/in-vitational 3: Brass & Shrapnel. Over. before 831

[Quagmire]

sup

[Quagmire]

Are we already engaged in serious discussion and it's not even page 2?

[Quagmire]

I'm voting CKD because he refused to vote MacavityLock with me, not because of his vote for you. I found his lack of camaraderie disappointing.

Fair enough, coy boy.

unvote
Vote: hasdgfas

I voted CKD because his entire post was scummy. He started by basically telling us to post as little as possible so he could be sure to catch up. Anti-town.

Then, hypocrisy. Doesn't like CKD's vote because it's "too easy" yet he votes for an easy target himself.

Oh don't give me that trash and tell me it's legit, cow!!

[Quagmire]

I'm voting CKD because he refused to vote MacavityLock with me, not because of his vote for you. I found his lack of camaraderie disappointing.

Fair enough, coy boy.

unvote
Vote: hasdgfas

I voted CKD because his entire post was scummy. He started by basically telling us to post as little as possible so he could be sure to catch up. Anti-town.

Then, hypocrisy. Doesn't like CKD's vote because it's "too easy" yet he votes for an easy target himself.

lol,

unvote, vote Hasdgfas

for taking a first random/irony joke vote trying to run with it.

This post was scummy. You're on thin ice.

[Quagmire]

Has it become a general consensus among people who have played with hasdgfas that he builds awful cases as town and scum? Because I seem to have noticed this.

[Quagmire]

Quag - are you suspicious of hasdgfas?

I don't know. Does hasdgfas always make bad cases? I'm inclined to believe yes considering the few games I've played with him, so I'm not suspicious. I don't get suspicious of anyone until a few pages in usually.

[Quagmire]

but lets say, for shits and giggles...it was. you are voting me because I want to return to the RVS? How is that scummy? How do you think as scum returning to RVS is helpful for scum?

If you're trying to return to the RVS after some semi-serious to serious discussion started, then it really looks like you're trying to squash that discussion because you don't like the direction it's headed.

Budja's reasoning is sound, but I think his read is off.

There's really not enough information out there to amke a legit case on anyone yet, but I really would appreciate it if people in general would stop using this kind of logic to implicate someone as mafia.

[Quagmire]

There's really not enough information out there to amke a legit case on anyone yet, so I know people are going to reach for cases, but I really would appreciate it if people in general would stop using this kind of logic to implicate someone as mafia.

This post should read like this.

[Quagmire]

@Quagmire (29): Why do you feel that hasdgfas' reasoning behind his vote isn't legit?
@Quagmire (34): Why are you playing both sides of the discussion between curiouskarmadog and hasdgfas?

(29): Because voting anybody for anything they did during the random voting stage isn't legitimate, unless there's an extreme case. He's grasping at straws.

(34): What do you mean "playing"? Do you mean that I could be setting myself up to vote for either of them?

Because if that's what you mean, I suppose that's true.

Vote: hasdgfas

. I'm sick of seeing his poor cases and weak accusations.

This curiouskarmadog wagon is really, really scummy. hasdgfas has been pushing weak cases and is the second person on this bandwagon.

[Quagmire]

For clarification: the ckd wagon is really scummy because

he's being voted for for things he did during the RVS

. Think about that for a sec.

[Quagmire]

For clarification: the ckd wagon is really scummy because

he's being voted for for things he did during the RVS

. Think about that for a sec.

RVS is no excuse.

Yes it is. What he did wasn't even scummy.

[Quagmire]

For clarification: the ckd wagon is really scummy because

he's being voted for for things he did during the RVS

. Think about that for a sec.

Are you suggesting that it's impossible for scum to do something to give them away in the RVS?

'Cause I've got a meta example that kinda contradicts that.

I'm not claiming that. Are you claiming ckd has?

[Quagmire]

Interesting how Quagmire jumps to a vote after being called out for being wishy-washy by KK. I'm sure his reasons for the vote are OK, but the timing isn't.

KK called me wishy-washy?

[Quagmire]

V/LA until Monday.

[Quagmire]

Why is hasdgfas not scummy? Can anyone make an argument for him being town?

[Quagmire]

huh?

[Quagmire]

Is there a reason people are voting for me? I noticed nobody's tried to attack my logic on hasdgfas yet.

[Quagmire]

- Quag- I'm voting for you mostly because of this. Nothing else during this (fairly inactive) game has jumped out at me for being off. So there you go.
I also don't like the "argue how hascow is town" thing.

What's wrong with it? He's been awful and scummy this entire game so far.

I'll take a look at your logic...
Wait, there isn't any..

So, for the benefit of everyone, what exactly

is

your logic against hasdgfas?

He pushes weak and useless cases really hard and is extremely sure of what the town needs to do, despite his logical shortcomings... it's like he's trying to deliberately start a bandwagon. I mean, really? Someone's scummy in the RVS? Are you serious?

[Quagmire]

Uh, I feel like I should make a "pot, kettle, black" joke here..

---

Everyone! Deadline is sneaking up quickly.. Quagmire's has got 3 votes and a verbal vote from molestargazer. We need to decide if we are going to lynch Quagmire or quickly go with someone else or go for a no lynch.

We've got about 30 hours to go, so some last minute discussion would be fantastic at this point.

Mod: What happens if the deadline lynchee is a supersaint? Does the last voter die?

Uh, my case is legit... hasdgfas seems to be continuing to push his case as if he's right. I'm not voting anyone for their actions during the RVS.

[Quagmire]

[quote="Kublai Khan"]
Well likewise, I'm not voting for anyone who moved to get us out of RVS. Building weak cases to get out of the RVS is a town-tell for me.[/quote
No it's not. How is it a tell at all?

Building weak cases to get out of the RVS isn't what's scummy, it's that he's really determined and confident that it's a legit case. It's like he's trying too hard to be the proud leader of a bandwagon.

[Quagmire]

My reason for voting Quagmire is, in its entirety, this post:

Why is hasdgfas not scummy? Can anyone make an argument for him being town?

"Prove he's town" is a mislynch-friendly mindset.

This sounds like you have a problem with my theory, and not my play this game.