FoS: ckool5000
1.) "yay scum doctor is dead" post. I think Mastin went over this at one point. (granted i think at this point it would have been hard for mastin to NOT mention something)
2.) saying that "lol" is a scumtell. complete nonsense.
3.) while speculating about which groups/people would have targeted which people...
And how is it WIFOM? The mafia would want to keep an easily lynchable person in the game. Case closed.
seems waaaay too sure of his analysis. it could have easily been WIFOM or a mafia/SK using random.org to pick a target.
4.) Calling people lurkers in a game with 10+ pages that started less than 24 hours ago...people have lives/work/are slow readers.
HoS: Johnny Rotten
1.) Wanting to lynch Mastin on playstyle rather than post content or any evidence at all. Especially since mastin's been one of the most active scum hunters.
2.) Saying that voting was a possible scumtell based on game phase. absurd.
3.)
BTW, I feel as though I am neglecting to answer a question posed to me earlier.....and to be honest, I am too lazy right now to go looking for it. So, if it is your question that I missed, please re-post, or direct me to the original one, and I will be happy to!
saying he's too lazy to look for questions posed to him also means he's too lazy to go back and look at posts for scum tells. combined with 1 means he's more concerned about eliminating the player he is least fond of more than the scum.
Concerning the miller claim:
no reason to lynch him, at least early on. it's exactly what an actual miller should have done. the most interesting part is basically rofl's reaction, when he says kublai is as good as confirmed town. i have the idea he basically said this as an attempt to draw out people who disagree and think the claim was scummy, otherwise that assumption doesn't make a lot of sense to me. i know rofl made a post about the drawbacks of scum claiming miller, but it assumes that kublai would have thought about all those factors as scum and therefore not thought it was a good idea.
basically i agree with the majority - the claim itself is a nulltell.
Concerning Mastin's posting:
He makes it incredibly hard to catch up if you miss anything.
