Mini 326- Buffy Mafia-Game Over

[Aelyn]

Vote: Adele

(Sibling rivalry)

[Aelyn]

Do not read this post.

Sorry

[Aelyn]

Nor do I, really.

Unvote, Vote: StevieT92

[Aelyn]

Stevie: It would be best to check with the mod if it's OK to answer, but whenabouts in Faith's period are you?

Also, I have a strong feeling he is Faith. But I'm not sure what alignment Faith would be.

Bah.

[Aelyn]

There were 12 people at the start of this game.

Presumably:
3 Mafia
1 Doctor (dead)
1 Cop
1 Vig
6 Townies (1 dead)

Faith didn't claim Cop or Vig. So:

3/8: Faith is Mafia
5/8: Faith is a Townie

There is a 38% shot Faith is Mafia. Given Stevie's actions that's not enough for me to unvote.

FOS: Notguilty

for speculating on the setup, without any proof, and then using this as a basis for maintaining a vote.

Twito: The game isn't timed, I believe that's stated explicilty. However, the role PMs we've seen have included the seasons of that the character - note that Finn was described as season 5 and not seasons 4 and 5.

Therefore it's worth checking, if Stevie is allowed to comment, if he's Faith from early season 3, later season 3, or even season 7.

As I say, we don't know the setup. A rolename cop's a real possibility in a theme game, and Stevie knows it. His claim really gives us no additional info on his allegiance.

Very true, which was exactly why I said I felt he is Faith :p

[Aelyn]

*drums fingers*

Can someone either hammer Stevie or say something incredibly scummy so we can get this game moving again?

[Aelyn]

Can someone either hammer Stevie or say something incredibly scummy so we can get this game moving again?

Discussion is good for town. Quickly forcing a lynch isn't.

FOS: Aelyn

Agreed, but frankly I wouldn't exactly call this discussion - at least, not the last few days.

I'll admit I said that somewhat out of frustration, but us sitting around waiting for someone else to place the hammer vote doesn't do anything, and I wanted to get the game moving.

[Aelyn]

Yes there were no discussion and I can understand you feeling frustrated. So nomore FOS on you. But now there is discussion and you could join it.

Yep, there is indeed.

Firstly, Adele's been attacking you by association, saying your actions were consistentwith you being a scumbuddy of Stevie's, and I have to sa I agree with her.

You voted him early, as the bandwagon began to form, but rapidly unvoted him when he began to look in real danger.

You repeatedly reminded him to roleclaim (once when you unvoted, then made a post which was basically "Hey, Stevie, RC") - admittedly this isn't scummy, but as soon as he does roleclaim:

Ok well that was the shortest claim I've seen but I guess I can believe it if we don't get counterclaim. Coz that really is a role I would expect in this game.

It seems like your main reason for believing him is that you'd expect Faith to be in the game.

You now say that, because he claimed Season 7 Faith, he should be innocent - you don't seem to be considering the possibility he's lying, which has been brought up.

Finally, you made a list of characters who could be innocent or guilty - now, it seems to me that that could well be you setting up to weaken other people's claims in the future, should we lynch Stevie and have him show up as scum.

Frankly, if someone claimed Willow, Spike or Angel, yes, I'd be perfectly willing to

consider

lynching them, if they seemed scummy. Even Oz could realistically be an SK.

And finally, presumably because Stevie's a lost cause, you hammer him. Immediately after inviting me to join the conversation.

Conditional FOS: Twito

[Aelyn]

*drums fingers*

[Aelyn]

This game seems quite dead. I'm gonna re-read and see what I can say.

[Aelyn]

I would like to be replaced. I'm taking a break from playing Mafia for a while...

I'm really sorry to do this, guys, but I simply can't motivate myself to play at all at the moment.