Loser Mafia (Game Over)

[dahill1]

/confirm

[dahill1]

i think that was a mistake..

Lynches are compulsory.

[dahill1]

vote armlx

is there any strategy anyone has for this kind of game?

[dahill1]

Dahill is scum, don't vote him.

(I've been waiting for a long time to say this.)

Also, Pokerface is friendly; perfect person to be lynching.

care to elaborate?

[dahill1]

I believe you were asking a question, therefore phising for someone to tell you what to do, in which case you would then proceed with that plan. If anything went wrong, you could fall back on whoever told you what to do next.

Which makes you scummy, and means we can't vote you. Ever.

This game will be the greatest fun I've ever had.

okay i can see how you would think that
but this is what it really was.."hmm i don't know how one would go about playing this type of game. i'll ask for suggestions to see if anyone has any good ones."

[dahill1]

Figure it out, learn something new, if you don't keep up, we'll lynch you!

well you could've just said that in the first place!

unvote vote the jester

because he seems to be scum hunting sincerely

[dahill1]

vote:dahill1

obviously a clueless noob!

In the basic framework of mafia we find scum by tells and observations of behaviour, I am guessing this still aplies but in its very own unique wierd and wonderful way!

not "obviously a clueless noob" because the basic framework of mafia applies differently to this game. plus, why would you vote for me? is being a clueless noob enough for a vote (basically you saying you think i'm town)?
i'm not going to vote you from now on

[dahill1]

Like he did NOT want to be lynched.

that defeats the purpose of the game because basically both sides want to get lynched. as for me "over-defensiveness", i think that's just what i naturally do in any game when one accuses me.

[dahill1]

Like he did NOT want to be lynched.

that defeats the purpose of the game because basically both sides want to get lynched. as for me "over-defensiveness", i think that's just what i naturally do in any game when one accuses me.

Yeah, but the thing here is that the only thing someone is accusing you of being is a TOWNIE. And, generally, most people do not get that defensive if they are a townie when someone accuses them of being a Mafia.

Mkay, let me lay out my logic, I am seeing how confusing it is right now.

1. I am presuming Dahill1 is slightly noobish.

2. I am presuming that it is natural for someone who is Mafia (in a regular game) to be over defensive when they are accused.

3. I am therefore presuming that, since Dahill1 got over defensive when he was "accused", that it is his regular game Mafia instincts coming out, thinking that getting voted is a bad thing, etc. etc.

4. Therefore, I presume he is Mafia. No other reason why Mafia instincts like that would come out.

ooh i thought you meant i was defensive with the jester.
TVOD is a whole other story. i was attacking him for voting me. i wasn't being defensive. it was strange that he would vote for me and i saw no reason why he would so i called him out on it

[dahill1]

unvote vote zombieslayer

Policy Quicklynch. JD?

Behold. The one time that I will NOT get angry at FlameAxe or JDodge for quicklynching/bandwagoning me.

I should savour this moment.

Ok, Dahill, why are you attacking someone for VOTING you? The point of this game is to GET voted.

people were accusing me of being scummy
i can understand if TVOD was random voting me, but why would you vote for the person who is apparently scummy? if i were him, my vote wouldn't go on me at this moment in the game

[dahill1]

i know that...
and no that is not true
the jester called me scummy and said he planned on not voting me. others voted jester (they thought he was town) then, TVOD voted me immediately after. i thought it was scummy for him to vote for me after the jester planned to not vote for me, and others somewhat agreed by voting the jester

[dahill1]

Ok...

How is it scummy to vote someone after someone else said they were scummy?

Maybe TVOD disagrees with Jester? Ever consider that?

yes, but even if he thinks i am a "clueless noob" doesn't mean i am automatically town

[dahill1]

well, let's just ask TVOD
TVOD, 1) do you think i'm scummy or not scummy?
2) why?

[dahill1]

ok, my main point is "I thought it was weird that TVOD voted for me after there was some suspicion of me."

[dahill1]

And this looks funny somehow cause it looks like you are saying you consider yourself looking scummy at the moment, and that you wouldn't vote yourself. Kinda sounds like you are saying you think you are scum.

i knew that would come out weird, but i'm saying that even though i know i'm town, if i were in his shoes i could seem scummy

[dahill1]

Ok, do NOT lynch helpful players, people. It may seem that they are town, but...

1. They may be Mafia being as helpful as possible to seem town.

2. If they ARE actually helpful town, why lynch them now? They should be the last ones to be lynched, so that they can help is through the game.

Unless we can talk after we are dead, of course.

i can understand this, but how should we decide who to lynch then?

[dahill1]

unvote

because there are starting to look like better lynch candidates then the jester

[dahill1]

If both these players turn up town, I think it would be fair to level charges against Jester and myself for bus'ing townies, and we should be next on the chopping block. Just trying to be objective here.

well any alignment could bus townies

[dahill1]

well PF's last post settles it

vote Pokerface

[dahill1]

unvote

- PokerFace is TOO useful. Given that we had leveled serious charges of being useful earlier on, a normal response would have been to correct this behavior, and become chaotic and useless. However, PF sank himself further when trying to find order and try to come up with a strategy. It's obvious that he wants to be lynched. I will not be a party to it.

haha "too townie" actually makes sense in this game

[dahill1]

dahills attack of PF

wha?
i voted for him because i think he's town

[dahill1]

dahills attack of PF

wha?
i voted for him because i think he's town

Yet even as a fairly confirmed townie, he is useful alive. We don't have to lynch him today, its not like normal mafia where if the lynch targets live longer town loses more people.

DGB's sea of WIFOM bothers me more than the Jester's anti-bussing, but neither should be lynched any time soon.

ok good point

unvote

but i would hardly call that attacking him

[dahill1]

Right. But we should be lynching people who appear to be town. So as to avoid lynching the jesters. Not scummy people. Those people we should not lynch.

Normally a good townie tries to act townie. In this game, a good townie tries to act scummy. Acting "townie" is, well, anti-town.

well how do we know that the person isn't scum acting scummy

[dahill1]

i'm starting to agree with random bandwagoning because of all this confusion
as someone said before (i think nocmen) we have 11/13 chance of getting town
i say we have someone roll the die and if we all agree on it, then we lynch that person

[dahill1]

unvote vote Shy Guy

LAHP

[dahill1]

vote ZombieSlayer

[dahill1]

i won't vote either of you, just to play it safe

[dahill1]

vote flameaxe

[dahill1]

wow this game moves like a bullet train. Sorry I have been a little neglectful as of late here. quick lynches have seemed to be working out for us very well so far so I see no reason for not lynching BBM today.
Jester is still my biggest scum suspect so would like to keep him around till end game closely followed by armix.
Will leave the hammer vote of as a chance to let everyone check in before nigfht.

TVOD and Jester are scum
also, unless people want more discussion (which i'm fine with) then we should =====[]

[dahill1]

Ahahahaha! (In pain)

it's funny cuz it's true

[dahill1]

Ok so I have a good feeling that if jester is scum and a lot of people have picked up on this then dahill or amix would most likely be his partner.

why?

But if Jester is not scum (slight possibility) I would certainly go for a dahill armix pair.

(see above)

[dahill1]

i'm thinking either TSN or armlx today

[dahill1]

TSN is the better lynch IMO, but basically just vote for whoever you think has contributed the least to the town's progress to far yet still has exhibited a large amount pro-town behavior.

vote TSN

IGMEOY: armlx, but in a good way
as in i plan on lynching you next

[dahill1]

(unless its intentional, see if SL is posting in other games).

it is definitely intentionally, he has been active otherwise

[dahill1]

I am never playing a game with

armlx or

The Jester again.

fixed for me