Mini 389: Potus Mafia - Whole Game Dead

[Thok]

vote eon

until he brings back his cat avatar.

[Thok]

unvote Eon, vote BrizzyBoi

, way too eager to jump on a self vote.

(I realize that Eon hasn't changed his avatar yet. Whatever.)

[Thok]

I think Rosso is being his normal self. Lyncher/lynchee aren't particularly common roles, and with what looks to be two scum groups (either two mafia or mafia + SK from the nightkills), having a lyncher/lynchee would lead to a setup that town has extreme difficulties winning.

[Thok]

if by "normal self" you mean "completely serious"

Given the recent posting, I'm even willing to change "normal self" to "completely serious".

[Thok]

Fair enough.

unvote BrizzyBoi, vote Sherlock

[Thok]

I've seen that before. It's fairly old. (It's also lots of coincidence; if I tried hard enough I could do a similar list with any pair of presidents.)

[Thok]

Just letting people realize that's lynch -2 on Sherlock. Feel free to try to explain your jumpiness on being given a second vote.

[Thok]

Not the cop. Don't see a reason to vote edion at the moment.

[Thok]

It means I'm specifically saying that I not counterclaiming you. (I think that's obvious, although it was probably a mistake for me to say it, in retrospect.)

I'm trying to decide if I want a name from you.

[Thok]

Looking at TR's wiki article, I've seen a reasonable case for TR as a cop. On the flip side, you could probably make a decent case for TR as almost any power role.

[Thok]

In addition, one of Roosevelt's jobs before becoming president was chief of New York City Police, where he basically completely reformed the entire department.

[Thok]

oh, and

Scum

, whoever you may be, tonight, I'm investigating Rosso. You might want to start thinking of your role-claim now, Rosso, in case I wind up dead in the morning.

Just on general principle, I'd appreciate you not announcing your night actions in advance. If you are the cop, all it does is make it easier for scum to decide who to kill.

[Thok]

OK, and what happens if Rosso is town and scum kills him tonight? You still look scummy, and scum don't have to worry about being investigated.

[Thok]

Posting only to prove that I exist and that I am still following the game.

[Thok]

I am here. I am hoping we don't need a hiatus.

[Thok]

Bumps in order to promote discussion or something.

[Thok]

Much as I don't like Rosso's reaction to edion's claim, it's silly to bandwagon him when he seems to have disappeared from MS completely.

Mods: Could you either prod Rosso (possibly indirectly through Maritya) or have him replaced?

[Thok]

It's not as scummy if Sherlock is scum.

We desparately need a vote count and possibly mass prods.

[Thok]

Not every game fetures a lyncher. In fact most of them don't.

If Lee Harvey Oswald was in the game, I'd expect him to be some sort of scum. There are more than enough presidental assassins to make a scum group, for example.

[Thok]

OK, this game is getting ridiculous. We desparately need a vote count. In addition, here are the last dates of posts of people in this game/on the site.

Sherlock (Dec 25/Jan 10)
Falcone (Nov 18/Dec 2)
edion0 (Dec 6/Dec 6)
Eon (Dec 18/Jan 5)
re2fan (Never/Jan 8, but before that Nov 18)
Nightson (Jan 7/Jan 10)
Thok (Jan 10/Jan 10)
Rosso Carne (Dec 15/Dec 15)
bethelmark (Nov 16/ Dec 31)
BrizzyBoi (Jan 8/Jan 9)

Seem to be around (posted in the thread in January): Nightson, me, Brizzyboi
Could be prodded (posted on MS in January): Sherlock, Eon, Re2fan
Probably need to be replaced: Falcone, edion0, Rosso Carne, bethelmark

If neither of the mods do something about the above soon, I'm going to request this game be abandoned.

[Thok]

Waves hi. Twiddles fingers.

[Thok]

Given that he did this in mutliple games, I think he's quitting the site.

[Thok]

Any news for us? There are surpringly few people I wouldn't mind going after; basically everybody myself, edion0 and Falcone (and the last is just from general feel).