Mini 1406: Sherlock Mafia (Game Over)

Zachrulez · Post Post #585 (isolation #0) » Sun Jan 20, 2013 1:07 pm

So our play is what happens when we don't really play this like AITP. Don't really like that setup concept... :-\

Zachrulez · Post Post #596 (isolation #1) » Mon Jan 21, 2013 2:49 am

In post 594, singersigner wrote:I started to think sotty was scum simply because I didn't see how anyone could possibly think we were scum with Hero for defending him so hard without a reason.

Meh.

"Lurking" is also not a scumtell for either of us (especially after calling V/LA in the beginning anyway), so for sotty/zach to push that so hard was weird.

Meh.

Quadz was also really pissed off that his only scumread (kthxbye) town-told like a mofo, and was fairly lost after that. Then I remembered CES was in the game and cheated by blindly following him. Apparently that works, lol.

Thanks for modding DDD. It was an interesting setup, and one I've never played in before. I also have to admit that I forgot I never read the role PM until Hero brought up the wincon question. Quadz told me we were town and so I was like, OH OK. Then I was like, "wow, Hero just derped but I think he's town" and he was like, "well yeah...we already know he's confirmed town." Go me. >_>

Actually reconsidered the read. You might have observed this in the form of drastically reduced attention on our part.

Zachrulez · Post Post #601 (isolation #2) » Tue Jan 22, 2013 2:07 pm

In post 600, Tierce wrote:You signed up for the game and gave no hint of being busy in the near future, were posting, then
suddenly ask the mod in private to be replaced
and disappear 24 hours after your latest post, only to come back and still participate in a different game.

Sorry to tell you, but people will most likely
not
interpret that in a positive light in a Mafia game. The only logical alternative was that you had somehow gained information you shouldn't have, and that didn't seem to make sense with
you
requesting replacement instead of the mod decreeing it.

Yeah, this.

Zachrulez · Post Post #603 (isolation #3) » Tue Jan 22, 2013 6:12 pm

In post 602, Magister Ludi wrote:Well it was a last minute thing. And, it was around 5 days later that I got a post in that other game, which was a random vengeance game where I simply posted one line.

It should not be interpreted positively or negatively as pertaining to the slot. All of the posts coming out of the wood work 'confirming' scummy-ness were complete crap (in my opinion.)

If you don't bother to explain your replacement in thread, you leave the townies in the game with a void and they will fill in reasoning for your replacement based on information they have available to them.