Pikmin Mafia - Game over

[skitzer]

/conform.

[skitzer]

I don't think everyone is a Pikmin. If you've ever played or read something about Pikmin, you'll know that their enemies are very creative. Excluding that would be almost rude to the nature of this game.

Also, the story does not completely confirm that all players are pikmin. It could be possible these enemies are hidden in the storage of the ship, possibily.

[skitzer]

In the game, Pikmin are usually peaceful creatures. Of course I guess maybe you might want to look at some pikmin stuff, Greasy Spot.

[skitzer]

Well I don't know anything about the Game of Pikmin, the movie, or whatever it is. All I know is my pm tells me I am a Pikmin. I assumed everybody was a Pikmin, just that some were bad Pikmin.

Can you say what kind of pikmin you are?

*cough*rolefishing*cough*

[skitzer]

That confuses me...

[skitzer]

Does anyone know why the votes to lynch is only 8?

I thought this was interesting.

[skitzer]

See, I told you the low majority lynch wasn't a joke...

[skitzer]

I would like you to explain your vote on me.

Vote: Shin Hatsubai

for now. Your semi-rolefishing still makes me a little wary...

I might read through and place more votes later.

[skitzer]

I just wanted to clarify that I was correct in my assumption. I feel a more proper use of the "I told you so" scum tell is when someone says, for example, in a game where the doctor just got nked, "See, I told you the doctor was going to get killed!"

[skitzer]

I am enthused by pictures.

The semantics discussion might not be valid, but it gives us a starting point. Let's talk.

[skitzer]

Yay: Another thing discuss: PyroDwarf is on the top three Bandwagons, and he want's us to lynch one of them. Let's Talk.

discussion topics

Greasy Spot's semantics
Pyro Dwarf's bandwagons
mikeburnfire's pretty pictures

[skitzer]

Vote: JamesThePhox for the above, + other vibes. I just don't see a townie thinking that way.

I think townies, or any town faction role, have to look at all possibilities. You can't blame someone for trying to help the town figure out roles.

[skitzer]

Unvote Claus

until we get further reads on him.

[skitzer]

Sonickid's post before leaving sounds like a mild defense of Greasy Spot.

Vote: Sonickid

I want to lynch GS as well, but I'm wating fro a claim.

[skitzer]

OK, my vote is on Sonickid for a defense of Greasy Spot, so

vote: Greasy Spot

Oh, and here is another thing. This is the vote total for the top three lynches, including my vote for greasy spot:

Kison has votes on all three top bandwagons.
Gorrad, Pyrodwarf, hasdgfas, and windkirby have votes on two. Note that gorrad is one of the top bandwagons.

Everyone else has either 1 or 0 votes in te top three.

Just thought this information would be helpful.

FoS: Kison, Gorrad

[skitzer]

unvote: Greasy Spot

I'd rather see a sonickid lynch, like I said before.

[skitzer]

Unvote, vote Greasy Spot

The reason I voted sonickid was because he defended Greasy Spot. That is why I am changing votes.

[skitzer]

just to note, before Greasy Spot voted, on previous votecounts he didn't have a vote, even on himself, but that should be fixed.

Also, a comment on why GS is a better lynch than Gorrad: I would be voting for Gorrad, if he hadn't been so blunt is his claim. I might look closer at him tonight.

[skitzer]

Oh, right. But still, why would someone say that?

[skitzer]

Oh, I guess I didn't see it.

In other news...Greasy Spot is much more convincing to me than JamesThePhox. He has slipped out of so many things. Coincidental that his name is Greasy Spot.

[skitzer]

Me sorry. Still very confident with the GS vote. But all these replacements aren't any help.

[skitzer]

Well, Sonickid defended Greasy Spot, and Sonickid turned out to be anti-town, so I figure Greasy Spot is probably ant-town as well.

[skitzer]

He first defends GS on the second day, when he wonders about why we're still hanging on the "you pikmin" issue, then, he does this strange thing in his final post in which he casts suspicion on Gorrad (a top lynch candidate of Day 2), then he says GS isn't scummy, and then he casts suspicion on JamesThePhox, who was appearing more scummy to others.

I think, that is reason enough.

[skitzer]

Yes, but the fact that he defended you and turned out to be mafia is quite proving...

[skitzer]

A little late, but is there a reason for a Kison lynch?

[skitzer]

You make a good point, Claus, but I'm still more convinced on the Greasy Spot case. Although it looks like we are heading towards a JTP or windkirby lynch.

[skitzer]

guys, watch out! windkirby has a tendency of using incredibly good wifom to mislead the town into a mislynch. Those probably aren't his real partners.

But, yeah,

unvote, vote windkirby

[skitzer]

Vote: Greasy Spot

And yes, I'm fine with the color claim.

[skitzer]

Blue.

[skitzer]

Vote: Greasy Spot

[skitzer]

Unvote, vote Greasy Spot

The reason I voted sonickid was because he defended Greasy Spot. That is why I am changing votes.

Vote: Greasy Spot

And yes, I'm fine with the color claim.

Oh, this is just the third day I've been voting you, I'm sorry if I haven't given enough reasoning.

[skitzer]

Mod: dcorbe has not been on the site for quite a while. He needed replacement in my game, so maybe you should look for a replacement.

I'm still pretty content with my vote. Purple Pikmin are strong, so whatever the Purple Pikmin's ability is (if they have one) is likely to be strong. I don't think there would be two in a game.

[skitzer]

What makes Greasy Spot easier to lynch than others? I think he has been incredibly dodging lynches so I wouldn't call him easy.

[skitzer]

armlx: I'm just amazed that I've been voting Greasy Spot every day now, and some people have actually agreed with me, but he hasn't been lynched yet.

Why I want to lynch him? I don't believe that this whole color claim thing is what it's meant to be. For starters:

Gorrad- Yellow
Xdaamno- Red
GhostWriter - Red
skitzer - Blue
Kison - Blue
armlx - Blue
Greasy Spot- purple
JamesThePhox- white
Nightson- white
Claus- bulbmin
The Jester- Red
dcorbe - Red

There were 6 red, 3 yellow, and 4 blue. Now, if any one claimed red pikmin became a yellow pikmin, then the numbers are 5-4-4, which is almost equal. Therefore, I'm not completely sold on the whole "red pikmin are scum" case.

Also, some selected posts:

HAHA...Don't get your panties in a bunch just yet. You pikmins are way too uptight. No wonder mod called you stupid.

I don't care if you call this semantics, it just seems so obvious that it must come from someone who isn't a pikmin.

No I'm a pikmin alright, just not a stupid pikmin like the mod called you all.

Don't know exactly about this, but aren't purple pikmin supposed to be slightly stupider than the other colors?

What the Hell...It's Hammah Time!

VOTE: ZombieSlayer54

What the Hell...It's Hammah Time!

VOTE: ZombieSlayer54

This was a strange hammer on Day 1. Especially with the lowered lynch vote.

IN many posts, he also pushes arguments off to the side (such as the "you stupid pikmin" slip and JamesThePhox's bomb ability. Also, I mentioned earlier how scum sonickid defended Greasy Spot. I believe there is perfectly enough reasoning to lynch Greasy Spot.

[skitzer]

What I mean by the 2 point is that if GS is a purple pikmin, they are stupider than other pikmin. So he would be stupider than other colored pikmin, therefore that doesn't make sense.

What exactly makes the slips null tells? Have they faded away into nullness?

I'll check on your case on Porochaz later.

[skitzer]

I will have limited access from August 1st to August 15th. Some days I know I wont have access, some days I will, and somedays I'm not quite sure yet. Here is a tentative schedule:

Red

= No Access

Yellow

= Possible Access

Green

= Definite Access

August 1st

August 2nd

August 3rd

August 4th-August 8th

August 9th

August 10th

August 11th-August15th

I will get to the analysis of Porochaz by Claus ASAP.

[skitzer]

Hmmm...I like the case a lot, especially because of one thing: GW defended sonickid, which is less WIFOMy than sonickid defending GS. That is a more solid point that I can agree with.

Unvote, Vote: Porochaz

- I'm not totally believing this red pikmin thing, but Claus's case on GW/Porochaz is good.

That's four votes, I belive.

[skitzer]

me, Kison, armlx, Claus - who is the other 1?

[skitzer]

I didn't see that the last time I checked the page!

Also, why are we so hesitant to put people at L-1. It's not like they're gonna claim...

[skitzer]

By day, do you mean game day or RL day?

[skitzer]

Readthrough since my last post, kind of wondering about the stalling Porochaz wagon.

[skitzer]

I don't know. I feel like we have enough information to lynch him, but it's just kind of...sitting there.

[skitzer]

OK. I'm feeling the saem way about Porochz, The Fonz. I think it is great that you are honoring your "side".

[skitzer]

Vote: Gorrad*

I will be right today. No one can move this vote.

[skitzer]

Thinking here: Does it seem like a town thing for gorrad to be acting the same both ways? I'm leaning towards yes, but it seems fishy to me.

unvote

I couldn't even make it 24hrs before changing my vote.

[skitzer]

Today is a massive reread/analyze/post day for me. Will get to this game along with many others.

[skitzer]

I haven't stopped completely with GS being scum, it just doesn't look that viable anymore compared with current cases.

I want to reread Xdaamno, armlx, and Porochaz/replaced by Porochaz, they have interesting things I'd like to see.

[skitzer]

Xdaamno (in isolation)

Post 12 - he votes JamesThePhox for his thoughts about the game setup, because it didn’t seem like a townie would do this. He finds it suspicious here, but hasn’t said much about it when Gorrad and armlx have discussed it. Also in this post he includes a pretty random vote of armlx.

Post 38 - Kison asks Xdaamno who the scummiest reds are. Not sure about this, but he mentions every other red except himself. Attempting to elude pressure much?

Armlx (in isolation)

Post 24 & 25 - armlx thought Greasy Spot was very scummy on day 1, but now he is thinking those tells are false. It seems somewhat floppy to me.

Posts 85 & 86 - armlx thought SonicKid defending Greasy Spot was the best scum tell for Greasy Spot, but then says it’s not that good? It doesn’t seem like these should be separated into two separate posts. If a reason is good, but not good enough, say that all in one big clump.

Post 228 - I’m not sure what other’s think, but I don’t think the vote here was well placed. It kind of reminds me where 2 people are arguing and one just can’t think of a counterpoint, so they just go “MEH!” and point a finger.

I decided not to do a Porochaz read, as the suspicions weren’t really valid. But I did notice this:

Post 2 of isolated greasy spot: the “you pikmins” slip. In Post 20 he says “us pikmin” without any trace of sarcasm or whatever.

[skitzer]

So Greasy Spot was/is Mafia, but the only way we can possibly win is if we don't lynch him. I am ENTIRELY ANGRY!

[skitzer]

Never feels good when you get

lynch

endgamed for being the only one who was right.

Fix'd...

Good job, mafia.