Mini 653 - Family Guy Mafia - Game over

[farside22]

[Peter, Cleveland, Quagmire, and Joe are grabbing the trophy they won]
Peter: There's only one way to settle this. [pulls out a revolver; everyone gasps] Russian roulette. [spinning the bullet compartment] Three bullets, last guy standing keeps the trophy. [points revolver at his head] Me first! No, no, no, wait a minute, this is crazy. [hands gun to Quagmire] You first.

Vote count:

Kloud 1 vote: (Save The Dragons)
No lynch 1 vote: (kloud1516 )

Not voting

reborn537
LlamaFluff
Elvis_Knits
RestFermata

With 6 people it takes 4 to lynch
Day ends Oct 6th 9:00am PST

[elvis_knits]

I have knee-jerk reaction to never do a no-lynch... but I know it is smart in some situations. I have to think about it and reread some of the strategy posts because I am bad at that kind of thing and my brain is tired anyway.

But I also agree that one or both of kloud/STD are scum. I really think STD is scum, regardless.

Do we want to contemplate the possibility of scum having power roles? What I mean is, that reborn or LF or kloud could be telling the truth about having a power role, but also be scum? I don't know if that would change my thoughts on each of them, but I just thought I'd throw it out there. I dunno, I guess I would still think reborn and LF are town and kloud is scum. But, anyone else have thoughts?

[reborn537]

Inventor cannot be a scum role. It's entirely unheard of out of a meta-breaking game.

[elvis_knits]

farside did say she's a bastard mod. Also, don't you thikn the scum might have a power role given the number of town power roles?

[reborn537]

Inventor doesn't work as a scum power role.

What does my role do, let's review

I give my RANDOMLY generated inventions to people. I don't know their functions. WHY would this be beneficial as a scum power role. And we already know one of the people I gave an invention to was town. RF and Kloud have confirmed receipt of my inventions.

I don't care what you say, anyone with half a brain can see I'm confirmed town. Stop tunnelling on me, I'm so sick of it.

[elvis_knits]

I actually don't think you're scum anymore, and I wasn't referring specifically to you even though you are one of the power roles. I am speaking generally about all the power roles so you can stop being defensive now.

Do you have any position about any of the other power roles being scum or do you want to imply that I have half a brain again?

[reborn537]

I think Kloud is very likely scum. I think LF could basically be in the same place as me whereby he considers himself so confirms that he doesn't feel he has to worry about being scummy anymore. I've got my eye on him though.

[farside22]

prodding save the dragon and kloud

[Save The Dragons]

Seriously like 3 minutes before I posted.

Inventor cannot be a scum role. It's entirely unheard of out of a meta-breaking game.

Inventor is a relatively weak role. It's essentially giving scum a power role that grants 1 shot abilities with a one day delay. It may be a pretty strange choice for a scum power role, but I don't think we can rule it out.

This is not saying you're scum, but in general.

Kloud, however, is scum, and as such, we should lynch him.

[LlamaFluff]

I still say we no lynch because it help the town. It allows another invention to come out and *maybe* a RB.

If we do no lynch I want Kloud to track me, as that way he only has a 1/4 chance of guessing my move correctly. If there is a kill, we have a 5 player lylo which I prefer. I see no downside to the no lynch.

[kloud1516]

I still say we no lynch because it help the town. It allows another invention to come out and *maybe* a RB.

If we do no lynch I want Kloud to track me, as that way he only has a 1/4 chance of guessing my move correctly. If there is a kill, we have a 5 player lylo which I prefer. I see no downside to the no lynch.

QFT. So you want me to track you as opposed to reborn?

[LlamaFluff]

I would say to track me, as where I went isnt visable.

[RestFermata]

No lynch is starting to look pretty good, actually.

I say Kloud should the lie detector TODAY, though, no matter what we do. And if he ends up confirmed town, that's when we take the information from the lie detector into consideration. If Kloud=town means StD=scum, using the lie detector to test StD doesn't make any sense, since we shouldn't consider the information until we're sure Koud is town anyway, thus confirming StD as scum. I think he should test E_K. You guys might consider E_K or me. I've already posted the sentence to be tested.

[LlamaFluff]

I agree with what RF just said. If Kloud is town, then he will find out the last mafia with the LD, and prove his role by tracking me.

[RestFermata]

Even if we lynch him, though, we will find out his alignment. But the possibly of two more pro-town players dying before tomorrow is leaving a bad taste in my mouth.

I have changed my mind once again.

unvote

Vote: No Lynch

[elvis_knits]

Am I supposed to post a sentence for the LD like this:

I am pro-town and I like puppies.

Still thinking about mechanics. I guess no-lynch is the way to go, but it really goes against my grain. I really think STD is scum... but I guess it's best not to gamble on the chance that I'm wrong and we lose the game.

[LlamaFluff]

I would even be more specific like

"I have a town aligned role in this game"

remember we are dealing with a bastard mod

[kloud1516]

So should I use the LD today, or wait to use it tomorrow?

[LlamaFluff]

I would say use the LD today on a "I have a pro-town role" statement from EK or RF

[RestFermata]

So is this how it's going to go? I want to make sure we have a solid plan no matter what happens.

--- IF KLOUD IS CONFIRMED AS TOWN ---

STD is confirmed as scum.

Lie detector results on E_K or me are taken. If one of us is found to be scum, the other is found innocent. If one of us is found innocent, the other is scum.

--- IF KLOUD IS CONFIRMED AS SCUM ---

...Then what?

[reborn537]

They could be bussing. Never rule that out - Kloud = scum =/= STD = town

[RestFermata]

Yeah I know, that's why we're always saying AT LEAST one of Kloud or StD is scum. I think there is a decent chance that Kloud is scum. If we No Lynch, he will probably then still be alive tomorrow, but we will know he is scum. Unfortunately that will be the

only

thing we know, and we will still have to lynch him AND another scum. Will this negatively affect the numbers game?

[reborn537]

I think we should lynch kloud today.

vote kloud

[RestFermata]

I'm really wobbling back and forth on this, but I'd like to hear what Llama has to say about what we do if Kloud is alive, confirmed scum tomorrow.

[Save The Dragons]

I don't know if we can know what to do. I think we'll just have to look back at his posts and see if we can find his scum partner.