InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Majiffy]

Ffery is a heavy analyst which isnt exciting but usually yields results.

[Always]

VOTE: Always
Scum

Prob-town.

Burn with fire.
VOTE: Abomination

This I'm having trouble reading, honestly. I

think

it leans town overall, but multiball makes that call more sketchy.

Mhork/Jiffy/Clyton/xofelf maybe iece

Mhork/xofelf/iece, sure. (Not going to go howling for their blood 'til I'm sure, though.) Jiffy, give it time. (He's a bitch to catch in multiball.) But Clyton, no.

Also, while I realize this is day one and there's too many variables to account for, it could help to have an idea for factional divisions if you can give them and what you think the numbers would be. (4/4, 5/4, and 5/5 being the likely candidates given game size.)

Wait but we don't know for sure there are multiple factions do we?
VOTE: ActionDan

Legit scumread here, now.

This is a derp-vote. (Dan is practically conftown.)
Mhork is not a derp-player.

Also, MDT's town.
And Abomination is hilariously town.

We should policy lynch this
VOTE: Abomination
Everyone who has a vote on the monster above gets a smooch! :*

So I know I said prob-town before.

But given multiball and this post, I'm saying possible-scum.

[shos]

guys abom has too little votes.

[Majiffy]

Whats he at?

[Always]

WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS ROLE

VOTE: ABOMINATION

STEALTH HYDRA IS ALSO SCUM

Town. (Okay. So I really shouldn't be calling Kats town. But screw it, I am, dealwithit.)

Unvote
Vote: Young and Beautiful

Decent chance of being town.

Vote Shos

Other scumreads are MDT, Beast, and Venmar. I think at least one of AD/Mhork is likely scum. I also think there is at least 1 scum on the Abomination wagon.

Okay, so you're basically O for 4, here. Venmar is town.
MDT's basically conftown.

Beast townslipped hard in the very post you're saying makes him scum.

Shos could be scum but is a boring wagon to be frank.

AD's basically conftown,
And Mhork's scum.

The Abomination wagon having scum in it is obvious, and a boring opinion to have.

Part of me wants to say so-hilariously-wrong-must-be-town.
The rest of me wants to say leaning-scum.

[Always]

The exact reason why we need to policy lynch this Abomination!

Yeahno.

I'd be more willing to policy-lynch the ones advocating a policy-lynch. If you can't read a hydra's alignment off of their posting and the mindset driving it, then you deserve to die, not them. They may have conflicting opinions that provide a literal contradiction in that they post two conflicting things, but it is a FUNDAMENTAL skill for a player to look at

why

they posted those conflicting things.

And the reasons behind Abominations' changes are hilariously,

hilariously

obviously town.

You try to lynch 'em, you have to go through me, first. Not to mention, any member of the Mastin pack that I manage to pull behind me.

[T S O]

Part of me wants to say so-hilariously-wrong-must-be-town.
The rest of me wants to say leaning-scum.

So what do you actually say?

[Abomination]

guys abom has too little votes.

Can we lynch this guy for real though?

[T S O]

I don't really disagree with you, I guess, but I have no interest in running him up.

[T S O]

The truth is, he's a really nice guy, and really nice guys usually aren't scum.

In fact, they're

never

scum.

[Always]

Mastin, I feel like something important was missing from this post.

Right, I forgot!

Yo.





(More seriously. Reasons are something I probably shoulda given, if nothing else than to my crime-buddies, but I slacked off. I'll give 'em when I feel like it.)

This pings because of timing, mostly. There's a shitton of stuff to react to and analyze by page 4 of this game

This was my initial thought that led me to an initial maybe-scum read. However, there was a thought that changed it into still-hard-to-read-but-leaning-town.

(geists is prob-town.)

On a more serious note, I do think shos is scum.

I actually don't doubt this.

I doubt the alignment driving it.

Oh wait, you were processing page-by-page. I'm curious why you thought Iece looked scummier than xofelf in post 51

Because Iece's posting was worse?

[Abomination]

My mind has been blown. I'm certainly convinced.

But would you be interested in the highly unlikely off-chance that he's a nice-scum-guy? I know I know, it's a crazy thing. But look at what he's done. He's character claimed in what looked like an attempt to get towncred from flavor knowledge players, he's seriously advocating for a bad policy lynch, AND he's with stupid. It's like a smoking gun of scumminess.

[T S O]

Dear wall.

How are you?

Non-responsive?

I've found you a friend with the same traits!

...Geists? No, that's not their name. It's actually Always!

[T S O]

My mind has been blown. I'm certainly convinced.

But would you be interested in the highly unlikely off-chance that he's a nice-scum-guy? I know I know, it's a crazy thing. But look at what he's done. He's character claimed in what looked like an attempt to get towncred from flavor knowledge players, he's seriously advocating for a bad policy lynch, AND he's with stupid. It's like a smoking gun of scumminess.

yeah, I agree with a lot of these, but the thing is I don't feel he's actually posted anything which would make me vote you. the policy lynch he's going for has been advocated by half the game at some stage and then dropped - him continuing to push doesn't really reek of anything. It's wrong, but it doesn't feel like he's thinking like scum, who have generally dropped off you at this stage.

Him roleclaiming was something he will need to answer for, but why would he do it as scum? Why would he namedrop on the first page? Either he's decided to waste a guaranteed fakeclaim or he's randomly namedropping. Neither have any benefit to scum.

I feel like someone's going to pull up Open 536, but this isn't the same.

[Abomination]

The claim still bothers me for reasons, but I can see it that way.

[Majiffy]

VOTE: Shos

Nero still scum, btw.

[Always]

Why are we all softclaiming and roleclaiming again?

Actual roleclaims have all given important info that needs to be given, akin to "I'm a miller". Most softclaims have been the same.
'Sides, this game's practically role madness by Ceph's own word, soyeah. Shenanigans. lolCeph-game.

Charizard, I think Nero Cain is probably the worst lynch for day one, in my experience he becomes easier to read as the game progresses. Besides, what he did here isn't exactly scummy, nor unlike him yet.

Basically this. We'll get a good Nero read. Even given multiball. (Nero's better at looking town in multiball because he actually can give legitimate effort.) Give it time.

Abom can you explain why BE left? His last few posts seemed town.

So Majiffy's thoughts are very largely compatible with my own, which is generally a fairly good sign he's town. (Which I was thinking anyway, but this certainly helps!)

Per their request, Burning_Earth is no longer part of Abomination.

I feel sad, because Burning_Earth is basically the only head I haven't played with and is also the head I was most identifying with in their posting.

Has mastin/always done

anything

worthwhile yet?

Yes. Iso us, sheep us*, and all will be good.

*Disclaimer: Sheeping Mastin may or may not be "good" at this stage.
Listen to her when she says stuff, though, is never a bad idea.

[Majiffy]

Oh hi Mastin are we going to cuddle and get along this game? I think we are.

[T S O]

isnt exciting but usually yields results.

look can you save the damn innuendo for later???????

gettin real tired of your shit

[Venmar]

Nero still scum, btw.

[Always]

Oh hi Mastin are we going to cuddle and get along this game? I think we are.

As do I. Hugs, kisses, and babies a plenty. (Probably a whole litter's worth.)

[Majiffy]

Nero still scum, btw.

Oh hi Mastin are we going to cuddle and get along this game? I think we are.

As do I. Hugs, kisses, and babies a plenty. (Probably a whole litter's worth.)

I can't afford a whole litera

cola

kids.

[Lord Mhork]

Mastin you are vastly overestimating my play. Everyone knows I'm shit town.

Anyway I don't think I've actually seriously sat down with this game in front of a real computer. I'll do that once I finally get home. You can expect it in around two or three hours probably

[Always]

Not enough posting for a readslist, but let's give an annotation list for reference.

1. Lord Mhork
^Scum.

2. geists (Natirasha & fferyllt)
^I'm upgrading prob-town to town now that I think about it.

3. shos
^Also still thinking town.

4. ProHawk
^Prob-town.

5. BulbaFenix (Bulbazak & EddieFenix)
^Slightly-scum.

6. Katsuki
^Posting looks town and has a lot which looks in line with own own thoughts. There's one or two things to be concerned about but meh, not worth pursuing yet.

7. Sakura Hana
^No posting; gimme a while to determine if no-posting-town or no-posting-scum.

8. beastcharizard
^Town.

9. T S O
^Prob-town.

10. Rhaego
^

Very

slightly townlean.

11. Birds of Prey (anonymous hydra)
^Probably scum lurking in a PT.

12. Iecerint
^Scum.

13. ActionDan
14. Moogle Dance Troupe (Kagami & Kazekirimaru)
^Town.

15. Svenskt Stål
^Gimme a bit.

16. Majiffy
^Town.

17. Nero Cain
^Sorting later.

19. Young and Beautiful (anonymous hydra)
^Currently leaning scum.

20. Clyton
^Town.

21. Abomination (Who, Axxle, Haylen, MTD, T-Bone, ika, & BipolarChemist)
^Ridiculously town.

22. The Goat
^Gimme a bit.

23. Venmar
^Town.

24. BBmolla
^Not giving me townvibes, which is a bit concerning, but not yet overwhelmingly so.

25. kdowns
^I should have a read here, but don't.

26. xofelf
^Scum.

27. Egg
^Give me a bit, though I think it's town.

28. Klick
^I'll double-check to make sure, but I do think town.

[Lord Mhork]

This is why I dislike playing with you Mastin. You tunnel like a motherfucker and think you're always right.