PYP 4: New Homes, Same Problems (Day 5)

[PranaDevil]

I'm also shocked that Gud never got nightkilled. Unless they were afraid that the watcher may have been watching Gud (when it was, in fact, that Gud was the watcher).

[Katsuki]

Yeah... I wasn't lying when I said I chose our numbers on a whim. I was one of those who forgot to submit their numbers and had spyspy sending mean threatening messages.

[Guderian]

Maybe a potential mislynch?

They blocked me night 1, maybe assuming I was vig/cop, and went after vollkan/chk, which they knew contained the gunsmith. Then the weak doc n2, and then the real gunsmith because cop was out.

I guess the WIFOM factor also considering they thought the watcher was who knows who also prevented them from trying it.

[Fate]

Nacho claimed scum in the QT yesterday, btw.

I didn't out him because I love him. I refuse to vote him.

Oh also I'm vanilla to roleblocker in case it wasn't obvious

[Hoopla]

Were you happy with what your gambits achieved? I don't think anyone got any info from them...

[Guderian]

Where be spyrex? I want to see all that nice scum/neighbor quick topics.

I don't think you messing around with tracker/tracker claims really threw the scum off their game. It was more the fact about inside knowledge of roleblocker.

[Katsuki]

Were you happy with what your gambits achieved? I don't think anyone got any info from them...

I for one thought they were absolutely ridiculous.

[SpyreX]

One more time we move. We hunt.

We succeed.

Nachomamma, Neighborizer, has been lynched.

TOWN WINS!

[Guderian]

Woo!

[SpyreX]

Guderian 1,1 3-Shot-Watcher 3-Shot-Watcher
Volkan 2,6 Gunsmith Gunsmith
chkflip 9,5 Super-Saint Super-Saint
Gandalf 12,1 Gunsmith Vanilla
Benmage 3,4 3-Shot-Watcher Vanilla
slowsilver 3,5 Jailkeeper Jailkeeper
Ellibereth 5,1 Neighborizer Neighborizer
Rabies 5,7 Neighborizer Vanilla
Hoopla 10,1 Jailkeeper Vanilla
Le Cupcake 10,6 Even-Night Vig Even-Night Vig
Jack 11,1 3-shot roleblocker 3-shot roleblocker
xvart 11,7 Even-Night Vig Vanilla
Fate 13,1 3-shot roleblocker Vanilla
PranaDevil 13,10 Cop Cop
llamafluff 8,1 Neighborizer Vanilla
Parama 8,5 3-Shot-Watcher Vanilla
inHimshallibe 8,7 Weak Doctor Weak Doctor
Drippinggoofball 6,10 Weak Doctor Vanilla
iamausername 6,11 Gunsmith Vanilla
Andrius 6,1 Super-Saint Vanilla
Sajin 6,1 Weak Doctor Vanilla
Pomegranate 6,1 NOTHING Vanilla

N1
slowsilver JAILS Vollkan SUCCESS
PranaDevil INVESTIGATES Pomegranate SUCCESS - Innocent
InHim PROTECTS Hoopla SUCCESS
Guderian WATCHES Jack FAILURE
Jack BLOCKS guderian SUCCESS
KILLS chkflip SUCCESS
Ellibereth NEIGHBORS Vollkan SUCCESS

N2
Le Cupcake KILLS Parama SUCCESS
PranaDevil INVESTIGATES llamafluff SUCCESS - Innocent
Guderian WATCHES llamafluff SUCCES - PranaDevil
Vollkan GUNSMITH Andrius FAILURE
inHim PROTECTS Fate SUCCESS
Ellibereth NEIGHBORS Fate SUCCESS
Jack BLOCKS Vollkan SUCCESS
Drippinggoofball KILLS inHim SUCCESS

N3
PranaDevil INVESTIGATES Le Cupcake SUCCESS - Innocent
Guderian WATCHES PranaDevil SUCCESS
Vollkan GUNSMITH Le Cupcake SUCCESS - GUN
Ellibereth NEIGHBORS DrippingGoofBall SUCCESS
DrippingGoofBall KILLS Vollkan SUCCESS

N4
PranaDevil INVESTIGATES Ellibereth SUCCESS - Guilty
LeCupcake KILLS DrippingGoofBall SUCCESS
Guderian WATCHES PranaDevil SUCCESS

[Parama]

My READS SUCKED WOO
I blame Fate for telling me early on that Jack was town.

[SpyreX]

http://www.quicktopic.com/45/H/kCg2GMpNNKu <--- Dead chat.

All other chats are up to the respective parties to party out.

All in all, once D1 went the way it did, I thought it was going to be a town sweep. And it was.

My only disappointment is the 2 modkills.

[PranaDevil]

Twice I've been called scum in these games and I've been town... When will you guys realize that I ALWAYS look scummy?

[Parama]

Start playing better then.

[Hoopla]

Strange game - a pretty lacklustre performance from scum. Being so far ahead as town from Day 3 onward kind of sucked the life out of the game, and made it a little unfun, to the point where I wasn't motivated to find scum. It's hard to say how much influence the numbers/role distribution had, or if the big win was due to the performances of each team - I think the game could have been so much different if we lynched, say, Guderian on D1 and lost our watcher, rather than scum going down to 4 players early. I expected a little more creativity, particularly with a Jack/Elli/DGB scumteam - it's a shame it fizzled out so quickly, because I think the roles on offer gave plenty of scope to creating false-confirmations, or clever framing of townies.

I'm curious to know how much effort the scum put into their pregame strategy, because I think it was an unusual set of rolechoices really.

[PranaDevil]

Start playing better then.

Says the guy who barely called any scum... and calls other scum "obv town", despite playing the exact same trick in the last game.

[Guderian]

I'm not sure why this game blew apart after D1, but it did.

Good on Llama.

[Benmage]

I'm sorry, but the whole scum team played atrociously, jack least atrocious of all...but this game was way too easy.

I half thought of nominating this town for a scummy....but the opposition didn't seem good enough....then again some of the things that get nom'd these days...

[Guderian]

spyrex, Did you have thoughts on the game, watching from your modseat?

[Pomegranate]

http://www.quicktopic.com/45/H/kCg2GMpNNKu <--- Dead chat.

All other chats are up to the respective parties to party out.

All in all, once D1 went the way it did, I thought it was going to be a town sweep. And it was.

My only disappointment is the 2 modkills.

It wasn't a sweep- we lynched Andy. If only he hadn't lurked so badly.

[Guderian]

Having five days and five scum dead is pretty sweep-tastic.

[Fate]

Were you happy with what your gambits achieved? I don't think anyone got any info from them...

Would've worked wonders if Cupcake was scum, agreed?

[Parama]

Start playing better then.

Says the guy who barely called any scum... and calls other scum "obv town", despite playing the exact same trick in the last game.

Yet very few thought I was scum. And I acknowledged my reads sucked, but if you want to see me owning scum, go check out Mini 1063, Mini 1079 or Mini 1093. Those are probably the three most recent examples.

[LlamaFluff]

Well my play in this game wasnt too great scum-read wise, but at least I was right on the Gud read from very early on, and sorta right on Andrius but caved there because it obviously wasnt going anywhere.

[Benmage]

Yet very few thought I was scum.

You killed for being believed to be scum....

but if you want to see me owning scum, go check out Mini 1063, Mini 1079 or Mini 1093. Those are probably the three most recent examples.

You can just tell me the size of your dick and I'll believe you.