So, a rundown of my reads.
3. zabriel
^
Lynch candidate number one.
It's either him or Yates.
4. Shahrizai mykonian
^
Town.
5. Kise
^Town side of null. I am re-evaluating his posts, but he's definitely not someone I want to lynch any time soon, if for no other reason than because he's not antagonizing anyone and has shown an evolution of reads which seems natural, with him willing to show reason and compromise with people. Could he be scum? Most definitely, he could be.
Is
he scum? At the moment, I'm saying no.
8. PeregrineV
^Cryptic Cheery Dog result. Presumably, when Cheery Dog dies we'll know what his results mean, and until then, PV gets a pass.
9. Amrun pidgey
^Been on the townside of null for much of the game. Amrun's posts were natural to me. Furthermore, pidgey's posts have largely been stream-of-consciousness-styled. If he's scum, he's managed to disguise it well. While I think he's pretty much wrong on everything, his posts just come across as being town. So
weak town
is my overall assessment.
10. Acosmist
^Claim about to be tested by the messenger. If the messenger refuses, I'm lynching their ass tomorrow, period end of discussion. Claim may be double-tested by Cheery Dog, though that's his choice. At this time, I believe his claim, for what it's worth.
11. Zoroaster MagnaofIllusion
^I currently am in line with AP's reasoning. MoI's frustration this game seems entirely genuine. And not in a "scum not getting their way" kind of genuine; it legitimately looks like frustrated town. Like Kise, I'm re-evaluating him, and like Kise, he's on the townside of null.
12. Yates
^
Lynch candidate number two.
If zab's not lynched, Yates will be.
14. I Am Innocent AngryPidgeon
^Mid-tier town. I liked IaI's posts, and AP's been dropping towntell after towntell after towntell. Though it's certainly possible he's scum tailoring his play to my expectations, I sincerely doubt that; his play seems like his normal ever-changing self, really.
16. jasonT1981
^Worth a look at in future days, he's utterly and totally null for me right now. Those on both the town-jason and scum-jason sides of the debate, I request that overnight, you prepare your case for your stance, so that when day five dawns, you can present it and I can weigh both sides of the argument while double-checking the facts presented.
17. snifit Cheery Dog
^Pretty close to confirmed town for his claim.
19. Kublai Khan
^Has been getting a pass from me most of the game. It's about time I got paranoid about that. I've had him as strong town, but the trend I saw in the VCA is something I want to investigate some more. Since the game will be in night over the weekend, that means I won't really get a chance to reread all 138 pages ('specially given my V/LA), but I really think that I should do so soon, in light of the flips we've got so far. I've been relying a lot on isos, and I think I stand a LOT to gain by looking at things in their entire context once more.
21. Nero Cain
^Not only do I know his claim to be accurate, not only do I think his play has been town, but we've also got a Cheery Dog cryptic result on him, soyeah; I'm treating him like a mason for me right now.
