Past Ages Mafia - Game Over

[raider8169]

~Ahhhhhhhhh... I have to share with a male! ~

Vote: forbiddanlight

First name I recognized ^^

Maybe my second head is on to something,

Vote: forbiddanlight

[raider8169]

Get a room, relationship challenged heads!

Im sure they already have a room, the problem is that the rest of us are forced to be in said room with them.

[raider8169]

^ I think they are just playing around with eachother... not being serious

I would think that at first glance but I know ortolan and he is a serious guy. Am I right, ortolan?

I dont see how they were not playing around unless he was trying to say his second head was scum.

Not sure if scum partners are paired together or not but it would make sense if they are not as the portal just merged people together. Seemed to be more random then anything.

[raider8169]

Mod

, just to be sure, no guarantee that our 2nd head is same alignment?

[quote="KaleiÃ

[raider8169]

never mind. totally failed sexual innuendo.

Yeah, I dont see it.

[raider8169]

On the one hand, we cut our losses.

On the other, we're essentially giving scum a free NK and we have less info to work with the next day. :/

maybe so but with a no lynch we do not risk 2 possible townies.

[raider8169]

"odd" is a euphemism for scummy, you are suggesting there was something untoward about my action.

I don't agree with this.I think that when a lot of people say "Odd", they mean that itsweird but not scummy.

I agree, though I guess it can change depending on the context.

[raider8169]

I've never heard it put like that before. =P

I have heard British people use the term a few times before.

[raider8169]

I'm so very sick of these self-voting discussions.

Do you have something else you would rather discuss?

[raider8169]

I dont get it, why is it even a big deal to talk about no lynching. Yeah it may not be a good idea but I would like to consider it.

My thoughts behind it are that is we lynch someone 2 people die. Unless one of those 2 people are scum we would be hurting really bad from the start. A no lynch in hopes that tomorrow we are no longer 2 people.

Granted at night there could be alot more deaths but those would happen with or without a no lynch.

Further more lynches are most townies only way of killing but scum could easily have control of half the votes if their other head is not around.

I am not saying we must no lynch but it would be stupid, if not scummy, not to at least consider the idea.

[raider8169]

One thing I noticed is that a lot of people got on UROE's case for

suggesting

a No-Lynch, but no one thought it was odd or scummy that Santos actually voted for a No-Lynch? How is making a suggestion worse than making an action? Yah he unvoted... but maybe he was hoping more people would run with it?

You say that like it is a bad thing, he is entitled to his own opinion even if it can be overruled by his other head.

[raider8169]

That's interesting...

I don't think I play any differently when I replace in.

I understand the point, when you replace in your dont random vote do you? If all the games you start from scratch you random vote then that alone would be a different playing style. My example is a moot point but I hope the idea behind it is understood.

[raider8169]

BSG, did you need anything from me? Were we going to make a decision or just

no lynch

?

I dont think this has been decided or really even looked into much. At least not enough from what I would like. The interest on a possible no lynch is a handful of people but not enough to make it happen even if it was discussed.

[raider8169]

Im still here, sorry I am falling horribly behind. I will have something worthwhile up as soon as I can. I keep getting side track with other stuff.

[raider8169]

Sorry everyone, I was hoping to have time to catch up only I have been sick, my daughter plus work it making this hard. If anything is being held up my me I can request replacement.

One thing I wanted to know:

@Brandi-why do you still have a long standing vote without much of a case? I want to unvote but I would rather have that answered until I can get around to catching up.

[raider8169]

Ok Im working on catching up and just reread Slicey. I didnt see anything scummy about his posts. He had a typo about the lynch, no lynch thing but was talking about power roles a tad bit but nothing worth lynching.

I just reread Santos as well. I am not comfortable with a Santos lynch then slicey however I would need to reread everyone else first and then present a case. My goal is to be caught up this weekend as I am starting to get over the flu as well as the rest of my family.

[raider8169]

Im still here, not really happy with Slicey lynch and would rather have a no lynch instead at this point.

Also brandi voted for tajo a long time ago and it wasnt in the unofficial vote count

[raider8169]

Really now?

Weren't you one of the ones that boo'd the no lynch idea? (raider)

Nope I was one trying to push discussion of it. I thought it was scummy for people to not even discuss it. I got the impression that the general population thought it was bad.

[raider8169]

Prodded, will update soon. Still sick and I need to shovel out my driveway

Stupid snow storm.

[raider8169]

Can someone sum up the case on slicey? I dont see what makes him scummy.

[raider8169]

Raider, I've already posted it twice. Go through my post history.

Was hoping there was something more to it. I guess for a day one that is about as good as it gets but nothing about it screams scum to me. Just a bunch of minor tells.

[raider8169]

Vote Santos

[raider8169]

BSG how do you want to work this? In the other PA game they still voted and whatnot.

[raider8169]

anyway...i think that we should treat it as a normal lynch.

I agree, but really we have to base everything off what BSG wants. BSG has the final say and really the only say.

[raider8169]

I voted for URoE as well.

Same here, and I thought I was the only one. I can not complain about the choice though.

[raider8169]

Raider, I disagree about BSG doing what she wants. The power should be with the majority of the group. Of course she has the power to say otherwise, but I'd prefer playing this like a normal day. We don't know what kind of rules we'll have in future days, so when we have the chance to play a normal day, we should do it.

I agree, but my point is that unless BSG agrees as well it really means nothing. BSG can end the day at anytime and for whatever reason, as I didnt vote for BSG and she has not even posted yet today we really dont know how this is going to work out.

[raider8169]

IKWDT

What? I dont know what that means.

[raider8169]

In Slent Mafia, you never get to talk.

Really now?

The problem is, I would've rather had everyone checked in, even if we DID vote Santos to be lynched, then do what we did.

That day went by fast, I checked in first thing tossed a vote on Santos and then when I came back to check he was already lynched. I was not sure how the day would work out but that did seem too fast.

[raider8169]

There are two players who are just sitting wrong with me. And both of them are by most seen as pro-town.

Care to share?

Agreed, also anything you want to ask?

[raider8169]

Im still here, I would still like BSG to answer the questions addressed to her.

[raider8169]

Looks like we are getting far. Where the heck is BSG?

[raider8169]

Yeah, I want BSG to post?

Yeah, I think this is asking too much. And yet most people voted BSG?

[raider8169]

Wow.

Greetings WhereIsTony. You are deciding who dies today.

That an interesting welcome. Hi welcome to the game, you have only a couple days to read and pick someone to die. The whole game is riding on you. Good luck!

*This post will eslf-destruct in 10...9...8...*

[raider8169]

Also Greetings WhereIsTony, I suggest you kill whoever you would like to have sex with least, as no pictures of the vast majority of these people are online you must now decide whether you'd rather shag:

A Puppet
Homer Simpson
julienvonwolf (I presume that is him in the picture)
A girl looking left (her left)
A cockrel
A smurf
or Nibbler while he's graffiti-ing
(Just from this page)

Good look

I could change my pic to something do to with the raiders as I have elsewhere however it wasnt very mafia like.

[raider8169]

Hmmm, so where is this Tony?

[raider8169]

The last couple of days should be an easy read. Just a bunch of voting to everyone waiting today.

[raider8169]

Mod

I thought the hotel I am staying in would have wireless but I was wrong. I will be limited access this week.

[raider8169]

The no lynch discussion by him was somewhat scummy, but afterwards I think his intentions were not antitown, therefore my read on him is currently townie.

How was is somewhat scummy? I find to be the opposite, those not willing to discuss it was more scummy. Discussing anything is never a bad thing it only turns bad when someone starts acting on their idea unless it was decided it was a good idea.

[raider8169]

indeed odd.

Which part that the voted president needed to be replaced or the replaced president needs to be replaced?

Either way this is going to be either a no lynch or a random lynch.

[raider8169]

The extended deadline is tomorrow, Tony got any questions or anything?

[raider8169]

Because if this town was not smart town might be convinced that the different mechanics (D1) make it OK for them to no lynch, which is not true. So it could be a plan of the mafia, but I highly doubt that now.

Couple things on this. Discussing it is NEVER scummy. Acting upon it might be depending on the circumstances. In our case it would have been a good thing as we lynched 2 townies. Granted we were hoping one was scum but as it didnt happen we now know what would have been better. Reguardless I was the one that brought it up and I think it would have been a good idea. I wanted other people opinions on this. You say it is not true care, to explain this?

[raider8169]

Do you want another no lynch discussion? No, no lynch wouldn't be good even with these different mechanics, for the same reasons as in a normal game, but I say this only because I expected two people to be killed at night, like 2 people were lynched. Since this was not true, no lynch might have been an option, but as always: if you don't lynch scum won't die unless there's a really lucky/smart vig/bus driver/whatever.

Eh, doesnt bother me any. While I agree with to a point though. No lynch is the only way to kill scum but when everyone is unsure it can be beneficial as the first day rarely hits scum. Though it does happen its much more common to hit town. Im sure someone has stats on it. Not that it matters much as in normal games a lynch it normally the best move.

At least this gives us something to talk about while we wait on Tony to let the deadline run out.

[raider8169]

So, yesterday was the deadline.

Yeah, cant say it surprised me any to know that our pres bailed on us. His name is very fitting at the moment.

[raider8169]

Not sure I understand how this works? Does only one person get the opportunity to blow themselves up?

If so we should vote on who it is, imo, and threaten them getting blown up by someone else if they fail to comply (and specify the second person for them to kill).

I am not sure if that will work as anyone can take it upon themselves to blow someone up and what happens if no one wants to do it?

[raider8169]

Killing lurkers never helps out town unless we just get lucky and they happen to be scum. At this point the changes should be about still.

[raider8169]

Ah, I guess it means look right?

Why, Max?
Its not our best move, I'll admit that, but what makes it so scummy in everyone's eyes?

1. We have 13 players. Its not like we are near LyLo.
2. Lurker's become more of a liability, the fewer players are left.

Julien was right in saying replacements are better, but he is the only one to actually give a reason so far.

How do you know we are not near LyLo? We have yet to kill any scum so and all we have is a huge list of dead townies.

[raider8169]

I invite opinions from all.

If you are willing to do it, I think it would be best for you to pick the target on your own accord. Looking more at the ones everyone else thinks would be good targets but remember a vocal scum can persuade the entire group.

[raider8169]

JVW lights his Dynamite

Yup, now you just have to wait 24 hours before you can use it. From talking with the mod you need will need to use it before like a week or so otherwise it will just explode. I asked the mod because I was just going to light mine if today was not going to progress.

[raider8169]

nobody else has any opinions?

marathon day is distracting. I'll reread today or tomorrow for reals and see what I come up with, not that it precisely matters today. Getting up to date will help in future days though, I'd think.

I didnt know you were in this game. Lurking much?

[raider8169]

Wow Shadowgirl you had surgery too? I guess I really haven't been paying attention. I DID have my jaw cut into, but getting my wisdom teeth out probably isn't as bad as what you have gone through... God I hope you feel better soon.

I enjoyed having my wisdom teeth removed. It was three days off of work for me for a little discomfort. It was more annoying for me as the drugs they gave me worked well.

[raider8169]

Remember Empking lit his too and I doubt he is going to wait very long.

Are you trying to rush him into blowing someone up?

[raider8169]

Im tempted to light mine and join in on the fun, its not often I get a role where I can kill someone.

[raider8169]

Kaboom!

I was getting ready to light mine too.

[raider8169]

Why Budja?

[raider8169]

Pics allowed?

[raider8169]

Try agian

[raider8169]

he knows^

Ort true?

[raider8169]

he knows^

Vote Brandi

[raider8169]

no PR's.

Why suspect?

Orts claim?

[raider8169]

unguaranteed sanity

Yesterday's investigation?

[raider8169]

have PR?

Outguessing mod?

[raider8169]

No Pr's

[raider8169]

outguessing mod

[raider8169]

Everyone else

[raider8169]

may think

[raider8169]

no PR's

[raider8169]

that is

[raider8169]

outguessing mod

[raider8169]

I sane?

Yesterday's results?

[raider8169]

Vote Brandi

More please

[raider8169]

More please

Why?

Post 843ish...

[raider8169]

More please

Why?

Post 843ish...

Budja post...?

Reread Brandi

[raider8169]

KMD, FL,

She put

[raider8169]

words in

[raider8169]

Ort's mouth.

[raider8169]

Post 843

[raider8169]

Dont understand

[raider8169]

Brandi voted

[raider8169]

for something

[raider8169]

Ort didnt

[raider8169]

say but

[raider8169]

she said

[raider8169]

he did

[raider8169]

was fine.

I disagree

[raider8169]

Quick lyncher

[raider8169]

Vote Brandi

More please

Quick Lyncher.

Took that

[raider8169]

to get

[raider8169]

your attention

[raider8169]

post something

How can

[raider8169]

this be

[raider8169]

forced?

[raider8169]

Yesterday.

Mass prod

[raider8169]

Or FL.

Why FL?

[raider8169]

here

Good point

[raider8169]

Problem though

[raider8169]

he plays

[raider8169]

same for

[raider8169]

both sides

[raider8169]

more absent

You're right

[raider8169]

Vote K7

[raider8169]

Vote Count?

[raider8169]

vote: k7

1st post

[raider8169]

someone lynch

[raider8169]

k7 please

[raider8169]

agree, like

Read his

[raider8169]

past games

[raider8169]

plus I'm

[raider8169]

sick of

[raider8169]

post restriction

[raider8169]

was in?

Correct