Is it really fair...

[mathcam]

If the mod wants to give the SK an extra ability, then yes, I think giving them a "first strike" against mafia is one way to do it. I peronsally usually give SKs one or two night-kill immunities depending on the size of the game, and have experimented with other ways of bumping them up.

But to propose a rule that mods have to do it that way? Nope.

Finally, nowhere in the rules of the game does it say that each player should have an equal chance of winning. I'm quite happy to play an un-boosted up SK, knowing full well that it will be a hard win, and that if I

do

win, it's worth being proud of.

Cam