Scummies 2010 Nominations

[CSL]

Third popsofctown

for Don Corleone.

Nominate: zoraster

for best new role for

traitor vig

from zoraster's Mafia 105.

Giving the traitor the ability to kill until he is recruited makes the mafia's decision of whether and when to recruit the traitor an interesting question, while the traitor doesn't know who the mafia are, and therefore has to choose carefully who to kill just as a town vig does, but in reverse.

Fourthed

and

Seconded

[CSL]

Fourth

. Ridiculous and amazing job there guys. Only wish I had the honor of being on that side. Ah, well.

Oh, that beauty of a game earns a

fifth

in my book.

[CSL]

Nominate Kise for Don Corleone for Open 184: Friends and Enemies Mafia

I would nom for Best Win From Behind-esque awards, but that award apparently disappeared.

This guy was put in a horrible situation from Day 1 - losing a scumbuddy Day 1, and his other buddy was heavily defended by the dead buddy, accidentally claimed scum Day 1, and was the replacement of CSL, who was force-replaced for self-voting himself to L-1. Kise was able to pull off a decent buss on SerialClergyman (CSL's replacement) and survive until the endgame, quickhammering for the win in 4p with a mason still left alive. What a game!

Third this amazing comeback player

[CSL]

Nominate Gayle for Funniest Player

Seconded.

He was pretty hilarious in Mafia 108.

Third.

Look at this post: viewtopic.php?p=2123383#2123383

Nth'ed Gayle for Funniest

Nth'ed + 1

Nth'ed + 2

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 47#2113847

[CSL]

Pthed

[CSL]

First post should be updated. Sorry for the delay.

Uhh, I fourth'd on pops.

[CSL]

Nominate animorpherv1 and spyrex as Best Mafia catchers in SWN II: The Curse of the Nekomata

Nailed the Greek Mafia AND the serial killer in one day. Ani was the vig.

Nominate the award: "Best Scum Player" under Body of Work (Player Award)

Nominate Maemuki for "Best Scum Player" of the American Mafia in SWN II Curse of the Nekomata

Lived for days without being caught. Post-restricted Miller claimed. If correct traget was picked during the night, we would've won.


^Read the game. I DARE you to.

[CSL]

nominate UncertainKitten for Best Third Party in SWN II

YAY! I WON BY CLAIMING THIRD PARTY! TWICE!

Seconded

[CSL]

SC, UK thirded the above already.

[CSL]

Second town of 109

Third

You better read it. You will agree.

[CSL]

Nominate Haylen for Paperback Writer for this game

Even though it wasn't finished because the town kept lynching too fast, it is a good read flavor-wise.

[CSL]

Nth I Am Innocent nom

An overall great player. Deserving of it.

Third Yabbaguy Best IC

[CSL]

6th hascow for smooth operator

[CSL]

Nominate

Vi

for

Name Should Be In Orange

; mostly for deleting hundreds of spam pages and users on the Wiki for a long time. When I saw the deletion log, I was blown away.

Definitely

seconded

.

Thirded.

Nth

because of epic WINnage.

[CSL]

Nominate Beefster

for most improved player. i played in his first game, in which he was scum, I nailed him Day One and his play was really bad. Later on I played in a game where I was lycnhed early and he replaced in and he is definetly a better player than he was. He really improved.

Can i see the second game please, i was his partner in first and still feel guilty for the bus.

Go look at Newbie 980.

Summary: Nexus was confirmed town. Beefster did NOT vote for singer, who was the only other player left.

I do not endorse this nomination.

[CSL]

Nominate Anon for Funniest Role Claim

Mini 1019 "Claim"

I

second

third

this.

Nth

and that should do it.

[CSL]

diddin, I'll

second

that. I was a player in that game, and he was scum perfection right there.

[CSL]

I would like to

Nominate Super Smash Bros. Mafia for Most Enjoying Game

.

Either you played it, and enjoyed it, or you were watching it in hopes to replace. That simple.

[CSL]

Also,

Nominate New Award: Best Hydra Performance

Hydras are becoming increasingly popular on the site. While not everyone particularly enjoys them and some players even despise them, I think it takes a certain skill set to actually play well in a hydra and good hydra play deserves to be rewarded. Not only does this help recognize players who do well, but it will help demonstrate to newer players how a hydra should properly exist in a game (ie, not schizo).

Second.

I think this would actually be a really great idea.

It'd increase the mainstream appeal of hydra-ing, and would promote more teamwork and less individualism.

It'd also make for some great reminiscence, after the fact.

HAMMERTIME!

Third

[CSL]

Second

Almaster. Both of them.

[CSL]

Nominate KittyMo Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion/The wiki - "Professor Mafia" Award

For her work in smoothing out the "Gameplay Improvement" thread and offering advice to people wherein (work in progress). Seriously, she combed the thread, organized it, and gave advice to a summer. AND no one even asked her to.

Second

Third

A TOTALLY deserved Fourth