Open 543: Pick Your Poison (Game Over!)

[Aegor]

I would still rather lynch Kalimar but this is fine, too.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I don't find N town at all. He's played three games with me and modded two with me in it. In the game which he modded and I was town, I was a hider and was slightly more subdued than normal. In my scumgame that he modded, I put up a huge pile of meta analysis to "prove" that my scumbuddy was town. I find it a bit ridiculous that N thinks I am bussing the hell out of all my team-mates when I put up such an effort to defend in that game. He's also been scumpartners with me. He knows this isn't my scumgame.

I'm hammering him. As for who to shoot if we're wrong, Beli just seems even more town with his request to vig. I dunno, use your best judgment. Beli isn't going to make it through LYLO with Maxous, but if you harbor suspicions of me, I too would rather you just shoot me to assuage your paranoia as opposed to leave me alive and potentially mis-hammer me in LYLO. Paranoia is the worst thing in LYLO and I know even Nacho lost a couple of them due to it.

VOTE: N

[Aegor]

Yes; I do not actually yet know for sure whom I will vig.

What just does not make sense to me is the NK sequence. Why would scum not NK the confirmed PRs?

[penguin_alien]

...can we please not lynch until I catch up tonight and KK checks in? And emeraldemon was the cop-confirmed innocent, as good as a confirmed PR. I don't want to be rude, but I'm concerned at the prospect of lynching when it seems that the replacements aren't wholly conversant with the game, myself included.

[Aegor]

He is already dead.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

Sorry Penguin. I slept over it and realized there was no way N was town and got impatient to see the flip and hammered. My mistake. I should have waited for you to catch up.

[Maxous]

What just does not make sense to me is the NK sequence. Why would scum not NK the confirmed PRs?

dunno about emerald but I assume they believed tammy to be the cop

[Belisarius]

Yes; I do not actually yet know for sure whom I will vig.

No sense fretting too much, the game's probably over

[Aegor]

I think so.

[JerryArr]

Open 543 Vote Count

VOTE COUNT 3.2

N (5): Kalimar, Maxous, Belisarius, Aegor, F-16_Fighting_Falcon

Not voting: penguin_alien, N, Kublai Khan

Day 3 deadline is 25 March, 2014 at 4 PM EDT, or in {(expired on 2014-03-25 16:00:00)}.

There are 8 living players, it takes 5 votes to lynch or no lynch.

NOTES:

Nothing of note.

Day 3 ends in a lynch of

Yiley

N, who was a

Mafia Goon

.
The

TOWN

faction (Maxous, F-16_Fighting_Falcon, emeraldemon, Tammy, Aegor, penguin_alien, BoroPhil, Belisarius, Kalimar, and Kublai Khan) has achieved their win condition, and has won Open 543: Pick Your Poison!

[Aegor]

OMG. Yay!

Not only that, town lynched perfectly.


Thanks, mod!

[Aegor]

Town played really well.

[Aegor]

Sorry you had to replace into such a crappy position, N.

[Maxous]

And before anyone bitches about me highlighting PoD's 437 when I replaced in and called everyone on my wagon communists, I remind you that communism is not alignment-indicative.

I might sig this.

ftr, done.

Well done, guys + gals, whole town played well.

[JerryArr]

The rest of the roles...

Slot	Role
Maxous (replacing JJcoolPants, who was replacing keybladewielder)	Vanilla Townie
iamausername (replacing ika)	Mafia Goon
F-16_Fighting_Falcon (replacing Acidic_TACO)	Vanilla Townie
emeraldemon	Vanilla Townie
Tammy (replacing anorway)	Vanilla Townie
Aegor (replacing YuniChikako)	Town 2-Shot Vigilante
penguin_alien (replacing Powerofdeath)	Town 1-Shot Cop
BoroPhil	Vanilla Townie
Belisarius (replacing LeMidget)	Vanilla Townie
Kalimar (replacing Zekrom25, who was replacing Misaka Mikoto, who was replacing RationalMadman)	Vanilla Townie
goodmorning	Mafia Goon
N (replacing Yiley)	Mafia Goon
Kublai Khan	Innocent Child

Night 1 Actions

iamausername Mafia kills Tammy
Aegor* vig kills BoroPhil
penguin_alien⁺ cop investigates emeraldemon (town)

Night 2 Actions

N Mafia kills emeraldemon
Aegor submits a no kill.

* - YuniChikako's action
⁺- Powerofdeath's action
Mafia QT
Dead QT

---

First of all, thank you all for playing, especially those of you that started the game and had to sit through replacements, the board being down, uncertainty of posts returning, and all that stuff. Hopefully you all enjoyed the game, as I enjoyed modding it.

Goodness, it took a lot to not blab stuff about the game until now.

I'm not going to count N has having lost the game since it was really a foregone conclusion that that slot was going to be lynched (or vigged) sooner or later. I was shocked that he wasn't the vig target, especially after multiple people were clamoring for that to happen Night 2. It sucks to be put in that position, and I apologize. FWIW, I randomly selected the slot each player replaced into during the Night 2 period.

I don't know if there's much else to say, though. If you have any advice on modding stuff, things I should change, things that I can do better, etc, feel free to tell me.

[Aegor]

From my read of the game and my experience in it after I replaced, I can find no criticism with your modding, which was excellent in every way.

I thought the chance of my being NKed was 0%, so there was no compulsion for me to use my Vig shot that night. I was reluctant to Vig someone without even talking to anyone in the game, and the worst case scenario was 3 confirmed town with 5 uncertain and 4 kills, so there was little need for me to Vig that night anyway.

[Belisarius]

It's nbd, there was no way N was dodging this lynch anyways.

I doubt Regfan could have done it.

[Tammy]

Yayayay!

:dancingbanana:

Good game town!

My replace in reads weren't half bad, so yay!

I misread KK but I'm glad falcon replaced into the slot I was horribly wrong on.

Thanks for running it jerryarr and letting me replace in!

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

Thanks for modding JerryArr. I had fun playing. You did very well with the timely votecounts, replacements, and getting through the unfortunate site issues with the missing posts.

I think town played awesome. The best thing you can do when scum get wagoned and claim a PR is not to lynch that PR but a different scum player and that's exactly what we did this game. It rarely happens as usually people don't buy the claim and lynch that scum or they compromise on a different townie. The town were all incredibly accurate and amazingly easy to work with. Definitely one of my better games and I am glad I helped influence the D1 lynch. GM, you played well but got unfortunately still got scumread. Not sure why you think it is a bad lynch. Sure, it was a deadline lynch but everyone had a chance to read through your play before making a decision. I will admit that you not being online near deadline hurt and you may have been able to talk yourself out of it had you been online and POD still lurked. But then POD wasn't online either so it goes both ways and the overall effect was fair since we were deciding between an inactive townie and inactive scum.

But yeah, town was amazing and I hope to see several players here again. The only miskill from the town was Borophil and he was so obvtown he was never going to get lynched anyways so from a collective standpoint, town was perfect. I especially thought Tammy's and Maxous's replace in reads were laser sharp, Beli came forth with his Yiley scumread at a critical point and convinced everyone to go for him, and Borophil basically kickstarted the GM lynch which pretty much sealed the game for town.

[Kalimar]

I definitely carried this game.

[Tammy]

THANK YOU KALIMAR!

Yeah I agree with falcon, town did really well at coming together this game

[penguin_alien]

Nice job, town, and sorry to be such a nervous Nelly. Thanks for the game, JerryArr!

[emeraldemon]

Nice play everyone.

F16 you said towards the end of D1 that I seemed scummy, any advice for playing a better town game? Or was that more paranoia?

[emeraldemon]

That question is open to everyone, actually, I'd love to hear anything about how to improve.

[Tammy]

I thought you were pretty town emeraldemon!