I was making a joke poking fun at the most extreme end of your position. So far in the game we've had votes for random players, votes for your hardline metagame decisions, votes for newbies, and votes for players who haven't posted once in the thread.
None
of those people are statistically more likely to be mafia than any other player--if we didn't vote for any of those entirely arbitrary reasons, nobody would have voted by now, and we
would
be heading for a no lynch. Obviously you aren't in favour of a no lynch (as you brought up), so where do you draw the line?