Open 83 - Polygamist Mafia (Game over!) before 628

[KNIGHT42]

/confirm!

[KNIGHT42]

Vote: Firestarter

It came to me in a dream

[KNIGHT42]

I bet the mafia group of chenhsi, Gimbo, chelseafan, and flea would like for me to claim my lover!

Unvote, Vote: Chelseafan

[KNIGHT42]

Check that...

Unvote again, Vote: somestrangeflea

[KNIGHT42]

not saying its true but lets say you four "claimed your lovers" urging others to do so, so you could just pick us off

[KNIGHT42]

nice try... but you aint gettin it past me!

Unvote, Vote:Gimbo

[KNIGHT42]

Ok heres the deal...

I thought it was kinda wierd that two pairs of lovers claimed right away.

IN my mind it was a plot among you 4 mafia (gimbo,flea,chesi,and chelsea) to get everybody to claim and since you though of the idea, nobody would lynch you, yet instead lynch the last pair to come in.

I debated between chelsea flea and you until i saw that you had already accumulated two votes and here we are!

[KNIGHT42]

even if you end up being a townie, you deserve to die for a stunt like that...

[KNIGHT42]

If I'm so off with my prediction of the 4 mafia, how come none are voting for the opposites?

I mean we do have to lynch if we want to win, right?

[KNIGHT42]

Gimbo (4) - Harvey Pew, Adel, SpyreX, KNIGHT42
Chelseafan (2) -

somestrangeflea

, forbiddanlight
KNIGHT42 (1) - Firestarter
Forbiddanlight (1) -

chenhsi

SpyreX (1) -

Chelseafan

Adel (1) -

Gimbo

Not voting (2) - MafiaSSK, Nameless



I guess flea has voted for his fellow mafia member...

I say to prove our point we vote for Chelseafan and see what happens with his vote.

Unvote, Vote: Chelseafan

[KNIGHT42]

Why do you think flea is voting for his fellow mafia member? The only reason you think they are mafia is because they claimed.

Why should Chelseafan's vote change because you voted for him?

If you really think we are scum, why don't you vote for Gimbo, who has more votes and is closer to being lynched?

I think flea is currently voting for his fellow mafia member because the vote is him of suspicion. I think that if we put a majority on chelseafan, flea would withdraw his vote if mafia,

making this a perfect litmus test

or keep it if he is either stupid or innocent. You may have misunderstood my writing, I meant to say that flea would change vote, not chelseafan.

That should answer all three of your questions and clear up any confusion.

[KNIGHT42]

Alright since everybody is having such a hard time understanding me we'll go through this again.

1. Gimbo WIFOM, claims scum along with flea
2. Chenshi and Chelseafan quickly follow suit
3. Silence
4. People suspect of Gimbo, votes accumulate (none from the possible mafioso)

I think that if mafia, flea has a vote on chelseafan to seemingly free both from suspicion.

So I think to test this, we should put a close (but not total... yet) majority on chelsefan.

If flea withdraws:
A. Both are mafia
B. Flea is mafia, trying to perhaps frame chelsea
C. Is town and = worthless
If he stays
A. Mafia and dumb at the same time
B. Town and innocent thus clearing the likes of gimbo






If flea

[KNIGHT42]

See Gimbo, what is wrong with my proposition? It gives the town a chance to find some mafia, and a chance for you to free yourself from doubt

[KNIGHT42]

I will gladly read up on SpyreX and Adel's response to what you proposed but I have one thing to add/question.

Why would flea withdraw his vote if he is a town? Because if we find go through with the lynching of Chelseafan, and he is innocent, I will thus reveal my partner leaving us with an easy win!!!

that's all for now

[KNIGHT42]

SSF is either a scum or a townie that isn't your partner. But now that you say it, we are kind of testing SSF too! even better

[KNIGHT42]

I still think my play would work but at this point with my identity revealed, plus nobody understands the logic... fuck it.

By the way Gimbo I read through Spyrex and Adel's reactions. While Adel didn't really catch me I was intrigued by Spyrex's reaction to a mass claim. As flimsy an idea it is on the first day, he openly condemned it. Something else... I forgot and I'm too lazy to go look so for the time being [/b] Vote: Spyrex

[KNIGHT42]

Fuck im tired and i fucked that up fuck fuck fuck fuck

Vote: Spyrex

[KNIGHT42]

actually, I say we take out spyrex. i personally think there's a good chance he's mafia, and even if he isn't, gimbo surely will be.

well not surely but there's a pretty good chance.

[KNIGHT42]

And you've got your failbot already in the shape of Knight/Forbid if they are also town. Not like it'll be hard to do, regardless.

I don't understand. What's this supposed to mean?

Kill Adel or SpyreX today, if they flip town, I give you all permission to lynch me tomorrow, how's that?

How about we do it the other way around. Adel and Spyrex didn't claim scum. However, since Knight is set on voting Spyrex, and I'll be the odd one on the gimbo wagon if this keeps up, meaning we get no info on the offchance gimbo IS town,

unvote

. I refuse to vote spyrex because I don't feel he's scum.

thats ok... I definitely would be willing to lynch Gimbo first, then go after spyrex

seriously

[KNIGHT42]

Unvote

[KNIGHT42]

either way, its a good plan

right?

[KNIGHT42]

To a degree. We can't just decide Spyrex needs to die no matter what happens. I want to see Gimbo die and flip, and then figure out what to do from there judging from actions up til then and voting patterns. In this case

vote Gimbo

. Thank you for coming around, KNIGHT.

no problem honeykins

Vote Gimbo

[KNIGHT42]

5/7 required votes

FoS: Firestarter

[KNIGHT42]

Knight, you need to be open to more than just Gimbo/Me. If Gimbo is town, thats what is going to lose it.

See: post 207

[KNIGHT42]

lynch gimbo. im not gonna back off and maybe we can learn something

[KNIGHT42]

Actually I may go for Firestarter if you flip town

[KNIGHT42]

yeah go ahead and replace me, i don't have time

looking for a replacement now - mod