Mini 1040 - Everyone's A Critic! [Game Over]

[DavidParker]

Vote: Antihero

First on the list for the first vote.

[DavidParker]

Jack is town.

[DavidParker]

mykonian is town for noticing we are town.. oh wait. Third to jump on obv scum!

[DavidParker]

Town:
Jack
danakillsu
Stef
Jelly Jiggler
Haschel

Scum:
XScorpion
Antihero

Take your pick out of those 2 for our lynch. Let's get this moving.

[DavidParker]

Town:
Jack
danakillsu
Stef
Jelly Jiggler
Haschel

Scum:
XScorpion

Antihero

RedCoyote

Take your pick out of those 2 for our lynch. Let's get this moving.

[DavidParker]

sorry guys i've gotten really sick and have the worst migraines so any form of looking at a screen does not go well with my head. Hopefully will be better in next few days.

[DavidParker]

Lay off Jack, he is definitely town.

[DavidParker]

Hey guys, I'm here now. (Much) Healthy(er).

You can choose to judge me all you want for those sporadic posts, but they were done just to keep from being replaced because I had every intent of catching up and providing input in this game. Monday I actually left work after 2 hours with a fever/migraines and I didn't eat for 2 days etc etc. It's now Thursday and I'm feeling considerably better. I posted a few times in between when I was bored of sleeping all day and couldn't sleep and was too uncomfortable from lying in bed for whatever reason, but I definitely couldn't force myself to catch up or think about this game.

Anyways, enough of the life story. Heh.

One thing that has stood out is a strong town vibe from Jack, however, that for me was all based on his initial post so I've definitely been biased from that. The fact he would come out and say the setup has 2 scum is a peculiar thing to say, something that a scum wouldn't want to inform the town on. As to how (or if he really does) know this information, I find somewhat irrelevent to me getting a town vibe. But the setup is somewhat important, so

@Jack: What makes you think there is only 2 scum?

Apart from that the initial scum list I made was just the impression of peoples random votes and the tone in them. Really, it's a weak form of scum-hunting, and usually ineffective, but it was my way of at least having some thoughts on players.

To me, RC's latest post goes against the scum vibe I had on him so a re-read of him is in order. (As well as a reread on the entire thread, since I'm not really up to date). Right now I'm leaning towards a mykonian lynch. Reasons to come!

[DavidParker]

Well yes, it's just a peculiar, attention-grabbing thing to say that doesn't strike me as something scum would do on page 1 with their first post.

Yes, it's WIFOM'y, but that's just how I see it. And I don't know anything of Jack's meta like you guys.

Also, mykonos, i'm anti-wall posts so don't expect a huge analysis on you.

[DavidParker]

Actually, my reason for voting you from earlier on in the day phase has been made moot by something I realized.

I'm going to do a '180 and OMGUS the socks off of Magna.

MagnaOfIllusion

For going after an "easy" target (me), and 10 pages in having his vote on someone (me) who hasn't even noticed it's been on him til now because of my absence from the game. To me that strikes as scummy behaviour wanting to use your vote somewhere you won't be called out for and you won't get caught on a bandwagon either. Your vote being on me has basically been as good as not voting.

And I'd like to reassert my sureness that Jack is, indeed, town!

[DavidParker]

You're out of my black-book for now.

[DavidParker]

That was

Vote: magnaofillusion

Btw.

[DavidParker]

Vote: dana

So we can actually get a bandwagon going, and me not wasting a vote on someone for a weak case that noone is going to join on.

I find the best case out of Dana/Jack/Stef to be this one.

Also, @MoI: Those lists I made were mostly just to avoid being prodded/replaced and a quasi-attempt of providing input to the game, even if it was generally false and bad input. I was too sick (have been on penicilin for past week or so) to do anything, until now. I couldn't focus/read/think about anything, so I just wrote some dribble posts. I have every intention of playing and actually following the thread from now on.

[DavidParker]

Well it just seems kinda useless to me...

[DavidParker]

Sure they might. I think any pseudo-PR stuff that comes in the open is bad for town and helps scum more.

[DavidParker]

Because I'm awesome.

[DavidParker]

Vote: mykonian

[DavidParker]

Yeah you might be waiting a while. For nothing. Just sayin'.
Definitely not surprised at shotty hopping on the same wagon as me so I don't pay attention to him. That's right, IGMEOY shotty.

I'd love to hear why DavidParker shouldn't be lynched today...totally loving his last vote btw, real pro-town to throw a vote out without explanation </sarcasm>
If I had to make a guess right now, I'd say Jack/DavidParker/Dana scumteam.

The fact you actually think that is the most probable scum team right now makes me question both your intelligence and your alignment. That is the practically the least likely scum team I see possible.

[DavidParker]

EBWOP:

Sometimes it's best to just set aside your suspect for a few days and let the game develop, it seems that way to me anyway.

This quote is hilarious after the White Flag Mafia fiasco.

I was in no such game.

Altrfinght, herdsz the deal. Ja k an d i were recently ina game called Whikte Flag Magia wi9th Roed COyote and Drmyshottyhjiszik. n this ghame we staretged a bandwagon on drmyushottyhikszei, that ultimately resulted on is lujnch. Redxcohyt was an unerequilteed bestf riend witbh drmyhshotthyjissik anre post garme we talke about how inf redcoutote had claimed earlier thane we might have avoided two mizslynfches.

Nopwe we bhave a game - the game ONE RIGHRTE AFTER WHItEFlag - where we have THE EZXACT SAME CILAIM in similar circumstances (i., e gthe firzst major bandwagon just happens to be congfiemed towen by someboyd esle- an Redcoyhtoe downsnt thintk it[s worht commentinhg on. i find terhisd bizawrre., I';m not sayuhjting that Jack is not a cunreequitred neigrfbor but ikt do think it is mindzbolrdvgggling that redcouvotye doent find this odd at all. SAtef and dqana have been invdceredibvly scumy this game, so werhen somebo9unbdyh sayhs something that cleafdredsx one oft mu two major suspectesx it'm fgoine to liik t6o see if thewstory mkaes sense. jacdk's stoyur is not impowssible. butr is it improbsbler? io thiknyt swo.

i UNDREWSTAND MYKONIKAN'S POJKNT ABOUT MOH THERE IS BEYR EW SCENARISONS TAHT RESULT IN A SCMMMM STEF FEVREN IF HHACK IS LYING BUT IF THINK THAERE IS A PISTTIBILIYT THAT JACK ASSUMES THAQT REDCOYOTE AND I WILL BE CAUTION WHEN VONTRONTED WHTI THE UNTEQUITED NERINGHBOR CLim so I'm noiw quite qure what to thinm,k. my gut says that jakf is lyinghm, but i'm noiut sure. hjis pluarystye this game is rapikdly becom3ing unJMaklike, and iwant to press Rodscotute to see what he hitnks.

aint he meantime i am not unffotinh Stref; zslghoui mykonisn raises a vsalaind point I think awite flang magia makines things not mneatly as cuyt and drikned.

WAIT. WHAT.

I just deciphered this and agree it is very bizarre.

BUT, Jack just DENIED being in said game. So..... Someone link or explain this.

[DavidParker]

So, can someone clear up the whole game issue that jack is saying he wasn't in and Haschel is saying he was in where Jack had the same role?

[DavidParker]

Jack this game:
Posts: 42/391 = 10.74%

Jack as lurking scum (vanillaside):
Posts:17/749 = 2.27%


My play this game is my town meta, check physics mafia. Difference is I held back my opinion for a while instead of vote hopping.

bonus:

Yeah I think

hero

-exe-

kdub

is most likely.

5.

Kdub

, The Higgs Boson;

Mafia Roleblocker

, lynched Day 1
2. Exe Nightwolf, Werner Heisenberg, Quantum Theorist (Tracker/Watcher), Killed Night 1 (vigged by ythill)
3. Jack, Wave Theory, Vanilla Townie, Killed Night 1
1.

Herodotus

, Sir Issac Newton,

Mafia Godfather

, lynched Day 3

I don't like you claiming yourself that this is your town meta. But I still find myko scummier.

[DavidParker]

Well magna is town, but so am I, so he's wrong about that :/

[DavidParker]

I'd like David. He's been sneaking around, his alliances and scumreads are all over the place, and he's absent when we need him most. I just feel like he's faking his scumhunting more than anyone else here (with the exception possibly of dr.shotty, but that's a different thing).

ALSO...what scumhunting is david faking?? He isn't really scumhunting. I find it very hard to believe that redcoyote finds david scummy for these reasons.

Haha this. I've never "faked" any scum hunting because I don't claim to have made a huge effort to scum hunt. I have posted who I find scummy and who I don't. And voted in accordance.

[DavidParker]

Of course you'll hammer, scum.

[DavidParker]

I'm glad you've found a way to "justify" your hammer.

[DavidParker]

Why wait?

[DavidParker]

Anyways, in that hour you gave me I couldn't figure out a good fakeclaim :/

SO..

Claim: Mafia Goon

[DavidParker]

davidp was clearly town and his claim was was clearly town...scum can think of a fake claim easy!

That rush to end the day confused me greatly.

Obviously!!!

DP calls Jack obv-town all game.
Jack claims a role that proves a scummy person is town.
Suddenly DP calls Jack scum.
DP claims scum.

I don't know how you can't think this makes Jack a pretty decent choice for scum. And even if you don't think it makes him more likely scum, how you turn that into "the person saying that must be scum". Also, as I stated, if the vig flip shows he is telling the truth, it clears Stef, which removes a mislynch target from the game (not ideal but not terrible). If he flips scum, YEAH!

What specifically about my play are you equating to Castlevania? Cause I don't see it.

Umm. I don't remember calling jack scum, in fact i never thought he was scum for a second, i just started getting skeptical when some game was brought up where he made a similar claim or a similar role was used and he claimed it here. Regardless, it was intentional, i never really thought jack was scum for a second this game. If at any point I suggested he might be scum it was probably merely to save myself since i knew i was town and was only 95% sure jack was town.

It's funny how jack was my only town read and he was so sure i was town, but everyone else was sure both of us were scum.