Mafia v. Wolves Redux: Finally Over!

[IH]

Vote:Flay

He doesn't random vote! Scum!

= )

[IH]

vote:Reyox

I'm pretty sure you'll be fine Raffles. Doubt there'll be a lynch with 21 playing over night.

I'm feeling a nice wagon on Reyox btw.

[IH]

Dude, it's a

bandwagon

. Why

wouldn't

I wanna be on it?

[IH]

Bandwagon=\=Speedlynch

Having everyother post doesn't help the game btw..... Especially if it's not game related... just all.... SPAMMEH!

[IH]

No Reyo, you need to read past games if you don't get it. = ( Seriously, we're not piling on and lynching someone for posting the most, it's not even that large of a bandwagon.

[IH]

Wagoning is funner than policies = )

[IH]

Avatar is from that show Tom goes to the mayor.

JEFFERTON ALIIIIIIVE JEFFERTON ALIIIIIVE!

[IH]

= |

I feel newb scum tells coming from Reyo....

of course I'll have to look closely, since newb scum and town tells are often very alike.....

probably a pbp sometime..... even if we're only on page 4.

[IH]

STOP STOP STOP! Ugh, Nuisance=\= scum!

unvote, FoS:Kison, OTU

You just don't lynch someone for "being a nuisance". Thats a horrible reason/excuse.

mod

can we have a vote count?

[IH]

I will most definitely be rereading over the thread, as I feel detached from this game.

There may or may not be a giant IH post.

[IH]

I'm sorry for being lax in this game, probably tonight I will give a giant post, but from post 259, I believe Reyo is town.

[IH]

Meep, sorry guys. I'll try to do a little bit of a reread, as I've let this game get away from me.

[IH]

Alright.

1.IH apologizes for inactivity. IH will get into this game as soon as possible.

2.Players can help IH, and the town, by giving their top three suspicions and why.

3.Has OTU claimed?

4.Have the deadline rules been clarified?

[IH]

So far, from looking through the filter, I'm going to

Vote:OTU

Seriously, at lynch minus 2 once, comes down, and is right back up there? Come on.

Al4xz never really complained about someone lurking. I don't see the hypocrisy.

I will

FoS:Al4xz

though, because I don't like any of his posts. They repeat one statement repeatedly (He's not defending himself, only shooting back responses!), and he has repeatedly said "Let's just lynch him. Come on, let's just do it, can we please?"

Yet, he hasn't really pushed anything else, he even says "Claim or death surely awaits you." His repeated statements about him defending himself seem more like 'Hey, you should defend yourself'

It confuses us that's why it's scummy in my opinion but like I said I don't know if that's your newb-ishness showing or your intent. But it seems to be mostly newbishness so Unvote.

This is uncommittal scum.

No I'm clearly stating that I don't know if you have prior experience with other sites, and games. Therefore saying I'm not sure if it's newb-ish qualities you're showing or if that's what you are trying to do on purpose. The second part is because I believe that you are showing more newb-ish qualities then experienced so it was the more likely situation that it was just newb-ishness showing than you actually trying to confuse us. In reference to Battle Mage's post you just want on a bandwagon, no actual reason? Just to vote me for the hell of it? Interesting.

Trying to keep a dying wagon alive while staying off of it just in case it does.

When he got to minus 2 and noticed it he didn't post for... oh, a full week.

I think OTU is the play for today, Al4xz would be a viable lynch for tomorrow I think. OTU's alignment will at least give me a large amount of information about Al4xz.

[IH]

= | Skipped a page in reading.

[IH]

Because I read page 20, and didn't think to look back when it hit 21, so I missed the minus 1 vote.

[IH]

Actually we'd be done tomorrow, as that is the deadline.

[IH]

That makes no sense. If I was a scum, why would it matter to me if I lynch a scum or a townie? Sure, it might be a better idea to lynch the opponent scum, but I wouldn't be a one to bitch so long as I don't lynch my scummate.

You look cleaner if you're not on the mislynch, duh. Scum backaway sharpish when a deadline hits, since they get the joys of a mislynch, and not having to be on it, therefore not connecting them to the town lynch.

BM is still using bad logic

Reyo, the OTU lynch was obvious at the time. Just going through his posts in the filter can tell you that.

[IH]

Sorry guys, I've been busy lately, I'll read the last few pages I missed and catch up, I don't want this game out of hand from me like it was earlier.

[IH]

Right now, I'm worried about where my vote is because Shanba placed his on DGB as well. It doesn't mean both of them can't be scum. It's just less likely. I also didn't like being accused of Role-Fishing XReyoX and would like an explaination.

This is just plain outright not true. Distancing/Bussing ftw.

If you are not Shanba, then I don't care what you would've done in the same spot. If you are Shanba, then why are you playing two roles in a single game?

MoS, he just finished a game with Shanba. I believe he's metagaming.

FoS:MoS

I didn't like how in his posts about Shanba and Akbar, he seemed to defend Shanba in a more roundabout way than I really thought was necessay.

Unvote, Vote:BattleMage

Seriously.

I'll comment on Shanba's post after this one.

[IH]

Battle Mage feels off to me. Most games I've seen him in (as pro-town) he's got an idea in his head and run with it bullheaded through any walls like common sense or proof that he's wrong that might stand in his way. This game he's much more opportunistic and widening his horizons, which is something I want to watch.

This is most definitely true. I agree.

I thought this post was going to be much larger.

I'm going to actually

FoS:Anyone who was being suspicious of Shanba's opening post

, which was clearly a reread.

[IH]

same old crap arguments. im beginning to doubt that your experience has taught you alot about this game, as you seem to have neglected the basic principles. if you think im that idiotic, by all means ignore me, or, failing that quit the game. you could even invest in a stress-ball for us when you read my comments. However, such an attitude is CERTAINLY going to be detrimental to the town, as it means we lose the majority of your contribution to the game. Still, im happy to sacrifice that, if it means that your comments stick to the actual game. If you want to criticise my logic, be specific and relevant, otherwise just set up a:
"I HATEZ BATLE MAGEE" thread in Mish Mash
believe me, its the latest craze.
NOW, can we get back on topic?
BM

The latest craze? This is not a craze. You are clearly not helping at all with this situation, and therefore keeping alive by not suggesting we just drop it. Therefore, by not admitting your own wrong, you are just as bad, if not worse, than those you are admonishing, and distracting away from the game even more. We're not going to ignore you, because that could be giving scum a free ride. Quitting the game would be stupid.
I would not have commented on this at all, but after it had already desisted, you fail you follow your own advice after it had mostly blown over in post 826, by staying off topic!
What does this tell me? You're trying to look protown by admonishing players to stay ontopic, without actually contributing anything to the game, while DGB defends you out the wazoo. Not to mention that this is NOT normal Battlemage as town play. BattleMage as town seizes hold of one idea, and does not let it go, no matter how irrational the idea is.

BUT, in this game he seems to have kept his options more open, and less aggressive, as I believe Shanba has already said.

[IH]

I dislike how BM's wagon has just been unsubstantiated as "kicking him when he's down" or "ad Hominem". It is something to note of.

[IH]

Mod, may I request replacement, because I am being a detriment to this game

[IH]

First of all, N9V is lying. I am the mayor, townie. (Rolename is mayor, role is townie).

Second of all, I'm sorry for my uber lurk everyone = \

[IH]

town wasn't at lylo, were they?

[IH]

= O The list of kills are amazing. Only two mislynches, and one crosskill. Nice.

Sorry I started lurking. I actually requested replacement and Phobeus begged me to stay in <.<;;

[IH]

Nope, I was the mayor. Pretty much a vanilla townie.... with the name mayor.