Gamma, DDD and Rayfrost get individual salutations for being the only players I’ve never played a game with.
--
Unfortunately I think Katsuki is Town. I wanted her to be scum because she’s an easy catch but without Fate or LLD to mindlessly defend her there is no way as Scum she’d go out of her way to antagonize me with her ‘Random’ first vote.
Gamma is obv-Town.
I’m in support of a Mass Domain claim. IMO it will allow people to more carefully consider their worship choices based on their Dayplay reads.
AGM’s claim is a whole big bag of Null. Not choosing Nobody Special as obv-Policy Lynch is meh. If Mothrax plays Pants on Head scummy we use the free lynch to test AGM’s claim. Not an Alligence tell at all that I can see.
--
Quadz wrote:P-Edit: Miller claim is +townpoints for sottyrulez.
It should be at best Null dependent on Sottyrulez’s play.
What do you think of Gamma’s ‘delayed’ Miller claim?
--
Equinox is a gut scum read – the 39 to 41 exchange is terribly bad.
“Nicki is asking fluffly horrible questions” (while Nicki is under pressure)
Faraday – Are you scum Equinox?
“Oops, made a mistake. Nicki is Town, wagon Quadz instead”
Equinox wrote:Anyway... hitogoroshi, AlmasterGM does have a point. This is a silly power to give to scum; it's not like scum particularly benefit from double day.
Please explain who scum would not benefit from a free mislynch if Mothrax is Town. I’m dying to know. Because AGM hasn’t claimed anything that gives him insight into Mothrax’s alignment as his choice.
--
Plum wrote:Why do you refer to this as 'theory speculation' given that it's an open question about mechanics, not a speculation (unless you mean to imply the speculation that alignment Evil = scum)???
Way too strained an effort to stratify the question’s basis when the premise (Evil may equal scum), at least form my point of view, may hold water.
Nothing in my role-PM makes any indication that Evil isn’t possible scum. Gamma’s late Miller claim combined with his claimed Alignment seems to support this. Scum points to Plum.
Plum wrote:This is not a straight 'No' sort of answer to 'are you scum'. That is scumpoints right there.
What response would you expect? There is one obvious answer to that question regardless of the player’s true Allegience – “No I’m not”
Unless you are anticipating a Lie Detector (which in a game like this is certainly possible) it’s at best a Null question with scum-hunting upside.
--
Hito wrote:What is this I don't even
Faraday is town for 45.
So Faraday is Town for voting Quadz, ostensibly because he is scum. Yet your vote isn’t on Quadz when you posted this and you didn’t change you vote. It instead is on Nobody Special, who had yet to post.
Yeah, that’s scumtastic. Damn, Nicki beat me to that observation.
And Hito’s response at 86 not impressive. I don’t buy at all the premise that “Is this a serious vote?” is a scum-tell. Sorry, seen it too many times from Town. Thus Faraday’s reaction to 44 isn’t obv-Town.
--
Nicki wrote:Um...yes? Because every player in this game should be a high priest of a Scummer, as opposed to the Scummer himself?
Mina dear if that is the case why would scum Zach not know that fact?
--
AGM wrote:You have to think of things in terms of catchability as well. In Trader and Bomb, he was easyscum. If I have a free policy lynch D1, I'd much rather use it on the person who you can never read and doesn't contribute than the person who will soon reveal himself to be obvscum.
In this player list do you have any expectations that scum-NS will not lurk like a champ? Seriously – it doesn’t take much for him to settle into a nice little groove of doing nothing.
AGM wrote:Also, even if mothrax wasn't NUMBER ONE choice, I'd still say he's at LEAST 2 or 3. So I don't see why we are complaining about a free lynch (remember, it's FREE).
1. Maybe because few people hold your personal feelings about Mothrax?
2. A free lynch is only good if it is likely to hit scum. Otherwise it only benefits scum. It's not like Mothrax is inherently bad on a Shotty / Furc level.
--
VV wrote:Well this is easy.
Vote: mothrax
I'll probably be voting for quadz after we're done with mothrax.
hito seems Town. Town hito is a wall posting baddy. Never seen a scum hito before so YMMV.
Scummy bad vote plus the rest of his post dedicated to saying nothing about Hito that’s effectively solid.
Into the scum pool with you.
--
VPB wrote:I dont' really buy all the people going "policy lynch = ZOMG BAD"
Why? Policy lynches should be reserved for the Worst of the Worst. The Furculows and DrMyShotty’s of the world. Realistically the only player on the list even CLOSE to that stature is Nobody Special.
--
Sottyrulez wrote:Paraphrased, our flavor with being a miller is that Troll speak effects the reading of our Allegiance.
Hmmm. I don’t see anything remotely flavor related in my Role PM. In light of the sample Miller PM not having flavor and Gamma’s statement I’m finding this suspect.
Sottyrulez wrote:The flavor is a passive ability called Trollspeak, this ability returns allegiance investigations as mafia and no result to all other investigations. We also can not be neighborized due to this passive ability.
Not sure that a description of an ability should be classified as flavor. Sottyrulez allegiance needs further examination.
I do like the Plum vote ... hmmmmm.
--
VOTE: VV – Bandwagon away ….