Mini 638 - Batman Mafia - Prozacmod 1 - Over

[charter]

I love pink cats.

[charter]

Should we massclaim our characters? I've got a few of them down from the cat-firmation stage.

[charter]

Flameaxe = robin
Darla = penguin
Albert = joker
Godget = whoever arnold swarzenegger played as a bad guy
Mine should be fairly obvious as well

[charter]

OOps, had a little cat-astrophe in my last post, won't happen again. Sorry.

[charter]

EBWOP: Damn didn't hit preview,

I also don't think the confirming words should be taken too seriously seems liek some stupidity to think the mod would make it that easy.

And I know Chazzy isn't stupid.

hehe hehe hehe

I'm not basing it off the cat-forming words, which were just as easy to pick out. (vase, green, pink, shadow, etc...)

[charter]

Which also make me wonder...

whose the good guys and who are the bad guys?

Don't know. However, I don't see how cat-laiming your role (ie. batman, robin, joker) will be detrimental to the town. Can someone explain to me how it is?

[charter]

Crap, you've found me!

[charter]

Cat-rap! Pretend I said that in my last post instead of crap. I'm really running out of words to cat-strate with my horrible puns.

[charter]

I'm sure at least one of the Mafia members would have a posting restriction.

What makes you so sure?

Darla = Riddler (if I didn't say that already)

Also, I think there's a way to unlock your role that you had on the outside of prison. These bars can't hold this kitty for long.

[charter]

I am in agreement with the cat that has been traipsing through my laboratory

Ahhh, the cat's out of the bag now!

[charter]

I am in agreement with the cat that has been traipsing through my laboratory

Ahhh, the cat's out of the bag now!

...I dont get it....

Grimmy
I should know This, but it Wont come Out.

Not everyone's purrrfect.

[charter]

Catwoman references??

[charter]

vote Inspectot Godot

My feline sense wonders how you're so sure the scum must have posting restrictions and at least one is a hero. Once again, what makes you so sure?

[charter]

vote Inspectot Godot

My feline sense wonders how you're so sure the scum must have posting restrictions and at least one is a hero. Once again, what makes you so sure?

Logic. Having all three heroes as pro-town would seem too obvious, as would having them all scum. So at least one hero is scum in my eyes. And having everyone that has a posting restriction as either all pro-town or all mafia doesn't seem right either. Should I put an OMGUS vote on you?

Whether or not all three heroes are scum or protown is WIFOM. Go ahead and vote me, you're just going to get clawed for it.

[charter]

Ok, this kitty doesn't understand why everyone feels the need to quote everyone's posts and then put up what role they think they have.

I think it was my first post, but shouldn't we massclaim our roles? This will put an end to speculating and maybe we can get some better discussion going. I don't see what harm it can do to the town.

I'm pretty obvious, Catwoman.

[charter]

My cat sense is tingling, that pretty much settles it, Zoneace is scum.

He wants to lynch me on page 4, and doesn't give a reason, other than "we need to lynch someone".

[charter]

EBWOP
That was in response to his first post (didn't see his second when I posted).

Doesn't change much though.

[charter]

Cause I was being somewhat sarcastic. Add ad hom attacks to his list of useless posts.

[charter]

I don't know what this cat can add. I question how he's so sure of the setup. All I was given in my pm was my role, my flavor, and what role I was on the outside. From those, I can't make any assumptions as to who the scum are based on roles.

[charter]

You're really the only one opposed to revealing your character, why?

[charter]

No. I'd think it scum logic to decree something like X number of hero's are the scum "because it just makes sense" or whatever other crap reason Godot gave. The only way to know is to lynch a hero.

[charter]

when did I decree that all the scum were heroes?


stop tryin got push shit on me

Learn to read, I even said Godot in my post. That wasn't directed at you.

No. I'd think it scum logic to decree something like X number of hero's are the scum "because it just makes sense" or whatever other crap reason Godot gave. The only way to know is to lynch a hero.

Learn to read.


And I'm not opposed to revealing my character, I'm just saving it just in case we get a mass character role-claim which would be so awesome. If you want me to claim, say the word.

Claim. Same goes for everyone else.

[charter]

Godot, if you're town, you have no reason to not claim first, since you should have nothing to hide. I've already said I'm Catwomn, if it isn't painfully obvious already.

[charter]

Why do you claim now?

[charter]

ABR does ahve quite a history of lying as a member of town, to be fair, but I'm not at all convinced that this should give him a 'get out of lying free' card particularly since I can see no pro-town reason at all to pretend to be a different character to the character you have been assigned.

Vote: Albert B. Rampage

For the record, I am Batman. I am town, but have no evidence either way about the other two heroes. Unlike others, I don't think it's a good idea at this stage to claim a role as well as a name - even those claiming vanilla is not helpful, as that helps scum to narrow down their list of potential power roles to target at night.

I had a feeling you were one of the heroes from the way you were keeping quiet. I'm thinking that you're going to have to defend yourselves from some posters pretty soon.

What the hell? YOU'RE one of the people that should be attacking him because he's a hero, why on earth do you post a warning for him? Cat sense is tingling.

[charter]

A dayvig?

[charter]

Also, on another point, didn't Godot say that he thought it likely that at least one of, rather than all three of, the heroes would be scum? In other words, that scumminess is independent of the alignment of the character in the world of the comics/films/TV?

Yes, I voted him for it and he OMGUS voted me back. He now seems to have developed a severe case of amnesia.

I don't put much stock in either of ABRs claims. Why he's being an idiot I have no idea though.

[charter]

Why the fuck did we just lynch him? That was idiotic, seriously. I'd bet all my catnip all three scum were on that wagon.

[charter]

Ok, everyone that voted for ABR, justify it now. You can't have actual reasons so I want to hear your BS. This kitty is mad.

[charter]

I'm looking for reasons he's scum, not that you don't like him.

[charter]

What part of if you weren't an idiot you wouldn't have wanted him lynched don't you understand. As bus driver, attracting a vig kill makes PERFECT SENSE. Nothing he did yesterday was anti-town if you have a brain and can think.

LAL is possibly the dumbest policy I've ever seen in a mafia game.

My feline feelings are saddened because you can't get your role that you were on the outside.

Anyhow, Godot is still scum.

vote Godot

[charter]

Grimmy, I said it was idiotic before we lynched him. Now I'm questioning the people that voted for him, because lots of them provided either no or little justification.

[charter]

As for voting ABR, it's been said by everyone already. He lied about his character and about his role. That's not helpful play to the town, and lying is much more likely to be scum tactics than town (even though ABR has an erratic style of play, this was even more unhelpful than some of his often clever gambits). "I'm a vig" followed by "I'm vanilla" followed by "I'm a power role". What? Why?

If Charter really can't see the reasons for what was, we can plainly see, a mislynch, then he really deserves suspicion.

So you even admit you lynched him despite him not being scummy? Not helpful to the town is very distictly different from making someone scum. Half of Zoneace's posts are not helpful to the town, but you don't suspect him do you? Flameaxe hasn't been helpful to the town so far, but he's free to go?

Your logic is singling out ABR when it should apply to others. If Godot didn't have another vote on him already, I'd vote you.

Go ahead and 'suspect' me because I can tell the difference between not helpful and scum.

[charter]

This game is stalling horribly. Question for everyone not voting, what are you waiting for? (I'm not telling you vote)

[charter]

Wondering why people who aren't voting aren't posting.

[charter]

Charter - What am I waiting for? I'm waiting until something is said or done which seems to warrant a vote. I will not vote just to move the game along or just for the heck of it - votes are the town's greatest power and shouldn't be abused. Doesn't mean I'll necessarily manage to vote for scum, but I'm saving my vote until I can see a clear reason to suspect that someone is scum.

You're my number two suspect. Add active lurking and waiting until you can join a wagon when it's safe to the reasons I suspect you.

[charter]

Lets claw Godot already.

[charter]

Tunnel vision and short days aren't going to help us hit scum.

Ironic considering you and Godot were in such a hurry to lynch ABR. No one has anything new to say it seems, or at least they aren't posting it if they do, no sense in waiting around when Godot is scum. Claw him.

[charter]

Can we get some prods please?

Meow.

[charter]

I hate to be a broken record, but prods? Crub, KE, anyone else?

I really don't see this game moving forward much when the only people that are posting are those that are already voting...

[charter]

Bowl of warm milk for the next person to vote Godot. If you're not voting Godot and want me to make a post recapping all the arguments against him, let me know.

[charter]

Bowl of warm milk for the next person to vote Godot. If you're not voting Godot and

want me to make a post recapping all the arguments against him, let me know.

I would appreciate this, as I have not been clear on your reasoning for some time now and have not had an opportunity to ask because of real life mania. The recap would be helpful, as it may point out something I could have missed

I'll do it as soon as I get time, hopefully tonight or tomorrow. Meow.

[charter]

Why Godot is scummy.

49, says one of the people with a PR must be scum. This is scumlogic. It allows him to say player X is scummy because they have a PR and then justify it because "it just makes sense!"

75, more scumlogic. Now at least one PR person is scum, and one hero is scum.

83, OMGUS votes me when I call him out for his scumlogic.

Extremely hesitant to claim his character, then claims a villain, so he's free from his ridiculous logic of scum having a PR and being a hero.

165, Now defends a hero, when the whole game he's been saying we need to lynch them.

Day 2, he starts out accusing lots of people, and votes lurkers like it's his job.

249, KE sums up Godot's flip flopping on massclaiming.
250, He goes back to voting me right after pwnz claims nightwing. Godot entirely ignores it and his stupid hero is scum theory. Shows he doesn't believe what he's saying, he's just trying to fit in and look protown.
265, says KE's suspicions aren't valid, but no explanation as to why. More scumlogic.

I also think SL is his partner, because they've been defending each other the whole time.

[charter]

Note his continued not attempting to explain his declaration of at least one person with a PR being scum, and his declaration of at least one hero being scum. It is scumlogic for the reason I said in my previous post. It allows him to vote for someone and justify it without reasoning that they're actually scummy.

Also note his very poor response to my accusations. Half of the time he says something unrelated and the other half are just bad defenses.

You either misunderstand or lie on purpose.

I misunderstand. Clarify.

SL is my number three pick for scum, Godot is one. I want my number two pick to post another time or two before I reveal them.

Meow.

[charter]

You either misunderstand or lie on purpose.

I misunderstand. Clarify.

You're trying to say that I'm going for a lynch all heroes approach. I'm not, I'm trying to go for the most suspicious one. SL is far from most suspicious. At this point that's probably Pwnz or the other one that hasn't claimed yet.

Ok... I did understand you. The point was is that someone claimed hero, and you say "Oh, well you're probably going to defend yourself" rather than questioning them, when in your head they have at least a 33% chance of being scum.

Question for you and the rest of the pwnz wagon. What has he done that's

scummy?

I agree he's being unhelpful, but as far as I can tell, he hasn't done anything scummy. Please enlighten me.

No need for that, going off your simplistic reasoning it's Zoneace for agreeing with me (which actually does seem odd).

Zoneace is an idiot, not scum.

can we get some prods or replacements?

I want chicken,
I want liver,
Meow Mix, Meow Mix,
Please deliver.
Meow. Meow! MEOW!

[charter]

Why the fuck did we just lynch him? That was idiotic, seriously. I'd bet all my catnip all three scum were on that wagon.

[charter]

I guess I was just after the last vote, during twilight.

[charter]

Thats all?

Will anyone else vote flameaxe with me, possibly to a lynch (I ask as I want to lynch Godot as well)? This is twice now he's jumped on a terrible bandwagon when it was popular with no reasoning.

[charter]

This is ridiculous. I hope you are in fact scum Zoneace, else you are bar none the dumbest mafia player I've ever encountered.

[charter]

Care to actually post a case against me or pwnz instead of your repeating "They're obvscum" a few more times?

[charter]

Replace me or Zoneace, I'm tired of putting up with his insults

Sorry guys.

[charter]

You've been insulting everyone who doesn't agree with you and follow you blindly. You think you're all that, but you're just an immature child. You don't even try and play mafia, you're just here because you think it's a shouting match and you have the biggest mouth. Grow up.

[charter]

Eh, I had two of the three. Anyone that could not see that ABR was a bad lynch is still an idiot. Good game guys.

[charter]

What Kloud said. But if anyone actually thought about something instead of going "ZOMG SCUMTELL!!! VOTEVOTEVOT!!!!!!1" It would have been a lot easier.