Mafia 112: Ridiculous Drama! (Game Over, town win!)

[MehPlusRawr]

Probably should've noticed this earlier! /confirm

[MehPlusRawr]

There were 20 items in your list. Here they are, randomized with pregenerated randomization based on persistent identifer http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... postdays=0&:

1. 5. Richard Massive
2. 15. Shadow Dancer
3. 12. Leafsnail
4. 6. the1iffi
5. 16. NavyCherub
6. 13. Blue
7. 18. Henry Hathaway
8. 7. DTMaster
9. 20. Julano
10. 4. SIR CYANIDE
11. 11. Shrinehme
12. 19. Jag Johan
13. 14. Farside
14. 3. FeFiFoFum
15. 2. Chronopie
16. 9. mehplusrawr
17. 8. konowa
18. 1. Fate
19. 17. Shattered Viewpoint
20. 10. JacobSavage

I

vote: Richard Massive

Meh.

[MehPlusRawr]

@Meh: Why random vote via generator? Do you have comments on anything going on thus far?

Ah, but if I were mafia I wouldn't be half so obvious. Because then I'd anticipate receiving votes from tunnel-vision players like yourself.

WIFOM defense? Check.
False tunnel-vision accusation (on page three for that matter)? Check.
Scum found on page three? Priceless.

unvote;
vote Blue

Everybody else was random-voting! Also, I haven't really had a chance to look over this game much... exams and such. I should still be able to post some stuff and help scumhunt.

Thus far, I haven't really had any leads. Regarding the last part of your post, though- I'd say WIFOM is often a nulltell. Blue is the best lynch so far, but that's only because I haven't really noticed anything scummy from anybody else. I'd like to hear his defence against your vote though.

[MehPlusRawr]

Okay,

unvote, vote: Sir Cyanide

for trying to start a bandwagon after there's already one on him. It looks as if he's really nervous and trying to get people to stop voting for him quickly. I also just realized that he OMGUS'd Farside.

I'd probably be okay with a lynch on him.

[MehPlusRawr]

Eh, we're getting a bit off topic.

Also, vote totals please? How many are on Cyanide?

[MehPlusRawr]

If Cyanide flips scum, we should definitely go after Julano.

</captainobvious>

[MehPlusRawr]

Oi wait a minute

@Meh

Thus far, I haven't really had any leads. Regarding the last part of your post, though- I'd say WIFOM is often a nulltell. Blue is the best lynch so far, but that's only because I haven't really noticed anything scummy from anybody else. I'd like to hear his defence against your vote though.

You don't have leads, but you think Blue is the best lynch so far? Say wut? Explain yourself. Isn't your lead on Blue right now?

I meant that nobody had really done anything to merit a lynch, disregarding Sir Cyanide, whom I voted for later, which you noted. (Runonsentencelolfail)

At that time, the only vote I had was an RVS on Richard Massive, who got replaced by Panama.

Repeating myself, because I'm often hard to understand- Nobody at that time had done anything making them appear completely scummy. Blue had done the only slightly scummy thing at the time. This wasn't enough to make me vote for him yet though.

Actually, I meant to FoS him, and I apparently didn't. I keep forgetting to do that.

FoS: Blue.

[MehPlusRawr]

EBWOP: I and everyone else need to stop misspelling Parama's name. You're making ME start.

[MehPlusRawr]

Blue, I liked your argument there. Since it looks like we're lynching Cyanide due to the way he's acting, we can get him lynched for that reason, and if you're right, we'll also have killed a mafia member and have a lead on another mafia member.

[MehPlusRawr]

I think it's usually a 4-1 ratio, and I think there are 20 people. 4 mafia maybe?

[MehPlusRawr]

These are the people I think are most likely to be mafia, and how I would vote according to what they flip.

Cyanide (For the reasons I posted earlier, as a policy lynch, and as a test- if he comes up mafia, we've got a good chance of finding another mafia)

Leafsnail (Singling out Julano for no reason. More suspicion on him if Julano is scum. Also, saying "Not sure how helpful putting 4 random votes on the same guy is", looks like he's trying to take votes off Cyanide. Even more suspicion on him if Cyanide is scum.)

Julano (OMGUS, liking what Cyanide said.)

Farside (Only if Cyanide flips scum. Because of Blue's musings on the subject.)

Jacobsavage (Trying to outguess the mod, voting no lynch.)

Shrinehme (Since he's been kinda lurking, not doing anything scummy, not doing anything townie, but posting enough so he's not prodded. His posts don't really contain anything useful either. Also, defended
Cyanide. If Cyanide flips scum, this guy is more likely to be scum too. Either way, he's not helping town and wouldn't be an incredibly bad guy to lose.)


Assuming no other info comes up, I'll probably vote this way.

Cyanide
If he's scum: Julano.
If he's town: Shrinehme
Julano
If he's scum: Leafsnail
If he's town: Shrinehme
Shrinehme
If he's scum: Any of the other people I'm suspicious of.
If he's town: Jacobsavage
Leafsnail
If he's scum: Farside
If he's town: Farside
Farside
If she's scum: Jacob
If she's town: Eh, still Jacob
Jacob
If he's scum: No idea, frankly. Anybody else.
If he's town: Same as above.


FoS all of the people I listed as suspicious.

Eh, had doubts about posting this, but a few of them are probably scum, and if I get killed in the night, this might be pretty helpful.

[MehPlusRawr]

Since it looks like we're lynching Cyanide due to the way he's acting,

What? When did we agree on this? Who wants to lynch someone without Spyrex's stamp of approval?

I think he had like 7 votes at the time, and everybody was shouting at him.

[MehPlusRawr]

Jag, if we lynch Cyanide, and he flips scum, THEN we go after Farside. Since there's a large BW on him anyway, if he gets lynched and is scum, we should go after her. Simple 'nuff.

[MehPlusRawr]

At Leafsnail's last post- Okay, the people you're calling scum are....

Parama- He looks rather pro-town. He thinks you're scum and you voted for him apparently just because he thinks you're scum. He also thinks we should lynch Cyanide.
Blue- Said that Cyanide and Farside were scum.
Me- Said that he, Cyanide, and other people were scum.

Each of the people you address are regarding Cyanide. You address Cyanide himself once, about V/LA, but it doesn't have any impact on your scumreads, which admittedly makes sense. It looks like you're trying to convey "I'm not DEFINITELY saying that he's town, so I'm including him in my post-that-accuses-people-of-being-scum but not calling him scum."

The one thing the three people you're calling scum have in common? We think it's a good idea to lynch Cyanide.

Let's assume that Cyanide is scum for a second.

He's been accused by a lot of people, some of the votes were random. He got more piled on him for rudeness. He's scum, and his buddies are getting worried. Now, let's assume that Leafsnail is scum. He comes in, accuses all the most recent people who votes for Cyanide of being scum, and nothing else.

Sound a bit scummy to you? Sounds scummy to me!

Unvote, vote Leafsnail

[MehPlusRawr]

I have no idea why I just voted for Leafsnail. That was a mistake =P.

Unvote (again), vote SIR CYANIDE (again)

[MehPlusRawr]

Eh, I made a mistake by being absentminded. I was thinking of Leafsnail at the time. As for my defending Parama- I had intended to write a sentence or so showing that each of the people there looked more likely to be town than scum, but I couldn't really think of anything to write for Blue so I skipped it, forgetting to erase the bit about Parama so it would be all nice, neat, and in a similar format.

Does anyone wanna listen to the points I made? >_>

[MehPlusRawr]

No, I'm saying that I was too lazy to go back and see what Blue did that I could use to show he was pro-town. I knew that Parama had made a big post with scumhunting in it, though.

[MehPlusRawr]

Sorry, all, I've been busy. What happened to the Cyanide policy lynch? Eh, I'll be back sometime later.

[MehPlusRawr]

Fate, I just realized that Blue said that. (referring to 284) Hey, this looks like more bandwagoning from me! Eh, only a little bit. Fate has a pretty good reason to lynch Blue.

Vote: Blue

Cyanide, I'm pretty sure you're only OK with those lynches because they both voted for you before.

[MehPlusRawr]

If we lynch Blue-

If he's town, lynch Shrinehme. I've been suspicious of Shrinehme for a while, and he was aggressively pushing for the lynch earlier.

"You were joking about extreme WIFOM and accusing me of tunnel-vision, but you're suspicious of people who jumped on you you because of your "joke"?

Did I miss something here?"

If he's scum, I'm not sure who to lynch.

[MehPlusRawr]

XD@Fate.

Come on, let's lynch Blue nao.

[MehPlusRawr]

Mafia wants to lynch pro-town roles. Town wants to lynch anti-town roles. This was my case on you earlier:

Shrinehme (Since he's been kinda lurking, not doing anything scummy, not doing anything townie, but posting enough so he's not prodded. His posts don't really contain anything useful either. Also, defended
Cyanide. If Cyanide flips scum, this guy is more likely to be scum too. Either way, he's not helping town and wouldn't be an incredibly bad guy to lose.)

[MehPlusRawr]

EBWOP: Oh, and @thelastpartofyourcomment- I was going to offer a situation for Blue's being scum and Blue's being town, but I couldn't really think of any people who seem connected to Blue in a bad way, if that makes sense. So, I just provided a situation for him being town. If he's scum, we'll see where to go from there.

[MehPlusRawr]

I have SOME individuality. Only a little, though.

[MehPlusRawr]

I have SOME individuality. Only a little, though.

And no answers to the accusations made against you, I see.

Where are those accusations? >_> I don't know what you're referring to.

[MehPlusRawr]

Alrighty, Maemuki.

Instructions: Take out your checkbook and write the answers to these questions on it.

Question 1: What is today's date?

Question 2: What is your na-

Oh, mafia questions?

Who do you think is likely to be mafia?

[MehPlusRawr]

scumMae

I see what you did there.

I personally think Julano was acting scummy and Mae isn't. There's a good chance that she's scum, but let's see how she herself acts, too.

[MehPlusRawr]

I think that Blue is town, but I'm going to keep my vote on him. There's a chance that he's scum, and if he's town, we'll have some nice new evidence against people that are more likely to be mafia. At L-1 (I think), I don't think we could dismantle this wagon and really kill anyone else. Shouldn't Blue have claimed by now? I'm new to mafia where people claim at L-1, for some reason, and not sure if he shouldn't have, didn't on purpose, or just hasn't been on.

[MehPlusRawr]

Fate is scum for 689. :eyeroll:

This day is too long. It makes my head hurt :X

[MehPlusRawr]

Okay, Blue wagon decided to stop, eh. I've found Shrine suspicious for a while, so....

Unvote, Vote: Shrinehme

For the reason I stated a long time ago- "Shrinehme (Since he's been kinda lurking, not doing anything scummy, not doing anything townie, but posting enough so he's not prodded. His posts don't really contain anything useful either. Also, defended Cyanide. If Cyanide flips scum, this guy is more likely to be scum too. Either way, he's not helping town and wouldn't be an incredibly bad guy to lose.)"

[MehPlusRawr]

Now we can use it as information-based reasoning, as you're protecting him. Anybody wanna lynch Blue now and use his flip for information regarding Jacob?

[MehPlusRawr]

FoS: Chrono for looking like he wants an easy lynch and using "I want Parama to eat a teabag" as an excuse.

[MehPlusRawr]

Mae, why do you live in a <3?

Also, I'm tending towards agreeing with whoever said "Blue is probably scum as nobody wanted to hammer him".

[MehPlusRawr]

If Blue was Townie, wouldn't some scum have hammered him though?

[MehPlusRawr]

PEOPLE NOT VOTING BLUE OR SHRINE NEED TO CHOOSE ONE NOW.

THIS. I'M SICK OF THIS DAY. WE NEED TO FINISH IT ALREADY.

[MehPlusRawr]

Well, I'll vote Blue if needed. I'd prefer a Shrine lynch but I'm okay with this one too.

[MehPlusRawr]

Well, if Jacob has evidence that says Konowa is an SK (And I guess that only an SK would kill and eat somebody...), then I'll vote for Kon.

Vote: Konowa

[MehPlusRawr]

Vote: MehPlusRawr

. I'd definately be behind his lynch for reasons stated yesterday, and he hasn't done anything useful since. And if Fate has role related reasons, all the better.

I think by "reasons" you mean OMGUS.

Also, come on, Fate, there's no way I can respond to that accusation.

[MehPlusRawr]

Keeping Konowa alive would be a bad idea for us. Can we please lynch him? :S

[MehPlusRawr]

Am I really at L-1 already?

Claim: Vanilla Townie

Eh, oh well. Doesn't exactly look like I can stop this lynch. Boo at all the people who are bandwagoning on me though.

My scumlist, for reference:

Cyanide
Maemuki
Shrinehme
Leafsnail
Fate
(Inb4oneofthemhammersme...)

I don't recall actually seeing any cases on me today, if any of the people voting me actually HAVE them, please tell me what post numbers they were. I don't exactly wanna reread D2 right now.

[MehPlusRawr]

BAH YOU GUYS SUCK FOR VOTING ME OUT.

Meh GL town.

[MehPlusRawr]

Yay for me failing at reads!

My first serious mafia game, I accidentally buddied with a scum, which messed up most of my reads in the other games I had joined slightly later. I got Leafsnail right, at least. Grats, town!