Mini 1604 -- Zodiac Mafia (Game Over)

[Aronis]

UNVOTE:

Hey guys.

[Aronis]

UNVOTE:

Hey guys.

Hey Aronis! Are you actually a Cancer?

Ofc.

[Aronis]

So a quick reads list now that I've caught up.

1. Nacho - Early on his posts were super town.

2. StrangerCoug - Really liking his playstyle so far, thought process seems town.

3. Xayzeck - He's seemed pretty town so far.

4. Toasty - Since replacing in his posts have seemed pretty town. I just wasnt a huge fan of Witness Protection.

5. Gemini Blind - Seems fairly town, like some of their comments about the Dayvig.

6. Elyse - She feels town, but seems to lack direction, which can be troubling.

7. Salamence20 - Early on he was absent, but posts have gotten some better. So maybe a slight lean town, just want to see more posts.

8. Iecerint - Im just really unsure what to think of him atm.

9. Dry-Fit - He seems scummy, but if my memory is correct, this seems sorta like his normal play. So a lean scum atm, but not convinced.

10. burn_209 - His play is just really lacking at this point and what he has said I dislike.

11. PergerineV - Imo, recently his posts have been dropping like a rock. Plus I really like the wagon atm.

VOTE: PergerineV



PergerineV

Null

Burn_209

[Aronis]

Page top!

[Aronis]

6. Elyse - She feels town, but seems to lack direction, which can be troubling.

Elab?

I said her lack of direction can be 'troubling'. I didn't say it is scummy, I didn't say it isn't. In my opinion her hesitance shows caution, which is good for the town, especially at first. But if she continues along that path forever and doesn't take more solid stances on subjects, it shows she is keeping all options open, which is scummy. So she's a slight town read at this point.

[Aronis]

aronis vote is fine but it could be better if he was voting somewhere else

Where do you think it could be best served?

[Aronis]

9. Dry-Fit - He seems scummy, but if my memory is correct, this seems sorta like his normal play. So a lean scum atm, but not convinced.

Anything about me in particular that looks scummy?

I didn't really like the push on Salamence.

[Aronis]

UNVOTE:

Want to think about things some more and see what the replacement does.

[Aronis]

Im just not that confident in my scumreads atm.

[Aronis]

@ Aronis are you less confident in your reads than your initial reads from before? (like have things changed) If so what has changed your mind on them?
Particularly PV since you've unvoted him. Is there a reason you find him less scummy than before? (If that's the case)

Not particularly. Im just not getting strong scum-vibes from anyone.

[Aronis]

Elyse is really really really town atm. Hopefully she wont die.

If she does, Sala's kill was careless and probably scum.

[Aronis]

VOTE: Salamence

[Aronis]

It's L-1? Anyways, that shot was terrible. He deserves to die.

[Aronis]

It's L-1? Anyways, that shot was terrible. He deserves to die.

Calling Elyse "really, really, really town" after the shot had already been made and extrapolating from that that she was a terrible kill is incredibly disingenuous. You were as ambiguous about her as you were about most everyone else previous to Salamance making the shot and considering that you had no suspects to speak of, I'd like to know what you would have considered a good shot.

You, PV, Icerint.

[Aronis]

VOTE: Salamence

That shot was awful. I doubt he had any idea about shooting. My guess is that he just needed to use it before imminent death, but at the same time try to preserve himself if possible.

[Aronis]

Hmmm.

UNVOTE: Salamence

[Aronis]

After looking over Xay/Elyse, I think there's a decent chance Xay is prob scum.

VOTE: Xayzeck

[Aronis]

why are people voting Aronis?

No useful content. Juls also doesn't have much content. Sort of hammered salamence. Salamence is likely town, worth at least keeping around if cop to verify.

I'd be willing to switch to Xayzeck personally; I will not vote Salemence today. I will reassess tomorrow.

~STD

I did not hammer Salamence. OK? Like get your fucking facts straight.

[Aronis]

So I feel like 9 out of 10 times, Salamence doesn't hold the dayvig for anywhere near this long, but the cop claim sorta explains it. But at the sametime, wouldn't town just lynch the guility? If he claimed and assuming it wasn't MyLo/LyLo, I'd probably go along with it. Plus the shot seemed really poorly timed. Why doesn't he claim dayvig, then shoot? I don't see any reason for the rush there. Then following it up with a cop claim, he's just trying to save himself at this point. I highly doubt he's the cop. So I will gladly hammer the conf scum for Gemini.

VOTE: Salamence

HAMMER!

======[]

[Aronis]

@Dryfit, Sala's play late in the day just sort of started falling like a rock, imo. Up until the dayvig shot, he didnt strike me as very scummy, after that my read on him took a sharp turn. At the time your push on him didnt give me a good feeling, but it turns out I was wrong.

[Aronis]

VOTE: Aronis

I'm fine with Nacho lynch too.

Why do you want to lynch Nacho?

[Aronis]

Why do you want to lynch Nacho?

The longer Nacho is alive, the more I want to lynch him.

Please elaborate. If you're saying it's because he's not getting night killed, I think that's too much speculation at the time being. It's only been one night, so it's really hard to tell. For all we know there's an Sk and the mafia and a doc blocked a kill.

If you're saying his play is really scummy lately, I'm not seeing it.

[Aronis]

Can I pick who hammers me then?

[Aronis]

Wait, you're alive? I thought you were just a talking dummie.