Mini 418: Blue Jam. Game over (Mafia win)

[Dagger]

random vote: _Converge

Ho Hum

[Dagger]

Noted.

Any discussion to start off the day with? Random mafia theories. Speculation on the set-up. First 3rd vote in the game ( )

FoS: AK9

[Dagger]

Argh!! You backstab me?? I thought we are the best of scumbuddies??!!

[Dagger]

*CALLS FL* Hey IT STARTED! GET IN HERE IDIOT!. DAGGER - FL SCUMGROUP!

Shhh... You are revealing far too much...

[Dagger]

Maybe he doesnt have enough votes on him yet.

unvote, vote FL

so true...
eh, for the fun of it;

Unvote, Vote FL

Oh Joy, a wagon of 4 in a mini.

Unvote, Vote: AKA Apokalypsekid9

Eh, I don't have enough votes. Can someone vote DeanWinchester for me?

[Dagger]

I put the fourth vote there to see is the scum were stupid enough to jump on it. My vote put you just over the half way mark and I felt it was safe to do it.
ATM there realy isin't a whole lot going.

Based on that same logic, I suppose AK9's 3rd vote is there to see if scums were stupid enough to jump on it.

[Dagger]

My vote will be staying on AK9 for now. Moderation is the key to everything, both as a townie and as a scum.

It might jump to DW though to create a more beautiful bandwagon after he next posts again.

[Dagger]

Last I recall, CES was voting you too.

[Dagger]

If that is the same AK9 from MTGS, then I can attest that he is still rather new, but he should have a few games on his belt by now.

Also, DW's explanations so far have not impressed me.

Personally, I think DW has a higher probability of being a scum right now.

Unvote, Vote: DeanWinchester

[Dagger]

AKAA's latest post is screaming 'scum' to me...

Heck, I think both DW and AKAA are scums.

When in doubt, choose the more experienced player to be lynched.

My vote stays as it is.

As for CPE, well, he's just erratic in every single game I have seen him in... >_>

I'm still a little confused why poeple are voting for me. How is putting the 4th vote on the waggon a sign of overtly being scum? Giving how it was formed, it was obvious he wasn't going to end up lynched. And if he did, the poeple who put the 5th and 6th votes on him would be broadcasting that they were scum. My vote did not put him in any danger period.

How is the 4th vote based on the reasons you gave to vote FL any less scummy than the 5th or 6th vote? Heck, do the 7th and 8th vote scummier then the 5th and 6th vote?

[Dagger]

unvote

I dislike being on the same wagon with scum.

If you found scum, vote him or her for the black and white record rather than being wishy-washy and staying by the sidelines, yes?

[Dagger]

Just checking in again to confirm my vote. Let's get a move on, people.

Actually, it would be easier to lynch CES right now.

Reason being?

[Dagger]

Fine, Can we Vig/Lynch AKAA Tommorrow then?

OMGUS much? If pushed, I can show compelling evidence as to how I'm not scum.

I am still waiting for this 'compelling evidence' that you speak of.

Also, those that think AKAA is a better lynch than Dean raise up their hands. We are not under a deadline so we can actually decide which is a better lynch. Personally, I am more keen on Dean but Dean actually made an attempt to defend himself while AKAA seemed to have given up.

[Dagger]

I am in favor of AKAA posting again before we proceed any further in that direction. Is it time for a prod yet?

Also, I am not in favor of anyone claiming unless they are nearly lynched.

FoS: FaerieLord

[Dagger]

To pressure, we need votes. Who is it that haven't voted?

[Dagger]

The way I see it dean and/or AKAA are scum in which case great, otherwise we go after the people that heavily pushed these lynches.

That's funny. I would rather go after those that stood by the sidelines and did nothing. I would call that 'distancing by scums on a townie wagon' if our lynch turns up town.

I'm fine with a claim from either.

@Dagger. Before you start point your finger at me, i wasnt the first to claim. And besides...i thought that there were at least 4 votes on dean by now :/

Noted. You both then.

Also, some people unvoted. There are 12 players though. Obviously some of us found it fitting to stay by the sidelines and do nothing.

[Dagger]

The way I see it dean and/or AKAA are scum in which case great, otherwise we go after the people that heavily pushed these lynches.

Or we could go after the lurking scum who has contributed nothing, except to jump on a wagon, without even explaining why he is on the wagon in the first place.

vote ThAdmiral

This is a sentiment I can agree with. Let's see what Admiral has to say about this.

[Dagger]

Confirming my vote on DW... again.

No point going after AWOL people and I can't remember what I last posted. I had a nagging suspicion I was keeping an eye on Admiral though.

[Dagger]

Okay, I am in agreement with DW claiming. This game needs to move instead of waiting.

[Dagger]

Oh, this is funny. Very funny.

Unvote

Can I ask how big is your group?

[Dagger]

OK then, here's an interesting fact. I am in a five-man mason group too. We

do not know

each other's alignment. And I believed we are in different groups.

Would it be possible for me to know the remaining two players who are not in both our mason groups?

[Dagger]

Brewski, Creampuffeater, FaerieLord and _Converge

Now, this is very very interesting...

Either everyone is in a mason group or FL and Converge have got some explainings to do.

[Dagger]

I am considering Dean's claim as valid pending a counterclaim.

I am interested in hearing from _Converge for being the only player in this game with the unique position of being in all 3 mason groups.

I find it interesting that for all of bird1111's analysis, he was just confirming what the rest of us have been saying along about AKAA and Dean.

CES interested me somewhat.

And yeah, I wanna be scumbuddies with CPE again.

[Dagger]

CeSc: No, I only know the names of the members.

But you were told you are in 3 mason groups?

Not sure exactly what you are talking about here, are you referring to my whole analysis or just the parts containing AKA and Dean?

The part where you concluded by voting one and fosing the other one.

Anyway, ThAdmiral:
1 random vote. 3 posts referring to or talking about his own inactivity. 1 post where he wagons dean, saying he feels he is the best lynch. 1 really horribly scummy post where he sets up a possible 1-2. 1 useless post about mason groups. I think he's scum, or at the very least completely unhelpful.

I would like to hear from AKAA first.
However, that is most likely my next choice.

[Dagger]

Im still here guys, but this game is going tooooooooooooo slow. Since cno replacement to AKAA, ill

Vote: AKAA

That wont lynch him and maybe get him to come out

You pinged my scumdar twice already.
Once when you refused to unvote DW after he claimed.
Once is in this post.

I'm the tracker.

And why on Earth are you claiming right now?

I'd still like to hear from AKAA or his replacement before I claim as well.

You too.

[Dagger]

I didnt unvote after DW claimed because i have my reasons. Saying my reasons would be worse than claiming this early :/. If you consider that scummy, oh well!

If your reasons will implicate DW as scum, I don't see how that will be worse.

ThAdmiral: geh. There wes absolutely no need for that claim with only two votes for you or for speculaiton purposes. If you were worried about being lynched, you could have at least tried, to defend yourself, if you wanted to speculate on the mason groups you could have seen dean has already claimed and thereby refuted that theory (not o mention that sort of speculation isn't helpful anyway). Honestly I'm finding you horribly scummy, but tracker is a provable claim and fairly powerful role, so

unvote

.

Provable, yes, but I have seen a mafia tracker before. I'll incline to believe him now though pending a counterclaim.

[Dagger]

Itll get me lynched though whatever

I counter claim. Im the doc here.

Happy?

Now your action actually made sense when DW claimed.

We need to hold off on invetible lynch untill this AKA issue is resolved, also arn't we waiting for a replacement?

FL what is your flavor?

Funny you seemed to believe FL? Shouldn't you be screaming fake or something like that?

What? That flavor makes no sense FL.
We are totaly in the rare scenario where the mafia are trading one to one to get a power role.

The mafia are rather dumb then. I would be totally happy for a 1 for 1 trade in a mini.

Unvote, Vote: DeanWinchester

[Dagger]

Ok, fine, I see your point. Although your flavor doesn't make any sense to me, your play is suicidal otherwise.

unvote, vote: DeanWinchester

Your immediate attempt at voting FL and and trying to defend DW before making a quick turnaround to hammer said DW is noted though.

[Dagger]

I thought bird1111 being misdiagnosed meant FL targeted him? It certainly sounds like the flavor of a quack doctor.

[Dagger]

Do none of you people know what a quack is? its just a doc that doesnt work, not one that kills.

FoS: Everybody byeing in to that crap lie

TCS You still havent claimed

Haven't play in a game with a quack doctor before is my only excuse.

@Simenon: I will eagerly await your explanations then, o wise one.

[Dagger]

Assuming he's speaking the truth, does that claim confirm him as a townie? I have never played with this type of role before.

[Dagger]

Why Shanba? There was only like 4 nominations and 2 of them on him.

Nevermind...

[Dagger]

*checks in*

We wait then.

[Dagger]

Fine enough by me.

Unvote, Vote: Simenon

. And that's apathy speaking. Will be inquiring further into this depending on its result.

And is Simenon really LFR? Or did I misread CPE's statement?

[Dagger]

It's a very very small world after all.

HAI LFR

[Dagger]

Oh? There is actually a mafia-based clan in MTGS? LOL

[Dagger]

Wow out of the loop dagger......

I am rather absent-minded at times. It's either that or I rarely check out the Clans section. It's either those two or I was lying to you. It's either those three or well, you get the general drift...

wow. Surely you found something to post over the weekend I was gone?

We need Simenon here to craft his own defence if he has one. Someone prod him.

[Dagger]

Cubus? >_> Damn.

So, both Shanba and TCS know this person then?

[Dagger]

*lips quirk up*

I am the cop.

Figured FL couldn't be a scum, because why would a scum went ahead and counterclaimed a doctor out of nowhere just to ensure a misynch? I thought a confirmation of his alignment would be useful because he would invariably come under fire the very next day. It was for this very reason that I thought the mafia would let FL alive if he really was town to draw fire onto him or FL would be alive anyway if he was scum.

I was rather disappointed when I was informed that someone killed him.

[Dagger]

Simple. People will keep bugging me about why I targetted FL last night and if I didn't explain, I anticipate several abilities being used on me tonight, including tracking, watching, roleblocking, and maybe vigging. We now know FL had the misfortune of being targetted by as many as 5 people just last night.

And besides, we still have a Watcher. I propose the Watcher watches me tonight, assuming he is town of course. In the event that I am NKed, we'll know who to go after.

I am seeing the field being narrowed down right now beautifully.

[Dagger]

I think Ecto really is the vig. I see no reason for a SK to target FL if he inevitably was going to come under fire the very next day.

I can see CES as a mafia watcher. He really didn't have any incentive to watch FL to see who would target FL if he suspected FL was a scum.

I have a rough plan in mind. I want to see what the town think about it.

We lynch one (CPE or SC) and vig the other. Since SC still has no replacement. I think the better lynch option would be CPE, after we extract a claim from him.

Then, we have CES watch me while I investigate him, and let the tracker (Admiral) tracks someone else who is a suspect (maybe Simenon).

[Dagger]

Once you eliminate the impossible, my dear CPE, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth. :p

Oh yeah, I would also appreciate it if the votes stop pilling up till we have everyone chiming in with their thoughts and/or we have already extracted a claim from CPE.

[Dagger]

Bah post!

GO GO TOWN.

DUN DIE.

[Dagger]

Aha, game ended.

It was a fun game to read along.

Nice one.