I have to disagree. When a vigilante tries to kill this mafia member and it fails, it could mean that a doc protected the target OR that the target is immune to night kills and possibly mafia.PolarBoy wrote:Giving it to a mafia member could be royally unfair in a game with vigs, as it could make the vig useless.
In Full Communication mafia, I was the godfather and immune to night kills. I believe that Dragon Slayer was a vigilante and he tried to kill me one night. Of cource, I did not die. They asked me to explain the next day. I made something up about being able to protect myself. They didn't buy it and lynched me.
So instead of killing someone that night, the vigilante becomes some kind of a cop.