Kingmaker II-Game Over

[Battle Mage]

i think i am the one who will be replacing Smashy. I will reread later and hope to get this game back on track.

[Battle Mage]

well im up to page 12 lol.
So far Ubertimmy looks like complete scum, though he has since been replaced so i wont vote yet. His sucking up to MoS, combined with MoS's subtle pushing of a Glork wagon make him pretty suspicious aswell.

Ill keep rereading, even though i havent got my role yet. Heres hoping i dont become Mafia, after revealing the identity of all my scumbuddies.

BM

[Battle Mage]

btw-can i just clarify that the only scum killed so far is Pooky?
The OP doesnt explicitly state the affiliation of anyone else, so i just wanted to be sure...
Im still rereading. Thought post 371 was worthy of an

FOS

.
Could anyone help by giving me a quick rundown of the important events of the game?
BM

[Battle Mage]

nobody has answered the questions addressed in this post.
it would be helpful for you to do so, so i can respond to anything of dire importance at the earliest opportunity.
BM

btw-can i just clarify that the only scum killed so far is Pooky?
The OP doesnt explicitly state the affiliation of anyone else, so i just wanted to be sure...
Im still rereading. Thought post 371 was worthy of an

FOS

.
Could anyone help by giving me a quick rundown of the important events of the game?
BM

[Battle Mage]

ok, ill try and do so asap.
im still on about page 20 atm-this is pretty heavy stuff

Well, your under major suspicion atm because of your predecessor's reigns day 3. If there was any one thing for you to address, it would be that about now.

[Battle Mage]

well a quick reread (as requested) of Smashy doesnt reveal alot. It doesnt look like he was particularly active, nor did he fully explain his reasons behind the execution. I disagree with many of his player analyses but to be honest i dont think he looks scummy. I just think he looks like someone who didnt really care about playing the game after he had enjoyed his moment of glory.
Still, I am not Smashy, and i will continue rereading to try and find out who is scum.
BM

[Battle Mage]

ive read the first half of the game fully, and have drawn my own opinions from that. Obviously this has allowed me to draw basic opinions on many of the players-especially knowing that Pooky was scum.
BM

well a quick reread (as requested) of Smashy doesnt reveal alot. It doesnt look like he was particularly active, nor did he fully explain his reasons behind the execution. I disagree with many of his player analyses but to be honest i dont think he looks scummy. I just think he looks like someone who didnt really care about playing the game after he had enjoyed his moment of glory.
Still, I am not Smashy, and i will continue rereading to try and find out who is scum.
BM

Um... I have to ask: How well have you read the game so far?

If your answer is in any way synonymous to "not very well", please explain to me how you can possibly "disagree with many of his player analyses"?

[Battle Mage]

rofl.

MoS: Battle Mage is Smashy's replacement (so yes, if Smashy turned up scum I would be wary of Battle Mage too.)

[Battle Mage]

actually, i have to agree, despite my previous thoughts that SV looked fairly neutral.
the consistent weak cases by SV do seem odd, as i have always considered SV a capable player. Nonetheless, im not sure whether this is scummy, as i think SV scum would make more of an effort than SV town. I dont really think an SV execution is appropriate, although i would like to see more from her before any execution takes place.
as for MoS, i think that would still be a good call for today. He looked very scummy early in the game, and although it seems he has improved, i still think he could well be scum.
I need to have a closer look at VR before i comment on him.
BM

I've got to say, I really like PJ's case against SV here. That's the first really convincing charge I've seen against SV, and I'm interested in hearing a response.

[Battle Mage]

when did i profess that?
truth is, the only way we can catch scum is by lynching those who appear scummy. What you just said didnt really make sense.

LoL, for someone who professes that "looking" scummy doesn't necessarily make him scum, you seem intent on getting someone else executed for "looking" scummy. Great arguments there, chief.

[Battle Mage]

i dont think you always look scummy..
In the games i have been with you in, you give off strong protown vibes. Here you dont. Other people may see it differently, but from my perspective its pretty simple. You look like Mafia.

I'd quote you, but it's in an ongoing game, so that'd be breaking the rules to quote it. The point is, you get by in games because people become convinced that you just look scummy in every game, and you've accepted that as valid reasoning from them. Then you turn around and ask for me to be executed because I look scummy, when a quick skim over some past games or just simply asking people who have been around and are familiar with my games would reveal that I tend to look scummy in most every game I play, especially ones like this where I start off the game essentially telling you that I'm going to look scummy and that I don't really care if you don't like it.

[Battle Mage]

hmm well personally i disagree with a Mnowax execution. he hasnt made a great deal of contribution-instead vote hopping like a chicken on speed.
he seems quite enthusiastic, but he just doesnt seem all that scummy to me.
He also agrees with me that MoS seemed scummy when he read through the game, so i dont think he can be all that bad.
helpful? not really
scum? probably not.
Im still much happier with an MoS execution.

BM

[Battle Mage]

do you have a reason for this, other than that im getting you lynched as scum in another game?
Also, i didnt even know you were playing. any reason for your inactivity, and lack of contribution?



[quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"]Still here. Hammer BM[/quote]

[Battle Mage]

lol i think everyone wanted Rikku dead. unfortunately, he wasnt scum. makes me wonder who, of his attackers, is scum trying to get a mis-lynch, and who are townies with genuine concerns?
BM


[quote="KaleiÐoscøpe"]No. You replaced Rikku. His kingship + behaviour reek scum. This has nothing to do with other games. If you read back, you'll notice I wanted rikku dead before you entered this game.[/quote]

[Battle Mage]

Sorry guys, but ive decided i am gonna request replacement. when i signed up for this game, i didnt mind the reading itself, but the depth of discussion throughout makes for a really heavy game to get to grips with. I really dont feel i have the time or inclination to be of great use to the town here, so im going to let someone better have a shot.
once again, sorry, and thanks for letting me play
BM

[Battle Mage]

good luck lol. you'll need it
Oh and btw-kill MoS while im away.

Hi guys.
I'm, uh, I'm replacing Shanba.
Jesus.
*begins to read*

[Battle Mage]

fyi-i promised Thok that id continue playing until he found a replacement.
dont expect any long posts out of me, but im still happy to go with a MoS lynch over a Mnowax lynch.

[Battle Mage]

Yay, nice win by the scum. I'm only sorry that i didnt do better when i was playing. unfortunately the game> me. I didnt have the time to read the thread and i didnt have the nerve to actually make a decent case against someone. Had i stayed, i'd have almost certainly cracked under the pressure.

BM

[Battle Mage]

On a side note, I tihnk this was the last game still running since I joined mafiascum. That's kinda an odd feeling.

actually, Royal Family Mafia is still going.

[Battle Mage]

EDWOP: Damn my slow typing.

[Battle Mage]

Shanba > BM

Glork > MoS