Choose Carefully Mafia: (Game Over)

[Empking]

/confirm

[Empking]

Vote: ZTR

I'm willing to believe OeJA about the tell.

Vote: Rope

For: Hp[leaves

- He random random voted.

[Empking]

STD, E and D aren't options. D as I hadn't posted besides confirmation, something that is essentially random for me based on if I forget to watch the topic or not (see: Dynamite Mafia); E as that happened AFTER he said the thing about having the info.

You're right about D - I haven't played enough to really use meta, anyway.
You're wrong about E - The BM post I'm referring to is 47. I make the setup claim in 54.

Unvote

Vote; CarnCarn

He was arguing that E could be correct when it couldn't have been. Since he's the person making the case.

[Empking]

What's your definition of wagon?

[Empking]

Ugh, the worst part about all this is that we can't go on anything that armlx has been saying. He's been playing the past four pages based off a different PM, meaning that any tells that he might have exhibited are null. Now, if we were to figure out which game he thought the PM for this one was for. . .

Unless he's lying.

[Empking]

The role isn't the most powerful role but I don't see why'd you bring that point up.

[Empking]

Unvote

I highly doubt three scum would lie together.

Not sure where to vote though.

[Empking]

I know.

I admit that its posible Carn Carn and Armix stumbled on Santos' role claim but I don't think its worth considering (yet).

[Empking]

Memorized everybody's roles?

I doubt it.

[Empking]

Memorized everybody's roles?

I doubt it.

We're in a 19 player game, by my count. If a Mod can't remember 19 roles, he's in a lot of trouble. How do you expect someone to moderate a game when they dont know everyone's role??
Wow.... 0.o

BM

Why would they need to know everybody's role?

[Empking]

Memorized everybody's roles?

I doubt it.

We're in a 19 player game, by my count. If a Mod can't remember 19 roles, he's in a lot of trouble. How do you expect someone to moderate a game when they dont know everyone's role??
Wow.... 0.o

BM

Why would they need to know everybody's role?

Because, roles do stuff. And in THEME games especially, the Mod really needs to be aware of who can do what. Do you think it's viable for a mod to accept night actions from vanilla townies? Daykills from Roleblockers?
This argument is ridiculous. The Mod should know everyone's role. End of story. -.-

BM

No, but the mod doesn't need to remember who has what role. Just have a record of who has what role.

[Empking]

On MS, no.

[Empking]

are you sre its a mason?

[Empking]

Bird: You don't have me in the not voting area.

[Empking]

Rope lynches scum, gun kills townies. Why would it be the other way around?

Gun kills Corsicans, Rope kills Sicilians.
Actually, after thinking about this some more, I'm beginning to think the NK methods for scum are different from the Gun/Rope lynch methods (they would have to be, based on the opening post, IMO).
For example, the Corsican can choose to NK with Rope or some other weapon that kills only townies (and to which the Sicilians are immune). Otherwise, the Corsicans can just NK with Rope all the time. So, each scum group is actually immune to 2 weapons, for this work out.
However, I don't understand why the Corsicans wouldn't choose Rope anyway because Rope should be able to kill townies as well (AFAIK, I have no protection against any weapon). This setup is driving me insane right now.

Their has been nothing to suggest that the Corsicans use rope as their night kill.

[Empking]

Christiano drago, would you mind explaining the Santos case?

[Empking]

I'd like to hear from everybody not voting for Santos why they are not doing so. That is, I want somebody besides Santos to plead a decent case for him.

Not this.

[Empking]

Vote: ZTR

His explanation wasn't good enough.

[Empking]

Vote: ZTR

His explanation wasn't good enough.

lawl.

Does that smiley go with what you're saying?

[Empking]

Can people who are voting Santos other than to bandwagon please raise their hands.

[Empking]

Yeah, scum talking pre-game isn't that unusual.

[Empking]

Yeah, scum talking pre-game isn't that unusual.

No, I think it's more often than not the scum are prevented from talking pre-game. I will admit there are exceptions, but I feel we're getting off topic here.
.

I don't see how they contradict themselves.

[Empking]

Vote: Oejo

I can't believe Santos quoted his role PM.

[Empking]

Personally, I don't think a two scum pair is very likely.

[Empking]

Why are six people not voting?

[Empking]

Do people still think that the town can get more from today?

[Empking]

Vote: OEJO

Vote: Gun

I expect this will be a boring day..

[Empking]

WHAT!?!?!?

First of all, that makes absolutely no sense. I have never even

heard

of someone immune to all lynches (one-shot very rarely, but never full). -Looks at backup mod- Damnit. You may not be lying.
.

I was immune to all lynches once.

[Empking]

Vote: Detspeed

Trying to look too townie.

Vote: Gun

[Empking]

Am I getting the blame that PP left?
This was my second game with him and I was probably the nicest to him in the first. He called me a *Beep* probably due to the third game.
.

I'm confused.

[Empking]

ZTR, Moses le fou, SocioPath, ribwich, ZazieR should be voting.

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: Hp

That's a really big scum tell.

[Empking]

Is the vote count right?

[Empking]

Unvote: Rope

Vote: Gun

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: Detspeed

Don't think HP is scummy enough.

[Empking]

Vote Detspeed

The win condition is the mafia die.

I didn't realize if I quoted the first post I could be killed.

This should say enough.

Vote Rope

This should say enough? All it says is that you are jumping on a band wagon the was on it's way to the contrary. Could you explain yourself? I don't understand where you are going with this.

I think (s)he's saying that he thinks, yuou thought that while gun was the preffered choice you couldn't be modkilled.

[Empking]

I mind who I kill. I'm just happy with either You or Hp.

I don't want ZazieR dead for example.

[Empking]

I'm now definately happy with my vote.

[Empking]

I'm confused about this game. I've looked at all the cases I've seen and I think the one against Santos is the best.

Vote: Santos

[Empking]

Vote: Gun

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: ZTR

- It looks like he's a shameless scumlurker.

[Empking]

So I disappear for a few weeks and I'm auto-scum? You guys are lacking logic. Although, I don't really see a way I can defend myself since the Townie role is in the first post. If the choice is really between Santos and I, you should take the guy whose been band wagoning on every suspicion since he got himself off of the hook.

There's more ways to defend yourself than that.

[Empking]

Unvote, unvote

.

I would like to hear from the others.

Did you think there might have been a QL?

[Empking]

I think he's claimed vanilla.