No-Eliminate D1: A bad move?

[hp [leaves]]

4) If the town's mentality doesn't change, how can I (as a mod) take advantage of it/change the rules to modify the player's mentality/design the game around the fact that D1 will likely have a no-lynch?

Well, Tarhalindur's Babylon 5 Mafia had a role that won and ended the game if any day ended in a No Lynch. Brutal; but there were never any no lynches after that point in any Tar game