I think the issue with FL was the fact that he had crumbs to back up his claim, and that's what was throwing me that it's "too perfect".In post 699, Enchant wrote: Mafia claims have two edges.
They are either really poorly, something which town mindset never does.
... And "too perfect".
Exceptions exist obviously.
If he hadn't crumbed anything then I may have seen it in a different light, like RN and the 2 attempts at RB Skellen it made me suspicious about the claim more than FL.