Mafia 64: The New "C9" - Game over!

[beanbagboy]

@Albert: Well, the only game you saw me in, I was scum, and in a position to speed lynch (which I took.)

Also, JDodge and SV being good mafia players is probably why they were taken out. They could be big threats to the mafia, right?

Finally, I don't think Glork's survival is any reason to blame him. We don't know what went on last night, it could have been any number of reasons that kept him alive.

Guardian, was that meant as a joke? It's hard to tell.

Vote: Jack

because I said so. (random...)

[beanbagboy]

Meh, all votes are random now. If you have a reason for it, all the better.

Also, your votes give others information, so as a rule voting is a good thing (in random voting)

Just some thoughts, I don't know how experienced you are, so I can't tell if that's a newbie mistake or a strategy.

No biggie, though.

[beanbagboy]

@MBL: How was SV an "odd" kill choice?

@Glrok: Why is MBL a bad boy?

[beanbagboy]

LOL
EW

[beanbagboy]

Wow. Sorry if I seem inactive, the pool just opened. ^^.

Hey... I made a question that someone needs to answer! I feel special! ^^

The night kill thing is stupid, agreed. Any kill that scum makes is a good kill. Killing off strong townies is better. The fact that they didn't kill Glork doesn't mean anything. Again, we don't know what happened last night.

Yeah, BM, come on. Random voting = jokey. IMGMEOY (lol I stole this one from bob: I maybe got my eye on you.)

[beanbagboy]

@HackerHuck: Er... no. That was from an objective point of view, I'm saying that to an extent they don't care who they kill as long as they kill SOMEone and that person is a reasonable threat to the town, so JDodge and SV getting killed tells us, like Glork said, nothing. I was saying what their intentions would be going into the first night.

Glork, I don't think BM is scum. Granted, he is acting very stupid, but metagame wise he's like this in other games I'm in with him. (Well, we're both still alive, so it is possible, but still.)

I do that all the time, saying I'm scum (as a joke.) Sometimes I'm not lying when I say it, though.

[beanbagboy]

@BM: Sure. You're twisting his words, as Haut boy just said, yes, he said it's TRUE that he's good at hunting scum, but Guardian was JOKING that he gets all the scum, all the time. I don't see how that's contradictory.

(More later, I'm busy...)

Also, Glork not getting all the scum, at least from what I've heard, is a sign that he's protown, as he usually seriously busses his scum buddies. (This is just what I've heard, I don't think I've ever played with Glork before.)

[beanbagboy]

HI! *flaps hands frantically in Yogurt's direction* LOL

[beanbagboy]

Albert does seem... lurky. But I'm in another game with him (Mini 449) in which he is doing exactly the same. Again, we're both alive, but it does seem consistent.

Jack has brought up an interesting point, Yogurt barely has posted, even more so than Albert. If we're going after non contributers,

Unvote: Jack, Vote: YogurtBandit

[beanbagboy]

Are you... supporting your own wagon? O.o

Also, BM, what the hell was that? Move to the... scumbag with the largest wagon? I'm sorry, that's too much.

Unvote, Vote: BM

[beanbagboy]

You're defending me jumping on your wagon. That's... strange...

[beanbagboy]

Er... wow. This town is... wagony. If I seem new, I've never done normal games before, only minis, so I might seem distant, sorry.

Unvote

, there are too many people too close to being lynched.

[beanbagboy]

Jack, I assume it's so he can analyze them. Would you like him to accept people who don't support their claims? [/rhetoricalquestion]

8. Good to know. Either way, I don't really know who to vote for, BM and AR are both acting scummy, but metagamingly they ALWAYS do this.

[beanbagboy]

Okay, I'm a bit fried, but Guardian seems the most scummy here. (and too many people beat me to saying it.) YB too, but he is in a lot of newbie games, and I vaguely remember him being new.

So:

Vote: Guardian

and

FoS: YB

[beanbagboy]

BRAWWWWWWWWWK! ok lol, sorry, I had to do that.

[beanbagboy]

Er, sorry, newb alert, why is this? Getting lynched being better, that is.

[beanbagboy]

Glork, I have to say, while... er... I

think

I agree with you on the vanilla claims subject, I really don't go for albert as scum. I think it's pretty much a null tell how he's acting, he does this all the time, or, at least it seems consistent with the other game I'm in with him. Granted, it's ongoing, but still, that's enough to keep my vote where it is.

Also, how does it make it easier for scum to lynch power roles? I think this is what Glork was saying (correct me if I'm wrong) that power roles are just as likely to claim vanilla.

[beanbagboy]

Oh, duh, of course they should claim, I'm an idiot. lol, glrok.

Also, @Hacker: Good point, they do seem to be... arguing a lot. I don't know, possible linkage via distancing. (But then again, they could be the masons.)

Whilst I think Guardian scummy, I think his defense of YB is not so unfounded. I think it's possible that YB is just being n00by. Mind you, that says nothing about his alignment, I'm still watching him, but it doesn't seem enough.... yet.

Also, just so I know, as I've never played in a normal game, how many pages is day one, usually? I think about 20, right? I know it depends on the game, but still, just so I get a feel.

[beanbagboy]

O.o

Er... I think Jack's like this, I don't have much metagame experience, but the other... one, or is it two? games I'm in with him he's silent.

Also, I forget who said it, I think YB, yes, it is highly unlikely that they're masons, but it's just as unlikely that anyone else is. The point, of course, being we're trying to figure out which of these people are masons, and we know the possibility is always small.

@Jack: Weird, strange, or weird, scummy? Also, if you're the walrus, I am the eggman. (Two points if you get the reference.)

[beanbagboy]

Hmm? It wasn't a deliberate mason hunt, rather a note that they seemed to be possibly linked via distancing. There are two linked roles: scum and masons. And as neither seem very scummy yet, I brought it up. I tend to think out loud a lot.

The cop? That seemed... er, random. And how do you know there IS a cop? That sounds like you ARE the cop, trying to distance yourself from the role. (Well, you got your way, lol)

Glork makes a few good points. YB has turned himself around in my mind, from null tell noob to townish. Not definite, though, just seems townie.

Am I one of those players, Glrok? [/paranoia]

[beanbagboy]

Okay, yes, Glork, I thought MBL speculating n0 choices was weird. Also, I just had a crazy, overanalytical, but interesting thought: what if MBL is distancing himself from the SK, because HE IS THE SK? SV got chainsawed, and we know the SK has a chainsaw, maybe THAT'S why he made that comment!

FoSK: MBL

Sorry for fingering lotsa pplz, it's fun though.

I was saying that scum want to kill people that are threatening to them, and vice versa for townies, actually. Por ejemplo, any townie that is generally good at scum finding makes a good kill. Vice versa, anyone in the town that is threatening usually gets killed by townies. I do the "look through the others eye" type thing a lot, it's my entire scumhunting basis.

YB is being scummy. He's wagony, hypocritical, and accusative, that whole thing with Jack was... forced, IMO.

Unvote, Vote: YB

[beanbagboy]

I already PM'd the mod, I'll need a replacement as large games are just too much to handle. Sorry, I would really have loved to stay otherwise.

[beanbagboy]

Pm'd the mod, I'm sorry to say I think a large game is too much for me right now, need a replacement. Sorry for the inconvenience, I would love to stay but it's a bit much.