Mini 256 - Peanuts mafia - Game over

[elvis_knits]

vote: sotty7 for mayor

....because of girl power

[elvis_knits]

Yeah, I think it's good enough to start with mlaker for mayor and impeach later if we need to. Electing someone to mayor may actually be a good way to tell if someone is scum.

unvote
vote mlaker for mayor

Actually...maybe we should go with a mayor who posts often. I see mlaker hasn't checked in yet. The game hasn't been open very long, but I think if we find ourselves (at any point) with a mayor who is lurking, we should elect a different one.

[elvis_knits]

Mlaker you have to remember many things but I think more importantly is this;

you are the single biggest target for suspicion

, not us, because if people see scumminess in you they will at least impeach you if not lynch you and you need to watch your step because power corrupts and power is a burden not a gift.

Is that why you voted mlaker before he even posted?

vote: pickle

[elvis_knits]

I was sort of confused about that too. I don't know if our lynching votes counted before Pinky posted the mayor election. A vote count would help, I guess.

[elvis_knits]

I <3 Pinky

[elvis_knits]

I can confirm that LyingBrian has also just done this hidden message stuff in another mini we are in. It's an ongoing game and what his role is (scum or town) has not been revealed. Not sure if that even matters. He could do it as scum or town, I think.

But, if nobody else claims Lucy, I'd be inclined to believe him. I think Lucy would definitely be a role that SOMEBODY would have, so if nobody else claims Lucy, we should believe LB.

[elvis_knits]

The more I think about it, Lucy could just as easily be a scum role. I mean taking the football away from Charlie Brown is not only sort of roleblocking, but evil and mean!

I agree Pickle has been acting weird, but in light of LB's claim and Snap's counter, I have to

vote: LyingBrian

[elvis_knits]

oh it would help if I unvoted first...

unvote
vote: LyingBrian

[elvis_knits]

Good point, Sotty. What's the harm in Snap revealing his role name?

[elvis_knits]

I don't think anybody jumped from voting LB to voting Snap. I think we are more inclined to believe Snap because LB claimed roleblocker under presure of being lynched, and then Snap came out as roleblocker to counterclaim LB.

Also, nobody's REALLY EVIL in peanuts. But relatively, Lucy *could* be evil because she always tricks Charlie Brown with the football. I also think she isn't that nice to Linus, her younger brother. Doesn't she call him a baby because of his blanket? (not sure).

[elvis_knits]

Good idea.

Vote Snap for Mayor

[elvis_knits]

Pickles are sexy.

I guess the only thing to do is consider your sanity, Pickle. To me, it doesn't seem likely for Charlie Brown to be insane. I mean, isn't he our hero? Seems like a good cop role.

It's possible that Snap can back you up, depending on who he roleblocked last night (as there was no kill). Then there would be no question of your sanity, and the doc could protect you while you find out who the remaining mafioso is. There's probably, three, right? And maybe an SK?

First we have to elect a mayor though.

[elvis_knits]

We had seven votes for Snap as mayor, and that's how many we needed yesterday, so I would guess it's enough today with one less person. And last time, votes to lynch DID count before Pinky posted the official mayor election.

[elvis_knits]

If DP is telling the truth, we just lynch Quidgyboo tomorrow. Seems like a good plan to me.

vote: Dragon Pheonix

[elvis_knits]

Pinky

, how many to lynch today?

[elvis_knits]

vote: Dragon Pheonix

I wish people would learn how to spell....

Oh, sorry!

unvote; vote Dragon Phoenix

[elvis_knits]

All hail Pickle!

Where are d_rouge and mlaker? I guess we can't be that hard on them because of the holiday, but I don't think either of them posted all yesterday. Not cool as far as I'm concerned.

oh and... Happy Merry HoHo's (belated)!

[elvis_knits]

In mini 255:

ill be going down to FLORIDA to visit family over the new years... dec 25 - jan 2

I think he has limited access though. But I'm not sure. But I do know he REALLY wants to be in this game.

[elvis_knits]

I agree with sotty. I thought a hider could protect themself, not protect someone else. But I also have never played with a hider before, so I don't know.

Pickle --
Why do you think Stoofer should claim? I assumed you investigated Stoofer in thinking that he is probably town, and if you get a guilty verdict you know you're paranoid. Maybe I'm wrong though. Do you think you're sane? If you're sane then Quidgbo and Stoofer are our two remaining scum, and you are an exceptionally lucky cop to hit scum 3/3 times. And if you're paranoid, your guilty investigation on Stoofer doesn't mean anything. I don't think he should claim unless we think he's guilty for other reasons.

[elvis_knits]

What is the harm in him claiming

I think the harm would be if he's a power role. Also, if he's not a power role, it narrows it down for scum who are trying to find the doc.

I'm less interested in Stoofer claiming right now than I am hearing about Quidgyboo's "hider" power. I want to know if he protects himself or whoever he hides with. I also have been thinking about the possibility that Woodstock is a "safe role" for scum and nobody really is woodstock. If two scum claim woodstock and we lynch one and find scum, we probably believe the other woodstock. But I think we should still keep an eye on Quidgyboo, especially because I don't understand the hider/protection angle.

[elvis_knits]

I agree with almost all of what Stoofer has said (don't use this against me like last time, Stoofer!). Highest on my suspicious list is Iammars and Sotty7. Next is probably mlaker because he's been lurking. Maybe that's excusable because of the holiday. Though he did say he would do a re-read on Monday and hasn't posted yet. d_rouge, I feel is impossible to read right now because he posted once (I think, not sure), and is going to be replaced.

I want to hear from Quidgyboo about his role before I vote, but I could go for either Iammars or Sotty to lynch.

[elvis_knits]

Oh. Mlaker totally posted... on this page. Still though, hasn't contributed much. When somebody promises a re-read, I expect something helpful.

[elvis_knits]

Why am I scummy to you?

The best thing I have is how you unvoted DP in the middle of the wagon on him yesterday. Other than that I just sort of feel like your posts have been "off." It's sort of a gut feeling.

To elaborate on the DP wagon unvote -- unvoting your scum buddy is a safe thing to do when there is no claim and counterclaim. Letting DP claim actually helped the mafia because it got Quidgyboo to counterclaim. Another power role outed for the mafia. Then when DP was one from lynch and looking unsavable, you put the finishing vote on DP.

Also, a lot of your posts have been speculation on set-up, which doesn't really help.

I can def. see two roleblockers in a mini, if the mafia has a lot of power.

Then you and DP went back and forth for a while arguing if this is possible, if it's "weird" or not. (All of which doesn't help find scum, IMHO).

Maybe we have no mafia at all, and the evil is in our heads!
Sorry, was reading the crucible, and this idea popped into my mind.

So I see where this is a joke and all, but combined with a lack of helpful posts, it makes me suspicious of you. Like you want to post, but you still want to lay low.

[elvis_knits]

Quidgyboo -- when I was talking about the possibility of Woodstock being a safe role I just meant that it was a POSSIBILITY. You are definitely not in the forefront of my suspicion, but since I didn't understand your role, I was just saying it is something to keep in the back of our heads.

My strongest suspicions are about Iammars and Sotty, but I have been waiting for discussion to pick back up. I think there have been some people on vacay and what not, but they should be getting back. Now we can get back to business.

[elvis_knits]

You haven't been replaced. Post away!

[elvis_knits]

/thirded...I do not believe pickle is sane.

I am up for voting Iammars or Sotty. Sotty has seemed to handle the suspicion in a very non-scummy way. I am thinking she is either scum just playing this very well, or that she is town and the fact that she was roleblocked is a coincidence. As for Iammars, I've gotten more of a scummy feeling (for reasons outlined before).

[elvis_knits]

Hmmm...[/thinking]

[elvis_knits]

[Indeed, I am perplexed as to why DP claimed Woodstock instead of claiming Sally. I for one would not have regarded Sally as a scummy role (though I still would have voted DP).]

I think that DP claimed Woodstock so that he could claim his "tracker" role better. Saying Sally is a tracker makes no sense.

The other possibility is that he claimed Woodstock as a safe role. Then Quidgyboo counterclaimed him to cement his own innocence. I know Quidgyboo is not a fan of this option , but I'm just saying it's a possibility. I wouldn't seriously believe this is the case unless I saw some other scummy actions from Quidgyboo, which I have not.

[elvis_knits]

raj replaced d_rouge, I believe.

Can the anti-stooferites please expand why they think he's scummy. And for Pickle, why did you investigate him in the first place.

[elvis_knits]

Actually, Iammars, your claim makes me less sure that you're scum. But I still think you're scum for the way you've been acting.

And if Stoofer says he'll claim tomorrow, I'm ready to end this day.

vote iammars

[elvis_knits]

THAT WAS AWESOME!

I thought that Stoofer was cop, but then when Pickle and Quailman (my mason) voted for Stoofer, I got very confused! I still thought Stoofer was probably a cop, but it couldn't hurt to a)challenge him a little and b) throw some suspicion his way so that maybe mafia don't kill him tonight. But now there is no night! Exciting.

I'm Marcie, and Quailman is Franklin.

Good job to all!

[elvis_knits]

Stoofer, when you made your post that did a run-down on everyone you found scummy, I posted and said how I agreed with "almost" everything you said. Then I left Quailman out of who I thought was scummy. Then I noticed you didn't go after Quailman. Did you realize he was my mason?

[elvis_knits]

Oh well, it still worked out anyway!