Cheese Thief | Game 1 Over

[mallowgeno]

/in

[mallowgeno]

I will say that I woke up with someone else

[mallowgeno]

I woke up at 1am

Popcorn

DragonEater

[mallowgeno]

I totally forgot there was peeking since I woke up with someone O.O What were the peeks?

[mallowgeno]

Can confirm I woke up at 3am

[mallowgeno]

I'm feeling like it might just be Star Gazer. I don't know if I fully buy them waking up at 6am with Silver. That's super easy for Silver to say that they saw Star Gazer at 6am to cover for them.

I am not sure though, camel could just be lying about when they woke up as well. But they don't feel scummy to me, maybe just confused?

[mallowgeno]

How about this:

Mallow and NDMath, please give us sound reasoning as to why neither of you are follower or cheese thief. I would like at least a paragraph (4 sentences).

I feel like I need to see a defense I can tear apart tbh

So as previously stated by y'all I cannot be the cheese thief unless both DragonEater and I lied (though math is claiming cheese was gone already so all three of us can't be lying). If I am a follower...does that matter at this point?

The question in my opinion comes down to did Math lie and they are just the cheese thief? Or is it Star Gazer? I'm leaning towards Star Gazer and I'm going to put my vote there

vote StarGazer

[mallowgeno]

Sure

[mallowgeno]

Sorry I know I'm not giving a lot here but I'm still going to go with the theory that Skygazer is the cheese thief and Silver is covering for them.

I trust DE as I know he's not the cheese thief, I suppose he could still be the follower but I don't think so as he's done the most analyzing imo

[mallowgeno]

i was afraid silverclaw was a townie who would vote against me if i called them out on math + silver so i revoked the possibility lol

also mallow what u doing

I refused to be going with consensus on the chance I was correct about Sky/Silver.

Good games, sorry I didn't chat as much as I did