numerous question dodges, he sorta defends lemmi so possible buddy me thinks.

[Nero Cain]

always called Clyton town, I assume that's what he's referring to

[Nero Cain]

I am really glad that OS replaced into a scum slot.

[Nero Cain]

eh, not voting. Lets see if you can change my mind.

[Nero Cain]

But Neil is more scummy?

sure? Not sure how one scum is "scumier" than the other scum but...atleast for Neil we have him defending lemi so I think that could be a possible buddy and an OS town offers more upside than a Neil town. + I don't like how you and him are pretending like I'm not confirmed NOT bo7. I'm town but from the perspective of any outsider not privvy to my role pm I think this would point to me being less likely to be scum.

[Nero Cain]

him is Neil but...gut read on me plox and why.

[Nero Cain]

I don't like how you and him are pretending like I'm not confirmed NOT bo7. I'm town but from the perspective of any outsider not privvy to my role pm I think this would point to me being less likely to be scum.

I would think I'm as confirmed on that as you are - you still suspect me. Or is it only scummy when other people do it to you?

I musta missed it when Rhaego/Lemi was voting you.

[Nero Cain]

shos
BulbaFenix
Squirrel Girl
notscience
Birds of Prey
Majiffy
neil1113
xofelf
^
b07 scum?

[Nero Cain]

Nope, Im town. Try again.

maybe. That's literally a list of the whole game - my town reads and those that were voted by rhaego/lemi

[Nero Cain]

I'll do a full catchup later but I instantly dislike the shroomish wagon 'cause there's only one town read on it. Neil or BOP seem the best lynches for the day.

[Nero Cain]

No one is talking about me 'cause I'm town you dumbo. SQ is just pissed that A.) I made her look like a moron B.) outted her as scum I lean a little more towards B but yeah.

[Nero Cain]

yeah, # of votes=/=alignment.

[Nero Cain]

Why would I vote you when I have scumreads with traction? but I have mentioned you as a lynch candidate today so my only assumption is that you are trying hard as fuck to discredit everything I say.

[Nero Cain]

Were you just blowing smoke with the 'outted scum' thing, or do you honestly believe I am outted scum?

I think you are very likely to be scum yes. That whole "no u are the scummy one for pointing out my contradiction" doesn't seem like a really townie reaction.

This arrogance is exactly what makes me want to lynch you. The fact that you tip toe around a certain fact that is mostly obscured from the town's eyes and pretend like it makes you town. If you're going to want to make me believe it (or the other's that have pestered you about it) then out right,

say it

. Otherwise, you aren't

confirmed

town.

In other news, Mist continues to fish more than scumhunt as far as the Neil situation goes.
People continue to have votes on Neil.

I don't exactly have a town read on Mist but that's not fishing.

[Nero Cain]

my guess is a reviver but why does it matter?

[Nero Cain]

VOTE:mIST

lets get one more vote then hear a claim.

[Nero Cain]

VOTE:mIST

lets get one more vote then hear a claim.

What do you think a claim will accomplish?

I'd like to vote for mist before I go to sleep so someone can unvote before I do or I can just hammer her.

So we should just lynch without a claim? pfft

I mean, IDK, there's prob not enough time time get a counter wagon if we like her claim or w/e. I dislike some of the company but that could be scum bussing her...its just doesn't feel right to be like "i don't care about your claim or anything else you have to say and we are lynching you."

Why do you want her lynched without giving her a chance to claim/get any final thoughts out?

[Nero Cain]

you do know that Abomination is scum, right?

[Nero Cain]

Does it matter? So she sits at L-1 (I'm assuming that you or someone will vote her) for however long till close to dl. Are you afraid she'll give you and the rest of your scumbuddies away or something? I see no reason why we shouldn't wait on her to claim/give any last minute thoughts.

Why do you want her lynched without giving her a chance to claim/get any final thoughts out?

+

Why are you not voting her?

[Nero Cain]

I'm mostly worried well no lynch

your fears are super unjustified.

[Nero Cain]

That and there's a ton of ppl not voting (mist) and its nearly impossible that one of those won't get on in 8 hours. This is NOT the lurky game he's pretending it is. + he's not even voting after whining about getting on the wagon...

[Nero Cain]

but at the same time, if he was so worried about a nl...why not hammer when he had the chance?

I am soooooooooooooooooo glad I have bullets this game.

[Nero Cain]

Who do you want me to kill tonight, Goat?

[Nero Cain]

1. Lord Mhork
5. BulbaFenix
6. Oversoul
7. Squirrel Girl
9. notscience
11. Birds of Prey
16. Majiffy
20. neil1113
21. Abomination
^^^^
those are my preferred targets.

but I might compromise on

3. shos
18. Always
26. xofelf
28. HighShroomish

choose wisely, goat.

[Nero Cain]

Nero, wtf you up to

I want my town reads to help me pick whom I should kill. Is there anyone from my list that you want dead?

[Nero Cain]

fair enough. I'll just shoot randomly from my list then.

[Nero Cain]

They could be scum:
Squirrel Girl (don't really see the towniness from this one)
Svenskt Stal (does this person earnestly contribute to the game?)
The Goat
Neil1113 (I did not like his interactions with Leminiscate, still think he possibly recruited her to play the game to be scums together)

Scummy:
BBmolla (has done literally nothing this entire game)
ProHawk (didn't like him trying to take credit for Lem)
Venmar (has done exceptionally nothing this game except be super brusque with people, I can't remember if this is Venmar town meta though)
Mist7676 (super defensive unnecessarily)

1. Lord Mhork
5. BulbaFenix
6. Oversoul
7. Squirrel Girl
9. notscience
11. Birds of Prey
16. Majiffy
20. neil1113
21. Abomination
^^^^
those are my preferred targets.

Well, we share SG and Neil.


Other than Mist, I really don't think any of those guys are scum. (the ones on your list)

Bulb is somewhat lurky and robotic. Bulb town is a bigger presence.
I think Abomination is incredibly scummy. You don't even need to look far, just look at that crap over this Mist wagon.
I TOTES disagree with Fery that Jiffy town meta says he'd tunnel on a single player all day. I'll have to look but I don't understand why he stopped pushing Shos.
I think this only really makes sense if they knew that she was blocked.
I kinda agree with you about TSO looking like POA (so you may have a point there) but I have some niggles about NS.
I'll discuss Mhork later.

Why should I be town reading those players?

[Nero Cain]

I'm sure Nero's around somewhere as well. That should handle it.

I'm already on. You to help me lynch abomination tomorrow.

[Nero Cain]

Nero, what's up? What'd you do last night? What happened?

your team blocked me.

[Nero Cain]

SG came in around 689, when Nero talked about her when not talking about other people, he said he wanted her gone, but didn't put her in any of his to-die or scum-reads lists until something like 2346

Are you stupid or scum? She'd been in every single "kill list"

vote:Shroom

There's a load of scum motivation to blatantly lie and play revisionist.

[Nero Cain]

i have had enough of this retarded game, bye forever

so replace out

[Nero Cain]

Why is NS town?

[Nero Cain]

neil, please explain..? if you got a guilty, claiming would be beneficial right now imo.

I agree! 'cause then you guys would lynch me but I'm going to flip town which confirms Neil as scum.

[Nero Cain]

Mala please control Neil.

Why would Mala control Neil?

BoP... lynch all liars philosophy. It doesn't help town at all, especially this early on in the game. It'd be different halfway through the game. Or with less people.

How is NC lying though?

This pretty yuck though. Its p obvious what Neil is getting at. I softclaim vig, no shot hence in his black and white mind I am "lying".

[Nero Cain]

It doesn't though. Just like his case on you is silly, the reverse of 'only scum would push this silly case' is equally silly.
It's easily possible he's crazy town who believes what he's selling. Frankly, as scum, i would tend to expect him to believe that town would sell what he's selling - so all we've established from him is that he generally does believe what he's saying. That's not a valid scumtell.

So if he were to claim a guilty on me and then I get lynched and flip town, you'd let him live?

[Nero Cain]

It affects what you said above 'cause I never said ANYTHING about "well he has to be scum 'cause this case is so cray cray"

What WAS said is that shos said that Neil should claim a guilty if he has one and I said that I agreed that he should so you guys can lynch him when I flip town. Its your 4439 that doesn't make any sense in the conversation.

[Nero Cain]

NS, have you ever played with Goat?

[Nero Cain]

Yes it is. He said that Nero was lying bc he crumbed vig. I was indicating I had no idea where Nero crumbed vig and to actually show that if he wants to claim Nero lied.

SG I don't know why you think NC is scum.

You should listen to scum here, SG. I fail to understand how OS is caught up but doesn't know why SG "suspects" me.

It affects what you said above 'cause I never said ANYTHING about "well he has to be scum 'cause this case is so cray cray"

What WAS said is that shos said that Neil should claim a guilty if he has one and I said that I agreed that he should so you guys can lynch him when I flip town. Its your 4439 that doesn't make any sense in the conversation.

*shrugz*

Am I giving you to much credit here? I would have thought you'd be able to follow the actual conversation so my only assumption is that this is fake derp.

[Nero Cain]

@Nero - no, he didn't claim a guilty on you,

and you acted like him buying the Vig claim and then being annoyed at it not being true = a scum case.

Your point was cray-cray whether you are aware of it or not. You not being aware of it just means you're unaware of your own craziness.

oh bullshit. Yes, I think Neil is p scummy, yes I think its possible that he's derp town. The conversation was literally

Shos: If you (Neil) have a guilty then you should claim it.
Nero: I agree that he should claim guilty b/c if he does he'll be lynched
SG: You calling Neil scum 'cause he's pushing a bad case on you is bad
Nero: I never actually said that...

I really don't see this coming from town. What it looks like is you ignoring the gamestate and defending Neil for town cred or he's your buddy.

So I'd like you to answer this for me: If you think that I'm scummy for wanting to lynch Neil if he claims a guilty on me, why would you also want to lynch Neil for claiming a guilty on me?

[Nero Cain]

Nero does this tunnel vision without a second thought to the logic all the damn time. Read Azkaban, Mainstream Mafia, and my other suicide games with Nero to understand.

Just keep trying to discredit me little scum.

TBF, I think you say and do stupid things ALOT. Your reactions to me in Azkaban were stupid, you DEFENDED scum in mainstream.

So you think I should just be like "ok! She said that she forgot her town read on Abomination, no way she's lying about that."?

[Nero Cain]

Mhork, why are you scum?

[Nero Cain]

Why are you parroting Neil here?

[Nero Cain]

regardless of alignment, you are a moron. ScumSG is sitting there and defending the fuck out of you with bullshit reasoning and you are just sitting there and ignoring her and EVERYTHING that's going on in this game in favor of "Nero is scum for x" and that's basically all you've said all game. Personally, I think you are pretty scummy but if you are town you'd be such a small lose, I mean fuck, even Goat is being more useful than you are.

[Nero Cain]

regardless of alignment, you are a moron. ScumSG is sitting there and defending the fuck out of you with bullshit reasoning and you are just sitting there and ignoring her and EVERYTHING that's going on in this game in favor of "Nero is scum for x" and that's basically all you've said all game. Personally, I think you are pretty scummy but if you are town you'd be such a small lose, I mean fuck, even Goat is being more useful than you are.

This doesn't make me feel good about you.

explain?

[Nero Cain]

You're advocating a policy lynch solely because Neil is scumreading you.

I've been scum reading that slot since Clyton and you (I'm assuming that I'm taking to Titus) should know how I feel about utility/policy lynches.

The last comment about Goat being more useful than he is just seems out of place, as if you would be trying to link the two together.

How in the world is that trying to connect Goat and Neil?

[Nero Cain]

The only "policy" that I ever really push often is a "I think you are scum and need to die" though I have been known to want to get rid of distracting/bad players.

Can you give me some examples of times that I've pushed a pl?

[Nero Cain]

Nero, you go after lynchbait all the time. Heck, your kill list in this game alone is primarily composed of less active players and people who disagree or scumread you. Let's be frank, the reason for most of those reads can be summed up as policy.

-Bulba

fool please. Stop your parroting of BOP.

[Nero Cain]

B/C IM NOT A VIG YOU STUPID ROLEFISHING FUCK

[Nero Cain]

now why don't you explain why it was important to know if I shot or not last night?

[Nero Cain]

Did I say I was a vig? I remember implying I had kill powers but I don't think I ever said I was a vig but tell me why you needed to know?

[Nero Cain]

So why am I scummy for that?

[Nero Cain]

oh shut up jiffy,he's obviously saying that 'cause I said I had killing powers that I was implying that I was a vig. Use common sense.

+

I'm really starting to think that Neil is not scum/not scum with Mhork since he's parroting the fuck out of him.

[Nero Cain]

Why are two town joats in a large impossible?

[Nero Cain]

Mastin is scum again isn't she?

[Nero Cain]

What made you town read Neil?

[Nero Cain]

That's kinda not my point. I'm asking why OS flipped her read.

[Nero Cain]

HIS!

[Nero Cain]

Nero, you go after lynchbait all the time. Heck, your kill list in this game alone is primarily composed of less active players and people who disagree or scumread you. Let's be frank, the reason for most of those reads can be summed up as policy.

-Bulba

fool please. Stop your parroting of BOP.

I'm not parroting BoP. It's something I've noticed you do regardless of alignment.

ok then. Lets say I do this regardless of alignment. I was scum reading Clyton on d1 and Neil hasn't done much to improve the slot. Titus ignores this and claims that this isn't true and you are just seemingly piling onto this defense of Neil. How are you not parroting here?

Sometimes lynch bait is you know...scum.

+

I wouldn't consider

1. Lord Mhork
5. BulbaFenix
6. Oversoul
7. Squirrel Girl
9. notscience
11. Birds of Prey
16. Majiffy
20. neil1113
21. Abomination
^^^^

alot of that lynch bait and the only two "lurkers" are neil and abomination.


Other than yourself, who do you disagree with and why?

Oh and bulba getting vigged tonight

Bring it SK, or do you think I've forgotten how for a supposed vig you were so accepting of Nero's vig soft claim.

How does that make him an sk?

he's not behaving like a townie that believes in what he's saying.

He's been dodging providing evidence to back up his claims. Obvious or not, he's not supporting his argument, just ranting on and on about how it's a slip.

I agree that his play is super horrible and wouldn't care if he dies. But today we are killing Shroomish and once the game is smaller we can kill the not mhork scum/town cancer.

No Nero, I haven't.

So why should Goat have a scum read on you for playing to your scum meta but not knowing your scum meta?

[Nero Cain]

Coughskcough

remind me why you stopped pushing Shos.

Alright night's vig is going to be either of {notscience, Bulbafenix}

pls add SG and Mhork to your pool of possible targets.

[Nero Cain]

s.

The last comment about Goat being more useful than he is just seems out of place, as if you would be trying to link the two together.

How in the world is that trying to connect Goat and Neil?

[Nero Cain]

pls add SG and Mhork to your pool of possible targets.

And oversoul and xof and we're perfect.

remind me of your XOF case. Why are you scum reading OS?

[Nero Cain]

s.

The last comment about Goat being more useful than he is just seems out of place, as if you would be trying to link the two together.

How in the world is that trying to connect Goat and Neil?

Goat hasn't exactly been useless, just what he posts tends to be scummy.

ok.....you think his posts are scummy so....me saying that Neil is less useful than Goat is connecting them?

*head explodes*

Maybe someone else can explain this to me 'cause I'm not getting it.

[Nero Cain]

You're connecting them by a) encouraging comparisons where Neil comes out townier than someone else widely suspected thus creating an "alternative" to lynching Neil, b) causing subsconscious associations to form regarding things that frankly aren't true and c) serves as a backhanded discredit to both slots as well.

but I'm town reading Goat so this connection shit is stupid and in my op I said "Goat is being more useful than you are." You being Neil and that is NOT me claiming Neil is townier than Goat as you contend.

[Nero Cain]

Then again Shos always calls me a boy too sooo~

We'll aren't you a tomBOY?

[Nero Cain]

re: Mhork: I dunno; I think that the fact that he *actually* prepared for a long time, in a way, the claim that there is an undead non-scum makes me sorta believe him. I don't think he should be our lynch or vig target. Mhork, if you're town, you should step up your game.

I was slightly suspicious of Mhork early game 'cause I think scum like to be "mb isn't confirmed, you slipped" but common sense says this game was very likely to have multile killing roles. He has some posts about being lost and not knowing whats going on and those read really fake. I also think his hop onto me is totes bullshit and 20x more likely to come from scum then town.

Why should I add SG to my viglist? she's a confirmed doublevoter, right?

Confirmed role=//= confirmed town.

I think SG is scum for wigging out when I noticed her flip on the Abomination alignment. I think her defending Neil is scummy as F all since she was avoiding the actual conversation and playing revisionist. Town doesn't or shouldn't do either of these.

[Nero Cain]

.

No Nero, I haven't.

So why should Goat have a scum read on you for playing to your scum meta but not knowing your scum meta?

OS, why are you town reading Neil?

[Nero Cain]

I'm p sure he was town reading you for some genuine frustration crap or something.

[Nero Cain]

What do I have to be frustrated about after I avoid the whole day

ummmm you were pissed that you were being scumread. Your question is like really really silly.

[Nero Cain]

vote:OS

Why are you town reading Neil?

[Nero Cain]

ok,

.

No Nero, I haven't.

So why should Goat have a scum read on you for playing to your scum meta but not knowing your scum meta?

OS, why are you town reading Neil?

Honestly I don't even care anymore because it is like people aren't even reading this game and the scum are bad if they haven't noticed this anyway.

It is pretty clear that Always + Neil are soft claiming masons with each other (at least). Mastin's assurance that some people are town I thought was him TRYING to fake claim mason early on as a crumb technique (which lol Lem foiled) but then Neil came to Always's defense when you were suggesting you would kill one of them.
I haven't had a look back at how either Neil or Always acted with Lem's claim, but I am not even sure that matters. I know I wouldn't have had a knee jerk vote reaction to kill Lem if I was a mason for fear that I was outting myself as a mason.

I've seen it but I'm not going to actually care unless they claim masons and even then? Scum fake claiming masons is still a possibility.

[Nero Cain]

OS, what made you think Kats was town?

[Nero Cain]

oh nm, you think its her town meta wich is generic and bland, meh.

Remind me of your reads mala?

[Nero Cain]

Alright night's vig is going to be either of {notscience, Bulbafenix}

Hear me.

You are absolutely, positively, not vigging NS tonight.

If you do, I will slaughter you and throw your worthless carcass into the street.

Okay?

You can back the fuck off me

holy fuck

listen to scum Goat, stop defending him.

[Nero Cain]

That sounds like a great idea

vote:NS

[Nero Cain]

kkk

(pick mhork)

[Nero Cain]

What is your case on him?

[Nero Cain]

I don't think he's scum.

i legit hate you

[Nero Cain]

*shrugz* maybe you are...deff strong hinting at a role that you think will somehow help the town. idk what to think.

[Nero Cain]

How is NC lying though?

This pretty yuck though. Its p obvious what Neil is getting at. I softclaim vig, no shot hence in his black and white mind I am "lying".

It doesn't though. Just like his case on you is silly, the reverse of 'only scum would push this silly case' is equally silly.
It's easily possible he's crazy town who believes what he's selling. Frankly, as scum, i would tend to expect him to believe that town would sell what he's selling - so all we've established from him is that he generally does believe what he's saying. That's not a valid scumtell.

It affects what you said above 'cause I never said ANYTHING about "well he has to be scum 'cause this case is so cray cray"

NICE CHERRY PICK! My "this is pretty yuck" was ob in response to BOP's 4430 but nice try trying to make it look like I was calling Neil scum over the cray cray case.

[Nero Cain]

neil

, please explain..?

if you got a guilty, claiming would be beneficial right now imo.

Here Shos says that Neil should claim a guilty on me if he has one.

I agree! 'cause then you guys would lynch me but I'm going to flip town which confirms Neil as scum.

Here, I agree that Neil should claim a guilty on me.

It doesn't though. Just like his case on you is silly, the reverse of 'only scum would push this silly case' is equally silly.

It's easily possible he's crazy town who believes what he's selling. Frankly, as scum, i would tend to expect him to believe that town would sell what he's selling - so all we've established from him is that he generally does believe what he's saying. That's not a valid scumtell.

here you are saying that nope it doesn't confirm him as scum (which IS really crazy 'cause you later go on to say that if he did claim a guilty we should lynch him after my town flip) which is ignoring the actual conversation that Neil would be confirmed scum if he claims a guilty on me.

[Nero Cain]

"BUT WAIT" she yells.

"4438 comes directly before 4439 so obviously my 4439 is responding to your 4438. Like Duh!"

Ok.

My 4438 was posted Wed Aug 06, 2014 7:12 pm
your 4439 was posted Wed Aug 06, 2014 7:13 pm

I kind of find it hard to believe that you both read my post and replied within a minute.

I also think that

I'm a Bird of Prey, I don't eat bread. I eat meat.

Crumbs are for Angry Pidgeons.

This isn't actually a reply to Nero's raised issue.

Shows that you understood that 4438 was highlighting an issue BOP and NOT calling Neil conf scum for his cray cray case as you later contend in 4647.

[Nero Cain]

Also, we should not lynch NS.

So why didn't you want NS lynched?

[Nero Cain]

yeah, the only thing Neil says about not wanting you lynched is that he doesn't think it would be profitable or w/e. I think it makes sense (to lynch you) to get Molla the shard 'cause he'd get more use out of it now vice later.

We should still be lynching out of Mhork, SG me thinks.

[Nero Cain]

abomination is a great lynch to.

[Nero Cain]

ok!

You are claiming that

It doesn't though. Just like his case on you is silly, the reverse of 'only scum would push this silly case' is equally silly.

is a response to

This pretty yuck though. Its p obvious what Neil is getting at. I softclaim vig, no shot hence in his black and white mind I am "lying".

I'm talking about why Neil thinks that I'm lying. I don't think that "It doesn't though." Really makes any kind of sense in reply to this.

neil, please explain..? if you got a guilty, claiming would be beneficial right now imo.

I agree! 'cause then you guys would lynch me but

I'm going to flip town which confirms Neil as scum

.

"It doesn't though" DOES make sense in reply to the bolded.

Town has no reason to lie, on this I agree with Neil. I'm pretty sure you are scum so I'm going to quit arguing with you. I kinda dislike how Shos doesn't want you dead 'cause you are a confirmed dv and I don't know if he's your buddy, other scum or just stupid.

[Nero Cain]

how did scum know you had a shard?

[Nero Cain]

I assume its some kind of power booster.

[Nero Cain]

He actually tries

I agree with this. Though I felt like Kat WAS half halfheartedly trying.

If shards pass via lynch hammer, then that presumably would be why NS would want to hammer. Guessing logically, that scum/vig kills can also steal shards. Otherwise, I cannot see two hammers and your role would be nonsensical. Having a townie pick who they want to hammer is logical.

I am so sad right now. I want like half the players dead. P sure all of Mhork, Bulb and SG are scum. Abom has a good chance of flipping scum. Still not a Jiffy fan. I'm back and forth on Shos. Like if he actually does vig scum then he's def town/other scum but his "SG is town 'cause she's a dv." is super dumb. BOP looks pretty scummy but Titus always says dumb things, still would lynch though. Mastin is 20x times more likely to lurk as scum and Mala hasn't done anything impressive so I'm a little worried there. Shroomsish is is just lurking off his suspicion so I think we should prob kill that. I 100% do not care if OS dies. Part of me is like well kill me and then you guys will know my reads are genuine. In order from strongest to weakest



SG
Mhork
Bulb
Abomination
Shroomish
BOP
Jiffy
OS
Mala
Shos

vote:abomination

[Nero Cain]

Nero I'm really, really town :/

tell me why I should have a town read on you?

@Y&B-ok, Titus is scum....who are her buddies?

[Nero Cain]

Compare Titus's play in this game: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=56559

to our current game here. BoP is not town; and it is incredibly frustrating to be unable to run her up.

- b -

No she's not scum

you are wrong I think. You might be right about Neil (he's aleast not on the team with Mhork and SG) but I have a pretty big issue with Titus not pushing Mhork but that's ongoing games so hush hush.

[Nero Cain]

because I'm town and my actions are town motivated?

hardly.

Like I really don't think

NEIL: NERO IS SCUM FOR LYING ABOUT A BEING A VIG!

mhork *squak* *sqwak* *squak* vote:Nero

has ANY town motivation. You aren't calling me scum despite that's where your vote is sitting which tells me that you were vote hoping. And if you don't think I'm scum then you are sidelining your vote which also has no town motivation. You'll prob claim that its a "pressure vote" which I think is a load of bunk.

[Nero Cain]

Mhork still not calling me scum 'cause he knows I'm not.

[Nero Cain]

Nero I know that you're lying

everyone one knows that I'm not a vig 'cause I said I wasn't.

and I know there's no town motivation to do so

and whats the scum motivation?

So my thoughts on this are that

I don't understand or think that TOWN would be pissed
I think this "lets talk about why you fake claimed vig" is really just Mhork trying to make it LOOK LIKE he's doing something. Why I fake soft hinted at being a vig is a conversation that I don't think has any game relevance.
I'm starting to think that this is really sneaky rolefishing and Mhork is trying to find out if I have bullets or how many.

[Nero Cain]

don't worry. Arguing with your scumbuddy isn't changing my mind on you.

[Nero Cain]

yes, I totes lack logic and I vote willy nilly like on EM.

[Nero Cain]

But I see how Nero could be classified as terrible town.

oh hehehe hahahaha

[Nero Cain]

Someone please vig neil.

I agree that Neil is useless and needs to go however, he claimed to have a shard so why vig him instead of lynching him to get molla the shard?

[Nero Cain]

getting Molla the shard seems far more beneficial then keeping one useless player around.

[Nero Cain]

Someone please vig neil.

I agree that Neil is useless and needs to go however, he claimed to have a shard so why vig him instead of lynching him to get molla the shard?

Why aren't you voting Shroomish?

I was earlier but Abomination is scum too so...

[Nero Cain]

I never claimed to have a shard.

TBF, I thought your post about having the same role as NS was a shard claim and I guess I sorta missed your claims that you didn't have a shard afterall.

You might be town but you are a stick in the mud and you're doing very little to help your supposed town wincon.

[Nero Cain]

Mhork, why did you not watch Shos on n1?

Though I still think that my "fakeclaim" is irrelevant. What if I were a vig and scum just didn't target me, would you still be mad then? This is why your "being pissed" is nothing more than bull.

[Nero Cain]

A) night 1 is a dumb night for actions in a massive game

What is the diffrence between n1 and n2?

B) I still don't understand what the fuck shos' role is and he's sketch as fuck.

He's a claimed self watching role thief. I don't think this is hard to understand and looks entirely fake.

I was trying to pressure you because

we

only had one shot and you weren't blocked or shot or anything.

Who is we?

[Nero Cain]

oh yuck.

[Nero Cain]

Mist7676 5 (geists, Serene2, Kagami, neil1113, The Goat)
The 3 players in black each have a 32% probability of being scum.

Will vote one of these 3 today:

30 TheGoat
30 Kagami
24 Lord Mhork

Why is Mhork her and not Neil?

[Nero Cain]

n

stop what?

When you're town and counterclaimed you want the other player dead.

kinda disagree. Similar roles is a p common mod tactic these days.

[Nero Cain]

n

stop what?

When you're town and counterclaimed you want the other player dead.

kinda disagree. Similar roles is a p common mod tactic these days.

STOP.
FUCKING.
CALLING.
FOR.
A.
VIG.
SHOT.
ON.
NEIL.

Are you like insane? True, I wouldn't give a shit if he dies but it was Jiffy that was actually calling for a vig, so why are you fusing at me and not him?

[Nero Cain]

The only think I agree with is Mhork is scum but everything else abom says is meh.

[Nero Cain]

truer words have never been spoken.

[Nero Cain]

I'm town reading Birds of Prey. On shroom, I was gut scum reading them, did an ISO, and changed my mind.

can you explain these plox.

So, like, me and Goat played with Sven in Nexus' WWE mafia. In that game he was active, friendly and jokey. This game not so much. I also played with Sven in Venmar's left for dead mafia. In l4d he was scum and NOT playing like he did in Nexus' WWE mafia. In this game he was again not playing to his WWE meta but I thought he came across as sort of townie with his "idgaf" type play here. I would have also expected someone who played with him in L4D to say something but no one did. I also do not like this scumputer crap 'cause I think it can be abused very easily. So I'm not really sure what to think there.

[Nero Cain]

4. ProHawk
8. beastcharizard
9. notscience
13. ActionDan
14. Kagami
15. Serene2
19. Young and Beautiful
22. The Goat
23. penguin_alien
24. BBmolla
26. xofelf
27. Egg

congratulations, I don't want ya'll dead yet.

[Nero Cain]

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

Spoiler: scum PMs

Greetings, notscience, you are

Cornelius Fudge, Ministry Mafia 2-shot Minister

, and your team mates are

bazinga, Lucius Malfoy

and

ArcAngel9, McNair

. You are also aware that there is a Dementor around, and that they are aligned with the Mafia, but do not have access to your QuickTopic. You guys, however, can discuss your plans at any time here. If you target the Dementor with a Night Kill, he will die.

'Come now Harry, the Ministry doesn't send people to Azkaban for blowing up their aunts.'

Abilities:

Minister (2-shot)

- Twice during the game, during a Day phase, you may PM me the names of two players. Those two players will then be chosen by you to go before the Dementor. That Night, the Dementor will decide which of the two he wishes to give the Dementor's Kiss to. This will Treestump that player the following Day, meaning they are unable to vote or take any actions, but are still able to talk in thread.

Kill

- During the Night you may choose someone that your team wishes to Kill. You must PM me the name of the person you wish to kill, and the person who PMs me will be the one who makes the kill. The last PM before Night ends will be the one I take. If nothing stops it, they will die that Night Phase. You may discuss your plans at any time in this Private Topic.

Vote

- During the Day you must blend in with Town, so you get a vote.

You know that Ron Weasley, Professor Dumbledore, Scabbers and Cho Chang are not in this game, and at any time you can PM me with a name and role to request a fakeclaim.

You win when your faction is the majority in the game, and nothing can prevent this from happening. The game thread is here. Please confirm by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, bazinga, you are

Lucius Malfoy, Ministry Mafia Rolecop

, and your team mates are

notscience, Cornelius Fudge

and

ArcAngel9, McNair

. You are also aware that there is a Dementor around, and that they are aligned with the Mafia, but do not have access to your QuickTopic. You guys, however, can discuss your plans at any time here. If you target the Dementor with a Night Kill, he will die.

'I always thought Father might be the one who got rid of Dumbledore. I told you he thinks Dumbledore's the worst Headmaster the school's ever had.'

Abilities:

Rolecop

- During the Night you may PM me the name of someone you wish to investigate. If nothing stops you, you will be given their rolename via return PM at the end of the Night.

Kill

- During the Night you may choose someone that your team wishes to Kill. You must PM me the name of the person you wish to kill, and the person who PMs me will be the one who makes the kill. The last PM before Night ends will be the one I take. If nothing stops it, they will die that Night Phase. You may discuss your plans at any time in this Private Topic.

Vote

- During the Day you must blend in with Town, so you get a vote.

You know that Ron Weasley, Professor Dumbledore, Scabbers and Cho Chang are not in this game, and at any time you can PM me with a name and role to request a fakeclaim.

You win when your faction is the majority in the game, and nothing can prevent this from happening. The game thread is here. Please confirm by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, ArcAngel9, you are

Mcnair, Ministry Mafia 1-shot Strongman

, and your team mates are

bazinga, Lucius Malfoy

and

notscience, Cornelius Fudge

. You are also aware that there is a Dementor around, and that they are aligned with the Mafia, but do not have access to your QuickTopic. You guys, however, can discuss your plans at any time here. If you target the Dementor with a Night Kill, he will die.

'Executioner, your services are no longer required.'

Abilities:

Executor (1-shot)

- Once during a Night phase, you can choose to make your Night Kill unblockable - it will succeed whatever happens.

Kill

- During the Night you may choose someone that your team wishes to Kill. You must PM me the name of the person you wish to kill, and the person who PMs me will be the one who makes the kill. The last PM before Night ends will be the one I take. If nothing stops it, they will die that Night Phase. You may discuss your plans at any time in this Private Topic.

Vote

- During the Day you must blend in with Town, so you get a vote.

You know that Ron Weasley, Professor Dumbledore, Scabbers and Cho Chang are not in this game, and at any time you can PM me with a name and role to request a fakeclaim.

You win when your faction is the majority in the game, and nothing can prevent this from happening. The game thread is here. Please confirm by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Agar, you are

A Dementor, Ministry Mafia Traitor Dementor

. You are aligned with the mafia (notscience, Cornelius Fudge, bazinga, Lucius Malfoy and ArcAngel9, Mcnair). You do not have access to their QT, and they do not know who you are, just that you exist. If they target you with a Night Kill, you will die.

'Dementors are among the foulest creatures that walk this earth. They infest the darkest, filthiest places, they glory in decay and despair, they drain peace, hope, and happiness out of the air around them... Get too near a Dementor and every good feeling, every happy memory will be sucked out of you. If it can, the Dementor will feed on you long enough to reduce you to something like itself...soulless and evil. You will be left with nothing but the worst experiences of your life'

Abilities:

Kiss (2-shot)

- Twice during the game, you will receive a PM containing the names of two people. These are the people that Cornelius Fudge has decided are deserving of a Dementor's Kiss. You will then decide which of the two you wish you Kiss, and that person will be Treestumped the next day. This is unblockable.

Kill

- If every other member of the Mafia dies, then you will be able to perform the Factional Kill, which you will do so via PM at Night.

Vote

- During the Day you must blend in with Town, so you get a vote.

You know that neither Harry Potter nor George Weasley are in the game, and at any time you can PM me with a rolename for a fakeclaim Role PM.

You win when your faction is the majority in the game, and nothing can prevent this from happening. The game thread is here. Please confirm by replying to this PM with your character name.

Spoiler: town PMs

Greetings, ChannelDelibird, you are

the Whomping Willow, Hogwarts Reflexive Roleblocker

.

'I told you, months ago, that the Whomping Willow was planted the year I came to Hogwarts. The truth is that it was planted because I came to Hogwarts.'

Abilities:

Aggressive Tree

- Being a magical tree, you attack anything that comes near you. This means that whenever anyone targets you at Night, their action will fail. You won't be notified about being targetted.

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, penguin_alien, you are

Remus Lupin, Hogwarts 1-shot Janitor Vigilante

.

'Your parents gave their lives to keep you alive, Harry. A poor way to repay them -- gambling their sacrifice for a bag of magic tricks.'

Abilities:

Werewolf

- Once per game you may PM the name of someone you wish to kill during the Night. If nothing stops it, you will kill them and they will die. However, you will maul them to an unrecognisable mess, meaning that no-one else will find out their role, or alignment. You, however, will manage to get their alignment out of them before you kill them.

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Malakittens, you are

Past Hermione Granger, Hogwarts Informed Townie

.

'You'll forgive me for saying so, my dear, but I perceive very little aura around you. Very little receptivity to the resonances of the future.'

Abilities:

Time Turner

- Due to the magic of time travel, you know that there is a second Hermione Granger in the game, and you know that she is aligned with Hogwarts.

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Cupboard, you are

Hermione Granger, Hogwarts Townie

.

'You're the cleverest witch of your age I've ever met, Hermione.'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Lucky2u, you are

The Marauder's Map, Hogwarts Amnesiac Tracker

.

'I solemnly swear I am up to no good.'

Abilities:

Magic Map

- Once per Night, you can PM me the name of someone you wish to track. However, being a map, you don't have a voice, so there's no point in me telling you the results. You also need to PM me the name of the person you wish to receive your result, and they will be PMed the name of who, if anyone, your Track target visited.

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, insanity018, you are

Percy Weasley, Hogwarts Head Boy

.

'And there'll be little flags on the hoods, with HB on them-

-for Humongous Bighead,'

Abilities:

Detention

- During the Night, you can PM me the name of someone who you wish to put in detention. This acts like a Jailkeep, meaning that they will be unable to take any actions, and are unable to be targetted by any actions.

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Mac, you are

Pigwidgeon, Hogwarts Irritant

.

'I've got to keep him up here because he annoys Errol and Hermes. He annoys me too, come to that.'

Abilities:

Hyperactive

- Once per Night, you can PM me the name of someone you wish to visit. Your visit won't do anything, just annoy. You have to do this.

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Kalimar, you are

Professor Snape, Hogwarts 1-shot Bulletproof

.

'"Mr. Moony presents his compliments to Professor Snape and begs him to keep his abnormally large nose out of other people's business."
"Mr. Prongs agrees with Mr. Moony, and would like to add that Professor Snape is an ugly git."
"Mr. Padfoot would like to register his astonishment that an idiot like that ever became a professor."
"Mr. Wormtail bids Professor Snape good day, and advises him to wash his hair, the slimeball.'

Abilities:

Bulletproof

- If, at any point during the game, you are targetted by a kill, the first one will not affect you. You will not be informed when this happens.

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Hermy, you are

Sir Cadogan, Hogwarts Townie

.

'What villains are these that trespass upon my private lands? Who dares challenge Sir Cadogan? Back, you scurvy braggarts, you rogues!'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, zMuffinMan, you are

Cedric Diggory, Hogwarts Townie

.

'He's that tall, good-looking one, isn't he?'
'Strong and silent.'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, FakeGod, you are

Fred Weasley, Hogwarts Townie

.

'The Dementors won't turn up again, Oliver, Dumbledore'd do his nut,'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Desperado, you are

Professor McGonagall, Hogwarts Townie

.

'JORDAN! ARE YOU BEING PAID TO ADVERTISE FIREBOLTS? GET ON WITH THE COMMENTARY!'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Voidwalker1234, you are

Oliver Wood, Hogwarts Townie

.

'Bad news, Harry. I've just been to see Professor McGonagall about the Firebolt. She - er - got a bit shirty with me. Told me I'd got my priorities wrong. Seemed to think I cared more about winning the Cup than I do about you staying alive. Just because I told her I didn't care if it threw you off, as long as you caught the Snitch on it first. Honestly, the way she was yelling at me ... you'd think I'd said something terrible. Then I asked her how much longer she was going to keep it ...'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Nero Cain/farside22, you are

Neville Longbottom, Hogwarts Townie

.

'Well… always the same hat. A tall one with a stuffed vulture on top. And a long dress… green, normally… and sometimes a fox-fur scarf.'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, Formerfish, you are

Crookshanks, Hogwarts Townie

.

'There's something funny about that animal! It heard me say that Scabbers was in my bag!'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

Greetings, snscompt1, you are

Professor Trelawney, Hogwarts Townie

.

'THE DARK LORD LIES ALONE AND FRIENDLESS, ABANDONED BY HIS FOLLOWERS. HIS SERVANT HAS BEEN CHAINED THESE TWELVE YEARS. TONIGHT, BEFORE MIDNIGHT ... THE SERVANT WILL BREAK FREE AND SET OUT TO REJOIN HIS MASTER. THE DARK LORD WILL RISE AGAIN WITH HIS SERVANT'S AID, GREATER AND MORE TERRIBLE THAT EVER HE WAS. TONIGHT ... BEFORE MIDNIGHT ... THE SERVANT WILL SET OUT TO REJOIN HIS MASTER ...'

Abilities:

Vote

- During the Day you have your vote to try and lynch someone.

You win when all threats to Hogwarts have been eliminated. The game thread is here. Please confirm you are playing by replying to this PM with your character name.

oh look! No Harry Potter! I also think that modkill junk is crap. You prob are the sk but I'm just going to leash you so you can help me kill scum.

[Nero Cain]

you know, the fact that MOLLA HIMSELF is voting xof shows that her claim is a pretty direct counter-claim to his own]


the people hemming and hawing about how two JOATs can exist? Well, maybe, but highly freaking unlikely. Go back and look--- it's Molla that's sure her role can't exist in conjunction with xof's. Xof is more along the lines of "oh, two joats, ha ha thats weird lol lol lets talk about something else"

the fact that she's a MISH MASH player just makes it MORE likely that she fucked up by revealing what are pretty obviously scum-JOAT roles. as a non-mafia player, she might not have known any better.



in other words, rope that shit

[Nero Cain]

TBF, she's (PA) been in this game for a smidgen over a week so I'd argue that she didn't "just" replace in.

So I'm kinda like well "ok, lynch Elf, I agree that she's not really helping town that much and I don't want to hear you guys fussing about her every fucking day"

but then again posts like 5319 as so full of bullshit and it makes me really uncomfortable. That quick surge on p213 also gives me bad vibes.

I'd still much prefer an Abomination or Sroomish lynch but w/e.

[Nero Cain]

Why Mala?

[Nero Cain]

but Molla is the one that needs the shard.

+ I still have doubts about Mala and Neil

[Nero Cain]

Nero, do we know Molla is town?

no but I'm sorta meta town reading him 'cause I remember him acting like this when we played together. I guess I could be misremembering and he was scum that game so I guess I need to look through my games and see what his alignment was.

Why should I think Molla is scum(my) other than not really doing anything?

Someone else brought this up but I'm kinda agreeing here that they are deff not masons with the way Neil reacted to Lemi's mason claim (maybe they were all going to claim masons together?) I don't really remember them replying to this point either. I don't think they are friendly neighbors 'cause they aren't pushing Y+B. Other than that I can't really think of anything that could confirm each other.

What do you think of that?

[Nero Cain]

HOLY SHIT
I can confirm xof and kill bulba tomorrow night if I get protected today
The ability I got n1 will be able to confirm if his claimed abilitiea are indeed as he says

We all believe the abilities are true

BBmolla is the town JOAT

xofelf is the scum JOAT

BBmolla is pushing for xofelf to die because he's town and she's not.

xofelf is perfectly fine with both her and BBmolla being JOAT

Because

She's

Scum

Both you and DGB (and Molla) are experienced enough to know that two JOATS in a large isn't impossible. Elfs reaction doesn't necessarily seem scummy to me either 'cause like in a game that I was in I was a jailkeeper and Nacho was a doc and was all like "our two roles can't co-exist!" Of course he later backtracked and claimed it was a reaction test.

If elf flips town is Molla scum?

[Nero Cain]

Well I'm confused then 'cause it sounds like you don't think that two JOATS can't exist together. Can you spell it out to me newbie style why you think this but don't think a Elf town flip would make you suspect Molla?

I also understand that one is a % JOAT and 1 is a regular JOAT.

[Nero Cain]

list of people who can die

YB
BB

fuck no

Really? VOTE: Shos

you do know that if Chamber of Uselessness flips scum we are insta lynching you, right?

vote:OS

[Nero Cain]

keep whining little scumbag

[Nero Cain]

just lynch off the elf wagon, that's likely a scum gold mine.

[Nero Cain]

but I don't know why. Can you whisper it into my ear?

Still could be an SK kill, multiple teams are possible too

[Nero Cain]

Is this a happy event?

fuck yes

[Nero Cain]

well ok but why was this not your first post? And I think it goes without saying that if he flips town then you are dead.

[Nero Cain]

well ok but why was this not your first post?

And I think it goes without saying that if he flips town then you are dead.

nevermind

vote:prohawk

[Nero Cain]

I guess you should claim your other results too

[Nero Cain]

please never breed.

[Nero Cain]

I guess you should claim your other results too

My role isn't as simple as just "tracker".

Bah, don't even entertain blatant anti-town role-fishing.

thats not even rolefishing you turd.

I'd like to hear how you and Mala were confirmed to you.

[Nero Cain]

Egg is claiming a guiltyish on prohawk. Maybe you should vote that.

[Nero Cain]

From my understanding a shard is a powerbooster. Molla is claiming JOAT with % powers and that a shard boosts his powers. And just why the fuck would prohawk as town steal the shard from NS?

[Nero Cain]

I think he's pretty likely to be town yeah. I guess he could go "oh hey guys, I have a shard, lets lynch me so Molla can get my shard!" as scum to get cheap town cred. idk

[Nero Cain]

unvote

consider me a fan of not wanting to lynch until we see the other flips + I'm tired and I need to reread the last two pages and think about them.

[Nero Cain]

but yeah, Jiffy tunneling on Shos for 230 pages is p bad. I still think that if we don't lynch prohawk today then we should be lynching off that elf wagon.

[Nero Cain]

jiffy targeted shos on n1 and I assume it worked

[Nero Cain]

Nero seriously how thick are you?

thick enough to know that hunting one scum when there are atleast 6 or 7 left is p bad.

Like I can't even remember who else (if anyone) you are scum reading.

[Nero Cain]

<-----how I feel about that claim.

[Nero Cain]

Why would that be a watcher?

[Nero Cain]

Shos *might* be the SK but it really doesn't matter 'cause he's not living to lylo and its time to kill team scum. So stop being pissed that he killed your buddy.

vote:Majiffy

[Nero Cain]

Muffin, Jake from state farm is 1,000x worse than shos

jiffy, who is scum (other than shos) and why.

[Nero Cain]

I honestly don't know why you people think Shos is scum when a) he killed Abomination, b) the scum kill wasn't missing according to the three deaths last night, c) Serene was the SK kill according to AD

Everything there is accounted for and that means Shos is the town Vig.

lol no

pls shoot this when you can kill again shos