Open 238: Trendy and Subversive Game Over

[mallowgeno]

Gonnano I"ve never played with you before...

Vote the liar, gonnano

[mallowgeno]

just kidding

[mallowgeno]

Looking deeply into things is good.

unvote, Vote ODDin

[mallowgeno]

unvote

Fos Gonn

Just a gut feeling. And I don't wanna waste my lynch on a random vote.

[mallowgeno]

I am currently not voting anyone jmj

Thank you mallow, I missed the post where you invoted. Get an avatar you

[mallowgeno]

You still didn't say why you're not voting, though.

This to me just seems scummy fmpov. Either you're:
A. trying to divert attention
B. genuinely wanting an explanation

I'm leaning towards the former...

[mallowgeno]

Vote ODDin

[mallowgeno]

whoops sorry

unvote, vote TeeJay

I think podium made a great case. voting w/o reasons is scummy as well as contradicting yourself.

[mallowgeno]

Hrm I misread that sorry.

unvote

[mallowgeno]

Diverting attention from what, exactly? In my very first post I said teejay didn't vote and said I didn't like it. Then teejay posted but didn't respond to it, so I pointed out he didn't respond. It's not like there was something to divert attention from.

Grr I need to read more carefully. I'm trying to contribute, but my scumhunting skills are very poor as you can tell.

[mallowgeno]

Now that you mention it ODDin, he has been AtEing a lot:

A. It wasn't

ME

that almost killed the game, it was gonnano... for quoting an ongoing game.

B. Gonnano accused me of being scum based on his (incorrect) notion that i was acting differently in this game... i disputed that. And here you are telling me that i am scum for disputing that? Really? What was i supposed to do, just agree with him and lynch myself?

Your vote on me is weak, incorrect, and generally not well thought out. Seems very scummy.

Wow, defensive rather quickly. Considering that this is only the second page, I find it disturbing that you were so quick to become defensive.

??

If someone seriously accuses you of being scum, then what is wrong with defending yourself... regardless of if it's page 1 or 21?

I'm 'disturbed' that you are more concerned with my justified response, than with his seemingly scummy accusations/vote.

Lol I found this one very funny:

Again, i ask you... how was my defense an overreaction? ?? What should i have done?? Agreed with him??

^overreacting when he's trying to say he wasn't overreacting

Overall analysis: Scum

[mallowgeno]

I wish millar posted more so I could ISO him. Three posts isn't going to cut it.

[mallowgeno]

vote podium

That puts him at L-1. I'd also like to hear from our inactive townies before the hammer.

[mallowgeno]

In my opinion, Day one lynches where it isn't mylo should be used as follows:

-Lynch an unhelpful player-Why have a player that isn't contributing squat stay in the game? If they aren't contributing now, what makes you think they will contribute when it really counts on lylo? If you keep them till lylo, then you will be questioning them with little response, making them look scummy (whether they are or aren't scum).

Therefore

unvote, vote millar

[mallowgeno]

*sigh* I'm not usually an active lurker. I'm just in too many games right now. I will never do more than 2 at one time again. I know I'm not a very good scum hunter. That's why I am usually lynched by the town day 1 or day 2.

unvote

I want to see what the replacement has to say. I do think that ODDin was legit when he said he didn't intend on lynching you Podium. I feel that he is town with the way that he posts. I still think that Podium could be scum.

[mallowgeno]

@ ODDin-I had my vote on millar

@ Podium-Fair enough

[mallowgeno]

Grah idk who to believe anymore >.<

[mallowgeno]

I would like to, however this game for me just seems to be ODDin vs Podium vs TeeJay

[mallowgeno]

that's because there's only 7 people... 1 of which was a heavy lurker, and 1 who is V/LA... that only leaves sawyer... who lurked at first, but is contributing lightly now.

(from everyone else's point of view, there were 2 lurkers... you and millar)

there aren't a lot of players in this game, which means it will feel a little different than your usual 9+ player game... and we have to be careful... a mislynch today means lylo tomorrow.

Well that explains it then. I do honestly believe that one of the three I named above are mafia. I just don't know who.

As a side note, I AM still new to this. This is like my 4th or 5th game. I'm still not used to this site. I've played hundreds of games of mafia on another website where you play each other live in like a chat sorta thing. All of those setups are open or semi open, but usually, there's a clear that starts the game off (i.e. a cop or tracker or sometimes even a bp). Then either a mafia ccs or they can't cc b/c the next day isn't lylo. So I'm still gettin used to this site and this game.

[mallowgeno]

I already said I'm unsure about who I find more scummy, TJ or ODDin, but at this very moment, I'm starting to lean TJ. I was actually going to vote hi mat the end of this post, but there hasn't been a vote count for a couple pages I just want to be careful.

Well make up your mind because just saying that isn't helping the town.

[mallowgeno]

I'm not impatient. I was just saying he was being indecisive and he needed to pick. Although, this is contradictory to me...I also am having trouble with who I think is scum. I think a reread is in order. But not right now. I've had a loooong day of marching and music.

[mallowgeno]

Tarazo, I want your claim now

[mallowgeno]

EBWOP:
Sorry I meant TeeJay