Cobalt wrote:Wait, that ISN'T what you said. You said you had information that you _think_ there are 3 win conditions. That doesn't mean there's a third party. It doesn't mean all 3 wincons are factional. Why are you saying something different now? Before you weren't even sure your information was correct, and now you think it's solid proof of a third party?
Also, no, Sens, you're wrong. It's simple linguistics and grammar. The town win condition says kill all the mafia players to win. If there was any 3rd party win condition, it would have to be individual OR require that some mafia members be alive to trigger. Otherwise, there would be a chance that the town wincon and this 3rd party wincon could trigger at the same time, leaving the game over with 2 factional win conditions fulfilled. This would be a broken game. I don't know why this is so hard for you to understand. Also, why did you not comment on my full claim after pushing hard for it?
I
think
there are 3 wincons, just like a Cop thinks he's Sane. I'm going to be acting on the assumption there are 3 wincons.
And based on the fact there are 3 win conditions, there is "Kill all Mafia" "Control the town" and "SOMETHING ELSE". The fact you assume that that something else can't take precedence over the Town wincon is ludicrous. I don't understand why its impossible there is a Jester/Lyncher/'NK-magnet' or something else that could win before the Mafia die
and cause the game to end on the spot.
In fact, I know its not impossible.
Hell, maybe there's an SK whose flavour is that he's a "Mafia Rogue" or something like that, and so needs to die for the Town's wincon.