Scummies 2008 Nominations! (Deadline: 1/15)

[SensFan]

Nothing against Oman, but it looks to me like he won that game mostly due to a lucky guess on page 1. With all due respect, I

oppose

the nomination.

[SensFan]

Nothing against Oman, but it looks to me like he won that game mostly due to a lucky guess on page 1. With all due respect, I

oppose

the nomination.

I wasn't a guard, so I don't know their though processes.

I'd say you read the full game if you haven't, where I had escaped being lynched at least once, and set up several lynches on others.

Really, this shits me, because I worked hard for that game, and now you're saying I won because I made one guess?

I would not be so arrogant as to make a statement such as that one without reading the entire thread.

Unfortunately, the rule about speculation only came in after you 'confirmed' yourself, and even then you got away with some speculation that more-or-less got Korlas modkilled. Heck, postgame, both other people in the final three said they pretty much overlooked all of the scummy things you did, because of that guess.

Now that I think about it, I think this situation is actually fairly similar to Martyr Mafia, in which I suicide-vigged N0, knowing that if I hit Town I would lose. Yes, it happened to pay off, but I don't consider it a brilliant move by any stretch of the imagination.

[SensFan]

I'll

/second

Pie.

[SensFan]

Best Performance in a Losing Cause?

[SensFan]

I don't think a team of 2 IC-level players should win an award for a newbie game.

Not that I think we should, but wolf is a Newb. I support his winning best Scum performance.

[SensFan]

I'd like to

Nominate Cavebear with a Toochache

for

Best New Player

. I IC'd in his first game, Newbie 550, and he was fantastic, one of the better Newbs I have IC'd, for sure.