A Roccisi Winter - Game Over

[TDC]

Status

Game Over.

Players

Alive(5):
03.

Sopianae

elvis_knits
05.

Ectomancer

Phate

Ectomancer
08.

Socrates

Nicodemus
11. Cobalt
19.

Sanhora

RichardGHP

Ellibereth

Dead (16):
09. kyle99, Doctor, Milan Street, Town, Lynched Day 1. (Role)
10. Benmage, Townie, Venice Street, Town, Lynched Day 1. (Role)
12. Bogre, Miller Mason, Pisa Street, Palermo Street Masonry, Town, Lynched Day 1. (Role)
17. tatetothetot, Townie, Rome Street, Town, Lynched Day 1. (Role)
18. charter, Townie, Pisa Street, Town, Lynched Day 1. (Role)
20. Neopi, Vigilante, Pisa Street, Italian Mafia, Lynched Day 1. (Role)
15. Annachie, Compulsive Bodyguard, Torino Street, Town, Shot Day 1. (Role)
04. nhammen, Odd Day Cop, Milan Street, Town, Lynched Day 2. (Role)
06.

Pyotr C. Romanof

crypto

HowardRoark, Weak Hider, Florence Street, Town, Lynched Day 2. (Role)
22. TheButtonmen, Mason, Torino Street, Palermo Street Masonry, Town, Shot Day 2. (Role)
16.

Starbuck

roflcopter, Townie, Torino Street, Town, Lynched Day 3(Role)
21. Plum, Backup Vigilante, Pisa Street, Italian Mafia, Lynched Day 3 (Role)
07.

iamausername

Nuwen, Goon, Rome Street, Italian Mafia, Lynched Day 4 (Role)
02.

Adel

DrippingGoofball, Townie, Venice Street, Town, Shot Day 4 (Role)
13.

populartajo

CSL, Townie, Rome Street, Town, Lynched Day 5 (Role)
14. ortolan, Goon, Milan Street, Italian Mafia, Lynched Day 5 (Role)
01. tubby216, Townie, Florence Street, Town, Lynched Day 8

Links

Rules - Setup

Day 1:

Start - Reveals - Actions

Day 2:

Start - Reveals - Actions

Day 3:

Start - Reveals & Actions

Day 4:

Start - Reveals - Actions

Day 5:

Start - Reveals - Actions

Day 6:

Start - Reveals - Actions

Day 7:

Start

Day 8:

Start - Reveals & Actions

Day 9:

Start - Reveals & Actions

End:

Remaining Reveals - Group Abilities - Actions

[TDC]

The Rules

• General
  • The site-wide rules apply.
    
  • Do not try to hide information within your posts by using encryption, invisible/white text or similar means. If you are unsure whether what you're trying to do is allowed or not, please PM me.
    
  • If you're dead (which is the case in the precise moment I announce your death), refrain from posting at all.
    
  • All Mod communication should go through PMs, please do not request me to do things in thread. You may never quote anything you received as PM from me.
    
  • Added on 2009-15-12: You may never quote anything from a QuickTopic.
    
  • I am not a lawyer, so if you think the rules have holes, please let me know. If you exploit such a hole, expect to be mod-killed.
• Voting
  • A proper vote must be bolded, include the word "vote" and something that I can trace back to one of the players. This may be the whole name or an abbreviation. Please make sure that I understand whom you mean to vote for. Otherwise, your vote won't count.
    
  • Unvotes are not necessary, but I'm sure the other players would appreciate them.
    
  • If you want to unvote without voting someone else, use a bolded "unvote".
• Deadlines
  • All game days will be deadlined to (PLAYERS_ALIVE/2+7 real days).
    
  • I reserve the right to alter the deadline under extreme circumstances.
    
  • There is no reduced deadline lynch majority.
  
  
• Lynching
  • Once an absolute majority of votes is reached, the player in question is removed from the game. This does not end the game day, but the vote count resets.
    
  • There is no limit on the number of lynches per game day.
• Actions
  • Unless explicitly stated otherwise, any player may submit one personal and one group action each day. The regular deadline applies.
    
  • Personal actions have to be submitted by PM, Group actions in the relevant Quicktopic.
    
  • Choices must be bolded and it must be reasonably clear to me which action(s) you take (if more than one is available) and whom the target(s) is/are supposed to be.
    
  • The submitter of a group action will be the one carrying it out.
    
  • Group actions may be vetoed (again, bolded) in the Quicktopic at which point they become invalid and may not be attempted to be used again that day.
    
  • If you submit more group actions than you are allowed to (by default: 1), I will keep them by order of submittal. The dropped actions will silently fail.
    
  • If the submitter of a group action gets lynched, the action may be resubmitted by another group member.
    
  • If the target of any action gets lynched, it may be resubmitted.
• End of Day
  • I will, as soon as possible and in that order:
    • Reveal all lynches of the day.
      
    • Process all actions and send out the results. All actions that were submitted before the deadline hit are treated the same. The precise moment does not matter.
      
    • Reveal all resulting deaths .
      
    • Announce the new deadline.
  • The vote count will reset, but the thread will remain open.
    
  • Reveals will include the full Role PM of the dead player, including group memberships, excluding group details. All active and passive abilities will be revealed, but for the sake of brevity, the first post will only contain a catchy role name and link to the actual Role PM. While alive, players don't know their catchy role name.
• Participation
  • I expect each of you to post at least once every three days. (Some leniency will be applied on week-ends)
    
  • I will prod you if you don't. This will be announced in thread by me and you will have to answer the prod by posting in thread.
    
  • If prods are not answered or if I have to prod you repeatedly, I will replace you.
    
  • If no replacements can be found in a reasonable time, I will have to modkill you.
• Information
  • I will try to post a vote count near the top of every page.
    
  • Additionally the first post will always contain the most current vote count and all other information you need.

[TDC]

The Setup

All Role PMs will have the following format:

• Active Abilities:
  • Ability 1:
    • Ability Modifier 1
      
    • ...
      
    • Ability Modifier N
  • ...
    
  • Ability N:
    • Ability Modifier 1
      
    • ...
      
    • Ability Modifier N
• Passive Abilities:
  • Passive Ability 1
    
  • ..
    
  • Passive Ability N
• Groups:
  • Group 1:
    • Group Abilities:
      • Ability 1:
        • Ability Modifier 1
          
        • ...
          
        • Ability Modifier N
      • ...
        
      • Ability N:
        • Ability Modifier 1
          
        • ...
          
        • Ability Modifier N
    • Group Members:
      • Group Member 1
        
      • ...
        
      • Group Member N
  • ...
    
  • Group N:
    • Group Abilities:
      • Ability 1:
        • Ability Modifier 1
          
        • ...
          
        • Ability Modifier N
      • ...
        
      • Ability N:
        • Ability Modifier 1
          
        • ...
          
        • Ability Modifier N
    • Group Members:
      • Group Member 1
        
      • ...
        
      • Group Member N
• Victory Condition:

List of Abilities (both for players and groups):

• Bodyguard: Bodyguard: Each day you can protect another player. You will give your life for theirs. You can block multiple attempts at your target's life.
  
• Cop: Each day you can investigate another player to find out whether or not they are anti-town.
  
• Doctor: Each day you can protect another player. You are only able to prevent a single kill attempt per day.
  
• Gunsmith: Each day you can find out whether a player has access to guns (via personal or group ability of Vigilante with any sort of modifiers)
  
• Jailkeeper: Each day you can jail another player. They will be unable to use their own day action, nor can anyone else target them.
  
• Hider: Each day you can hide in the house of another player. You will only die if they die.
  
• Motivator: Each day you can enable a player to use one more ability the following day .
  
• Nightwatchman: Each day you can find out whether the player you target used an ability that day .
  
• Roleblocker: Each day you can block another player. They will be unable to use their own night action(s).
  
• Role Cop: Each day you can receive the list of all active and passive abilities (with modifiers), excluding group abilities, of the player you target.
  
• Tracker: Each day you can find out whom another player targeted that night.
  
• Vigilante: Each day you can try to kill another player.
  
• Watcher: Each day you can find out who targeted another player that night.

Notes:

• The Cop ability may or may not be accompanied with sanity confirmation.
  
• The result of a Cop investigation will be either "Guilty", "Not Guilty" or "No Result".
  
• These abilities will receive a "Yes" if the action is successful and the target meets the stated criteria: Gunsmith, Nightwatchman.
  
• These abilities will receive a list of all players/abilities that meet the stated criteria if the action is successful: Role Cop, Tracker, Watcher.
  
• These abilities will receive "No Result" if the action fails or if the action has no results: Gunsmith, Nightwatchman, Role Cop, Tracker, Watcher.
  
• In short, the only ability that can tell whether or not it failed is the Cop.

List of Ability Modifiers:

• 1-Shot: You can use your ability only once.
  
• Amnesiac: You forget your own results, so you have to name another player who should receive your results.
  
• Backup: Once someone with the same ability dies, you can use yours.
  
• Collaboration: The ability is only available as long as at least two group members are alive.
  
• Compulsive: You have to use your ability each day.
  
• Even Day: This ability can only be used on even days.
  
• Inventor: You cannot use your ability yourself, but each day you can give another player a 1-Shot of your ability for use on any subsequent day.
  
• Final Chance: This ability is Free (see below) for the final member of the group.
  
• Final Chance+: This ability is Free (see below) for the final member of the group. This final member may self-target with the ability.
  
• Free: This ability does not count against the one personal and one group action per day rule.
  
• Group only: This ability may only be used on members of this group.
  
• No Back-to-Back: This ability cannot be used on the same target twice in a row.
  
• Non-group: This ability may only be used on players that are not part of this group.
  
• Odd Day: This ability can only be used on odd days.
  
• Solist: This ability can only be used by the final member of the group.
  
• Weak: You die when you target scum.

Notes:

• A 1-Shot ability will be used up, once the player/group attempted to use it, regardless of success.
  
• The Amnesiac modifier only applies to investigative abilities (obviously) and the results will have the form:
  Ability: x
  Target: y
  Result: z
  
• The following Modifiers only apply to Group Abilities: Collaboration, Final Chance, Final Chance+, Group-only, Non-group, Solist.

List of Passive Abilities:

• Bulletproof Vest: You can survive one attempt at your life.
  
• Godfather: If Cop-investigated you appear pro-town. If Gunsmith-investigated you seem not to have a gun.
  
• Known Identity: The mentioned group knows your identity.
  
• Miller: If Cop-investigated you appear anti-town. If Gunsmith-investigated you seem to have a gun.
  
• Multitasker: You can use one additional ability per day.
  
• Kill Immunity: You can only die by lynching. This does not guarantee endgame win.
  
• Survivor: You lose when you die.

List of Group Types:

• Mafia: All members are confirmed to be mafia together and share an anti-town victory condition.
  
• Masonry: All members are confirmed to be pro-town and share the regular town victory condition.
  
• Neighborhood: Alignments are unconfirmed.

All groups can talk at all times and will do so in a QuickTopic thread I provide.

The Vanilla Townie Role PM is (more examples can be found here):

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • none
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

[TDC]

Roles are going out now. As mentioned in them, this thread will open in about 24 hours. Please confirm by PM.
Those that have access to QuickTopics are free to use them at any time, including before this thread opens.

[TDC]

I would like to point out that the same rule that applies to things coming from me, applies to the quicktopics. You may paraphrase but not quote or post screenshots (which is for all I'm concerned the same thing as quoting).
If you are concerned whether what you're going to post will go through as paraphrase, please aks me before you post.
I will add this clarification to the rules.

[TDC]

"I declare the Games open!"
"What?"
"I said 'I declare the Games open'!"
"What the fuck are you talking about?"
*camera zooms out and shows a small Italian village, covered in snow*
"This isn't Vancouver, is it?"

Status

It is now Day 1.
Deadline: Sunday, January 3rd, 14:00 CET (GMT+1)
Remember that QuickTopics may be used at all times.

With 22 alive, it's

13

12 to lynch.

Note: Neopi is the only player not to have confirmed so far. I will wait another 24 hours before searching a replacement.

[TDC]

Vote Count #1

tubby216 (2): Sanhora, iamausername
tatetothetot (2): Sopianae, Pyotr C. Romanof
populartajo (1): tatetothetot
Benmage (1): TheButtonmen

Not Voting (16): tubby216, Adel, nhammen, Ectomancer, Socrates, kyle99, Benmage, Cobalt, Bogre, populartajo, ortolan, Annachie, Starbuck, charter, Neopi, Plum

[TDC]

Vote Count #2

tubby216 (4): Sanhora, iamausername, kyle99, Annachie
kyle99 (2): Pyotr C. Romanof, nhammen
tatetothetot (1): Sopianae
populartajo (1): tatetothetot
Benmage (1): TheButtonmen


Not Voting (13): tubby216, Adel, Ectomancer, Socrates, Benmage, Cobalt, Bogre, populartajo, ortolan, Starbuck, charter, Neopi, Plum

With 22 alive, it's 12 to lynch, of course, not 13

[TDC]

Vote Count #3

kyle99 (6): Pyotr C. Romanof, nhammen, Adel, Sopianae, Plum, ortolan
tubby216 (4): Sanhora, iamausername, kyle99, Annachie
populartajo (1): tatetothetot
Benmage (1): TheButtonmen
Annachie (1): charter
Pyotr C. Romanof (1): populartajo

Not Voting (8): tubby216, Ectomancer, Socrates, Benmage, Cobalt, Bogre, Starbuck, Neopi

12 to lynch

Deleted the DeathNote post.
Looking for a replacement for Neopi, who still hasn't confirmed.

Since there still seems to be confusion about this:
All Action choices need to be in by deadline and will resolve simultaneously at deadline. When you send them in is irrelevant, just needs to be before January 3rd 14:00 CET.

[TDC]

Vote Count #4

kyle99 (6): Pyotr C. Romanof, nhammen, Adel, Sopianae, Plum, ortolan
tubby216 (4): Sanhora, iamausername, kyle99, Annachie
Benmage (1): TheButtonmen
Annachie (1): charter
Pyotr C. Romanof (1): populartajo

Not Voting (9): tubby216, Ectomancer, Socrates, Benmage, Cobalt, Bogre, Starbuck, Neopi, tatetothetot

12 to lynch

Neopi has confirmed now, so not searching for a replacement anymore.

[TDC]

Vote Count #5

tubby216 (7): Sanhora, iamausername, kyle99, Annachie, Benmage, Neopi, Bogre
kyle99 (6): Pyotr C. Romanof, nhammen, Adel, Sopianae, Plum, ortolan
Benmage (1): TheButtonmen
Annachie (1): charter
Pyotr C. Romanof (1): populartajo
Bogre (1): Socrates

Not Voting (5): tubby216, Ectomancer, Cobalt, Starbuck, tatetothetot

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #6

tubby216 (7): Sanhora, iamausername, kyle99, Annachie, Benmage, Neopi, Bogre
kyle99 (5): Pyotr C. Romanof, Sopianae, Plum, ortolan, Adel
Bogre (2): Socrates, tatetothetot
ortolan (2): Ectomancer, nhammen
Benmage (1): TheButtonmen
Annachie (1): charter
Pyotr C. Romanof (1): populartajo
tatetothetot (1): Cobalt

Not Voting (2): tubby216, Starbuck,

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #7

tubby216 (6): kyle99, Annachie, Benmage, Neopi, Bogre, Starbuck
kyle99 (5): Pyotr C. Romanof, Sopianae, Plum, ortolan, Adel
tatetothetot (4): Cobalt, Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
ortolan (3): Ectomancer, nhammen, iamausername
Bogre (2): Socrates, tatetothetot
Annachie (1): charter

Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #8

tubby216 (5): kyle99, Annachie, Benmage, Bogre, Starbuck
Bogre (5): Socrates, tatetothetot, Adel, Cobalt, Neopi
kyle99 (4): Pyotr C. Romanof, Sopianae, Plum, ortolan
tatetothetot (3): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
ortolan (2): Ectomancer, iamausername
Ectomancer (2): nhammen, charter

Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #9

Bogre (6): Socrates, tatetothetot, Adel, Cobalt, Neopi, ortolan
tubby216 (5): kyle99, Annachie, Benmage, Bogre, Starbuck
kyle99 (3): Pyotr C. Romanof, Sopianae, Plum,
tatetothetot (3): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
ortolan (2): Ectomancer, iamausername
Ectomancer (2): nhammen, charter

Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

I would like to remind everyone that the site-rules apply and that I will take action if I feel they are violated.
Specifically:

Within a game, criticism of another player's play is acceptable - making it personal is not, and may result in action by the moderator of that game.

That's not asking too much, is it?

[TDC]

Vote Count #10

Bogre (6): Socrates, tatetothetot, Adel, Cobalt, Neopi, ortolan
tubby216 (5): kyle99, Annachie, Benmage, Bogre, Starbuck
tatetothetot (3): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
kyle99 (2): Sopianae, Plum,
ortolan (2): Ectomancer, iamausername
Ectomancer (2): nhammen, charter
Annachie (1): Pyotr C. Romanof

Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #11

Bogre (5): tatetothetot, Adel, Cobalt, Neopi, ortolan
tubby216 (4): Annachie, Benmage, Bogre, Starbuck
tatetothetot (4): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen, Plum
kyle99 (3): Sopianae, Pyotr C. Romanof, Socrates
Neopi (2): charter, kyle99
ortolan (1): Ectomancer
Ectomancer (1): nhammen
nhammen (1): iamausername


Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #12

Bogre (7): tatetothetot, Adel, Cobalt, Neopi, ortolan, Starbuck, Annachie
tatetothetot (4): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen, Plum
kyle99 (3): Sopianae, Pyotr C. Romanof, Socrates
tubby216 (2): Benmage, Bogre
Annachie (2): Ectomancer, charter
Neopi (1): kyle99
Ectomancer (1): nhammen
nhammen (1): iamausername


Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

roflcopter will replace Starbuck

[TDC]

Vote Count #13

Bogre (6): tatetothetot, Adel, Neopi, ortolan, Starbuck, Annachie
Annachie (5): Ectomancer, charter, Bogre, iamausername, Cobalt
tatetothetot (4): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen, Plum
kyle99 (2): Sopianae, Socrates
Benmage (2): Benmage, Pyotr C. Romanof
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #14

Bogre (6): tatetothetot, Adel, Neopi, ortolan, Starbuck, Annachie
Annachie (5): Ectomancer, charter, Bogre, iamausername, Cobalt
tatetothetot (4): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen, Plum
Benmage (2): Pyotr C. Romanof, Sopianae
kyle99 (1): Socrates
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (2): tubby216, Benmage

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #15

Annachie (5): Ectomancer, charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum
Bogre (4): tatetothetot, Neopi, ortolan, Starbuck
kyle99 (4): Socrates, Pyotr C. Romanof, Cobalt, Benmage
tatetothetot (3): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
Benmage (3): Sopianae, Adel, Annachie
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (1): tubby216

12 to lynch

As a clarification: As I understand the "not posting about on-going games" rule and how it tends to get used on this forum, there is nothing wrong with reffering to when and how much someone posted where (and indeed, such is done quite often). Rather it is aimed to prevent talking about the game itself anywhere but in the relevant game thread.
I would appreciate if everyone tried to say as little as possible about other games. Especially, I will consider everything that goes beyond things that everyone can obviously verify (like when someone posted) to be "talking about the game".
When in doubt, ask me first.

I hope that's clear enough, though it sure is a murky distinction to make.
Feel free to PM me if you have anything to say about this. This thread is not the place for it.

[TDC]

Vote Count #16

Annachie (5): Ectomancer, charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum
kyle99 (5): Socrates, Pyotr C. Romanof, Cobalt, Benmage, tubby216
Benmage (4): Sopianae, Adel, Annachie, roflcopter
Bogre (3): tatetothetot, Neopi, ortolan
tatetothetot (3): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (0):

12 to lynch

Prodding kyle99.

[TDC]

Vote Count #17

Annachie (5): Ectomancer, charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum
kyle99 (5): Socrates, Pyotr C. Romanof, Cobalt, Benmage, tubby216
Benmage (4): Sopianae, Adel, Annachie, roflcopter
Bogre (3): tatetothetot, Neopi, ortolan
tatetothetot (3): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (0):

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #18

Annachie (5): Ectomancer, charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum
kyle99 (5): Socrates, Pyotr C. Romanof, Cobalt, Benmage, tubby216
Benmage (4): Sopianae, Adel, Annachie, roflcopter
Bogre (3): tatetothetot, Neopi, ortolan
tatetothetot (3): Sanhora, populartajo, TheButtonmen
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (0):

12 to lynch

Phate will replace Ectomancer.
Prodding iamausername, populartajo, ortolan, tatetothetot and TheButtonmen

[TDC]

Vote Count #19

kyle99 (8): Socrates, Cobalt, Benmage, tubby216, ortolan, Pyotr C. Romanof, Sanhora, roflcopter
Annachie (4): charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum
Benmage (3): Sopianae, Adel, Annachie
Bogre (2): tatetothetot, Neopi,
tatetothetot (2): populartajo, TheButtonmen
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (1): Phate

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #20

kyle99 (10): Socrates, Cobalt, Benmage, tubby216, ortolan, Pyotr C. Romanof, Sanhora, roflcopter, Annachie, Adel
Annachie (4): charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum
Bogre (2): tatetothetot, Neopi,
tatetothetot (2): populartajo, TheButtonmen
Benmage (1): Sopianae
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (1): Phate

12 to lynch

[TDC]

Lynch Count #1

kyle99 (12): Socrates, Cobalt, Benmage, tubby216, Pyotr C. Romanof, Sanhora, roflcopter, Annachie, Adel, Phate, Neopi, ortolan

Annachie (4): charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum
tatetothetot (2): populartajo, TheButtonmen
Bogre (1): tatetothetot
Benmage (1): Sopianae
Neopi (1): kyle99
Cobalt (1): nhammen

Not Voting (0):

kyle99 has been lynched and is dead. Vote Count reset.

Vote Count #1

Not Voting (21): Socrates, Cobalt, Benmage, tubby216, Pyotr C. Romanof, Sanhora, roflcopter, Annachie, Adel, Phate, Neopi, ortolan, charter, Bogre, iamausername, Plum, populartajo, TheButtonmen, tatetothetot, Sopianae, nhammen


11 to lynch

Prodding Plum and tubby216.

[TDC]

Vote Count #2

Benmage (7): ortolan, Annachie, Sopianae, roflcopter, Cobalt, Neopi, tubby216
Annachie (3): charter, Phate, Adel
Neopi (1): Plum
charter (1): Socrates
tatetohetot (1): Benmage

Not Voting (8): Pyotr C. Romanof, Sanhora, Bogre, iamausername, populartajo, TheButtonmen, tatetothetot, nhammen

11 to lynch

Searching replacements for iamausername and tatetothetot

[TDC]

Nuwen replaces iamausername.

[TDC]

Lynch Count #2

Benmage (11): ortolan, Annachie, Sopianae, roflcopter, Cobalt, Neopi, tubby216, TheButtonmen, Socrates, Adel, Nuwen

Annachie (2): charter, Phate
Neopi (2): Plum, Benmage
Cobalt (1): populartajo

Not Voting (5): Pyotr C. Romanof, Sanhora, Bogre, tatetothetot, nhammen

11 to lynch

Benmage has been lynched. Vote Count reset.

Vote Count #1

TheButtonmen (1): Pyotr C. Romanof

Not Voting (20): ortolan, Annachie, Sopianae, roflcopter, Cobalt, Neopi, tubby216, TheButtonmen, Socrates, Adel, Nuwen, Sanhora, Bogre, tatetothetot, nhammen, charter, Phate, Plum, Benmage, populartajo

11 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #1

Bogre (9): Cobalt, Adel, Socrates, tubby216, Pyotr C. Romanof, roflcopter, ortolan, Annachie, Sopianae

Not Voting (11): Neopi, TheButtonmen, Nuwen, Sanhora, Bogre, tatetothetot, nhammen, charter, Phate, Plum, populartajo

11 to lynch

[TDC]

Lynch Count #3

Bogre (11): Cobalt, Adel, Socrates, tubby216, Pyotr C. Romanof, roflcopter, ortolan, Annachie, Sopianae, Phate, Nuwen

Not Voting (9): Neopi, TheButtonmen, Sanhora, Bogre, tatetothetot, nhammen, charter, Plum, populartajo

Bogre has been lynched and is now dead. Vote Count reset.

Vote Count #1

Not Voting (19): Neopi, TheButtonmen, Sanhora, tatetothetot, nhammen, charter, Plum, populartajo, Cobalt, Adel, Socrates, tubby216, Pyotr C. Romanof, roflcopter, ortolan, Annachie, Sopianae, Phate, Nuwen

10 to lynch.

[TDC]

Vote Count #2

tatetothetot (6): charter, TheButtonmen, Nuwen, Plum, ortolan, populartajo
charter (3): roflcopter, Adel, Socrates
nhammen (2): Pyotr C. Romanof, tubby216
tubby216 (1): Cobalt

Not Voting (7): Sanhora, tatetothetot, nhammen, Annachie, Sopianae, Phate, Neopi

10 to lynch.

Deleted DeathNote post.

Remember to get your choices in by deadline, which is in 3 days and 45 minutes.

If you'd like to help with the replacement search, feel free to make people aware of this game's needs.

Prodding Sanhora.

[TDC]

Lynch Count #4

tatetothetot (10): charter, TheButtonmen, Nuwen, Plum, ortolan, populartajo, Cobalt, Adel, roflcopter, tubby216

charter (1): Socrates
ortolan (1): Pyotr C. Romanof

Not Voting (7): Sanhora, tatetothetot, nhammen, Annachie, Sopianae, Phate, Neopi

tatetothetot has been lynched.

Vote Count #1

ortolan (1): Pyotr C. Romanof

Not Voting (17): Sanhora, nhammen, Annachie, Sopianae, Phate, Neopi, charter, TheButtonmen, Nuwen, Plum, ortolan, populartajo, Cobalt, Adel, roflcopter, tubby216, Socrates

10 to lynch.

[TDC]

Vote Count #2

charter (3): Annachie, roflcopter, Pyotr C. Romanof
Neopi (3): ortolan, charter, Plum

Not Voting (12): Sanhora, nhammen, Sopianae, Phate, Neopi, TheButtonmen, Nuwen, populartajo, Cobalt, Adel, tubby216, Socrates

10 to lynch.

[TDC]

Vote Count #3

Neopi (6): ortolan, charter, Plum, tubby216, Cobalt, Nuwen
charter (5): Annachie, roflcopter, Pyotr C. Romanof, Phate, Socrates

Not Voting (7): Sanhora, nhammen, Sopianae, Neopi, TheButtonmen, populartajo, Adel

10 to lynch.

[TDC]

Vote Count #4

charter (7): Annachie, roflcopter, Pyotr C. Romanof, Phate, Socrates, Adel, Nuwen
Neopi (6): ortolan, charter, Plum, tubby216, Cobalt, populartajo

Not Voting (5): Sanhora, nhammen, Sopianae, Neopi, TheButtonmen

10 to lynch.

[TDC]

RichardGHP replaces Sanhora

[TDC]

Vote Count #5

charter (7): Annachie, roflcopter, Pyotr C. Romanof, Phate, Socrates, Adel, Nuwen
Neopi (6): ortolan, charter, Plum, tubby216, Cobalt, populartajo

Not Voting (5): Sanhora, nhammen, Sopianae, Neopi, TheButtonmen

10 to lynch.

Bit less than 11 hours to go.

[TDC]

Lynch Count #5

charter (10): Annachie, roflcopter, Pyotr C. Romanof, Phate, Socrates, Adel, Nuwen, Cobalt, RichardGHP, ortolan

Neopi (4): charter, Plum, tubby216, populartajo

Not Voting (4): nhammen, Sopianae, Neopi, TheButtonmen

charter has been lynched.

Vote Count #1

Neopi (1): Nuwen

Not Voting (16): nhammen, Sopianae, Neopi, TheButtonmen, Annachie, roflcopter, Pyotr C. Romanof, Phate, Socrates, Adel, , Cobalt, RichardGHP, ortolan, Plum, tubby216, populartajo

9 to lynch.

For what it's worth, I would count votes that are cast post-lynch for the new vote count.

[TDC]

My apologies, I missed that post.

Vote Count #6

charter (8): Annachie, roflcopter, Phate, Socrates, Adel, Cobalt, RichardGHP, ortolan
Neopi (5): charter, Plum, tubby216, populartajo, Nuwen

Not Voting (5): nhammen, Sopianae, Neopi, TheButtonmen, Pyotr C. Romanof

10 to lynch.

Vote Count will resume where it was.

[TDC]

Lynch Count #5

charter (10): Annachie, roflcopter, Phate, Socrates, Adel, RichardGHP, ortolan, Nuwen, Cobalt, Neopi

Neopi (4): charter, Plum, tubby216, populartajo

Not Voting (4): nhammen, Sopianae, TheButtonmen, Pyotr C. Romanof

charter has been lynched. For real.

Vote Count #1

Neopi (1): Adel

Not Voting (16): nhammen, Sopianae, Neopi, TheButtonmen, Annachie, roflcopter, Pyotr C. Romanof, Phate, Socrates, Cobalt, RichardGHP, ortolan, Plum, tubby216, populartajo, Nuwen

9 to lynch.

[TDC]

Lynch Count #6

Neopi (9): Adel, nhammen, Nuwen, Neopi, Pyotr C. Romanof, Socrates, Annachie, Cobalt, tubby216

Not Voting (8): Sopianae, TheButtonmen, roflcopter, Phate, RichardGHP, ortolan, Plum, populartajo

Neopi has been lynched.

Vote Count #1

tubby216 (6): Adel, Cobalt, Nuwen, RichardGHP, Annachie, roflcopter

Not Voting (10): Sopianae, TheButtonmen, Phate, ortolan, Plum, populartajo, nhammen, Pyotr C. Romanof, Socrates, tubby216

9 to lynch

1 hour

[TDC]

Final Vote Count of Day 1

tubby216 (6): Adel, Cobalt, Nuwen, RichardGHP, Annachie, roflcopter

Not Voting (10): Sopianae, TheButtonmen, Phate, ortolan, Plum, populartajo, nhammen, Pyotr C. Romanof, Socrates, tubby216

9 to lynch

Day 1 Lynches

kyle99, Doctor, Milan Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • Doctor
    • No Back-to-Back
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Milan Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Benmage, Townie, Venice Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Venice Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Bogre, Miller Mason, Pisa Street, Palermo Street Masonry, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • Miller
• Groups:
  • Palermo Street Masonry:
    • classified
  • Pisa Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

tatetothetot, Townie, Rome Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Rome Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

charter, Townie, Pisa Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Pisa Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Neopi, Vigilante, Pisa Street, The Italian Mafia

:

• Active Abilities:
  • Vigilante:
    • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • The Italian Mafia:
    • classified
  • Pisa Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition:
  classified

Action resolution coming shortly, Thread will re-open in a few minutes.

[TDC]

Deaths

Annachie, Compulsive Bodyguard, Torino Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • Bodyguard
    • Compulsive
      
    • No Back-to-Back
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Torino Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Status

It is now Day 2.
With 15 alive, it's 8 to lynch.
The deadline is Sunday, January 17th, 12:15 CET.

[TDC]

crypto "replaces" Pyotr C. Romanof ;p

[TDC]

Vote Count #1

ortolan (1): crypto
crypto (1): ortolan

Not Voting (13): Sopianae, TheButtonmen, Phate, Plum, populartajo, nhammen, Socrates, tubby216, Adel, Cobalt, Nuwen, RichardGHP, roflcopter

8 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #2

nhammen (5): roflcopter, TheButtonmen, crypto, Socrates, Cobalt
crypto (1): ortolan

Not Voting (9): Sopianae, Phate, Plum, populartajo, nhammen, tubby216, Adel, Nuwen, RichardGHP

8 to lynch

Prodding populartajo.

[TDC]

Vote Count #3

nhammen (4): roflcopter, TheButtonmen, Socrates, Cobalt
crypto (2): ortolan, Adel
roflcopter (1): nhammen

Not Voting (8): Sopianae, Phate, Plum, populartajo, tubby216, Nuwen, RichardGHP, crypto

8 to lynch

Adel will be replaced as requested.

[TDC]

DrippingGoofball replaces Adel!

[TDC]

Vote Count #4

nhammen (5): roflcopter, TheButtonmen, Socrates, Cobalt, Phate
crypto (2): ortolan, Adel
roflcopter (1): nhammen

Not Voting (7): Sopianae, Plum, populartajo, tubby216, Nuwen, RichardGHP, crypto

8 to lynch

crypto has been banned and will be replaced. I consider this a precedent on how the powers that be interpret the site rules, and so should you.

[TDC]

Vote Count #5

nhammen (6): roflcopter, Socrates, Cobalt, Phate, DrippingGoofball, ortolan
roflcopter (1): nhammen

Not Voting (8): Sopianae, Plum, populartajo, tubby216, Nuwen, RichardGHP, crypto, TheButtonmen

8 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #6

nhammen (6): roflcopter, Socrates, Cobalt, Phate, ortolan, DrippingGoofball
roflcopter (1): nhammen

Not Voting (8): Sopianae, Plum, populartajo, tubby216, Nuwen, RichardGHP, crypto, TheButtonmen

8 to lynch

Prodding RichardGHP.

[TDC]

Vote Count #7

nhammen (7): roflcopter, Socrates, Cobalt, Phate, ortolan, DrippingGoofball,Plum
roflcopter (1): nhammen

Not Voting (8): Sopianae, populartajo, tubby216, Nuwen, RichardGHP, crypto, TheButtonmen

8 to lynch

HowardRoark replaces crypto.

[TDC]

Lynch Count #1

nhammen (8): roflcopter, Socrates, Cobalt, Phate, ortolan, DrippingGoofball, Plum, tubby216

roflcopter (1): nhammen

Not Voting (6): Sopianae, populartajo, Nuwen, RichardGHP, HowardRoark, TheButtonmen

nhammen has been lynched.

Vote Count #1

Not Voting (14): Sopianae, populartajo, Nuwen, RichardGHP, HowardRoark, TheButtonmen, roflcopter, Socrates, Cobalt, Phate, ortolan, DrippingGoofball, Plum, tubby216

8 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #1

TheButtonmen (5): DrippingGoofball, roflcopter, Cobalt, Sopianae, Socrates
RichardGHP (1: tubby216
roflcopter (1): TheButtonmen

Not Voting (6): populartajo, Nuwen, HowardRoark, Phate, ortolan, Plum

8 to lynch

RichardGHP has requested replacement.

[TDC]

Vote Count #3

TheButtonmen (3): DrippingGoofball, roflcopter, Socrates
RichardGHP (1): tubby216
roflcopter (1): TheButtonmen

Not Voting (9): populartajo, Nuwen, HowardRoark, Phate, Plum, ortolan, Cobalt, Sopianae, RichardGHP

8 to lynch

Ellibereth replaces RichardGHP

[TDC]

Vote Count #4

HowardRoark (4): populartajo, ortolan, Ellibereth, DrippingGoofball
TheButtonmen (2): roflcopter, Socrates
roflcopter (1): TheButtonmen
tubby216 (1): Cobalt
Phate (1): tubby216

Not Voting (5): Nuwen, HowardRoark, Phate, Plum, Sopianae,

8 to lynch

[TDC]

Vote Count #6

HowardRoark (4): populartajo, ortolan, Ellibereth, Plum
Phate (2): tubby216, roflcopter
roflcopter (1): TheButtonmen
tubby216 (1): Cobalt
populartajo (1): DrippingGoofball

Not Voting (5): Nuwen, HowardRoark, Phate, Sopianae, Socrates

8 to lynch

Prodding Phate.

[TDC]

Vote Count #7

Phate (5): tubby216, roflcopter, DrippingGoofball, Socrates, Ellibereth
HowardRoark (4): populartajo, ortolan, Plum, Cobalt
roflcopter (1): TheButtonmen
Cobalt (1): HowardRoark

Not Voting (3): Nuwen, Phate, Sopianae

8 to lynch

Phate will be replaced.
Also, starting tomorrow I will be on vacation until the 31st. SpyreX will look over you during that time. I might or might not have access between now and then.

edit: Ectomancer is back in for Phate!

[TDC]

Vote Count #

HowardRoark (5): populartajo, ortolan, Plum, Ellibereth, Socrates
Ectomancer (2): tubby216, roflcopter
populartajo (2): Cobalt, DrippingGoofball
roflcopter (1): TheButtonmen
Cobalt (1): HowardRoark

Not Voting (3): Nuwen, Ectomancer, Sopianae

8 to lynch

Bye!

[TDC]

You can vote to end the day. If that happens the deadline will be moved to 72 hours from when the vote succeeds.

[TDC]

Hey. I'm back now. Give me a bit of time to get back into the game. I think deadline is fairly soon if not already over. I'll check with SpyreX to make sure no actions are lost.

[TDC]

Day 4 Lynches

Nuwen, Goon, Rome Street, Italian Mafia

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • The Italian Mafia:
    • classified
  • Rome Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition:
  classified

Action Resolution coming shortly.

[TDC]

Day 4 Deaths

DrippingGoofball, Townie, Venice Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Venice Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Status

It is now Day 5.
Deadline: Friday, February 12th, 9:50 CET (GMT+1)

8 alive, 5 to lynch.

[TDC]

Uh.. I compare the words?

[TDC]

That's probably better discussed via PM.

[TDC]

Vote Count #1

CSL (1): elvis_knits

Not Voting (7): tubby216, Ectomancer, Socrates, Cobalt, CSL, ortolan, Ellibereth

5 to lynch

Prodding tubby216.

[TDC]

Vote Count #1

CSL (5): elvis_knits, Cobalt, Socrates, Ectomancer, tubby216

Ectomancer (1): ortolan
tubby216 (1): CSL

Not Voting (1): Ellibereth

CSL has been lynched. Vote Count reset.

Note that deadline is less than 72 hours away.

[TDC]

12 hours.

[TDC]

Reveal

CSL, Townie, Rome Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Rome Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Action resolution coming shortly.

[TDC]

Everybody still alive.

Status

Day 6.
With 7 alive, 4 to lynch.
Deadline: Tuesday, Feb 23rd, 11:40CET

[TDC]

Lynch Count

ortolan (4): Ellibereth, Ectomancer, Cobalt, elvis_knits

Not Voting (3): tubby216, Socrates, ortolan

ortolan has been lynched

Vote Count #1

End Day (3): Ellibereth, Ectomancer, tubby216

Not Voting (3): Socrates, Cobalt, elvis_knits

4 to lynch

[TDC]

Deadline: Thursday, Feb 18th 18:30 CET.

[TDC]

1 hour

Will probably be back in about 3 hours.

[TDC]

Reveal

ortolan, Goon, Milan Street, Italian Mafia

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • The Italian Mafia:
    • classified
  • Milan Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition:
  classified

[TDC]

Everybody still alive.

Status

Day 7.
Deadline: Sunday, February 28th 20:30 GMT.

6 alive, 4 to lynch.

[TDC]

Deadline: Tuesday, February 23rd, 04:10 CET

[TDC]

Everyone is still alive.

Status

It is now Day 8.
Deadline: Friday, March 5th. 11:00 CET

6 alive, 4 to lynch.

[TDC]

Searching replacement for Socrates

[TDC]

Nicodemus replaces Socrates

[TDC]

Prodding tubby216

[TDC]

Lynch Count #1

tubby216 (4): Ectomancer, Nicodemus, Cobalt, Ellibereth

Cobalt (1): tubby216

tubby216 has been lynched.
Deadline is in 33 hours and ten minutes.

[TDC]

Won't be around near deadline (4 hours from now). In fact, might take a day or so.
Sorry for the inconvenience.

[TDC]

Lynch

tubby216, Townie, Florence Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Florence Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Actions

Everybody still alive.

Status

Day 9. 5 alive,3 to lynch, Tuesday, March 16th 0:30 CET

[TDC]

Vote Count

elvis_knits (2): Nicodemus, Ectomancer
Nicodemus (1): Cobalt

Not Voting (2): elvis_knits, Ellibereth

[TDC]

Lynch Count

elvis_knits (3): Nicodemus, Ellibereth, Ectomancer

Nicodemus (1): Cobalt

Not Voting (1): elvis_knits

elvis_knits has been lynched.

[TDC]

Deadline is in one day, four hours, thirty minutes.

[TDC]

Lynch

Sopianae

elvis_knits, Townie, Florence Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Florence Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Deaths

Cobalt, Godfather, Florence Street, Italian Mafia

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • Godfather
• Groups:
  • The Italian Mafia:
    • classified
  • Florence Street Neighbourhood]:
    • classified
• Victory Condition:
  classified

The Town of Roccisi has prevailed yet again. Congratulations

Survivors

Ellibereth, Mason, Napoli Street, Palermo Street Masonry, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Palermo Street Masonry:
    • classified
  • Napoli Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Ectomancer Phate

Ectomancer, Kill Immune Vigilante, Napoli Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • Vigilante
    • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • Kill Immunity
• Groups:
  • Napoli Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Socrates

Nicodemus, Townie, Napoli Street, Town

:

• Active Abilities:
  • none
• Passive Abilities:
  • none
• Groups:
  • Napoli Street Neighbourhood:
    • classified
• Victory Condition: You win when all anti-town forces are eliminated.

Group and Action Reveal and Commentary soon.

[TDC]

Group Abilities

• The Italian Mafia:
  • Bodyguard:
    • none
  • Gunsmith:
    • none
  • Jailkeeper:
    • none
  • Motivator:
    • none
  • Nightwatchman:
    • none
  • Vigilante:
    • 1-Shot
      
    • Soloist
• Palermo Street Masonry:
  • Tracker:
    • Odd Day
  • Watcher:
    • Even Day
• Florence Street Neighbourhood:
  • Watcher:
    • Even Day
      
    • Inventor
  • Tracker:
    • Amnesiac
      
    • Odd Day
• Milan Street Neighbourhood:
  • none
• Napoli Street Neighbourhood:
  • Doctor
    • Group Only
• Pisa Street Neighbourhood:
  • Gunsmith:
    • Inventor
  
  
• Rome Street Neighbourhood:
  • Nightwatchman:
    • none
• Torino Street Neighbourhood:
  • Vigilante
    • Soloist
• Venice Street Neighbourhood:
  • Roleblocker
    • Collaboration

Note: QuickTopic link for the Mafia will be added if they agree to it being public.
Also, the deceased (or at least those I did not forget to inform) had access to this thread: http://www.quicktopic.com/43/H/8PGVPZHEUxd

[TDC]

Actions

• Day 1:
  Nuwen (Rome) nightwatches: Annachie (Result: Yes)
  Ortolan (Mafia) jailkeeps: Cobalt
  Plum (Personal) kills: nhammen (Result: Bulletproof Vest used up)
  TheButtonmen (Masonry) tracks: Annachie (Result: Adel)
  Pyotr. C. Romanof (Florence) amn. tracks: nhammen to roflcopter (Result: Cobalt)*
  nhammen (Personal) investigates: Cobalt (Result: No Result)
  Phate (Personal) kills: Annachie (Result: Annachie dies)
  Annachie (Personal) bodyguards: Adel
  Phate (Napoli) protects: Socrates
  
  *Note: As nhammen's investigation failed due to Cobalt being jailkept and not due to nhammen being roleblocked he could still be tracked.
  
  
• Day 2:
  Socrates (Napoli) protects: Ellibereth
  Ellibereth (Masonry) watches: TheButtonmen (Result: Plum)
  Plum (Italian) kills: TheButtonmen (Result: TheButtonmen dies)
  Cobalt (Florence) invents Watcher for self and watches*: ortolan (Result: No Result)
  ortolan (Mafia) jailkeeps: Cobalt
  Nuwen (Rome) nightwatches: Ectomancer (Result: No Result)
  
  *Note: This was a mod error, as the the watcher could, in theory, neither be used on the same day, nor be given to oneself.
  
  
• Day 3:
  Cobalt (Florence) amn. tracks: Nuwen to DrippingGoofball (Result: No Result)
  ortolan (Mafia) jailkeeps: Ellibereth
  Ectomancer (Napoli) protects Ellibereth
  Ellibereth (Masonry) tracks elvis_knits (Result: No Result)
  
  
• Day 4:
  Ectomancer (Personal) kills: DrippingGoofball (Result: DrippingGoofball dies)
  Ellibereth (Palermo) watches: Ectomancer (Result: No Result)
  Ectomancer (Napoli) protects Ellibereth
  Cobalt (Florence) invents Watcher for self and watches* Ellibereth
  
  *Note: In an incredible act of stupidity I did not brief the neighborhood on the mistake SpyreX made (for which I do not blame him) and thus it happened again and I saw no choice than to accept the action as the deadline had already passed when I noticed it.
  
  
• Day 5:
  Ellibereth (Masonry) tracks: ortolan (Result: Ectomancer)
  Ectomancer (Napoli) protects: Ellibereth
  ortolan (Mafia) jailkeeps: Ectomancer
  Cobalt (Florence) amn. tracks: Ectomancer to Ellibereth (Result: No Result)
  
  
• Day 6:
  elvis_knits (Florence) invents Watcher for: Ellibereth (Result: Ellibereth receives Watcher)
  Ectomancer (Napoli) protects: Ellibereth
  Ellibereth (Masonry) watches: Ectomancer (Result: No Result)
  
  
• Day 7:
  Ellibereth (Personal) watches: Ectomancer (Result: Cobalt)
  Ellibereth (Masonry) tracks: elvis_knits (Result: No Result)
  Cobalt (Florence) amn. tracks: Ectomancer to Ellibereth (Result: Ellibereth)
  Ectomancer (Napoli) protects: Ellibereth
  
  
• Day 8:
  Cobalt (Florence) invents Watcher for: Ellibereth (Result: Ellibereth receives Watcher)
  Ellibereth (Masonry) watches: Cobalt. (Result: No Results)
  
  
• Day 9:
  Ectomancer (Personal) kills: Cobalt (Result: Cobalt dies)
  Ellibereth (Personal) watches: Ectomancer (Result: No Result)
  Ectomancer (Napoli) protects: Ellibereth
  Ellibereth (Masonry) tracks: Nicodemus (Result: No Result)

[TDC]

Now let me add a few things.

First off, I'm not too happy about how this went. In hindsight, I should've postponed the game until I was sure I could run it from start to end without having to load it off on SpyreX for two weeks. He was bound to oversee something and it happened. That said, I don't think that error (and it's continuation two days on) were particularly significant.

I did also not consider that there might come a phase where people just lynch and then want to end the day. The hastily drawn up 72 hour rule was probably far from optimal and made the game drag out unnecessarily. I figure 24 hours would've been enough.


Now, the setup.

1. The multilynch mechanic. One of the reviewers likened it to Lights Out, arguing that the town will play as fast as necessary to get as many lynches as it wants regardless of how short the deadlines are. I didn't really buy that, but I think that looking at D1 it is clearly the case. Getting those six lynches was certainly an advantage, especially so since the last one hit the most important member of the mafia team. Had Neopi stayed alive a bit longer, chances are Plum would've, too. Which brings me to

2. The swingyness. I'm prepared to accept whatever your verdict is and will admit that this game was rather on the swingy side. I think the scum team also just had a lot of bad luck though. As mentioned Neopi got drawn into the most important mafia spot and that certainly didn't help affairs. (In hindsight, I should've had higher entry bars for this game, Neopi should probably not have been in it in the first place).
Trying to get rid of one of the masons certainly was a bit of a risk and it happened to be the wrong one. (Also who knows what would've happened without ortolan's jailings of Cobalt and Ectomancer).

3. The masonry. As Xyl said during the review:

"You can either make something so simple that there are obviously no problems, or so complicated that there are no obvious problems."

The good news is I don't see any obvious problems with the setup.

The coincidence of a potential information gaining Mason having more or less direct access to a Doctor was missed, and if there's anything I would say is wrong with the setup itself, I'd say it's that. I suppose having the Miller Mason in there instead would've meant a bit more fun.

4. The mafia. Now much could be said here and I figure that the unfortunate turn of events of them that meant they lost their ability to kill in record time makes them look worse than they were equipped. It was the general plan of the game to have a rather large team (which with day talking is powerful in itself) and have them chose from a wide choice of actions. The mechanism of limited killing ability was a secondary thought that seemed to play well in limiting what would otherwise be a very powerful team. The second main idea was:

5. Having everyone in neighborhoods. Now, I figured if everyone was in neighborhoods and they had nothing to do there, there wouldn't be much reason to talk. So most of them received some sort or other of ability. But how would that impact balance? How much would scum in a neighborhood be able to influence what happened with the actions (clearly they would at least be aware of what happened (as long as alive), so investigative hood powers were going to be rather weak). I'm still not really sure about that. The doctor hood played an important role (see above), but that didn't have any scum in it. Anyway, the preceding and this point lead to much

6. Complexity. Arguably too much of it. It would probably have been better to make two or three setups out of this. I feel this had a detrimental impact on everyone's enjoyment.

I will take the fact that most everyone thought they were gonna lose for most of the game as a positive sign, though.

Anyway, I'd like to thank SpyreX for his backing up and all of you for playing and (for the most part) not needing replacement or for replacing in. If applicable, I hope you accept my apologies for what went wrong.

[TDC]

That sounds as if you think it would be less of a pro-town mechanic if quoting from it was allowed?
I think it's the other way around.