Mafia 88- Return to New Catania- Game Over!

[killa seven]

hey guys.

[killa seven]

i need a read

[killa seven]

welcome volkan and incognito

[killa seven]

It's been almost 11 hours since my first post. Why isn't Puta Puta lynched yet?

Im guessing he doesnt have enough votes.

[killa seven]

Side note: Someone please nightkill killa seven. Vig, mafia, I don't care who. Daykill would be even better.

How rude.

[killa seven]

but idk what's going on... -.-

are you serious?

[killa seven]

I thought he was at L-2... we clearly need more frequent votecounts.

Me too. If I'd thought he was at L-1, I totally would have hammered. If anyone deserves a policy lynch, it is Puta Puta, and that would be an awesome way to enter the game.

Hi all, I've been semi-following this game as it's been going, but now I'm actually in it, I'm working on a more thorough reread.

Iam's First Post replacing in.

Said puta puta deserves a policy lynch.



His next post

And my reason is more then he's picking on GC, my reason is GC would be a good target for scum to eliminate if he's town.

So basically I'm deciding if he's more likely to be town, or if you [Battle Mage] are

. I'm much more inclined to lynch you though, since that will at least show GC isn't aligned with you. Though sadly if you flip town we effectively learn nothing.

OK, the first thing that strikes me as notably suspicious in this game is this here massive false dilemma set up by THE GUY I REPLACED. Thanks, Sobeahero.

SensFan's entrance is interesting. ckd overreacts massively to Sens choosing to vote before he's finished catching up, and then changing that vote each time he gets further caught up, which I think is a very reasonable way of compensating for his absence at the beginning. Unless there was a risk of him accidentally hammering someone (and there clearly wasn't at this stage), how would this be harmful to the town, ckd?

On the other hand, Sens says in Post #210 that he's caught up, and yet his vote is still stuck on Page 3? Did nothing at all happened on pages 4-9 that was worthy of comment?

...I don't get the anti-Sir T thoughts at all. I have absolutely no idea what it is that everyone is seeing as so scummy there.

vollkan is the first one to pick up on predecessor's total scuminess. I'm surprised he didn't get more attention before this. I've never replaced someone who was my prime suspect before, I'm not really sure how to handle it. I mean, I can't exactly dispute vollkan's arguments when I agree with them.

#312 is :goodposting:. Once we've got the necessary policy lynch on Puta Puta out of the way, OGML is definitely a person of interest.

...And that's a reread done. Besides Puta Puta being terrible, I think SensFan's little "playing five pages behind" thing has generated by far the most interesting reactions. Pretty much, anyone who attacked him for this is on my suspect list, because I don't understand how they could possibly see it as being scummy, but especially so when they had previously said this:

Oddly enough, I agree with BM. GC undermined his own argument in the process of writing it.

Yeah, but is that actually scummy?

The flaw in his reasoning could have been an honest mistake, but there's also a good possibility it wasn't

(its very easy for scum to jump on a standard anti town tell such as voting no lynch)

, and its light years better than a random vote. The random voting stage does exactly zero for forward momentum.

Now, obviously, voting before you've finished catching up on the thread is not a standard anti-town tell, but I think the core argument, that it is easy for scum to jump on someone

acting outside the accepted norms

, actually applies better to the SensFan situation. I understand why a No Lynch vote on D1 is seen as anti-town. I don't understand why making temporary votes while you're catching up on the thread is.

---

Hammer without a claim? Why would anyone want to do that?

What on earth gives you the impression that Puta will do something as helpful as claiming?

Vote: Puta Puta

. He is the worst.

brief alalysis, then sais "what gives you the impression puta will claim" then eagerly votes him.



very next post after the puta heat dies down.

Eh, if he's lying scum, there's pretty much no way we won't figure it out before endgame.

Unvote, Vote: OGML

.

he immediately switches to omgl.



Then 2 real life days later

Unvote, Vote: killa sven

My vote's not going to do anything much while OGML is away, and I know k7 can be more helpful than he has been so far in this game. Let's get this wagon a-rollin'.

he immediately switches to me when a wagon forms on me.. saying his vote on omgl isnt going places.. really 2 days.. and you didnt even push.

Iam.. why do you keep switching votes so fast from wagon to wagon?

[killa seven]

Moving on... I have some questions for killa seven: Why did you wait over 20 pages before making a useful contribution to the game? Do you feel that lurking is good town play?

have you played with me before?

[killa seven]

going on vacation.. please dont replace

[killa seven]

going on vacation.. please dont replace

For how long?

a week.

[killa seven]

I'm back, catching up.

[killa seven]

Killa seven has gone four days without posting, having been prodded twice already. According to the rules, he will now be forcibly replaced.

yea sorry im still out of town. my apologies.