Smalltown Marathon! Game Over ~ Town Win!

[Alduskkel]

/in JOAT

[Alduskkel]

Confirm.

[Alduskkel]

I always figured he was Dr. My Shotty Is Sick

[Alduskkel]

I propose a mass claim.

Discuss.

[Alduskkel]

I am pro-Town. Shadow Dancer should go next.

If anyone counterclaims me they're scum.

[Alduskkel]

Vote: Shadow Dancer

for counter claiming me.

[Alduskkel]

Anyone who doesn't claim in their next post is trying to think up a fake claim and is scum!!!

[Alduskkel]

Is that a hippo-based government system?

[Alduskkel]

Brandi should be the one to hammer ani if we ever want to lynch him.

[Alduskkel]

Why would Mafia kill someone who is just going to come back to life?

[Alduskkel]

Unvote, Vote: gandalf5166

bandwagoner.

[Alduskkel]

Given the nature of the role, Brandi is twice as likely to be scum as anyone else.

Walk me through this logic.

[Alduskkel]

Unvote, Vote SocioPath

for crap logic.

[Alduskkel]

Why?

[Alduskkel]

I wonder how Brandi's probability of being scum when she revives is calculated.

[Alduskkel]

How is my SocioPath vote opportunistic?

[Alduskkel]

Role Claim: JOAT.

Would you lynch one of your power roles???

[Alduskkel]

"Walk me through this logic." = Rhetorical response. I had already decided it was crap logic.

[Alduskkel]

"Walk me through this logic." = Rhetorical response. I had already decided it was crap logic.

You had already decided you were going to vote me too then I assume.

Yes.

[Alduskkel]

Brandi had the same odds of being scum as anyone else at the beginning of the game.

Then, we don't know what the odds of her being scum after revival are.

So, it was crap logic. Case closed. Does anyone actually buy SP's logic?

[Alduskkel]

What am I at, L-1?

[Alduskkel]

But I'm

right

, Parama.

[Alduskkel]

By the way, if Brandi flips scum first time, she has to be scum second time. Oh, and I'd be happy lynching SD or Ald.

Why would she have to be scum second time?!

Otherwise she'd know who all the scum were but would be pro-Town.

Once again I have the superior logic and I'm still getting lynched...

[Alduskkel]

Crap logic is scummy if you're using it to make someone else look scummy when really they aren't.

[Alduskkel]

[Alduskkel]

This is also so sudden. Now I have to figure out the vote count and stuff.

SP, your logic is still crap.

[Alduskkel]

I never said SP was Town. All I said was his logic was crap. That's a fact.

Also, since I'm the Mod I get to see the revival odds so yeah I'm fucking right here.

[Alduskkel]

Shadow Dancer (3) - Parama, animorpherv1, SocioPath
Parama (1) - Shadow Dancer

Not Voting (3) - Brandi, ReaperCharlie, gandalf5166

Votes were reset after my death. And with 7 alive it is 4 to lynch.

[Alduskkel]

Shadow Dancer (4) - Parama, animorpherv1, SocioPath, gandalf5166
Netlava (1) - Shadow Dancer

Not Voting (2) - Brandi, Netlava

With 7 alive it is 4 to lynch.

[Alduskkel]

Shadow Dancer was lynched. He was Town.

Night 1. Send me your actions.

[Alduskkel]

Also, talking during the Night will result in modkill.

[Alduskkel]

Parama was killed. He was Town. Day 2 ends 15 minutes from this post.

[Alduskkel]

Brandi (1) - gandalf5166
animorpherv1 (1) - Brandi

Not Voting (3) - Netlava, animorpherv1, SocioPath

5 alive 3 to lynch.

[Alduskkel]

Brandi (2) - gandalf5166, SocioPath
animorpherv1 (1) - Brandi
gandalf5166 (1) - animorpherv1

Not Voting (1) - Netlava

5 alive 3 to lynch.

[Alduskkel]

Deadline in 3 minutes.

[Alduskkel]

Brandi (3) - gandalf5166, SocioPath, Netlava
gandalf5166 (2) - animorpherv1, Brandi

Not Voting (0)

5 alive 3 to lynch.

Brandi was Town. She revives as an unknown alignment/role.

Night ends in 7 minutes from this post.

[Alduskkel]

gandalf5166 and Netlava were killed. Both were Town.

With 3 alive it is 2 to lynch.

[Alduskkel]

SocioPath (1) - gandalf5166

Not Voting (2) - Brandi, SocioPath

3 alive 2 to lynch.

[Alduskkel]

animorpherv1, Scum, was lynched.

SocioPath, Town, explodes.

Brandi, Town (New Role: 1-Shot NK Immune) and the rest of the Town, wins.

[Alduskkel]

Reincarnator Table:
1. Town
2. Town
3. Town
4. Town
5. SK
6. SK
7. SK
8. SK
9-10. Mafia/Cult/Lyncher
-- equal chance of each

Inventor Table
1. suicidebomb
-- Kills another player and yourself.
2. hide
-- Makes yourself untargetable for one night.
3. guard
-- You can guard another player. If that player would be killed, you will be killed instead.
4. jailkeep
-- You can jailkeep another player, protecting and roleblocking their action.
5. inspect
6. kill

Reincarnator Table only applies if Brandi is Town the first time around. If she was Scum the first time around, the table would be different (but I don't know what it would be).

Therefore, the logic debate between me and SocioPath is UNRESOLVED.

[Alduskkel]

Whoops on my part though for partially confirming SocioPath. As you can see from the above table though, Brandi might have been Third Party and would have won alone.

[Alduskkel]

Yes, but if Brandi had gone SK then the game would not have been over.

[Alduskkel]

Yes, but if Brandi had gone SK then the game would not have been over.

Point was she had twice as many opportunities to be scum.

I can do the actual math if you want...

I don't think you can do all the math without the Reincarnator (Scum) table which you'd need KittyMo to give you.

[Alduskkel]

I can do the actual math if you want...

Correct me if I'm wrong. ( )

But 6/8 town slots is 75% town.

On death, 1-4 were town for 40% town.


Math says % chance of Brandi remaining town throughout the game: 30%

Except that Brandi would not necessarily die. Also, depending on the Reincarnator table for scum she could have gone from scum to town, though that sounds game breaking to me, and a town option might not have been in there, but if you make that assumption then you'd always want to lynch Brandi again if she was scum the first time, which defeats the purpose of the Reincarnator role, so maybe you would want to include a town option.

[Alduskkel]

If BOMBSCUM is lynched before the other scum, it's not a useless role.

[Alduskkel]

Or NK'd for that matter.

[Alduskkel]

I think Town loses if a town member hammers BOMBSCUM. If the last Mafia member survives the night and makes a successful NK, that leaves 1 town member and 1 scum. Game over, Mafia wins.

[Alduskkel]

Well, what if you force someone who you think is scum to hammer the bombscum?

[Alduskkel]

Well, bombscum is useful if he gets night killed.

[Alduskkel]

Then that makes Bombscum NK immune.