Not necessarily in this sort of setup. There's 3 different killers all trying to find the others and get rid of them.ButteBlues wrote:A random lynch has been and always will be better than a no lynch. This is basic friggin theory. You should know better. In fact, I'm damned sure that any player who's been here more than a week knows this.
Unvote, Vote: Mastermind of Sin
No lynch'ing in this game is a death wish. I'm confident that any player worth their salt knows this. So either you've got to be a complete noob at mafia or you're scum. Plain as that.
Can you give examples, or just vague generalizations on something that hasn't even happened yet?In setups like this, it takes an aggressive town who's willing to lynch to win. It's been proven time and time again.
I think you're wrong.YagamiLight wrote:Are you trying to Argue for or Against MoS? I think the SK's will want to take out townies untill our numbers are less then start trying to lynch SK's.YogurtBandit wrote:EBWOP: I forgot we have 15 pro town, so We would have 11 left.YogurtBandit wrote:Yes, but if we Lynch a Townie, and All 3 Sk's make sucsessful kills, We only have 5 Townies left..Mastermind of Sin wrote:Why would a no lynch be bad in this situation? I would rather no lynch than lynch randomly. If we no lynch, we lose no one. If we lynch randomly, we most likely lose a townie. Having no one die is better than having a townie die. That's why we need to make an informed lynch instead of randomly wagoning, because that's not going to help us.
No, no, I know that, but this little exchange is worth even less than the game theory and random lynch ones, which at least haveSir Tornado wrote:JDodge, I don't think it's Ryan alone... everyone is to blame for this. I don't think we have actually started to hunt scum yet. Some arguments on "Whether to random lynch or not" and "Does the Game theory for this one differ from general game theory" occupy most of the past few threads. And, to tell you the truth, I haven't got the slightest idea where to start from.
OMGUS? You haven't accused me of anything.ryan wrote:WOW. If that isn't the biggest OMGUS comment I've ever seen. I'm not a SK, so why should I say I am?
First, this is the way I talk. If you have a problem with it, you may kindly deal with it.ryan wrote:Get over yourself JDodge, you are trying WAY to hard to start something that isn't there. Jump on the DYH bandwagon and see what happens at night my friend and WOAH lay off the caffeine, yikes.
Actually, there was a point to why I said it that way. I wanted to see if you would ignore the meat of my statement and go for the seasoning to attempt to try and debunk the statement, which you did.ryan wrote:Stop trying to argue and show how big a man you are, it's a game, take a step back and a breath of fresh air and remember that. Kindly deal with it? Come on now, what are we in California with the valley girls now? Shall I await a "talk to the hand" comment next? You haven't found scum, so move along and stop making yourself look so childish. DYH volunteered himself to be lynched, are you missing that or shall I requote it for you?
Really?Estes wrote:A day in which nothing was solved. And no leads were really made (evidence by the lynching of ryan, a townie).JDodge wrote:Yes. In reaction to the fact that you were keeping a random vote on someonehalfway through day one.
We learned that (CUE THE CHEESY MUSICAL NUMBER):Estes wrote:Well then tell us all what you've learned. I have zero leads after yesterday. I'm interested to know what you've come up with based on the events of yesterday and last night.JDodge wrote: Really?
I find it somewhat foolish of you to think that we have to lynch correctly to learn anything from a day.
What bugs me is that nobody that IYagamiLight wrote:I know it was pretty bad math, normally I"m pretty good, but it's been years since I've had Statistics. Also, I didn't vote you for the claim (I tried to explain to everyone about how it seems to be a unique townie claim) and I"m the only one to vote you after you claimed, and anyhow I'm going tounvoteyou because JDodge is looking pretty suspicious now. JDodge, the lack of reasoning wasn't suspicious to me because this SK only game seemed like it would be hard to find good reasoning, especially Day 1 and parts of Day 2. What's so suspicious is that you believe that Jordan and Lowell are suspicious for FoS'ing you for the lack of reasoning.
Explain