Battle Mafia: Game Over

[charter]

Vote Spyrex

[charter]

There is only one true criminal here.

The one who stole my illustrious spot by having a whole new number put in for them.

Charter, you have been judged.

You have been found wanting.

24 shall exist no more.

Vote: Charter

Oh, if you look in my profile, 24 is even in my interests, so yeah... DIESCUMDIE!

[charter]

vote to save IH

[charter]

My scum sense is tingling.

unvote, vote Mariyta

[charter]

Guys, I can explain my ninja scumhunting skills, but first we need a wagon on Mariyta, the bigger the better.

[charter]

unvote, vote tubby

Scumslip and such.

[charter]

Picking up where I left off.

vote Maryita

[charter]

Oh wow.... >>;;

oh btw EBWOP:

Vote: Charter

>>;;

Are you daft? I tell everyone to vote Maryita, and EB comes straight out of the gate and accuses me of being scum. Look at what happened to EB. You're seriously going to try the same thing as him? I would advise you to look at how EB ended up and ask yourself "do I want this to happen to me?". If the answer is "No" then I suggest you, and everyone else, listen to me and vote for Maryita.

This is my last call for people to vote for Maryita.

Those that do not vote Maryita in their next post will stand to face the same fate as EB. I'm not explaining, so do not ask.

[charter]

Oh shit, I'm a retard. Gieff died. Ignore that last post, except you all still need to vote for Maryita.

[charter]

I'm not explaining, so do not ask.

[charter]

charter, I'm assuming you're some sort of cop, you might as well come out and say it, since any scum are going to highly suspect it now. Might as well persuade us to lynch scum before the night phase, since I'd imagine as a potential cop you might be killed then.

Why are you rolefishing? I'm not explaining why everyone should vote maryita, why are you pushing it?

[charter]

Vote: Randomlunatic

The hell?

Obviously RL is scum as well, but right now we're lynching Maryita. I got a message saying that she poisoned IH after he got saved. Obviously this was the work of scum, not town. ARE YOU ALL FREAKING HAPPY NOW? Since I spoke of this, I don't get this luxury again, but I figured it was worth it before idiots (RandomLunatic and ElectricBadger) spun this on me. OBVIOUSLY I HAD INFO ON WHO THE SCUM WAS. DO YOU REALLY THINK THAT SOMEONE WHO MAKES THREE POSTS IN THE GAME, ALL SAYING "LYNCH THIS PERSON" IS SCUM? NO, THEY AREN'T THAT OBVIOUS.

Randomlunatic and EB have earned themselves lynches after Maryita.

Lynch Please.

[charter]

Actually, I haven't taken the time to go back and look at SpyreX in depth, but he makes a fair candidate for scum, however, RL and EB are impossibly lost and unhelpful (though I'm not sure on their alignment).

Since after Maryita gets lynched I am obvtown, I would say cicero is scum as well in case I suddenly die for some reason.

[charter]

It's now OBVIOUS Maryita is scum, because she isn't calling me a liar or anything. No vote for me, doesn't even refute what I'm saying really.

I say we lynch EB straight away after Maryita.

[charter]

Not fullclaiming.

[charter]

Nope.

Diescumdie

[charter]

@charter: Fullclaim or be voted.

No.

@Everyone: If you are a townie who poisoned IH, please claim now.

Yes.

[charter]

You sir, are an idiot.

[charter]

About 5 minutes before charter decided I was scum.

post number?

Charter's post #? 241. My block on you was confirmed about 5 minutes before.

It's almost like I got my message at the same time, read it, then made my post in the thread. It all fits together so perfectly!

Mariyta's claiming of blocking Nik doesn't make much sense at all to me. First off, how can you change a dayroleblock ability? You could have just roleblocked everyone and stopped a bunch of these killings. Doesn't add up at all. Not to mention, blocking CKD and Nik makes no sense. Coupled with Nik's obvious crash and burning in the same fire Mariyta is going down in, and it looks an awful lot like distancing.

I realize I've named like five of her buddies recently before she's actually flipped, but I will rank them in the order I find them suspicious.
Most
cicero
Nik
EB
RL
SpyreX
anyone else not obvtown after Gieff died.
Least

[charter]

Voting charter upon the possibility that he is a lyncher is stupid. If he doesn't want to full-claim, it's because there's some factor of his role that he doesn't want to reveal.

Also, I seriously doubt that the mod is going to put a role in a 24-person game that could end the game Day 1. If charter is a lyncher by some weird chance, then I'm sure his win condition wouldn't be mutually exclusive to everyone else. I even doubt he's a lyncher, because lyncher in a closed setup is a pretty easy win.

Don't try to outguess the mod. A lyncher is exactly what Charter seems like to me, frankly.

Think about how he isn't even questioning the message he's gotten. How does he know what it says is true? He doesn't care. :p

HA! Looks like I was right about you. If I sound exactly like a lyncher, why aren't you voting me? The obvious answer is you know that there is no way Mariyta is escaping lynch, and you know she's scum and I'm town. Why are you so afraid of lynching Mariyta? Why do you think we have a lyncher? When have you ever seen one outside of an open game?

And no, I'm not questioning my message. This is a pretty terrible attempt at rolefishing as well, might as well just get your buddies to kill me off, then Mariyta will be speedlynched, and should be immediately followed by you and then EB.

[charter]

So you are so certain beyond any doubt that I'm a lyncher, that you won't even follow me and vote Mariyta? It seems inconceivable.

[charter]

It's almost like I got my message at the same time, read it, then made my post in the thread. It all fits together so perfectly!

Except that she used her ability on CKD and you supposedly got your message TWO DAYS after the poisoning. The mod would have sent you a message directly after he posted the save scene if he was going to send a message at all. How does that fit together 'so perfectly'?

Ask BM why he sent it then not earlier. I didn't even realize this.

I'm going to try to skim the thread this evening, if I can, but first, does anyone know what the hell is going on here?

We are lynching Mariyta, vote her. Once she flips scum, we are lynching cicero. This explains.

So you are so certain beyond any doubt that I'm a lyncher, that you won't even follow me and vote Mariyta? It seems inconceivable.

Shrug. Seems too easy. Full claim and I'll assess the claim. Accuse me of fishing. I don't care.

No, stop fishing. Vote Mariyta.

[charter]

I am sure she is scum. Vig away for all I care, we can lynch EB or cicero if someone can dayvig her.

[charter]

Lulz, have fun Yos.

DT and Nik are taking as many steps backwards as possible, I don't know if this complete and total self destruction is to try and save themselves or just poor play.

DT, why would you assume multiple scum factions? What on earth in GIEFFs revealed name led you to believe that?

[charter]

I already said yes. Where did I dodge it?

[charter]

Given a game this size it's not unlikely to have multiple scum roles in play. Do you have something to suggest we are only dealing with 1 faction here?

Because look at Gieff, he was just 'mafia', normally if there's multiple mafia factions, there's some kind of name to them. Sure we can have SK's, I thought you were talking about multiple groups. Regardless, any SK's will be outed in due time.

As for the rest of your post, you're going about my claim completely the wrong way, which is why you are imploding (so are lots of others). Yos is going about it the right way. It's fishy to say the least, but I've got enough scums without you muddling up the picture right now. And no, you aren't getting quotes, I'm not going to explain this to you. Hopefully you learn yourself.

[charter]

Haha. Someone hammer Mariyta so we can continue with the game.

[charter]

CKD, your questions are just more rolefishing. I'm not explaining.

To the people voting me: Switch your vote to Mariyta, if she doesn't flip scum, you can lynch me. You're not going to lynch me first, so stop trying.

[charter]

You're also not going to get me to explain anything, so stop trying that as well.

[charter]

And remember that cicero is scum with Mariyta, in the event I get killed.

[charter]

After she flips scum, we lynch DT Master tommorow.

Agreed. Let's try and go for the all time speedlynch record as well. Then we can speedlynch cicero. Really anyone that is present and isn't voting Mariyta is pretty much confirmed scum by this point.

[charter]

You're not really present. Why are you so worried?

[charter]

You're not really present. Why are you so worried?

I'm not. I'm being difficult for the hell of it.

Ok, that's what I figured. You had best vote Mariyta in your next post, or you WILL become scummy.

[charter]

Oh, yet another point in the mountain of evidence of Mariyta being scum. If she was town, EB would have jumped all over the opportunity to lynch her, then lynch me. There's boatloads of other evidence as well if you go digging.

[charter]

Well, lets just figure out all the scum now and why this lynch hasn't happened.

Alive: (19)

1. BloodCovenent
3. ZazieR
4. RandomLunatic
5. Nikanor
6. Shanba
7. Mariyta
10. Yosarian2
11. IH
12. Cicero
14. Crazy
15. CuriousKarmaDog
16. Vi
17. Populartajo
18. Benmage
19. Kairyuu (Rep. Seraphim)
21. DTMaster
22. Alkaline
23. SpyreX
24. Charter

Currently voting Mariyta (townies) (9)

Charter, Vi, Shanba, SpyreX, Benmage, Randomlunatic, Crazy, BloodCovenent, Yosarian2

Chronic Lurkers/Unable to post (potential scum) (5)

ZazieR, IH, Populartajo, Alkaline, Kairyuu

Here but not voting Mariyta (likely scum) (2)

Cicero, CKD

Not voting Mariyta (confirmed scum) (3)

Mariyta, Nikanor, DTMaster

So really we're waiting on CKD or a whole slew of lurkers to suddenly show up.

The Breakdown:

A 24 player game is likely to have between 4 and 8 scum. We have two scum already dead. This means that after lynching the 3 scum, we will have at most 3 scum remaining. Hopefully we can mop that all up day three or so.

[charter]

I went back and highlighted other scumfessions that lead to Mariyta being 100%, absolutely confirmed scum to hopefully speed this up, since this has been dragging on in an agonizing manor.

For the amount of day actions in the game, this seems reasonable - otherwise the first day, especially, would be completely random. And changing it doesn't make it over powered, but...well, changable. And if she were trying to look town I don't think she'd make up something this unusual.

Defending Mariyta's claim when he should have no reason to believe it. Why wouldn't he believe my claim

Her ISO 0-3 I also think have scumtells, but meh.

Nik you should vote, not wait, I'd wager she might self hammer to prevent more of her buddies being dayvigged.

[charter]

She might just be trying to get charter in trouble with that post.

Nah, I'll sort it out tomorrow if I'm alive.

[charter]

Lulz at Cicero being lyncher.

Who wants to be lynched today?

[charter]

You're taking advice from DTMaster, Vi? Why?

[charter]

Holy shit. This is bar none the absolute biggest implosion in the history of mafia. I wasn't serious with all my quicklynch and confirmed scum stuff from yesterday, but holy cal.

vote DTMaster

[charter]

GUYS! NEW PLAN! LYNCH SPYREX NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!

UNVOTE, VOTE SPYREX

DO NOT QUESTION THIS. WE ARE SPEEDLYNCHING SPYREX! GOGOGOGOG

IF ANYONE VOTES FOR DTMASTER FROM NOW ON, YOU ARE SCUMMIER THAN HE IS.

[charter]

@Charter: Mari was scum, but no poisoner. You threatened that people would die "just like EB" when EB was in fact alive. He died later, though. Can you explain any of this? Are you going to expand on your claim today? Or ever?

I will not explain. Do not out yourself as scum by continuing asking either. Just know that it is in your best interest to lynch Spyrex ASAP.

[charter]

GUYS! NEW PLAN! LYNCH SPYREX NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!

UNVOTE, VOTE SPYREX

DO NOT QUESTION THIS. WE ARE SPEEDLYNCHING SPYREX! GOGOGOGOG

IF ANYONE VOTES FOR DTMASTER FROM NOW ON, YOU ARE SCUMMIER THAN HE IS.

But DTMaster is also very likely scum.

Why dont we let Spyrex to our lovely vig?

Also, why did you target Spyrex?

You get lynched next. I was very specific when I said "DO NOT QUESTION THIS"

Absolutely no more questions will be answered. Absolutely anybody that does not immediately unvote DTMaster and

especially anybody that does not vote SpyreX in their next post will be considered scum (not joking this time).

[charter]

tajo looks a LOT like SpyreX's buddy who knows he is bulletproof or something. Yes, I remember Rocossi, and what I learned from it is, if you're a scum cop KEEP IT TO YOURSELF and just build cases on your targets to confirm yourself like that. For all I care you guys can lynch me as soon as I tell you to lynch someone and they aren't scum. Until then, lynch who I say unless someone has concrete information otherwise, and they are free to out themselves as scum as well.

[charter]

I'd like to make this perfectly clear.

IF YOU ARE A VIG, DO NOT SHOOT SPYREX!

Clearly something bad will happen to you if you do.

[charter]

Well, judging by how SpyreX immediately jumped on to DTMaster, and despite atrocious play by DTMaster, I don't see how he is scum. I certainly wouldn't mind him getting vigged, but we are not lynching him. I don't think scum can afford to bus anymore, because I think their numbers must be dwindling.

I'm pretty sure one of the lurkers/flakers is scum (just probabilities) but you've stepped up in to that role nicely. If we lynch someone besides SpyreX (which we're not going to do, but hypothetical) it would be you.

None of what I have said this game is a "baseless assumption". I'm not explaining anything, but there is plenty to back it up.

[charter]

Awesome, great job town! Wooo.

Thanks for modding BM, was a wacky and fun game.

[charter]

Oh, can we get role PM's? Curious as to what a lot of the people did.

[charter]

Who actually poisoned IH?
This has been bugging me for pretty much the whole game. I was hoping someone else would fess up, but no dice.

[charter]

I was just told I was a daycop, that was it. I said Maryita poisoned IH since it was really obvious that was the work of scum, so I thought I might get another one to claim it, then bag two scum at once. I actually wanted to just let IH die, since I knew he would flake, but didn't think anyone would agree with that.

I really have no clue why EB and RL acted like they did. They outed themselves and not even to try and save a buddy. Nikanor's actions at least had some motive behind them.