Large Normal 209: BooneyToonz VI - Journey to Boon Island!

[Egg]

Hello. Bear with me, gonna be playing from behind for a bit. If I can stay awake, I'll put some time into this when I'm done in my online pool league tonight. Worst case, tomorrow this game gets a shit ton of attention from me.

[Egg]

Who should I vote in the mean time?

[Egg]

Who should I vote in the mean time?

Me

Why?

good plan.

are you in mulch's secret mason hood?

Nope.

[Egg]

We are killing Mulch today.
There are no Ifs.
There are no Buts.
Mulch dies today no matter what because he is not town.

Why isn't he town? What is alisae vs mulch about?

[Egg]

Start reading from here

So he claimed cop for no apparent reason and got wagoned as a result? And where is alisae in all of this? Part of a hydra or something?

[Egg]

Oh, ok. So why does all of this make mulch scum and not bad town. You mentioned meta. Is this really his idea of some brilliant scum strategy or something? And why are we so sure that we aren't giving him a night to give us a result and then just lynch him tomorrow?

[Egg]

Do you have enough of his scum games to show a pattern? I've never played with him before.

[Egg]

Yes people have already posted like two of them.

Ok, you seem to forget I haven't read the thread yet.

egg are you scum too?

Nope.

He has the night phase to do that Nagito.

I don't catch up during night. Possibility of being killed and inconvenience of thread being locked and no where to type.

[Egg]

V/LA for the weekend. Will do some reading monday night

Noted.

[Egg]

Pisskop:

I don't catch up during night. Possibility of being killed and inconvenience of thread being locked and no where to type.

[Egg]

I owe it to this game to start playing. I'm off work tonight but going to bed right now. Will put time into this later.

[Egg]

Ok, bear with me on outdated early game stuff. It's more for me than anyone else anyway. I will try to be quick on the real early stuff and not say too much on it, but I need the full context to help me get reads.

I don't love Dunk's assertion of multiple teams at first glance. Maybe it really is Mod WIFOM like he says, but it comes off like having more info than the rest of us. But with two deaths a night so far and a vig flip, and Nagito flipping simply "mafia" in red text, it looks like he was wrong anyway. So if anything, that looks like real speculation coming from town. I also like his vote on Nagito as a "serious vote" to start the game. Doesn't feel like distancing because labeling it serious so early creates momentum against the target. I'm not convinced he did that to a buddy.

Early town vibes from Transcend, but I always town read him so I'm gonna try not to make too much of that yet.

Kokichi's "I am mafia" stuff really rubs me the wrong way. Like, obviously I'm not trying to suggest that it's a scum claim or anything like that, but it comes off...I dunno, like he's got something to hide and he feels like we won't figure it out. Like I picture him smirking when he posts. It's really hard to describe, but man it's a weird feeling.

Something Smart's post about not forming reads is...just ugh. I don't believe it "half jokes". I think a half joke is a hidden truth. However, the reasoning he gives about not being able to separate signal from noise sounds like he legitimately WANTS to sort everyone but just struggles to do so early in the game. So yeah this can be an early town read.

Kaede seems to be posting a lot of nothing. Feels like an attempt to stay under the radar. Granted I'm basing this on the first five pages, but ew.

Uhhh. Something Smart's not wanting to have reads thing that I said was townish looks less townish after his self meta claiming he's careful who he scum reads as scum.

Early town vibes from tchill. I like his point against something smart and his wagon vote on Nagito. I'm not sure what to make of Unabomb's Nagito vote though. I hope it's not just the smilie fucking with my head, but it felt like he was trying to be deceptive and that vote being a distancing move fits that bill.

Spoiler: Not game related

guys im pulling 17hour days several times a week

any day longer than 12 hours should be illegal imo

Heh. I call mine 16, but realistically I get there 30-45 min early and leave 15-30 min late so....yeah. Once in a while I do 8 hours and I call that a half day.

I've seen whymafia as scum and it felt like his entire focus was blending. His entrance here is the exact opposite. I see real scumhunting that he didn't seem capable of in that game. This is my strongest read to this point. He looks town and that read will probably stick when I'm done reading.

Tywin is probably town for the comment about having to write down reads because of the anime names. Mixing up reads is something that can come off scummy and he showed no fear of being voted for it.

Nagito's "forgot to mention I town read Something Smart" feels forced. Possibly talking about a buddy there. His interaction's with Himiko about Transcend feel like scum vs town though. Himiko's comment about being "concerned" feels real and Nagito's assumption that Himiko was town reading Transcend felt manipulative. Nagito reducing Transcend's scum read on Kokichi to "for posting a gimmick" is horrible too. Possible chainsaw defense of Kokichi. Also town points for Transcend in all of this.
^On all of this, I was dumb and hadn't realized Himiko had died. I came back here when I realized it to get rid of my stuff about town reading him because it's useless, but there's stuff that's still relevant to Transcend so I'll leave it here.

I want to mention that while Kokichi doesn't look good to me so far, there is one thing I don't care to go into at this time that gives me hesitance. I'd probably have Kokichi as my strongest scum read if not for that one thing.

Transcend's 205 gave five scum reads. One flipped scum. Of the other four, I really like three. Screen is the one I don't feel the same way on yet, but he's not a strong town read either. Too bad I wasn't here from the beginning. We would have really been on the same page. Assemble's reaction to being on that list sucks by the way ("show me where you pull shit like this as town"). Screen's actually isn't any better, saying that scum Transcend would fake confident reads.

The gimmick is the character he is RPing as likes to lie and troll like that.

Oh. That would have been helpful to know. Still don't love the fact that flipped scum is the one who jumped to Kokichi's defense, but that does explain a lot of my concerns.

Srceenplay [7]: Maki Harukawa, WhyMafia, Monaco Towa, Nagito Komaeda, Transcend, TywinL, Mulch

Alright then, ill trust this for now
VOTE: Screen

If Screen is town, this is ugly.

At the very least one scum in:
Maki Harukawa
Monaco Towa
Nagito Komaeda

I know everyone has their thoughts on whether Rule of 3 is real or BS, but all of these players have flipped and guess what.

I'm through Page 13. Will have a ton more time tomorrow but there's a start at least.

Town on top, scum on bottom:
Whymafia
tywin
Transcend
tchill
Dunk
Kaito/fykus/skirt
Kokichi
Unabomb
Something Smart
Screenplay or Kaede
Assemble

[Egg]

Like I picture him smirking when he posts. It's really hard to describe, but man it's a weird feeling.

Why do you think that?

I don't know. It's just the way you come off.

[Egg]

Honestly tho, im just gonna be a walking ball of WIFOM for as long as I live. Town's win precedes whatever utility my role may have and if my sacrifice will get confscum lynched then so be it.

I don't want to stay alive if im just gonna be potential lynchbait any future days.

This doesn't sound like scum. If this day is Kaede vs Assemble, I'm probably supporting an Assemble lynch although I do need to read more before deciding that for sure. Was gonna do it now but my two year old is in crisis mode because he washed his hands and now they are wet (like holy crap no shit they are wet) so I'm gonna hold off until the kids are in bed.

[Egg]

Why.
I already said I wanted to be lynched today...

And you seem to mean it. Scum would only say this to look town (I don't think you are doing that) or because they are playing against their win condition (the Mod hasn't intervened).

[Egg]

Ok, one kid in bed, the other eating dinner and watching TV. Maybe I can get some reading in.

Screen asking what is bad about his bad post might be worse than the original post (Page 14, post 341)

Kokichi looks better here noticing some of the same things I did (comments on Unabomb, Screen, and Transcend)

Spoiler: My reads list, few changes

Town on top, scum on bottom:
Whymafia
tywin
Transcend
Kaede
tchill
Dunk
Kaito/fykus/skirt
Kokichi
Unabomb
Something Smart
Screenplay
Assemble

Ugh. Made it through two pages. Can't concentrate over a two year old's fart noises in my ear. Should have just waited for bed time.

[Egg]

Sorry but I'm old and set in my ways. Almost zero chance I remember to do that.

[Egg]

341
Wrong.
Already been discussed and pointed out.

Why am I wrong?

[Egg]

Kokichi's issue was the "I don't care" and "why is it bad" together? I actually see your side of that argument that they were about different things. But I don't like the way you asked why it was a bad post. It felt like "shit, did I say something scummy?"

[Egg]

I went back and looked just now with that in mind and it still feels more defensive than it feels like you questioning someone's intentions. Especially with this tacked on:

Him trying to goad me into voting him and me doing it?

[Egg]

Rhetorical

Probably why it came off defensive.

[Egg]

Now that there is nothing to distract me...

Kokichi and Tywin did a lot of talking about tchill's meta without really getting specific. I'd love to know what they have noticed in his meta because I haven't figured him out yet. I read him incorrectly in our one finished game.

Whymafia's question about town reads on him and some other consensus stances is one that I see coming from town. I had actually just noticed myself that a lot of people's reads were matching my own. Then I looked back over my reads and yeah they all seem to be consensus reads. I feel like a lot of people are just on the same page. But that doesn't mean everyone is right. If a lot of those consensus reads turn out to be wrong, we need to look at the people who made those reads consensus. I'd suspect that 1-2 players who are consensus town reads and seem to be leading the charge probably turn out to be scum in that case. Problem is I don't know who that would be. Maybe Transcend? *shrug* (And of course after I type this I see three other people strengthen their whymafia town reads because of this post...)

I like Kaede recognizing a flaw in her own logic regarding tchill/screen being the same alignment.

I'm through page 20. Only a few things stood out in that stretch. Taking a break.

Town on top, scum on bottom:
Whymafia
Kaede
tywin
Transcend
Dunk
Kokichi
tchill
Kaito/fykus/skirt
Unabomb
Something Smart
Screenplay
Assemble

[Egg]

Can someone summarize the claims we've seen so far for me?

[Egg]

@Egg
We have Kaede - Who went from vig to SK to vig
Assemble, the even? night loyal JK who has confirmed Kaede is not the same alignment as him
and Fykus, the JOAT who used an invest N1 to find Piss had a gun, healed? Transcend N2, and now has a 1 Shot JK

Oh wow.

So Assemble who is scummy anyway can't be town with Kaede...which explains the 1v1.

Why did Fykus claim?

I'm using a bit of meta, but just look at his ISO lol
He's been active elsewhere as well ..

Well my question is more about his meta. What is different between his scum play and town play?

[Egg]

Am I counting wrong or was whymafia's vote hammer?

[Egg]

This is what I get for trusting kokichi saying he would "clear" me.

Both tchill and egg should be able to confirm this btw.

Yeah that happened but you said it would be a waste.

Anyway I think kaede is town and I don't like the Lynch but I can see it's happening anywY. So *shrug*

[Egg]

@Kokichi:

This is what I get for trusting kokichi saying he would "clear" me.

Care to explain?

I never said I would. Nee-heehee~

Actually that's technically true...

[Egg]

Well that's awesome lol. I guess I'm just a sucker for AtE

[Egg]

like, after me, the person doing the most scumhunting is... a fucking werewolf. come the fuck on. less than half the game is being helpful.

I have plenty of time Wednesday Thurs Fri and maybe Saturday.

[Egg]

Not in a hood.

Not in any PT for that matter.

I think "ne-hee-hee" -animoo is overplaying a character, or trying to backpedal EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. they soft a role or noticing a "slip" or whatever.
I think I'm back to listing them as scum, just so I can say tomorrow I want to them lynched..

Lol at the bolded.

[Egg]

Kokichi, in response to your big post in the hood, why do you think mafia have a rolestopper and not a roleblocker?

____________

I have no issues with a massclaim at this point.

[Egg]

I went into today thinking the maf in the group was srceenplay, and the people in my neighborhood can confirm. But, they died so. That changes things.

Confirming. I actually expected you to scum read skirt when I saw screen flip town. The neighbor spec mostly seems like Mod WIFOM I don't want to get into except that those in hoods with Assemble and Kaede probably aren't wolf. Not sure what to think of the pisskop death though. Kaede could be lying and he could have been their kill. Especially if Screen was a wolf kill because it would set up skirt for exactly this thinking. I don't think it's worth lynching him for this when I've been townreading his play.

____________

I don't get the kokichi votes...

____________

Piss didnt even soft vig. But, yes.

Wait, what?

i can see a world they're scum in tho

This doesn't sound as confident as I'd expect after that wagon hop.

_____________

Vote Unabomb

I actually think this is our best chance to hit scum. He's really my last scum read still alive and he makes sense with either team unless I'm missing something.

[Egg]

I mean these are his only Nagito mentions:

...this game so far... I feel like already skipping the RVS...

VOTE: Nagito Komaeda to start the RWS! (RandomWagoningStage)

At the very least one scum in:
Maki Harukawa
Monaco Towa
Nagito Komaeda

Also: Fykus has entered the building.

An RVS vote and a possible Rule of 3 post.

His Assemble "mentions" (Ctrl+f) are pretty much all inside of quotes.

His Kaede interactions seem mostly fine, but I don't see any reason they CAN'T be scum together either.

[Egg]

I think he's a much better lynch than skirt

[Egg]

That actually is pretty weird

[Egg]

Skirt and transcend, thoughts on a unabomb Lynch today?

[Egg]

Why don't any of y'all wanna lynch TChill

The only reason anyone gave me that he could be scum in inactivity. I've seen recently that he can be active as scum and knows what he is doing. Do you have a better reason? What do you think of unabomb?

tchill is probably the wolf if he's scum

That would make tchill and kaede neighbors together and wolves together.

[Egg]

Why don't any of y'all wanna lynch TChill

The only reason anyone gave me that he could be scum in inactivity. I've seen recently that he can be active as scum and knows what he is doing. Do you have a better reason? What do you think of unabomb?

tchill is probably the wolf if he's scum

That would make tchill and kaede neighbors together and wolves together.

hm

maybe

just maybe

u shouldn't base reads off of something like hood spec that

doesn't impact game balance whatsoever and could literally be randomized as has been done in the past

Probably true, but why is he likely wolf if scum?

you can lynch una if you want. frankly, i don't really give a shit, he isn't a "town read"

Wanna help? I only have one vote so I can't do it myself.

[Egg]

But Unabomb could be wolf or mafia. And your numbers show wolf lynch is best.

[Egg]

Vote Unabomb

I actually think this is our best chance to hit scum. He's really my last scum read still alive and he makes sense with either team unless I'm missing something.

Out of the left field..

Eddie also already cased me: I'm a useless lurker, not scum.

I'd be interested in hearing WHY you scumread me?

It's really not. My posts should answer your questions. Go back and read them so I don't just end up repeating myself. I admit there is PoE involved but I was definitely scum reading you before now. Reading past this post, I do see that you went back and realized this. If you are town, the mentality in 3101 is your problem. Until you've really mastered some things, dont try to look town as town. Just find scum and let your play speak for itself.

Transcend are you asking for reads from me or unabomb in 3106?

Unabomb if you noticed all of that on your little trio why not point it out when they were alive rather than just saying at least one is scum?

[Egg]

I was referring to the bolded:

I'm not stupid even if my play seems bad at times, it's just that

I'm still trying to learn what people scumread on this site

, and what not.
And before people jump on that being something only scum say, nah.

Most of being a good townie on this site is being able to towntell yourself

, and then getting NK'd or lynched anyway. ("obvious" townie/paranoia)

I think my biggest problem on forum-mafia is that I'm way more "complete" in my communication when I can use facial expressions and actual tone.
Trying to convey tone by text...ech.

[Egg]

Can you show me where you explained tchill?

[Egg]

Or is it just this?

TChill has given two stances this whole game ....

[Egg]

Ehhhhh, I'm really not convinced but it's probably better if he responds to each point than if I do.

[Egg]

I'm town neighbor

[Egg]

Skirt I don't know if you mean me or not but I claimed truthfully. I'm not a doc.

[Egg]

why can't we just lynch kokichi

Because unabomb is more likely wolf and could be mafia. Kokichi is probably not wolf.

As far as you bussing kaede, I'd be more surprised if scum DIDNT bus at that point.

[Egg]

Can you say why you scum read me?

^I second this. WhyMafia has felt pretty obvtown for a while.

[Egg]

Everyone in your next post please hard decline being doc/rs/protective. If you do so, and you try and claim it later, we quick lynch you. I am very sure there's a town protective lying here and I think whatever thought process makes you think that's a good idea is wrong.

Third time doing so, but yeah. I'm not doc.

[Egg]

I mean I think dunk is town, just the argument that he wouldn't have bussed is BS when kaede was already going down at that point.

[Egg]

Anyone else notice unabomb making a self preservation vote but acting like he's finding real reasons to vote kokichi?

[Egg]

Kokichi is maf, egg could be the partner, una could be wolf I guess. It's basically whether you wanna lynch a 90% mafia or a 40% wolf

WM, I would do kokichi here. If he magically towns egg is maf WKing him. Up to you tho. Chill, you aren't gonna care about what I say so u do u.

Wouldn't you be voting me if I'm scum regardless? I don't think you are scum, but you are confirmation biasing hard here on both kokichi and myself.

[Egg]

Kokichi is maf, egg could be the partner, una could be wolf I guess. It's basically whether you wanna lynch a 90% mafia or a 40% wolf

WM, I would do kokichi here. If he magically towns egg is maf WKing him. Up to you tho. Chill, you aren't gonna care about what I say so u do u.

Wouldn't you be voting me if I'm scum regardless? I don't think you are scum, but you are confirmation biasing hard here on both kokichi and myself.

If I thought you had a better chance of flipping scum than Kokichi, yes, I would be voting you.

Yet you honestly believe I'm either scum with kokichi or scum white knighting kokichi? Think about how much sense that makes for a second.

[Egg]

looking through your iso there is very little mention of nagito throughout the whole thing, yet you're claiming to have been a major contributor. looks like bussing to me

also any reason you mysteriously stopped pushing me when kaede came along? you aren't pushing me when i'm obviously a valid wolf candidate.
you said you were scumreading me multiple times yet today not one word about me.

This feels very town

[Egg]

Anyone else notice unabomb making a self preservation vote but acting like he's finding real reasons to vote kokichi?

I never had any trouble voting here, but I have still been torn on that slot for the entire game.

It's the kind of "wifom" (not exactly that in this case I think?), where you think no scum would act so blatantly scummy and fake..but then again..but then again..and so on.

Couldn't tell by your posts. Looks more like kokichi was a straight scum read until you got used to the posting style and then he was a straight town read. *Shrug*

To your big post, I thought Eddie might have meant me on the doc this g because he mentioned the possibility that kokichi was doc protected which makes sense for me . I agree with your next quote. I think you are wolf and can't rule you out as mafia, not the other way around. Also not irritated with Eddie. I just think his logic is off and wanted to help him take a step back and fix it.

[Egg]

Bad progression

False, I'm not progressing at all.

I wanted to hear who was your pick for being the protective.
I can only think of two slots that could do it at this point, and it would still make sense to me.

It's obvious who he means. Let him deal with it how he wants for now.

[Egg]

Fell asleep reading this last night and lost what I had typed out but basically...I don't buy Eddie's claim obviously. So unless he wants to tell us why town would fKeclaim there, my best guess is that kokichi was right about mafia having a rolestop and Eddie is wolf who shot transcend so he believes he has a true guilty.

Eddie, it makes no sense for tchill to have claimed to me. I didn't suspect him and he didn't trust me. If he was going to claim, he'd have done it in the thread during the day. At the same time, if I was scum, why wouldn't I just shoot a scum read who I wasn't able to get lynched like unabomb. If I was wolf, I'd be desperate to hit mafia because I'd be outnumbered. If I was mafia, I'd want to eliminate the wolf NK in case they were coming after me. Either way, I wouldn't be shooting town reads right now.

As for the tchill shot iself, I'm guessing whichever team shot him probably was shooting a scum read. No other reason for it.

Kaito, you asked what tchill and I discussed last night. He made one post asking for my reads. I gave a thought out reply and landed on unabomb as a wolf and skirt/dunk as my best guess for mafia. Basically I figured mafia has at least one member in control of things which gave me at least one of Eddie/transcend and then PoE would point me to dunk or kaito next. Whymafia is still solid town to me.

Eddie's claim changes things for me though. I now think he's wolf and transcend is mafia. I'd guess unabomb for the second mafia but would need to check interactions if transcend were to flip mafia at some point.

[Egg]

Eddie you're in a normal game making a claim that would be off in a theme game. To why you'd claim it as wolf, maybe you thought everyone was dumb enough to buy it. On not getting unabomb lynched, say what you want but I pushed hard and it didn't happen. And on tchill why would him not claiming not change anything when your point relied on him claiming?

Kaito is that to me? Because if so, I honestly don't care. I don't see why that couldn't be possible.

I typed he above before reading Eddie's big post. Hmm. My question is if we have to hit wolf first and those are your reads why fake the guilty on transcend and not unabomb? I mean you explained thinking you might die and everything but getting transcend lynched from that point of view is still far from perfect. You should have just come in helping me Lynch unabomb if you are town. That post is about all I was waiting for to call you town though. That claim was never believable and as I said I needed a reason why town would do it before calling you town.

I haven't found the bracket keys on my phone yet but I'd vote unabomb if I could. Will do so Tuesday when I have my computer if nothing has changed. But yeah I'm back to unabomb as wolf and probably transcend mafia with dunk or kaito.

[Egg]

Lol he called the shit doodoo

[Egg]

Why would transcend be confirmed?

[Egg]

Dunk could fit as scum by PoE but I haven't scum read his play.

[Egg]

is there any reason we shouldn't lynch between transcend and skirt rn

Neither is likely wolf and I don't trust scum to crosskill for the first time all game.

I haven't found the bracket keys on my phone yet but I'd vote unabomb if I could. Will do so Tuesday when I have my computer if nothing has changed

It's Tuesday.

Vote Unabomb

[Egg]

Dunk why do you want today to be transcend vs skirt so badly?

Why not unabomb? You said the wolf pool is too big but what happened to this:

i mean wolf pool is basically (kaito, una)

[Egg]

i mean i guess, but appearantly whymaf is now back in and i obviously am too, plus transcend vs skirt 95% of the time has a scum in it so

whatever you guys want tho

I want unabomb.

[Egg]

I want unabomb.

This alone should tell that Egg is scum - he has still to say why me over Dunker/WhyMafia/Kaito.
I know PoE is an actual thing, but just saying "I did PoE - you are scum" is the equivalent of "I'm not interested enough in this game to do the effort".

I thought this game was sort of getting better at the end of last day, but since Kokichi didn't flip scum, it feels like we are so so boned..

I also feel like discussing future nightkills at this point only helps scum, so I'd rather not do it further.

My ISO has plenty on how I developed my reads. Of everyone alive, you're my only original scum read still alive which I've also already said. It shouldn't come as a surprise that I'd rather Lynch you than people I originally had as town reads. Now that we have more Info and want to Lynch a wolf, that's another thing that points to you because anyone else I can see being scum makes more sense as mafia than as wolf (dunk would probably be my second pick for wolf and I have him in my mafia team). I've also said mutiple times whymafia is solid town for me so I'm surprised to see his name in what you seem to assume is my wolf pool.

Transcend wrote:
Sometimes i feel like you're town because scum wouldn't dare make the awful posts you are making rn

Because everyone is perfect when they are scum?

Unabomb wrote:
No, I wouldn't claim scum at a time like this.

When would you claim scum?

[Egg]

I mean you're a very stubborn dude but also a very wrong dude

Sucks because usually you're someone i can trust to read me correctly

I could make this exact post to you right now...

[Egg]

What would we even be trying to accomplish with a no Lynch?

[Egg]

Kaito is like my third pick for wolf and maybe third for mafia. I'm not gonna vote there. I'd actually rather Lynch dunk than kaito. Which you'll probably call distancing but I don't care lol.

[Egg]

I do care so vote unabomb

[Egg]

These latest events should definitely make it clear that unabomb is a better Lynch than dunk. He's actually right that his push to Lynch mafia which is against the grain, is more likely to come from town. Scum him should be perfectly happy with the non-him wolf pool being lynched. Why waste time on Eddie and transcend when he could just NK them when the Lynch is clearly not happening?

[Egg]

These latest events should definitely make it clear that unabomb is a better Lynch than dunk. He's actually right that his push to Lynch mafia which is against the grain, is more likely to come from town. Scum him should be perfectly happy with the non-him wolf pool being lynched. Why waste time on Eddie and transcend when he could just NK them when the Lynch is clearly not happening?

As WW, if he lynches 1 member of mafia, that leaves only 1 member of mafia left. That means if he has a successfully kills the last member of mafia tonight, he's pretty set. Or is that wrong.

It doesn't matter to the wolf who is lynched today. He needs to survive. That's it. I mean, Boon's answer to Eddie about whether the game would end at 2:1:1 is interesting and maybe the wolf would be most comfortable with one more mafia death but he has a NK for that. Staying hidden is still more valuable to him than lynching mafia today. So, like I said, why go against the grain? It's a big part of why I ended up townreading Eddie when he faked a guilty on a mafia read. Eddie's exact defense to my wolf accusation was that mafia would kill him in that case meaning it was better to stay hidden. Yet I say something similar and he just posts "lol" to it. But yeah after Eddie said that I realized wolf absolutely does not want mafia knowing who he is. His best chance at winning is with his NK.

[Egg]

And if you're town, telling mafia that probably wasn't the best idea....

[Egg]

Dunk I also never got an answer when I asked why not unabomb here:

Dunk why do you want today to be transcend vs skirt so badly?

Why not unabomb? You said the wolf pool is too big but what happened to this:

i mean wolf pool is basically (kaito, una)

Voting unabomb feels like the only way you survive right now which should matter to you regardless of your alignment at this point.

I'm almost wondering if we've been completely off all day and the mafia team is unabomb/dunk the way dunk has avoided giving an opinion on unabomb. I hope not but man...that would suck although crosskill could still happen. I'm over thinking but yeah...

[Egg]

Unabomb I acknowledged that I'm over thinking (not reaching, there is a difference) but I don't agree with you making "no sense" as mafia. I'd say mafia makes more sense than town but much less sense than wolf.

[Egg]

i've defended myself already and i don't feel like repeating myself
transcend and skirt are both mafia it's pretty obvious imo
una's been towny even though 3678 was scummy, kaito's been towny so that leaves whymaf.
i'd do whymaf or una at this point

Well I don't think whymafia is getting lynched in The next 48 hours so......

[Egg]

Fucking knew it.

But no

Everyone would rather Lynch dunk

...

Well hopefully they are both scum.

[Egg]

So Dunk town would leave us me/transcend/kaito/whymafia with 2:1:1 in mafia's favor

Dunk mafia would leave the same four but 2:1:1 in town's "favor".

Dunk wolf would make zero sense because both mafia claiming is stupid here.

That's assuming both unabomb and transcend are being honest about their kills, but it's pretty much in their hands now.

*sigh*

[Egg]

After reading the dead thread, the biggest thing I want to talk about is the joint win rule. I want to clearly states that joint win was never my goal. I would NEVER sacratice a member of my scum team with the intention of joint winning as I see was discussed there. Anyone who has seen me in games with multiple scum team knows I like to take out opposing scum as quickly as possible. The perfect NK is not in the obvious Lynch pool, is a threat to your game, and could be opposing scum. Boon's rules change this might dset when you are ahead of the other team. Yes the threat of being g NK'd still exists. But at the point where I mentioned joint win, kaito and I were not exactly everyone's strongest town reads. We needed as many players dead as quickly as possible and as long as we aren't likely wolf NK targets, having a wolf alive is beneficial to us. It's double NKs. We also had the benefit of the rolestop just in case we were worried about the wolf kill. So yes, I wanted the wolf to survive at night. That being said, I had no idea it was whymafia.

As far as the last night goes, my PT shows my thoughts there. We didn't need the wolf anymore and killing him was the simple path to victory. I fully believed unabomb and never even considered believing transcend. I'm impressed with unabomb for thinking of that because it did remove eddie from my kill pool. I actually did consider killing whymafia before during dunk flipped and unabomb claimed, ironically enough, because I didnt think wolf would shoot him. My biggest thing was I didn't want to Target the same person they did.

Also fully thought wf knew who I was that last day because we used the rolestop on me and both teams shot tchill.

Fun game, Thanks boon. And sorry it took me so long to get going. Work drags me away from these games which is why I don't play as much as I used to. I do t join larges from the beginning when I can help myself and I'm now in zero games which was unheard of from me for nearly a decade.