InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Klick]

Hi Mhork, Nati, ffery, shos, ProHawk, Bulba, Katsuki, Hana, TSO, Iecerint, AD, Sven, Majiffy, NC, mastin, Mala, Who, Axxle, Haylen, T-Bone, BPC, Venmar, Molla, kdowns, xof, Egg, and everyone I haven't interacted with before!

VOTE: kdowns

[Klick]

VOTE: Nero Cain

[Klick]

xof please don't be scum

[Klick]

I agree with, like, three of those.

[Klick]

Flipping a coin for Abomination's alignment

Original Roll String: 1d2

1 2-Sided Dice: (1) = 1

[Klick]

I agree with, like, three of those.

I'm certainly no scumhunting god, even though I happen to think I'm more right than wrong, but could you tell me which ones you agree/disagree with and if you can, why?

Well, to start, I'm voting for one of your town-reads.

I think xof's probably scum. kdowns could be scum. Other than that, either I'm still null on everyone you've mentioned, or I have an opposite read. In particular, Iece is probably town, and Abomination is scum.

[Klick]

How am I probably scum, Kleeck?
I know you aren't all that great at giving words to your reads, but try would you?

Thought I answered this, sorry. The main thing is that I don't like your early defense of Abomination. I don't think anyone here is dumb enough to actually go through with an Abomination PL Day 1, but you seemed to be seriously defending them. It feels like either a chainsaw defense or white-knighting (and I'm leaning the former).

[Klick]

Ah, okay. False alarm, xof's town.

I screwed up the meaning of that apparently after looking at it on the Wiki. Chainsaw defense is defending your scum buddy by attacking the person who attacked them. But that's not really what I meant to say, it was more of just defending a buddy in general.

[Klick]

UNVOTE:

NC, explain Clyton to me.

[Klick]

Those nero votes (someone + klick) on pg2 were p bad

Please inform me about the error of my ways, that I may see the light.

PEdit: If we dedicate the entirety of D1 to having everyone take out Abomination, even if he flips scum, we're not going to have enough information to make good decisions later in the game. Here's a prime example of why what you're proposing is a bad idea:

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=21433

[Klick]

Those nero votes (someone + klick) on pg2 were p bad

Please inform me about the error of my ways, that I may see the light.

PEdit: If we dedicate the entirety of D1 to having everyone take out Abomination, even if he flips scum, we're not going to have enough information to make good decisions later in the game. Here's a prime example of why what you're proposing is a bad idea:

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=21433

Page 2 hammer in a large theme of 25 = epic winnage. (VI SHOULD KNOW.)

And no it's impossible for it to be a bad idea. Plus, you're linking a mini where the dynamics are entirely different from a large.

Does that change the fact that having a two-page D1 results in less information? We just disagree on a fundamental level about whether or not a quicklynch would help us ever.

[Klick]

If I were to policy lynch anyone in this game so far, it'd be Katsuki.

a glorified policy lunch

This sounds delicious. And I agree, Katsuki's most likely town for her behavior right now.

[Klick]

I do exist! I'll admit it, the pace and size of the game is making me procrastinate. However, I'm committed to actually doing stuff in this game.

I don't have any major scum reads at the moment, but there are quite a few people that, during skim-reading, I got a pretty decent town read on. I didn't really keep notes, but Iecerint, Abomination, Venmar, and xof are among the list. Reasons are a mix of mostly gut and a few specific things that stood out to me while I was reading. I'm willing to go over anyone in particular if someone would like. Otherwise, I'm probably just going to start gathering information from this post forward.

[Klick]

...I think I may have mixed him up with someone else. I get literally nothing leaning one way or another from his ISO.

I'm confident in the other three, though.