Animals Upick [Game Over]

[Conspire]

Claiming

Mafia Mason

. We will be siding with the town this time around.

VOTE: Birds and the Boys Happy with this lynch, they haven't done enough for me.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

You are loved, Holden.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

Aren't you that same Penguin from Madagascar?

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

You can't just graciously accept my validation and not dish some back at me.

Compliment my vast array of skills.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

I don't buy it. You must be in the scum PT and had someone tell you.

Is it bad I thought your donkey was a dog?

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

Votecount 1.2

Birds and the Boys(3)

~ PenguinPower(8), Calvin and Hobbes(1), Conspire(3)

votato(1)

~ HoldenGolden(3)

Blatant Scum(1)

~ votato(2)


Not Voting (12): jjh927(0), farside22(2), mastina(0), chemist1422(1), Birds and the Boys(0), Bingle(0), Clover Ebi(0), Dunnstral(0), Blatant Scum(0), April Ludgate(0), Dr Easy Bake(0), Creature(0)

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Day 1 deadline is in (expired on 2020-05-11 11:45:27)

Gonna try my hand at some VCA here. We have an early wagon on

Birds and the Boys

, but there seems to be some

Resistance

with counterwagons developing on

votato

and

Blatant Scum

.

If

Birds and Boys

flips scum, we should be looking into

HoldenGolden

and

votato

as poential suspects.

Also worth noting is that

Conspire

was the 3rd vote on the wagon, which makes them slightly more likely to be bussers. However, I know we are town which means the busser must be in {

PenguinPower, Calvin and Hobbes

}.

Birds and the Boys + PenguinPower/Calvin and Hobbes + HoldenGolden/votato

is my initial

Solve

.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

Claiming

Mafia Mason

. We will be siding with the town this time around.

VOTE: Birds and the Boys Happy with this lynch, they haven't done enough for me.

-Cosmic

This is not a thing that would ever happen.

This must be scum, I shall appraise the high majesty of your execution at once!

~April

VOTE: Conspire

Why the hesitation with the vote, April?

Were you

Scared

, or afraid to vote someone you knew was

Town

?

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

PenguinPower speaks the

Truth

.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

I don’t think it’s possible for me to be happy except for when I am scared. Or someone else is in extreme pain.

~April

This makes sense. Thank you for your

Time

. Please inform me of your biggest fear so that I can help make you happy.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: Birds and Boys

This is the

Turning Point

of the Birds and Boys wagon. It is looking more and more likely that this lynch will go through, so votes following this one should be looked at under a bus driver's magnifying glass.

VOTE: votato

I shall now bolster a counterwagon to see if any scum take the

Bait

.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

Shame.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

We have been

Banned

and are therefore unable to hear your accusations.

-Cosmic

[Conspire]

We have been

Banned

and are therefore unable to hear your accusations.

-Cosmic

This is absurdity.

Why would I need you, the accused, to hear the accusatory remarks. They are not for you. Do not think otherwise

~Ludgate

If I was

Unbanned

and able to hear what you were saying, I would tell you:

No.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Great news, everyone: We have been

Unbanned

.

We have been

Banned

and are therefore unable to hear your accusations.

-Cosmic

This is absurdity.

Why would I need you, the accused, to hear the accusatory remarks. They are not for you. Do not think otherwise

~Ludgate

If I was

Unbanned

and able to hear what you were saying, I would tell you:

No.

~Cosmic

Let’s start a war between the tilde users and the dash users!

~April

This is a form of buddying.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I shall

Sheep

the

Donkey

.

VOTE: April

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

This is a fair point, Holden.

VOTE: Blatant Scum

I noticed your Miller crumb.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I noticed your Miller crumb.

Where is it?

Are both

miller

claims hardclaims?

And you thought you could get away with it.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Don't claim flavours. Some roles can target only certain flavours.

You willingly give us this information about your

Role

? This is very kind of you! But I must ask: why?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

A fair point,

Blatant Scum

!

Please elaborate,

April

.

VOTE: April

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

A fair point,

Blatant Scum

!

Please elaborate,

April

.

VOTE: April

~Cosmic

Do you really w anna elaboration on that? The vote at that point in time is extremely interesting to me.

Interesting how? Has your scumread on us from the beggining of RVS been serious or in jest?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

April is

Mean

. Blatant Scum may be

Town

.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Does Donkey Kong count as a dinosaur?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I rate this image 12/17.

My favourite dinosaurs:

5) King Bob-omb
4) Jurassic Park
3) TrueSoulEnergy
2) Yoshi
1) JJH

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Conspire, list your favourite dinosaurs or I tell everyone who esper is

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

No one knows who I am either...

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Conspire, list your favourite dinosaurs or I tell everyone who esper is

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

No one knows who I am either...

~Cosmic

I feel like I made it clearly obvious I did

Oh, I get it now...

Fine,

2

people know. This is acceptable.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: HoldenGolden

I shall

Sheep

the

April

.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I’m pretty sure I knew both of you at some point because of modding, but can’t be bothered to check. As such, I have decided you are MathDino and Ellibereth and will be held to the appropriate standard. You have 20 minutes to catch the scumteam.

I only needed 5:

Clover Ebi + votato + HoldenGolden + Creature

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I'm glad you're assuming your guess is wrong because I'm not the other party. Conspire is and it would be rude for me to confirm or deny anything

Clearly, there is no "

N

" in Cosmic or Esper. The guess is incorrect.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I'm glad you're assuming your guess is wrong because I'm not the other party. Conspire is and it would be rude for me to confirm or deny anything

Clearly, there is no "

N

" in Cosmic or Esper. The guess is incorrect.

~Cosmic

Is there a z?

Sure, Esper likes to sign as Esperz sometimes.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Its that thingy from Ice age

Scatch I think?

Why aren't you

Claiming

?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: HoldenGolden

too late

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: votato

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: votato

~Cosmic

pedit: hint I don't

You know you wanna hop on. We could get everyone to claim by the end of today.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: votato

~Cosmic

UNVOTE:

we get a claim and immediately unvote? lynch this now. since im confirmed scum and conspire is voting me, conspire must be town. so VOTE: bingle

It's a provable claim. A special kind of claim. The kind of claim you dream about. I hope you have such a claim.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Day Heal: votato

Not so fast. Let's allow him to spew his buddies first.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Day Force Commute: votato

Yeah, I don't think so, Calvin.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

JJH is confirmed town. We had a pregame check on him. Esper will be able to confirm this.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Conspire and I are Masons btw

-Calvin

You didn't need to out that already...

It's alright though, I have wizardy fiendish powers that can protect and keep you alive.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Ah,

And conspire I can give you a better way to invest him as I am 1 shot gunsmith. I only am able to gift it to the "Hot Wheels" animal group though.

We're a

Hot Wheel

! We'll take it.

Spoiler:

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Wow this game drastically slowed down once the Votato wagon picked up. That’s probably scum indicative.

Who was on Holden, but not Votato?

People just can't handle the heat of my glorious 1 shot confused tracker miller claim

Yeah, I think scum got scared you’d shoot at them because you just random claimed tbh

But he'd lose his shot if he was dead.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Penguin, Conspire, and I are a town block.

We are Penguin. We are Cosmic. We are Power. Time Is Money, Money Is Power, Power Is Pizza, Pizza is Knowledge.

We are the Cosmic Penguins.

Do you accept this invitation to become a Cosmic Penguin?

To: April
From: Cosmic

Spoiler:

March April,

Does being a Penguin come with Power? If so, I'm in!

Love,
Cosmic

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I hereby declare mafblack as the Cosmic Penguin's national theme. Team Leapord Seal use mafTigers

shudder

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I may be

Naive

but Creature's happiness at rolling town feels genuine.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Why aren't we lynching Birds and Boys? They

Scumclaimed

????

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Can I call you "Misty", Chemist1422? I think that would be a nice nickname for you.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Why aren't we lynching Birds and Boys? They

Scumclaimed

????

~Cosmic

And? I scumclaim in every other game.

Why haven't you done it this game? Do you only do it as

Town

?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Why aren't we lynching Birds and Boys? They

Scumclaimed

????

~Cosmic

Put your money where your mouth is?

-turducken

No need. We'll leave you alive until Day 4 under the pretense of thinking you're town.

On an unrelated note; who are your top 3 scumreads?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

The more this game goes on the more I realized there were better picks I could of done

Cosmic is slowly revealing more and more who they are by the moment. They should just name claim

Don't you dare. Our identities are a well-guarded secret. This discussion is incredibly anti-town and should stop immediately.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

@Krazy:

Please give HoldenGolden a confused miller JOAT strongman 0-shot Quack Doctor Ability please. Thanks.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

The game has

Died

. This means the current wagon on votato is a scum one, and the scum are hoping we grow distracted and naturally move to other wagons.

I recommend a counterwagon to give scum the opportunity to

Hop

onto the opposing wagon, so that we can find votato's buddies.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

hey heres an idea: why dont we wagon someone else? that votato guy really comes off as town to me.

Who would you propose? Lead the charge.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Thanks!

What makes you think this is a RVS wagon rather than serious one?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Esper checking in o/
I skimmed through the first half of the game and am liking jjh (as a person). Will be back to read the rest/play tomorrow!

~Esper

[Conspire]

Intent to Hammer.

It's now or never, votato.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I don't get it. What does that do?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

farside, are you saying you're not 100% sure the pic was a joke?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Ill just play in my own little world.
VOTE: dunnstral

*adds birds to scum list*

Do you disagree with bitmap disliking Bla's recent posts, or is the dunk into the scumlist for other reasons?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

@Cosmic Penguins: I kinda get townvibes from Bla. The way he was taking things very seriously/at face value and informed everyone that we shouldn't state type of animal while everyone was RVSing around him was maybe townie.

Alrighty, then. Can't break anything with pressuring people.
VOTE: Blatant Scum

That said, why self-vote here, Bla? What's to be gained?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

fine. I'm a town night 1-3 combined janitor-doctor watcher.

What does this

Mean

??

VOTE: blatant scum

ok. if you cant/wont help, why keep you around?

Justification here is

Dodgy

. Are you voting him because you think he's useless or because he's scum?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Blatant Scum is one of the

Old Greats

. He would single-handedly carry town in heavily scumsided setups back in the day. Those days, scum were garbage, so most games started in LyLo with 4 scum, 5 town setups being the norm.

Without Bla on your team, winrates were fair at 50/50. With him as town, it was 90/10 in town's favour.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Are you saying you did it to try and make us think you're town?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Are you saying you did it to try and make us think you're town?

~Cosmic

Or to make you think that I am scum. You will never know.

Well, I had a theory you were starting a wagon on yourself to get reads/reactions, but if you claim you're just doing it because you want to create WIFOM as town, I might have to

Rethink

some stuff, Bla.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I am

Scared

of Dr Easy Bake.

votato, could you paraphrase the role description in your PM? Does it explain the modifiers seperately, or together?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I agree that farside is towny.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Oh, I didn't realise that was hammer. He was scum...

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

votato, could you paraphrase the role description in your PM? Does it explain the modifiers seperately, or together?

~Cosmic

Answer this when you can, votato!

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Dr Easy Baker feels townish because of his no fear accusing/solving. I promise this isn't a

OMGUR

.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Pagetop.

Interesting

Pagetop

from Blatant Scum here. He included a full stop which might indicate he cares a little more about the

Presentation

of his posts. Could be scum-indicative.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Is this a meta read or just the fact he hasn't posted content so far?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Will

Catch Up

later. It better not still be Day 1, surely we should be on Day 3 or 4 by now.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I'm

Back

. What'd I miss from the last 20 pages?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Thanks for the

Catch Up

. I kinda want to see this glitch in the matrix though.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I'm not sure if I mentioned this before, but I found Forebronger's excessive confidence in Misty!scum to be pretty scummy. Where's he at with that read now?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

votato, you strongly townread Birds, who you think you are town and are defending you, but don't townread April as highly, because you're afraid she may be buddying you. What's different about them?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Quality

interaction tbh.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Both conspire and C&H are lurking, and every time conspire appears it seems to be to try and get my wagon going again. because its lingered so long, and because the people on it seem to have tunneled so hard, i feel like theres gotta be at least one, probably two scum pushing my wagon, so in {BS, conspire, PP, (C&H)}.

My reasons for thinking you're scum are:

• Early awkwardness that could be scum not sure what to do.
  
• Your claim, and not knowing what the role does, despite the fact it should be explained in the role PM.

I'm gonna go ISO April to see why she thinks you're town.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Alright, so votato is a watcher that will heal the "janitor" part of a kill of the person he watches, correct? So, Player Y gets nightkilled and janitored, votato will see Player SCUM visit Y, and Y will flip the next day due to votato's janitor "heal". Correct me if I'm misinterpreting that.

April is implying she can kill and her kill comes attached with a janitor ability, so should be able to clear votato, since it doesn't really make any sense for votato to have a janitor-heal as scum. If they're both scum, this is a 77,108 IQ move, but that's

probably

not the case.

I agree we should lynch someone else if my assumptions above are correct.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

who to sheep, who to sheep

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Ah, so I didn't understand how that worked at all lol. I understand now though.

for now VOTE: Birds and the Boys

shrog

The Misty push early on pinged me.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

So, Bingle was killed without flpping basically?

votato should claim what he did/results before April does.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: votato

Nice! I guess votato knew he was caught and was just assigned the kill.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Coward.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I have NEWS.

Also, did everyone get that 1-shot janitor message then?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I recieved a message in the night, but I don't really get the motivations behind it if I'm being honest. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I've been told someone is town, and that I should out this information at some point today.

Now, if I'm being messaged by some kind of hybrid odd-night cop, even-night mailman, then why do they want me to out their inno straight away? Surely, that paints a target on the person's back to be nightkilled.

And I'm obviously not going to claim it as an inno of my own, since I have no reason to completely trust them, and then there'll be questions into my role/why I lied in future.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Should I out the person???

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Should I out the person???

~Cosmic

You received a mailman saying that someone in particular was town?

- turducken

Yep. Get contrasting opinions here.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

*getting

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Should I out the person???

~Cosmic

You received a mailman saying that someone in particular was town?

- turducken

Yep. Get contrasting opinions here.

~Cosmic

if it is not pp, holden, chemist, clover, us, mastina, you should claim it

- turducken

Alright, fine:

They say Dunnstral is town.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

It was an anonymous message from a player. Wasn't a very long one either, they didn't even include an pleasentries of well wishes. Kinda rude if you ask me.

It just said Dunnstral is town, they would rather not out it themselves, ideally we should out it at some point tomorrow.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

V/LA until Wednesday

[Conspire]

Both conspire and C&H are lurking, and every time conspire appears it seems to be to try and get my wagon going again. because its lingered so long, and because the people on it seem to have tunneled so hard, i feel like theres gotta be at least one, probably two scum pushing my wagon, so in {BS, conspire, PP, (C&H)}.

Calvin's dead. Penpow's gotta be town. Bla could be scum off of this unless he's actually just listed all town slots.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

By the way, now that I'm reminded:

Why didn't you post at deadline, Conspire?

What do you mean?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Interesting how despite shading Dunny for most the game, votato's only on him briefly after being asked why he isn't voting him, and then moves of him shortly after because "the wagon isn't gaining momentum" (3 votes) and then moves to a smaller wagon (farside on 2 votes).

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I've not been scumreading PP since I looked at his iso again when he told me to and especially now he's made things more explicitly clear.

I'm still pretty confident on Farside but w/e

VOTE: Dunn

lets do it! VOTE: dunnstral

Actually, this later is a better look for Dunny.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

because i read the thread

me too.
This whole thing reads as one big rvs. People talking about wagons, people voting and creating wagons. People trying to out alts.
I actually wanted out when I saw this player list because they play a lot differently and I have no clue how to scum hunt with the nonsense I see in here.

lucky for you you rolled scum so now you get to stay and "hunt" which is pretty easy.

HmM

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I'm here to vote too btw

VOTE: dr easy bake

Hey, Misty. Why didn't you vote for the votato or any other wagon in the first post, and only joined the Baker wagon in the second after some others swung to him? Did you have any reads on the wagonees at the time?

I like DEB's catchup

It's just game-related enough to hit that sweet spot where the thoughts look stream of consciousness without looking forced or disconnected

Also, what changed your mind.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Ah right, I forgot Bla was dead, farside.

By the way, now that I'm reminded:

Why didn't you post at deadline, Conspire?

What do you mean?

~Cosmic

You were active onsite at deadline but did not post here.

Forgot it was deadline, was more invested elsewhere I suppose.

Who do you want to vote, Conspire?

Misty based on what I've seen.

VOTE: Misty

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Stuff in 2160, and not finding anything towny from his ISO.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Helloooooooo

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

we are an activatable double voter so chem is functionally at l-1 right now

claim time chemmy boy

- turducken

Odd cop/Even messenger

Got an inno on Dunn n1 then sent it to Conspire n2

D:

Sorry for pushing you, Misty.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

See my post to Clover about Conspire. They haven't done anything today and I find that suspicious. I also do not think they have done anything really townie all game.

What about our interactions with votato? Looking back, I kinda think those are hardly ever SvS tbh.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I'm thinking about where I want to move it. What'd you think?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Who made the JJH case that I can read?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

VOTE: birds and the boys

Only person I could honestly say has felt scummy from the current players. I've missed a lot of content though.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Right now I haven't a clue tbh

I like the idea of one of birds/conspire, probably leaning on conspire there because they're playing a different game from the boon upick
But I'm still a bit lost

This might be town-indicative considering this comes while we're actively debating who to vote. Maybe.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Fire's early forced push on someone and feeling a lot less playful than his townself. Gobsie felt a little off, and Oka's just been not in it this game?

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Sigh, I've just missed the last 50 pages of the game. Maybe this isn't a good idea.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Alright, don't worry everyone. I have a solution.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

The Cosmic Penguins can LIVE ON forever. They'll always be in our hearts.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

o7

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

Great game. One of my favorites, I think.

@PenguinPower - Was the thing you were laughing at the fact that I never bus?

I made it blatantly obvious to Penguin who I was Day 1, and I believe Bingle knew. Not sure if Conspire did, or who else. Miss Lynch probably figured it out.

Yeah, I figured it out. Very well played.

~Cosmic

[Conspire]

I wasn't 100% sure though. Your "rawr"s and the way you acted at times were nothing like any of your other games, so it was a good performance lul

~Cosmic