Secret Alt Mafia – Game over!

[Stimpson J Cat]

You both seem to be informed of Draco's alignment before the flip, and are already cooing for my mislynch.

Yeah OK I'm a a scum 1-shot poisoner.

[Squirrel Girl]

I'm glad that you value coherence.
Sadly, you'll find very little of it here, and the folks who intend to use it are doing so for scummy reasons.

Is this you saying that your lack of coherence is a town tell? You didn't seem to feel that way with Draco since you dinged him for lack of articulation and tunneling.

Who are the scum using coherency for scummy reasons?

[Squirrel Girl]

Oh I see Pro hammered malfoy.

If malfoy flips town as I expect, speedlynch EAPro tomorrow.

If he flips scum will that change your read on Edgar?

[Edgar Allan Pro]

You both seem to be informed of Draco's alignment before the flip, and are already cooing for my mislynch.

Yeah OK I'm a a scum 1-shot poisoner.

We'll see what Drama flips, although if there's two scum factions, it doesn't really clear you. In fact, if there's two scum factions, giving one of them poisoner is probably a balancing move.

I'm glad that you value coherence.
Sadly, you'll find very little of it here, and the folks who intend to use it are doing so for scummy reasons.

Is this you saying that your lack of coherence is a town tell? You didn't seem to feel that way with Draco since you dinged him for lack of articulation and tunneling.

Who are the scum using coherency for scummy reasons?

Dio and, to a lesser extent, Stig was.

[Squirrel Girl]

So Diomedes and...me. That feels pretty weak, and looking at the evolution of your reads in your iso it looks pretty weak there too.

[Quilford]

Couldn't get on earlier due to timeout errors.

In any case I'm not gonna have time to get to this until Thursday night. Enjoy your break!

[Quilford]

Okay! Let's do this.

[Quilford]

“I have grown to love secrecy. It seems to be the one thing that can make modern life mysterious or marvelous to us. The commonest thing is delightful if only one hides it.”
― Oscar Wilde

>>>

draco malfoy

(6) Ruthless MD, Drama Llama, Lea, The Jolly Old Man, Big Government, Edgar Allan Pro

<<<

Edgar Allan Pro

(4) Squirrel Girl, mangi, Powerful Diomedes, Stimpson J Cat

mangi

(1) draco malfoy

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

A lynch has been achieved.

Flip incoming.

[Quilford]

“I have grown to love secrecy. It seems to be the one thing that can make modern life mysterious or marvelous to us. The commonest thing is delightful if only one hides it.”
― Oscar Wilde

>>>

draco malfoy,

Town Neighbouriser

, lynched Day 3!

<<<

It is now Night 3.

Night ends in (expired on 2013-11-24 07:02:32).

[Quilford]

“I want to be with those who know secret things or else alone.”
― Rainer Maria Rilke

>>>

Drama Llama,

Vanilla Townie

, killed Night 3!

<<<

>>>

Stimpson J Cat,

Town Poisoner

, killed Night 3!

<<<

>>>

mangi,

Town Weak Doctor

, killed Night 3!

<<<

>>> mangi targeted Powerful Diomedes with an action during the Night. <<<

It is now Day 4.

Seven players remain.

All information above is guaranteed to be true. Flavour has no relation to the gamestate.

[Quilford]

“I want to be with those who know secret things or else alone.”
― Rainer Maria Rilke

Not Voting (7) Ruthless MD*, Squirrel Girl*, Lea*, Edgar Allan Pro*, Big Government*, The Jolly Old Man*, Powerful Diomedes*

(* = hasn't posted yet)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch or no lynch.

Deadline hits in (expired on 2013-12-02 08:05:55).

[Big Government]

This is probably lynch or lose but we have confirmed scum in Powerful Diomedes.

*Read entire mod scene to see why. I was looking through mangi's posts looking for any breadcrumbs/townreads he had to figure out who he targeted until I saw it
*

Ruthless and Lea are probably the other scum.

Vote: Powerful Diomedes.

[The Jolly Old Man]

Hooooh boy... I need to refresh on my weak doctor stuff but wouldn't it mean that Stimpson targeted Powerful Diomedes?


However that may be my mind just going random... Not sure about the Ruthless read but I can agree with the Lea one.

[Lea]

VOTE: Powerful Diomedes

will reread for interactions... or maybe the lack thereof

[Big Government]

End of Day 1:

For the sake of posterity VOTE: Lea

Beginning of Day 2:

Lea is off the table.

Big government I have explained. Now vote shrumz for the sake of the game. I think you need some help. Your read on lea is worse than the shut down. I'll help you with that.

Actually I think mangi may have targeted Lea night one. These are only some of the posts he made that indicate this.

Jolly Old Man, weak doctor dies if they try to protect a scum player, not if the player they protect gets targeted with a kill. mangi targeted Powerful Diomedes and died. Therefore Powerful Diomedes is scum.

[The Jolly Old Man]

I'll double check that information, but for right now, let me take your word on it.

VOTE: Powerful Diomedes

[Powerful Diomedes]

VOTE: Diomedes

Took you fuckers long enough.

[Quilford]

“I want to be with those who know secret things or else alone.”
― Rainer Maria Rilke

>>>

Powerful Diomedes (4) Big Government, Lea, The Jolly Old Man, Powerful Diomedes

<<<

Not Voting (3) Ruthless MD*, Squirrel Girl*, Edgar Allan Pro*

(* = hasn't posted yet)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

A lynch has been achieved.

...

[Quilford]

“I want to be with those who know secret things or else alone.”
― Rainer Maria Rilke

>>>

Powerful Diomedes,

Werewolf Loud Tracker

, lynched Day 4!

<<<

...

...

[Quilford]

>>>

It is no longer possible to prevent a win condition from being achieved!

<<<

...

...

[Quilford]

>>>

Ruthless MD,

Werewolf Even-Night Roleblocker

, endgamed Day 4!

<<<

...

...

[Quilford]

“Life is more fun if you play games.”
― Roald Dahl

>>>

Squirrel Girl,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Lea,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Edgar Allan Pro,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Big Government,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

The Jolly Old Man,

Vanilla Townie

, survived and won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Dream of Eden,

Vanilla Townie

, posthumously won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Madotsuki,

Town Universal Backup

, posthumously won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Willow Ghost,

Town Loud Roleblocker

, posthumously won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

draco malfoy,

Town Neighbouriser

, posthumously won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Drama Llama,

Vanilla Townie

, posthumously won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

Stimpson J Cat,

Town Poisoner

, posthumously won the game Day 4!

<<<

>>>

mangi,

Town Weak Doctor

, posthumously won the game Day 4!

<<<

The

Town

has won! The

Werewolves

have been defeated.

This game is now over. Role distribution, setup reveal, Night actions, and mod comments are to be revealed.

[Quilford]

Setup Reveal

Here's the Mod QT, containing role distribution and Night actions. You'll note that the game ended because Ruthless MD had been poisoned the previous Night, and there was no way for him to reach his win condition before he died of poison and the Town's win condition be fulfilled. http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/NUeeMHT5vttx

My mod comments and the Role PMs are incoming.

People can reveal their mains as they please.

[Quilford]

Spoiler: Town Role PMs

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Town Loud Roleblocker

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special ability:

• >>>
  Loud Roleblock
  : Once per Night, prevent a player from using any Night actions by naming them to the moderator.
  If successful it will be announced in-thread at the start of the next Day that that player was roleblocked, but not by who.

You win the game if:

• %%% all non-Town aligned players are eliminated and at least one
  Town aligned
  player is alive.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

---

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Town Poisoner

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special ability:

• >>>
  Poison
  : Once per Night, poison a player by naming them to the moderator.
  They will die at the end of the following Night unless cured by a Poison Doctor.

You win the game if:

• %%% all non-Town aligned players are eliminated and at least one
  Town aligned
  player is alive.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

---

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Town Neighbouriser

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special ability:

• >>>
  Neighbourise
  : Once per Night, add a player to your neighbourhood by naming them to the moderator.
  During Nights, you may talk to the other players in your neighbourhood in your private QuickTopic.

You win the game if:

• %%% all non-Town aligned players are eliminated and at least one
  Town aligned
  player is alive.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

---

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Town Weak Doctor

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special ability:

• >>>
  Weak Doctor
  : Once per Night, protect a player from kills by naming them to the moderator.
  If you successfully target a player who does not hold the same Win Condition as you, you will die unpreventably.

You win the game if:

• %%% all non-Town aligned players are eliminated and at least one
  Town aligned
  player is alive.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

---

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Town Universal Backup

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special ability:

• >>>
  Universal Backup
  : You will become the role of the first Town aligned (non-Vanilla Townie) player to die.
  This ability can only be prevented from activating with your death.

You win the game if:

• %%% all non-Town aligned players are eliminated and at least one
  Town aligned
  player is alive.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

---

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Vanilla Townie

.

You have no abilities apart from your voice and your vote.

You win the game if:

• %%% all non-Town aligned players are eliminated and at least one
  Town aligned
  player is alive.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

Spoiler: Werewolf Role PMs

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Werewolf Even-Night Roleblocker

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special abilities:

• >>>
  Even-Night Roleblock
  : Once per Night, prevent a player from using any Night actions by naming them to the moderator.
  You may only use this ability during even-numbered Nights.
  >>>
  Factional Kill
  : Remove a player from the game each Night by naming them to the moderator.
  Only one player in your faction can use the Kill power each Night.
  >>>
  Nighttalk
  : During Nights and in Pregame, you may talk to the other players in your faction in your private QuickTopic.
  You may submit abilities via PM or in boldface in the QuickTopic.

Anyone in your faction may perform the

Factional Kill

ability and other abilities in the same Night.

You win the game if:

• %%% at least one
  Werewolf aligned
  player is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The other members of your faction are:

• ### [playername], a
  Werewolf Loud Tracker
  , with your
  Factional Kill
  and
  Nighttalk
  abilities and the following special ability:
  
  >>> Loud Track: Once per Night, learn who a player targeted during the Night by naming them to the moderator.
  If successful the results of your action, but not your identity, will be revealed in-thread at the start of the next Day.
  
  ### [playername], a
  Werewolf Goon
  , with your
  Factional Kill
  and
  Nighttalk
  abilities only.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

---

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Werewolf Loud Tracker

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special abilities:

• >>>
  Loud Track
  : Once per Night, learn who a player targeted during the Night by naming them to the moderator.
  If successful the results of your action, but not your identity, will be revealed in-thread at the start of the next Day.
  >>>
  Factional Kill
  : Remove a player from the game each Night by naming them to the moderator.
  Only one player in your faction can use this ability each Night.
  >>>
  Nighttalk
  : During Nights and in Pregame, you may talk to the other players in your faction in your private QuickTopic.
  You may submit abilities via PM or in boldface in the QuickTopic.

Anyone in your faction may perform the

Factional Kill

ability and other abilities in the same Night.

You win the game if:

• %%% at least one
  Werewolf aligned
  player is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The other members of your faction are:

• ### [playername], a
  Werewolf Even-Night Roleblocker
  , with your
  Factional Kill
  and
  Nighttalk
  abilities and the following special ability:
  
  >>> Even-Night Roleblock: Once per Night, prevent a player from using any Night actions by naming them to the moderator.
  You may only use this ability during even-numbered Nights.
  
  ### [playername], a
  Werewolf Goon
  , with your
  Factional Kill
  and
  Nighttalk
  abilities only.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

---

Welcome to

Secret Alt Mafia

, [playername]!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are a

Werewolf Goon

.

Along with your voice and your vote, you have the following special abilities:

• >>>
  Factional Kill
  : Remove a player from the game each Night by naming them to the moderator.
  Only one player in your faction can use this ability each Night.
  >>>
  Nighttalk
  : During Nights and in Pregame, you may talk to the other players in your faction in your private QuickTopic.
  You may submit abilities via PM or in boldface in the QuickTopic.

Anyone in your faction may perform the

Factional Kill

ability and other abilities in the same Night.

You win the game if:

• %%% at least one
  Werewolf aligned
  player is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The other members of your faction are:

• ### [playername], a
  Werewolf Even-Night Roleblocker
  , with your abilities and the following special ability:
  
  >>> Even-Night Roleblock: Once per Night, prevent a player from using any Night actions by naming them to the moderator.
  You may only use this ability during even-numbered Nights.
  
  ### [playername], a
  Werewolf Loud Tracker
  , with your abilities and the following special ability:
  
  >>> Loud Track: Once per Night, learn who a player targeted during the Night by naming them to the moderator.
  If successful the results of your action, but not your identity, will be revealed in-thread at the start of the next Day.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You must confirm by replying to this PM with your role's name.

The game thread is here. Good luck, play fair, and have fun!

[Quilford]

Thanks for playing, everyone, and thanks to our two replacements for stepping in! <3

The Town Weak Doctor should never have existed. It's far too powerful. In hindsight, it should've been a limited Doctor or Cop, or a VT. That's my opinion about the setup balance. I hope the scum don't feel too hard done by: everything just came together perfectly for Town last Night. They lost not because they played particularly poorly, and the Town won not because they played particularly well: it simply came down to two well-informed, well-timed actions from mangi and Stimpson J Cat.

I certainly don't think anything's wrong with the 3:12 ratio. I think the scum were doing pretty well until Day 4. I think 3:12 is the ratio of the future for 15p games.

The activity in this game was too low, but that's okay. I think I prefer it to the Large Themes these days where tens of pages are produced in less than 24 hours and players have to drop out because they're simply too far behind. You guys needed to post more often, but I should've cracked down earlier in the game as well.

I don't really have any comments for individual players. I'll post more if more things pop into my head, I guess.

EDIT1: Oh!

Scum should know that they were able to perform individual actions and the kill on the same Night, as per 'Anyone in your faction may perform the

Factional Kill

ability and other abilities in the same Night.' in their Role PMs.

This could've been the difference between identifying mangi a night earlier and thus killing him before he nailed Diomedes and what actually went down.

Thanks again for playing!

Dead QT
Scum can reveal their QT if they wish.