Mini 762 - Secret-role Mafia, Status: Mod Gone, Plug Pulled

[AWA]

I'm gonna go ahead and /confirm because it's tradition.

I'm also going to

Vote: AshKetchummm

for having way too many m's at the end of his name.

[AWA]

Vote Water

For your belief in tradition.

NOTE (to mod): "AWA" is the rough pronunciation of the Arubian word for water, so I am voting AWA

Wow, creative...I've never heard of that.

For future reference, however, my name is pronouced like the individual letters, that is, "Aey Dubleyoo Aey".

[AWA]

Sorry I haven't been posting; I had a school project that was killing me. I'll try and be more active.

Here's my view on things so far:

I don't have a read on Beyond yet
TCold is super-lurking
Ash hasn't posted much more
AWA is definitely scum, let's lynch him! (</sarcasm>, in case you missed it. Last game, people did...>.>)
Xenaroth responds to and attacks other players; overagressiveness is antitown (not necessarily scum!)
skitzer hasn't posted much
I'm getting a bad vibe from Lowell...call it gut feeling
millar comes off as a bit immature
NabNab appears to be well-versed in formal arguments...not anti-town, but could be tricky in middle/endgame
Elias is kind of shifty to me
Simpor has only made one real post, and it was a wagon.

Unvote

because we're out of RVS.

[AWA]

Perhaps I should elaborate a bit:
-----
I don't have a read on Beyond yet

I truly don't have a read on him; while he has posted a lot of content, it has been largely neutral. Consider me sitting the fence with him

TCold is super-lurking

Not much to say here

Ash hasn't posted much more

Not much to say here

AWA is definitely scum, let's lynch him! (</sarcasm>, in case you missed it. Last game, people did...>.>)

I try to be as amicable and humorous as I can be in the first day, and I always include a "Oh we should lynch AWA" comment in my first list of feelings (check my meta for other examples). I'll stop if you guysing think it's a bad idea.

Xenaroth responds to and attacks other players; overaggressiveness is antitown (not necessarily scum!)

I had a player like this in one of my previous games; and while he didn't turn out to be scum, he was extremely irritating later in the game. While I'm not necessarily stating that you will be irritating, I'm just posting from past experience.

skitzer hasn't posted much

Again, not much to say...

I'm getting a bad vibe from Lowell...call it gut feeling

Gut feeling, I don't have any evidence, but I just have this feeling

millar comes off as a bit immature

A few of his recent posts just made him come off that way a bit. It's early yet; I may be misreading him.

NabNab appears to be well-versed in formal arguments...not anti-town, but could be tricky in middle/endgame

I too know all about formal argument, and in my previous game, there would be looong posts by someone very similar. All I'm saying is that we need to watch out for him; he has the potential to be dangerous.

Elias is kind of shifty to me

Not much to say here, it's like Lowell; I just get a shifty vibe from him

Simpor has only made one real post, and it was a wagon.

I wasn't actively attacking you, I was just writing an observation. Don't get so defensive...

-----
Hope that's a little clearer.

[AWA]

Mod: I unvoted

Fixed. - the mod

[AWA]

Hmm... Cop's Partner, never heard of that before.

Beyond: That isn't a recant; this is just a blind vote to kick off the day. I accept that I haven't been as active as I could have been, but that's two school projects and an essay for you. Now that school is winding down, I promise I'll post more, starting with my evaluations of Beyond and millar13, who have been the most active thus far.

[AWA]

If I don't post much, it's because there's nothing to post on; almost all of the "content" in the game has been arguing back and forth about non-game related things. The people who have posted, BB and millar, are mainly going back and forth on each other without any real substantial evidence besides that which they have taken out of context to utilize against each other. Elias has done an ok job of contributing, and I'm pretty sure Lowell hasn't made one game-related post yet. I'm sorry for not contributing more, but I can't contribute with nothing to work with.

[AWA]

Right there is a prime example of what I'm talking about. Lowell, who thus far has made zero posts that really contribute, jumps on the first bandwagon that is proposed for the reason that it was proposed. Not only is this anti-town, this is a nigh scum tell.

Vote: Lowell

[AWA]

To pre-emptively cut off a comment involving Elias' signature:

I am not against bandwagons, I am against them when they have no substance. When someone jumps on a wagon simply because it exists,

that

is scummy.

[AWA]

Well we got a vote out of you, anyway. Even if it is a bit OMGUSy.

I don't ever OMGUS; it's bad form. I will occasionally vote for someone who has recently voted for me, as just happened, but it will never be for the reason "OMGUS".

[AWA]

Well, I'm not at L-1. I guess now would be a pretty good time to claim:

Cop

And btw, millar13 is innocent.

I'm going to die either today (lynch) or tonight (by night kill) so it doesn't really matter to me anymore.

[AWA]

EBWOP: *I'm now at L-1.

[AWA]

If I could get a word in, I would like to say that initially, millar struck me as scum, but after the innocent result, it looks more and more like Beyond is scum.

My thoughts are that Beyond_Birthday and Lowell are the scum.

[AWA]

charter: No one is going to claim cop now; it is guaranteed that the scum will kill me tonight, to stop me from getting another reading; thus, anyone who claims cop will be tainted by the role reveal.

[AWA]

I have a gut feeling to hammer BeyondBirthday, but it has almost no concrete proof beyond logic. This gut feeling tells me that he is scum. As the cop, I am predisposed toward removing scum, especially as, with only two, it negates the strategizing that usually occurs at night.

I won't hammer yet, but now would be a great time to start collecting evidence.

[AWA]

Actually, I don't think there is anything to claim, since he's not cop. No other power roles in the setup.

False. Check the OP; the very first power role is the Cop. I'm assuming the Cop's Partner is the secret role.

Come to think of it, millar may be the Godfather. I forgot that that role existed.

[AWA]

Yeah, but BB posted plenty after you claimed, and never countered, so he's clearly not the cop. There's no other power role for him to claim, so he's either mafia or a townie, and his claim is going to be townie either way.

Ah, I see. I thought you were referring to me with the "he". I apologize.

And millar, I did not outright accuse you. I Brought up the possibility. There is a difference.

[AWA]

My feelings are irrelevent next to the safety of the town; remember, I still win even if I am dead, but the scum are lynched.

[AWA]

Very well, but only to get the game moving.

Incidentally, since I'm going to be killed tonight, good luck guys. It was fun (sort of).

Vote: Beyond_Birthday

[AWA]

Sorry, I was away for the day. I would investigate Elias.