Prophecy Mafia - Over

[Phate]

Vote: BBM

[Phate]

Curse you, dice gods!

[Phate]

DGB (winwin).

[Phate]

They don't. They also don't benefit town. When did I claim they benefit either?

[Phate]

No, you don't have to stop doing acid. But it is Day 2.

[Phate]

unvote; vote: Tarharlindur

[Phate]

I'm getting sick of the spam too. I find it possible that at least some of the spam is a scumtactic.

Who agrees? Why or why not?

[Phate]

Mod, votecount please?

[Phate]

Agreed. Policy lynch?[/provoke]

[Phate]

CKD, pretend I haven't been paying attention and summarise the DoS case.

Oman or anyone, ditto with the FL case.

[Phate]

Am not.

Who's gorrad?

[Phate]

Am not.

Who's gorrad?

[Phate]

lurk much?

Sorry for double post, by the way.

[Phate]

What worries me about Gorrad is the fact that he hasn't posted in forever, yet answers on the same day that I ask for him. This suggests to me that he is following the game without contributing.

[Phate]

Ok. Everyone, I just about admitted to lurking, albeit for what I'd call good reason, who wants to take advantage of my saying that to vote me? After that, maybe someone can call that person out for being opportunistic, we can yell at each other a bit, and there'll be something to talk about.

Vote: Gorrad

Lurking != good play. Gorrad, I'd like to know who you think is scum, complete with reasons, quotes, and detailed analyses. I'd also like to know who you think is town.

I mean, surely you have opinions of some kind.

[Phate]

Cow, I replaced in more recently than he did. I haven't been lurking.

[Phate]

Why?

[Phate]

Ok. Everyone, I just about admitted to lurking, albeit for what I'd call good reason, who wants to take advantage of my saying that to vote me? After that, maybe someone can call that person out for being opportunistic, we can yell at each other a bit, and there'll be something to talk about.

Vote: Gorrad

Lurking != good play. Gorrad, I'd like to know who you think is scum, complete with reasons, quotes, and detailed analyses. I'd also like to know who you think is town.

I mean, surely you have opinions of some kind.

And to your last post: bullshit. Acting scummily and then saying you're helping the town when someone votes for it != helping town.

[Phate]

If it was 'clearly and obviously stated', why do you think I 'fell into it'? Does the fact that I quoted that post in my vote for you tell you anything? Do you think the fact that you all but said "If you vote for me, you're scum" without giving any good reason at all has anything to do with my voting you?

[Phate]

Xpom is town. This is a scum-driven wagon, and I will have no part in it.

[Phate]

Look how fast Xpom went from L-6 to L-2. Look at the reasons being provided.

Ok, my Phate vote's going nowhere fast. Unvote, Vote: Xpom. I trust Bookitty (and to an extent, Oman)'s scumhunting to have picked up something I missed.

Oops, I totally forgot about this game.
Right now, my suspicions are on Xpom/FL because I haven't seen any contribution from either of them that was useful at all.

I vote because I care.

ok fine Oman

I mean, COME ON. All Xpom has done is display typical newbie behaviour - someone decided it would be fun to fuck with the new guy and tell him that you don't have to reread threads you replace into. He mentioned that, and BOOM! L-2. This looks way too much like a newbietown lynch, and we should not be lynching off the newbies for being newbies, let alone on D3. FaerieLord was admittedly scummy, and I don't have a problem with BooKitty's vote, but all of the last four speedvotes were scummy, especially Gorrad's and Cow's.

[Phate]

Conveniently, though, you've jumped onto the easiest lynch with no reasons that Xpom can defend against, or indeed, any reasons other than "FL was scummy, I agree with what was being said, Xpom hasn't contributed anything (although contradicting that last point, I'd completely forgotten about this game). So I'll vote him."

[Phate]

Note: My last post was an answer to Cow.

I mean, COME ON. All Xpom has done is display typical newbie behaviour - someone decided it would be fun to fuck with the new guy and tell him that you don't have to reread threads you replace into. He mentioned that, and BOOM! L-2. This looks way too much like a newbietown lynch, and we should not be lynching off the newbies for being newbies, let alone on D3. FaerieLord was admittedly scummy, and I don't have a problem with BooKitty's vote, but all of the last four speedvotes were scummy, especially Gorrad's and Cow's.

A) But how does that make him town, exactly? That was what I was referring to.

If a great deal of scummy-looking people all suddenly jump onto a wagon in a very scummy way, the person they're jumping onto is likely town.

B) Bookie's vote/reasoning most likely swayed a lot of people.

"Sure, I agree. Let's lynch now." = scummy. Especially when 4 people in a row say that pretty much in unison.

C) You say Faerielord was scummy, but earlier you say:

Xpom is town.

This is a scum-driven wagon, and I will have no part in it.

Funny thing is, Xpom is in fact...FL. Contradictions are cool.

See my answer to point A. He's not town because of his behaviour, he's town because of others' behaviours towards him.

[Phate]

Cow, multiple people jumping on someone's wagon in a short time period isn't

necessarily

scummy. But when they all provide no reasoning or, in your case, hollowly echoing other people, it is scummy.

[Phate]

Xpom is not the lynch.
DoS is not the lynch.

FlameAxe is not the lynch today.
UA is not a great lynch today.

Gorrad is the lynch today.

[Phate]

UltimaAvalon - 2 (Mastermind of Sin)

Somebody has a good opinion of MoS.